How come so many Catholics don't follow Church Teachings?

  • Thread starter Thread starter LovelyLadybug
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I know of so many famous Catholics who support sinful things that go against Church teachings. Why do they do that? The CCC teaches that those things are wrong. But, I know of many Catholics who support abortion, the LGBTQ community, birth control, etc… Many Catholic colleges and Schools have pro-abortion and pro-LGBTQ events/speakers. I just don’t understand why, since those things blatantly contradict Church teachings. We must pray for those confused Catholics!!! 🙏 Any thoughts on this? Thank You!!!
Aside from issues regarding marriage, sexuality, and reproduction, Catholics generally do follow Church teachings. Aside from these issues, Catholicism is not a particularly difficult religion to embrace, and it is not particularly difficult to follow her tenets. Try to think of something outside of marriage, sexuality, or reproduction, that is a struggle to live by, and you’ll see what I mean. Many religions require giving up alcohol, fairly broad categories of food, 10 percent of one’s income (some say 10% of your gross), coffee, the possibility of blood transfusion where it is needed to save one’s life, “worldly” entertainments, and a host of other things. Aside from the areas I cited, the hardest thing about being a Catholic is going to Mass every Sunday (in essence, giving Our Lord back two hours per week out of 168, and by the time you leave your house, drive there, assist at Mass, and drive back home, it’s at least two hours) and abstaining from meat on Fridays of Lent (as well as other Fridays of the year if you elect not to perform an alternate penance or act of charity). That’s a pretty easy religion.

So there you have the answer. These aspects of life — marriage, sexuality, and reproduction — present more challenges than anything else, and nurturing a lifelong Catholic consciousness of these matters, from youth onwards, disciplining oneself, never allowing bad habits to develop, avoiding the near occasions of sin, and not doing things to complicate one’s life in this regard — remember that, not doing things to complicate one’s life in this regard — will go a long way in keeping oneself out of trouble. (I speak as one who has not been perfect in this regard, so don’t anyone accuse me of having lived a sheltered, “uncontaminated” life, not understanding real people in the real world.) If you marry — and in Catholicism, it is always if and not when — only marry someone who will help you to save your soul and be a help to you in living the Catholic Faith. The very first question, in any courtship, even before the first date, should be “is this relationship something that will help me get to heaven?”. Don’t marry someone who will lead you astray or insists upon departing from Catholic morality. Get the hard questions out of the way right up front — how many children, and when, and what to do about NFP, and what happens if NFP proves to be difficult to use? If you can’t get the best answers, be prepared to walk away. There are worse things than not getting married, or not being able to marry the person you would prefer to marry.
 
When anyone criticizes what Scripture instructs and calls Holy and merciful, then I cannot see how demons are not influencing that person.
I really don’t think I’m influenced by demons just because I’m challenging your personal interpretation of cherry-picked Scriptures.
what exactly is the purpose of a community if there is no purpose or agenda?
You’re confusing community with network.

LGBTQ people are not a monolith. Sometimes a gay person’s only “agenda” is getting through a trying day at work and catching the latest episode of whatever’s on Netflix.
 
Last edited:
LGBTQ people are not a monolith.
Then it’s better not to use the word community . This is a word which actually does imply shared life, ideals and interaction distinct from those who are not part of it. It would not include for example a homosexual man who doesn’t mention his homosexuality to anyone.
 
There’s are also gay people who don’t like the gay scene itself.
 
Last edited:
I really don’t think I’m influenced by demons just because I’m challenging your personal interpretation of cherry-picked Scriptures.
What are you trying to say? That Scripture does not instruct believers to admonish one another?

It is one of the seven Spiritual Works of Mercy.

You are interpreting very differently than the Catholic Church to think otherwise.
 
I think many of you need to read and understand what the Church actually means when she says “fraternal correction”. Most of us are not in a position to be “correcting” anyone.

http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04394a.htm
From this article:
Every one, however, whether having an official competency or not, is bound to give the admonition when the sin, committed though it be from ignorance is hurtful to the offender or a third party or is the occasion of scandal.”
 
Also from this site:

This is reckoned to be so only when
  • the delinquency to be corrected or prevented is a grievous one;
  • there is no good reason to believe that the sinner will adequately provide for himself;
  • there is a well-founded expectation that the admonition will be heeded;
  • there is no one else just as well fitted for this work of Christian charity and likely to undertake it;
  • there is no special trouble or disadvantage accruing to the reformer as a result of his zeal.
I draw your attention to the fourth point- how many of us fit this description, especially when it comes to many of the things we feel must be admonished.
 
