ID in public schools

  • Thread starter Thread starter edwest2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Miracles have everything to do with ID and evolution. The only kind of ID I believe in is the one that says God is the Intelligent Designer. The only kind of evolution that works is the God intervened kind. Not the evolutionary theory in textbooks.

And some people seem to think that God does not intervene in His Creation. The Living God does so all the time. He performs miracles, now, today. He operates on “natural” reality in a supernatural way because He is God. No one has unique access to doing science. The 400 year old Pontifical Academy of Sciences does science. I do not separate science from the Church.

God bless,
Ed
 
Miracles have everything to do with ID and evolution.
Hmm… don’t see any connection between miracles and evolution. Have you forgotten the definition of “miracle” again?
 
Miracles have everything to do with ID and evolution.
I must admit, I would probably pay good money not to have that explained to me in detail, but, Catholic guilt compels me to give an honest response. From the Catholic Encyclopedia:
Miracle
(Latin miraculum, from mirari, “to wonder”).
In general, a wonderful thing, the word being so used in classical Latin; in a specific sense, the Latin Vulgate designates by miracula wonders of a peculiar kind, expressed more clearly in the Greek text by the terms terata, dynameis, semeia, i.e., wonders performed by supernatural power as signs of some special mission or gift and explicitly ascribed to God.
So, honestly and sincerely, I can actually see how two items could be loosely connected. Evolution is a theory to explain the measurable and observable world around us. Since one of the most wonderous things we are aware of is our own existance, it potentially brushes against both definitions (though not in the same context, one is science, the other theology).

But I don’t get how ID fits in. It is the opposite of the Greek definition, instead of wonder, it is the rejection of the observable world. It also seems sadly lacking in the Latin Vulgate usage. Since it actually strives to diminish the complexity and scope of God’s creation.
The only kind of ID I believe in is…
But didn’t you also believe that the Church prohibited belief in abortion? You cited a lay article, but after I highlighted the parts (quoted from the Church) that stated the opposite of your interpretation, the subject disappeared.

Do you still ‘believe’? If so, what possible context is there for discussion? You seemingly reject science because measurements and observations don’t match your beliefs and you also seemingly reject Catholic doctrine and theology, since you show zero interest in reading even what you quote in that area.

This leaves us with only a context of “What Ed Believes”. My response, with all due respect, is, fine, I get it. We now all know what Ed believes. Let’s just stop pretending that it is anything beyond that, like Science or Catholic Doctrine.
 
Basically if we go down the scientific route we are putting God in a materialistic box and saying - tou HAVE to act like this.
Excellent point. By excluding God’s influence and role, science makes a statement about God.
 
But I don’t get how ID fits in. It is the opposite of the Greek definition, instead of wonder, it is the rejection of the observable world. It also seems sadly lacking in the Latin Vulgate usage. Since it actually strives to diminish the complexity and scope of God’s creation.
I have a comment only on this portion of your post.

Beyond what I say below, I’m not going to argue about what ID is, or isn’t. I’m just trying to give you another perspective.

I’m not sure where you got your definition of ID, but it doesn’t seem to be accurate. The way I look at it, ID makes an assumption that when creating the universe 14 billion years ago, God left some “tracks” so to speak. The finely tuned fundamental constants of the universe for example. Things that can’t happen by chance. Elements of design. Things we can explore, using science amongst other things, so we can better understand and appreciate the complexity and scope of God’s creation, and stand in greater awe of God.

Finding design in nature does not diminish God or God’s creation, quite the opposite. God isn’t hiding from us, in fact, he wants us to search for him in every possible way. God is quite clearly identified in the Bible (Psalms, Book of Wisdom, etc) as a designer, whose designs we should appreciate. How can we do this if we deny that the universe was actually designed, and therefore deny God?

ID is not the rejection of the observable world. ID actually is taking what we already know of the observable world, the data, the science, the math, and looking within that data for elements of design. “Tracks”.

ID is the opposite of those who say there is no design in the universe, and therefore no Designer. Everything happens according to the anonymous “laws of nature”, with no outside influences needed, not even a lawgiver to make those laws. They say that you shouldn’t look for design, because it’s not there, it can’t be there. And even if it were there, science couldn’t find it. This attitude seems to me to be abandoning the capabilities that God gave us to search, explore, & reason.

A good book on this subject is “A Meaningful World” by Wiker & Witt. This is a “pro-ID” book (IMO), it’s entire purpose being to help us appreciate God’s wondrous creation from the perspectives of art, science, human genius, & even mathematics. If you’d like to better appreciate God’s creation, and the some of the “design” behind it, read this book.
 
