Hi, Shredderbeam,
Let me take two of your response and work with it …
It’s not that I’m not willing to acknowledge a pattern maker, it’s that I simply don’t find Aquinas’s teleological argument particularly convincing.
You’re describing my argument as illogical, but you haven’t told me why. You haven’t demonstrated that complex patterns always need a pattern creator.
These two statements are tied to the same idea, so I will treat them as one.
If you saw the video link I posted, here you have visual proof of the incredible complexity of a developing human being. As the narrator stated, it is complexity that just staggers the intellect of all who study this. Now, look around … look in a mirror, in your house, down the block, in your neighborhood, in your city … and while you could go on … you can stop there. Look at all the humans! . What we are really looking is the evidence of patterns… Now, look at a modern automobile manufacturing plant.
Here we have very sophisticated technology in the form of various computer chips going into cars to mix gasoline and air in the correct proportions to enter each cylinder at the right time to turn a crank to move a car forward. Complex? Yes, without a doubt. How is this compared to a human would be like comparing a Swiss watch to wooden building blocks! The human body is far more complex and sophisticated. Yet, no one thinks that cars with all of this technology … just happen! There is a Chief of Engineering that is responsible for all of these items coming together so that a blueprint can be drawn to get the ideas down to the shop floor so the car can be built. There really is a pattern maker who is responsible for the car you drive. There really is a Pattern Maker for you. And, that is the logic of the process
Here’s the thing: I don’t believe that Jesus actually came back from the dead. If I thought he had, I wouldn’t be an atheist. That would be rather stupid of me.
Just imagine for a minute that you are in charge of an orgaization with a long and established history. People look up to you - and, you demand their respect! Your word and opinion counts! Suddenly, some ‘country bumpkin’ comes into your organization and challenges you, embarrasses you in front of your subordinates, humiliates you by doing things that you wish you could do, but can’t. This guy causes you to lay awake a night - not thinking of how you can do better - but, on how you can get rid of him and his annoying manners. Finally, you come across a plan - not necessarly the high point of your career becaues it involves framing this guy of a crime he did not do, lying about it to the point of purjury, encouraging others to suborn purjury and then watching as civil authorities carry out the death penalty. Hey, he is out of your hair - and it is business as usual! No one can stop you from going back to your old and familar ways. But, then you think - maybe some sicko will steal his dead body and try to pretend he rose from the dead.
You have your own security guards - and they are armed - so you post them by the tomb. In 72 hours no one is going to steal a rotting corpse and this will be one bad dream you just woke up from. But, then you got the word that the security guards let you down - and they were obviously too drunk to see what happened because they spun this incredible story of blinding lights and angels. His body was stolen by followers of this major annoyance in your life! But, you will expose them for the frauds they are - he died and that is that. Since you could not do the deeds he could do - neither can any of his followers. In another 24-48 hours you will expose them for what they really are. But, you had better take that seething hatred and move quickly to do this exposing. But, you fail!
Now, just think about this little story for a minute. The high priest Ananias was in such a position. He hated Christ because of jealousy. He was determined to have Christ killed and worked very hard to do this and break every Commandment necessary to bring this about. Do you honestly think that a bunch of bumbling fishermen could steal a rotting corpse and claim Christ rose from the dead and ruin your plans - and you not expose them for the frauds they obviously were. I mean, everyone knows that no one had arose from the dead (oh, yeah, there were these annoying stories about some widow having her only son who died being brought back to life, and then there was that annoying story about some buddy named Lazarus being dead for 3 days and being rasied by the dead…but, these were just stories designed to capture the simple minded.) His followers weill quickly be unmasked - and you had all the manpower, money, and equipment to do the unmasking! Odd, despite all this - His followers continue to this very day.
You know, the original 12 Apostles were obviously foolish men who were enchanted by a charismatic speaker. And, those others who saw Christ - well, they must have been enchanted, too! But until the Edict of Milar in 313AD there were murderous persecutions cdonducted by the Roman Empire against these early followers of Christ - called Catholics. These people were 10 generations removed by Christ - and they were dying for what He said. A person may be crazy enough to die for a charismtic leader … but, someone 10 generations removed doing the same thing is very unlikely. Today - over 100 generations removed from Christ, His followers are still being killed for believing in Him.
I think this is compelling evidence.
You think whatever you want.
God bless