Last edited:
Our adversary, Satan, wants us all to feel inadequate. He shames us into submission. Then no one ends up admonishing sin!

Dont be afraid. Dont feel like you are judging. Help one another by being kind and merciful. Encourage one another to overcome heresy and sin.
 
Last edited:
I am not afraid.
I will admonish someone, if and only if, the situation calls for it based on these principles laid out.
I have yet to find a time where I could honestly say it was my “duty”.
I have enough trouble with my own sinfulness.
 
Then stop sinning. The Church needs your help.

The irony, is that your post #103 is attempting to correct many people in this thread.
 
Last edited:
I know of so many famous Catholics who support sinful things that go against Church teachings. Why do they do that?
We must pray for those confused Catholics!!!
leave people alone and quietly pray for them.
While I agree whole heartedly that we must pray for them,and that it is the best thing we need to do, I also think asking these questions, responding in truth with our words and acting where needed are all very important.

People over the last several decades have been catechised so poorly many are confused as to what Catholic teaching truly is.

I also believe this is so true: The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing. Edmund Burke
 
* the delinquency to be corrected or prevented is a grievous one; * there is no good reason to believe that the sinner will adequately provide for himself;* there is a well-founded expectation that the admonition will be heeded;* there is no one else just as well fitted for this work of Christian charity and likely to undertake it;* there is no special trouble or disadvantage accruing to the reformer as a result of his zeal.

The bolded is interesting. In order to avoid admonishment, one would have to judge that the sinner will refuse admonishment.
 
Last edited:
40.png
Thom18:
So why is it that, when a war is waged against the unborn, some choose to praise this genocide? And why is it that it is celebrated in the public square, with those in opposition being labeled as misogynists (or worse)?
I am assuming your questions are not rhetorical, so I am going to try to help you with understanding the issue.

People who don’t believe abortion is murder believe that a zygote or a fetus insn’t a human person, generally. That is the end of the argument for them.

Nobody celebrates abortion. They celebrate living in a country that allows its citizens the right to choose what they do with their own body. That is the celebration. Lets not say they are celebrating abortion. They aren’t. Abortion is an unpleasant (at best) medical procedure for any woman to sustain. At worst, it can be painful and dangerous. Lets not put spin on the way we talk about it to support an agenda.
If I make some argument that homeless people aren’t actually people, it doesn’t change the fact that everyone is horrified by my proposition. But for some reason, I live in a country where I am told that I’m merely “woke” for dehumanizing some other group and supporting their “removal”, so to speak. And in this country, we seem confused because we’re under the impression that imposing our will on someone dependent on us for survival actually means “my body, my choice”.

Call it what you like. We have people marching for “abortion on demand, without apology”, prospective pro-life groups being banned from forming on high school and college campuses, support for abortion is the litmus test for one of the United States’ two major political parties, and, if you’re like me, you’re called a misogynist at the March for Life because you oppose this dehumanization. Call it celebration, call it expectation, call it whatever you like.
 
Nobody celebrates abortion. They celebrate living in a country that allows its citizens the right to choose what they do with their own body. That is the celebration.
That would not be quite correct. Feminists have been celebrating abortion for a very long time. Long before it was even legal (see the 1916 movie Where are My Children?) and long before people were saying it is just a zygote. It is a celebration of freedom from responsibility. There is a whole lot more to the issue of abortion than a woman deciding what to do with her body. Not only that who decides what to do with the baby’s body?
Abortion is an unpleasant (at best) medical procedure for any woman to sustain
It is not a medical procedure in that “medical” refers to the science of medicine and the treatment of illnesses and injuries.
At worst, it can be painful and dangerous.
This part I would completely agree with. Much of the pain a woman will face will be the PTSD that follows them afterwards and yes it is dangerous. Anytime an invasive procedure is done on a person there is danger involved. Many women have had serious medical complications post abortion.

With all that, the biggest thing and the best thing we need to let post abortive women know is that God is a God of mercy and healing and as the OP said, we need to pray for these confused Catholics who support such a thing. God is waiting always with open arms.
 
Last edited:
Judging others…
“I am a good Catholic. I do this and that, and so many other things. You don’t. You need to be a better Catholic…”
 
But who are you to know, if a brother or sister is sinning.
Are you a self-appointed Catholic police person?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top