I can't stand other Catholics

Status
Not open for further replies.
Before you ask the obvious question, I’m here to get answers for my questions about the faith.
Keep em’ coming

Nearly all Catholics I meet are of the cafeteria variety. I can’t stand them. I was a liberal atheist once, and the less reverent forms of Catholicism are too much like what I left.
**Well, believe it or not, most Catholics don’t practice their faith. I think it was close to 10% of Catholics in Europe and 25% in America that go to Mass every Sunday, one of the most basic precepts of the Church. It wouldn’t be illogical to presume that the majority of Catholics would not agree with one Church teaching or another. Catholics who are practising and are faithful to the teachings of the Church are a minority. I am presuming that you are talking about in public of course, rather than those in the pews. **

I have three choices. I can turn away from Catholics altogether.
Extra Ecclesiam Nulla Salus.

I can join a schismatic section that is more obedient to Church teaching.
As far as I know they wouldn’t fulfill the Sunday obligation because they are excommunicated per Can. 1364 §1. They also wouldn’t have faculties for various sacraments.

Or I can learn to like these people who turn away from God to keep up their cherished sins while calling themselves Catholic.
Unless they are running about publicly proclaiming they are pro-abortion and Catholic, I don’t think it is suitable to state this. Only God judges souls.

I would like to meet another Catholic who loves God like I do, but that’s obviously not part of God’s will for me. I’m leaning toward the first choice and want to avoid the second. But I’m willing to do the third if I can. I’m just not sure I can.
You must be very careful of pride here. "I would like to meet another Catholic who loves God like I do" is a very judgemental and somewhat prideful statement, in my eyes. We have absolutely no right to judge the sincerity of another’s faith.

Is it all right not to be part of the Catholic community if I still love God and my neighbor? (I’m working on loving my neighbor, but it’s really hard)
Nope.

Any help would be appreciated.
You could try another parish, run by traditionalist priests such as the FSSP and ICKSP. I would take puzzleannie’s advice to heart.

I suggest that you also read the following and reflect on it, I think I just might too.
[9] To some who were confident of their own righteousness and looked down on everybody else, Jesus told this parable: [10] "Two men went up to the temple to pray, one a Pharisee and the other a tax collector. [11] The Pharisee stood up and prayed about himself: ‘God, I thank you that I am not like other men – robbers, evildoers, adulterers – or even like this tax collector. [12] I fast twice a week and give a tenth of all I get.’
[13] "But the tax collector stood at a distance. He would not even look up to heaven, but beat his breast and said, ‘God, have mercy on me, a sinner.’
[14] “I tell you that this man, rather than the other, went home justified before God. For everyone who exalts himself will be humbled, and he who humbles himself will be exalted.”
Luke 18:9-14
God Bless and good luck.
 
How can one claim to be of God when they don’t see God in every person they meet?

Jesus hung out with prostitutes and murders, so if a few cafeteria catholics are your problem, then you have it made!

God speed,
Joshua
 
You could always try another parish like the others have said here.I commute back and forth so I hang out with 2-3 different parishes on occasion and there is a difference in terms of community.

But things take time. I had similar feelings like that before I went to RCIA. But I decided not to take these sorts of things so seriously and just be humble. I got to know more about other people and I focused on their good points. My experiences have become richer since then.
 
OK, there seem to be a few points I haven’t been clear enough about.

A cafeteria “Catholic” is not a devout Catholic who makes mistakes, or a Catholic who is simply ignorant. We all sin, we all make mistakes, and ignorance can be fixed. I am talking specifically about people who know what the teachings are and disagree that they are God’s laws, and yet claim to be practicing Catholics. Nearly every Catholic I meet is one of those, in one way or another.

When I said that one of my options is to avoid other Catholics, I did not mean I would stop going to Mass. I was talking about not seeking their company. There are so many non-Catholics who need the Gospel, and I do more for them by bringing them into the Church than by socializing with people I hope will be as devout as I am, and yet turn out to be supporters of such sins as abortion, fornication, etc., especially the etc.

And frankly, I’m appalled by how many of you took this opportunity to judge me as some kind of self-righteous jerk. This is exactly the intolerance of intolerance I’m complaining about from liberals. I’ll have you know I’ve sacrificed many a weekend to help some lost soul or other experience the joy I get from knowing God. Shame on you.
 
My :twocents: ,
read & meditate on Mark 12:28-33.
OK, there seem to be a few points I haven’t been clear enough about.

A cafeteria “Catholic” is not a devout Catholic who makes mistakes, or a Catholic who is simply ignorant. We all sin, we all make mistakes, and ignorance can be fixed. I am talking specifically about people who know what the teachings are and disagree that they are God’s laws, and yet claim to be practicing Catholics. Nearly every Catholic I meet is one of those, in one way or another.

When I said that one of my options is to avoid other Catholics, I did not mean I would stop going to Mass. I was talking about not seeking their company. There are so many non-Catholics who need the Gospel, and I do more for them by bringing them into the Church than by socializing with people I hope will be as devout as I am, and yet turn out to be supporters of such sins as abortion, fornication, etc., especially the etc.