ID has become a political weapon wielded by anarchists that call themselves the Discovery Institute. Their methods are questionable and not Christian. Unfortunately, anarchists have only one goal and that is to cause strife.

The Catholic Church recognizes design in nature:

catholiceducation.org/articles/science/sc0060.html

But one of the anarchists’ hobbies is to discredit something. They think by discrediting something it will go away. Eveyone will react negatively whenever they hear the discredited subject brought up again. Not so. Not everyone.

God bless,
Ed
 
"The commission’s document, however, reaffirms the perennial teaching of the Catholic Church about the reality of design in nature. Commenting on the widespread abuse of John Paul’s 1996 letter on evolution, the commission cautions that "the letter cannot be read as a blanket approbation of all theories of evolution, including those of a neo-Darwinian provenance which explicitly deny to divine providence any truly causal role in the development of life in the universe."

And that’s fine. Evolutionary theory does not, and cannot deny anything at all concerning God. Good to see that Shonborn is in agreement with the Magesterium on this.
 
"abucs:
Quote:
obviously i realized when i wrote about being scientific that the theory is supposed to come last. But in reality i would argue that this is not really so.
I can’t think of an example like that right now.
Many scientific hypotheses started with simply a philosophical thought. The universe, for example was thought of as being eternal and static. This was a philosophical opinion having such an influence that even Dr. Einstein “invented” a cosmological constant in order for his model of the universe to remain static.
The atomic theory is another philosophical opinion which was later tested for it’s validity as an hypothesis. Incidently, Dalton’s view of the atom is not what Aristotle had in mind, as the atom is not
the ultimate indivisible particle. Quantum Mechanics would be considered closer to Aristotle’s atomic view, where even spacetime is now believed to be quantized…that is, having indivisible discrete numerical values.

Andre
 
Many scientific hypotheses started with simply a philosophical thought. The universe, for example was thought of as being eternal and static. This was a philosophical opinion having such an influence that even Dr. Einstein “invented” a cosmological constant in order for his model of the universe to remain static.
Yes. Hypotheses, but not theories.
The atomic theory is another philosophical opinion which was later tested for it’s validity as an hypothesis.
Actually, Democritus cited various kinds of evidence for his theory of atoms. It was, for it’s time, a remarkably good theory, and explained what was then known about matter. Remarkably, he correctly inferred that taste was the result of different shaped atoms on the tongue.
Incidently, Dalton’s view of the atom is not what Aristotle had in mind, as the atom is not the ultimate indivisible particle.
Aristotle didn’t like the idea of atoms, and consider matter to be composed of varying parts of four elements; earth, water, air, and fire. And Dalton proposed Democritus’s atoms; indivisible.
Quantum Mechanics would be considered closer to Aristotle’s atomic view, where even spacetime is now believed to be quantized…
Um, could you expand a bit on that one?
 
Because of experimental results it is thought that at the quantum level matter ‘jumps’ from one discrete space to another without going through a continuous space.

The previous idea of continuous space, has in the theory at least been replaced by an idea of space being divided up into discrete points.

The religious like me would think that all matter is a projection from a deeper reality as would materialistic scientists.

Where we differ would be that we beleive that deeper reality has intelligence (God) and the scientific materialist would beleive it contains a natural mechanistic process - hence string theory defined in 10 dimensions.

Both would go with the experimental results that suggest space is not continuous and would postulate ‘other realms’ acting on our discrete space reality.

Not sure where Aristotle stood on such matters but i guess Zeno was involved there somewhere with his ancient discrete space paradoxes.

Respect.
 
I’m not sure where you got your definition of ID, but it doesn’t seem to be accurate.
Innaccurate how? If a ‘theory’ is inherently untestable, it isn’t science.

So it is theology, but is it good theology? God has to leave tracks? Finding those ‘tracks’ is better to appreciate his awe?

It is just another form of constraining God. What happens when and if we better understand dark energy, or dark matter? We know from looking that there is a force at work other than gravity, similiary, we can actually map dark matter’s presence by the way it bends light.

What if the constants then go in flux? Does that ‘disprove’ the existance of God?

How is this any different from literalist interpretations of Genesis. The moon does not glow, it only reflects light from the son - does this contradiction from Genesis ‘disprove’ the existance of God?

What is the point in arbitrarily assigning special significance to one particular aspect of nature, when we know from centuries of experience that our understanding of the natural world continues to expand, shift, and grow?
 
