Hunting Animals - Your Opinion

  • Thread starter Thread starter Seagull
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Seagull

Guest
What’s your opinion on hunting animals - for sport ?

A man was recently on the news who killed a family of monkeys - back lash.
He had to resign from his position as Idaho commissioner - ( fishing and game official ).

I don’t like it.
Africa - isn’t what it used to be.
Human population seems to be abounding -

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
Hunting can be done responsibly to manage populations and balance ecosystems. The picture you included with the giraffe makes me cringe, but pictures of my family hunting squirrels to make squirrel gumbo do not.

Edit: during squirrel season with proper licenses.
 
Last edited:
Several of my friends are hunters, but they hunt deer and wild turkeys primarily for the meat, and if one of them gets a trophy buck, so be it. Years ago, I was in the military, stationed in an area where 90% of the work force was employed in the copper mines. When the mines shut down, the locals were hunting to feed their families, and the sheriff would look the other way, but if he caught a trophy hunter from ‘the city’ hunting out of season, he’d ‘throw the book at him’. A wise man.
 
Humans need to eat meat - vegans have to do a lot of diet gymnastics to make sure they meet all of their nutritional needs without eating meat. I don’t agree with hunting for sport/trophy, but I have no problem with people hunting for food. I would be a hunter, but my wife is convinced that meat comes from the grocery store.
 
I do regular mission work in Africa, Tanzania to be specific.

As such, I very much support the hunting efforts done there.

You are correct, the human population is expanding, and that is a good thing. Everyone of those people was specifically created by God, therefore God wants them to be.

In modern Africa, there are a number of nature preserves, areas where the animals are shielded from human pressure. Again, a good thing.

The problem is that nature preserves require animal management to ensure healthy populations. In a preserve, the animals cannot be allowed to breed to such an extent that they overwhelm the ability of the land to support them ( called ‘carry capacity’)

So that leaves the park management with two options. PAY someone to kill the excess animals, or sell hunting licenses and have someone PAY to do their work for them. Pretty much a ‘no brainer’, especially when the funds can be used to hire more park rangers and buy equipment to go after poachers.

On the plus side, the meat gained from legitimate hunting is generally given to the local population. That is a major plus, as the local diets are very short in protein. Contrast that to poaching, where the meat is simply left to rot.

I know quite a number of people, faithful Catholics, whose livelihood is positively impacted by the money that hunters spend. Because it is not just the hunting license fees that the hunters bring, but money spend on food, accommodations, purchasing local crafts.

So it is easy to sit here in our comfortable, Western world, and decry pictures of hunters with giraffe, lions etc… but in every effort I see to ban legitimate hunting, I see only attempts to economically hurt I lot of people that I deeply care about. And that giraffe or lion or whatever was going to be shot anyway, most likely by a park ranger, as it’s death was needed as part of scientific wildlife management.
 
A man was recently on the news who killed a family of monkeys
Where on Earth is hunting monkeys legal? i don’t know of any and it sounds more like it was illegal poaching which I strongly condemn. those kind of jerks wreck it for the rest of us. i enjoy hunting. I always eat what i harvest. I know a few people who do not eat the game the harvest but they donate to someone who will. I don’t know how wide spread it it is but around me there is a program called hunters helping the hungry or something similar to that. I find nothing wrong with hunting and the hunting community by and large is fairly involved in conservation efforts.
 
Humans need to eat meat - vegans have to do a lot of diet gymnastics to make sure they meet all of their nutritional needs without eating meat. I don’t agree with hunting for sport/trophy, but I have no problem with people hunting for food. I would be a hunter, but my wife is convinced that meat comes from the grocery store.
Totally agree with this.

Hunting and fishing because we need the food is one thing.

Hunting and fishing for “sport,” for the “joy” of killing the animals, is something completely different.
 
I’m not a fan of sport hunting, mainly because it’s unnecessarily wasteful. If you’re hunting for food, or to take out a predatory animal, or something along those lines then hunting’s fine. I wouldn’t do it unless I had to, but there’s nothing innately wrong about it.

Hunting just to kill, on the other hand, seems… wasteful.
 
They were baboons, not monkeys, and the hunt was legal. Which is not to say that posting the picture with the dead animals was a smart thing to do. On the other hand, I believe he also “trophy hunted” a giraffe, for which he had a permit, but which I find repulsive.
 
If hunting is necessary, it’s necessary. But all too often it isn’t, and I disagree with hunting for sport.
 
The average man does not need to hunt for food we have farms, butchers and supermarkets to buy any kind of meat you want, that way the animals are killed humanely.
 
Last edited:
Where on Earth is hunting monkeys legal?
In addition to what was mentioned, it’s also legal in parts of South America. (I recall seeing that show where two guys would live with a secluded tribe for a while and one of the tribes hunted monkey.)
The average man does not need to hunt for food we have butchers and supermarkets to buy any kind of meat you want, that way the animals are killed humanely.
Near where I live in the U.S. the forest preserves have a high population of deer that need controlling. By allowing hunting, the deer population is controlled and people get their meat.

I’d also say that while the death of a farm animal may be more peaceful, it’s life is a subject for debate.
 
high population of deer that need controlling.
I agree, I supported fox hunting here in the UK because it was pest control, the pack of dogs would kill the fox immediately but shooting does not guarantee instant death.
 
40.png
Xystus:
Where on Earth is hunting monkeys legal?
Most of Africa. Certain species, such as vervets, are commonly considered to be ‘pest’ animals, similar to racoons in the US.
I learned something new today, thanks. I take take back calling him a poacher.
 
My brother and brother in law are avid hunters. They hunt deer, dove, turkeys etc. They eat what they kill and that is my philosophy. If you kill it, eat it.
 
Baboons are monkeys. The greater apes are: gorillas, orangutans, chimpanzees and bonobos. The lesser apes are gibbons and siamangs. The rest are either old world monkeys or new world monkeys. (Edited for clarity).
 
Last edited:
From what I know foxes do not die immediately when torn apart by a pack of hounds.

If I lived in Africa I don’t think I’d be too happy about the lions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top