And frankly, I’m appalled by how many of you took this opportunity to judge me as some kind of self-righteous jerk. This is exactly the intolerance of intolerance I’m complaining about from liberals. I’ll have you know I’ve sacrificed many a weekend to help some lost soul or other experience the joy I get from knowing God. Shame on you.
 
Before you ask the obvious question, I’m here to get answers for my questions about the faith.

Nearly all Catholics I meet are of the cafeteria variety. I can’t stand them. I was a liberal atheist once, and the less reverent forms of Catholicism are too much like what I left.

I have three choices. I can turn away from Catholics altogether. I can join a schismatic section that is more obedient to Church teaching. Or I can learn to like these people who turn away from God to keep up their cherished sins while calling themselves Catholic. I would like to meet another Catholic who loves God like I do, but that’s obviously not part of God’s will for me. I’m leaning toward the first choice and want to avoid the second. But I’m willing to do the third if I can. I’m just not sure I can.

Is it all right not to be part of the Catholic community if I still love God and my neighbor? (I’m working on loving my neighbor, but it’s really hard)

Any help would be appreciated.
Our devotion to and love for God are in direct proportion to our love for neighbor-one doesn’t exist without the other from my understanding. Our faith can be quite a challenge. 🙂
 
Our devotion to and love for God are in direct proportion to our love for neighbor-one doesn’t exist without the other from my understanding. Our faith can be quite a challenge. 🙂
This is what I was trying to get across.

I think I’m gunna have to back out of this conversation because it is very very frustrating to me and I find it angering me.

God’s blessing for all of you,
Joshua
 
OK, there seem to be a few points I haven’t been clear enough about.

A cafeteria “Catholic” is not a devout Catholic who makes mistakes, or a Catholic who is simply ignorant. We all sin, we all make mistakes, and ignorance can be fixed. I am talking specifically about people who know what the teachings are and disagree that they are God’s laws, and yet claim to be practicing Catholics. Nearly every Catholic I meet is one of those, in one way or another.

When I said that one of my options is to avoid other Catholics, I did not mean I would stop going to Mass. I was talking about not seeking their company. There are so many non-Catholics who need the Gospel, and I do more for them by bringing them into the Church than by socializing with people I hope will be as devout as I am, and yet turn out to be supporters of such sins as abortion, fornication, etc., especially the etc.

And frankly, I’m appalled by how many of you took this opportunity to judge me as some kind of self-righteous jerk. This is exactly the intolerance of intolerance I’m complaining about from liberals. I’ll have you know I’ve sacrificed many a weekend to help some lost soul or other experience the joy I get from knowing God. Shame on you.
I apologise, but maybe you could of been a bit more clear in your description.
 
And frankly, I’m appalled by how many of you took this opportunity to judge me as some kind of self-righteous jerk. This is exactly the intolerance of intolerance I’m complaining about from liberals. I’ll have you know I’ve sacrificed many a weekend to help some lost soul or other experience the joy I get from knowing God. Shame on you.
I hope you don’t take it too harshly. Most of the responses seem to be genuine advice coming from a place of brotherly love (mine was anyways!). It’s easy to become defensive, but try not to be. You asked for some advice, and this is the advice given. No one is judging YOU, just assessing the situation. The internet is anonymous, blind, and uninformed of the complexity of your situation. All we can do is read, “I am devout, these others are not devout, it drives me crazy. I’ve got several options on the table including leaving the church.” Its possible this was misunderstood though…it happens easily on forums. But, we take what we can and then we advise the best we can. Of course the situation I crudely summarized is more nuanced than that, but when it boils down to it we are just trying to get to the root of the issue and help! 🙂

Also, be aware that ignorance comes in many forms. You can’t really say someone is not ignorant…how can you know? We are usually completely ignorant when it comes to knowing the level of ignorance in other people. 🙂 You would have to know a person quite intimately to know what they really know and believe, and what they don’t. Someone can know the church teachings, but not understand them, or not know them enough to trust and have faith in them. Or they are just weak…living a life of sin…and they can’t come to terms with some of the precepts of the church because they would be condemning their own souls in their mind. Some people are just not at a place in their life where they can handle that. There are so many different possibilities.

If you think you can spread the Gospel to unbelievers, you should! In the end, your frustration is founded in a love for God, and there is nothing wrong with that. Just do your best to love and forgive your brothers and sisters, and not resent them. 🙂 That’s all.

edit: I used the word “we” but I can’t speak for everyone. It’s important for people to give advice with charity, and some people could have been a bit more gentle I agree.
 
OK, there seem to be a few points I haven’t been clear enough about.

A cafeteria “Catholic” is not a devout Catholic who makes mistakes, or a Catholic who is simply ignorant. We all sin, we all make mistakes, and ignorance can be fixed. I am talking specifically about people who know what the teachings are and disagree that they are God’s laws, and yet claim to be practicing Catholics. Nearly every Catholic I meet is one of those, in one way or another.

When I said that one of my options is to avoid other Catholics, I did not mean I would stop going to Mass. I was talking about not seeking their company. There are so many non-Catholics who need the Gospel, and I do more for them by bringing them into the Church than by socializing with people I hope will be as devout as I am, and yet turn out to be supporters of such sins as abortion, fornication, etc., especially the etc.

And frankly, I’m appalled by how many of you took this opportunity to judge me as some kind of self-righteous jerk. This is exactly the intolerance of intolerance I’m complaining about from liberals. I’ll have you know I’ve sacrificed many a weekend to help some lost soul or other experience the joy I get from knowing God. Shame on you.
Try not to take the comments too personal. You are getting some tough love, that’s for sure.

I am glad you posted this thread, however, as I struggle with intolerance for “cafeteria Catholics” as well. :o I go to confession and pray for God to help me with this…I will add you to my prayers.
 
And frankly, I’m appalled by how many of you took this opportunity to judge me as some kind of self-righteous jerk. .
I didn’t see that happening. I hope you will bring up this issue in Reconciliation very soon and get advice from a priest who is more qualified than people posting on forums.
 
I didn’t see that happening. I hope you will bring up this issue in Reconciliation very soon and get advice from a priest who is more qualified than people posting on forums.
I’m not the OP and I saw the judgmental comments. 🤷 Some people on this thread were really quick to judge the OP as quickly as he was to judge other Catholics. It’s ridiculous.
 
I’m not the OP and I saw the judgmental comments. 🤷 Some people on this thread were really quick to judge the OP as quickly as he was to judge other Catholics. It’s ridiculous.
I think it’s important to draw a distinction between judging a person and judging their actions. We are not to judge another person, only God should do that. However, we are absolutely called to discern right from wrong, and point this out to others. Saying to someone “you are being judgmental right now” is not a judgment in terms of “don’t judge lest ye be judged.” It is actually a mercy!

However, if one were to say “you are a judgmental person and a jerk” that is inappropriate.
I hope no one said this to the OP, and if they did, he should ignore them.
 
I think it’s important to draw a distinction between judging a person and judging their actions. We are not to judge another person, only God should do that. However, we are absolutely called to discern right from wrong, and point this out to others. Saying to someone “you are being judgmental right now” is not a judgment in terms of “don’t judge lest ye be judged.” It is actually a mercy!

However, if one were to say “you are a judgmental person and a jerk” that is inappropriate.
I hope no one said this to the OP, and if they did, he should ignore them.
I won’t argue the point. I am aware of the distinction between judging the action and the person but I believe some people on this thread crossed that line, if only with a toe.

That’s just my opinion. 🤷 And I agree. The OP should ignore them but I know it can be frustrating when you come with a legitimate question and instead you get judged and railed on.

CAF - they certainly believe in tough love.
 
In such a circumstance where one finds oneself less
than enthusiastic, it helps to remember that Faith
comes to us as a gift. We can’t and don’t deserve it.
It is a free gift from Almighty God. We must cherish it.

Knowing that fact at every moment, one can only
pray for an increase in Faith, Hope and Charity for
ourself and for all who are believers. Literally, one
must remember to thank God for such a gift and in doing
that (as St. Paul says we must) we might find ourselves
far less likely to criticize anyone else.

Given the fact that we are in posession of the
greatest gift, Faith, we need to remember to pray
for all who have grown tired or lukewarm or upset.
If our faith is truly strong, then the call to us is to work
to uphold our brethern in their weaknesses. In this
way, we uphold and preserve the Body of Christ.
 
In such a circumstance where one finds oneself less
than enthusiastic, it helps to remember that Faith
comes to us as a gift. We can’t and don’t deserve it.
It is a free gift from Almighty God. We must cherish it.

Knowing that fact at every moment, one can only
pray for an increase in Faith, Hope and Charity for
ourself and for all who are believers. Literally, one
must remember to thank God for such a gift and in doing
that (as St. Paul says we must) we might find ourselves
far less likely to criticize anyone else.

Given the fact that we are in posession of the
greatest gift, Faith, we need to remember to pray
for all who have grown tired or lukewarm or upset.
If our faith is truly strong, then the call to us is to work
to uphold our brethern in their weaknesses. In this
way, we uphold and preserve the Body of Christ.
👍 Exactly. To whom much has been given, much will be expected.
 
One priest said to lighten up in regards to other people. They just might be standing right next to you in heaven.🙂 I used to cringe and gnash my teeth at the shennanigans during Mass, the ignorance, etc. Now not so much.
I know what you mean and perhaps the underlying problem is complacency. I’m a revert and sometimes am glad of it because I don’t take my faith for granted. But there are cradle Catholics who never left the church who are not lukewarm in their faith. Where?
Hey, I know…why can’t the Catholic people in CAF be in my parish!!!😃
 
Turn every moment of annoyance into a prayer for the person! The instant you feel the annoyance rising in your mind or emotions, say “aloud” in your heart, “O God, bless that person and save their soul!”

You can also offer bearing the annoyances patiently in reparation for your own sins, in thanksgiving for your conversion from atheism (glory to God for that!), and for the conversion of the people in question!

The suggestion of joining a schismatic sect is the devil whispering in your ear… :hmmm:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top