Many scientific hypotheses started with simply a philosophical thought. The universe, for example was thought of as being eternal and static. This was a philosophical opinion having such an influence that even Dr. Einstein “invented” a cosmological constant in order for his model of the universe to remain static.
The atomic theory is another philosophical opinion which was later tested for it’s validity as an hypothesis. Incidently, Dalton’s view of the atom is not what Aristotle had in mind, as the atom is not
the ultimate indivisible particle. Quantum Mechanics would be considered closer to Aristotle’s atomic view, where even spacetime is now believed to be quantized…that is, having indivisible discrete numerical values.
Your examples are an explanation of why we have the scientific method and peer review. Einstein developed a theory to explain some anamolous data. He concocted the Cosmological Constant because he didn’t like, emotionally, that it implied that the universe must be either expanding or contracting.

He later described it as his largest blunder. None of us is perfectly objective, but Einstein is a pretty good poster child. He loathed the implications of quantum mechanics, but still contributed to the development of the theories (it is for that work he was awarded the Nobel Prize).

As for the rest, I’m not sure I follow your point. I suppose one could argue that Aristotle’s views are vaguely like some modern theories. But we could also argue that Genesis is vaguely like big bang and evolution theory - in form one would explain them to a child (or a drunk shriner). In hindsight, Einstein might have guessed right, since we are still looking to explain the accellerating nature of the universe’s expansion, but the similiarity between dark energy theory and the cosmological constant do not make Einstein a prophet in the world of science.
 
Innaccurate how? If a ‘theory’ is inherently untestable, it isn’t science.
Nowhere did I say that it was testable, or that it was science.

I was responding to your comment (I guess it wasn’t really a definition):But I don’t get how ID fits in. It is the opposite of the Greek definition, instead of wonder, it is the rejection of the observable world.
God has to leave tracks? Finding those ‘tracks’ is better to appreciate his awe?
No God doesn’t have to leave tracks. But what if he did?

I am an engineer and tend to look for “designs” anyway. When I see a good one, I appreciate it. Other people would not respond this way. I’m not saying that finding tracks of design will lead to more awe for everyone, just as finding “beauty” in nature is more likely to inspire awe for “artistic” types.
It is just another form of constraining God. What happens when and if we better understand dark energy, or dark matter? We know from looking that there is a force at work other than gravity, similiary, we can actually map dark matter’s presence by the way it bends light.
Dark Matter / Energy is a whole nother discussion.

Looking for God’s hand in nature is not constraining God. It is using the abilities he gave us to better appreciate his works.
What if the constants then go in flux? Does that ‘disprove’ the existance of God?
Of course not. That’s ludicrous. This is not a situation of “If I find tracks, God exists. If I don’t then God doesn’t exist.” Finding tracks is a bonus, that will help some better appreciate the glory of creation. But it doesn’t work for everybody.

Actually, if the laws go into flux, then that’s more likely to disprove the existence of science [Note: that was a joke].
How is this any different from literalist interpretations of Genesis. The moon does not glow, it only reflects light from the son - does this contradiction from Genesis ‘disprove’ the existance of God?
Literalist interpretations of Genesis say the earth/universe was created in 6 days. I see no connection to looking for design in nature.
What is the point in arbitrarily assigning special significance to one particular aspect of nature, when we know from centuries of experience that our understanding of the natural world continues to expand, shift, and grow?
Science is composed of many things. Many of these things can give the right person (not all) a better appreciation of God’s works, and therefore a better appreciation of God. Looking for elements of design is just one more aspect of this. One more way of expanding, shifting, and growing our understanding of nature.

BTW - a slightly different subject:

I’ve noticed that you and our good friend Spiritmeadow seem to object to “ID” partly based on the thinking that (paraphasing) “God got it right the first time and doesn’t need to tinker with his creation.” I’m not trying to misrepresent your thinking, so either/both of you correct me if I’m wrong. But something struck me about this that I think is important.

In English, DESIGN is both a verb and a noun. As a verb, it implies a process that takes time, and usually some mistakes that need corrected along the way. As a noun, it means “the final product” so to speak. e.g. The architect points at the skyscraper and says “That’s my design.”

The D in ID is not talking about design as a verb, a mistake filled process, it’s talking about it as a noun, the final product. There is no constant tinkering implied (although for separate non-ID reasons, I tend to think that God interacts with his creation).
 
Yes. Hypotheses, but not theories.
Agreed; my point however being that an hypothesis can come from a philosophical thought, being the reason why I believe the two cannot be separated. Certainly, one can specify and speak of science as measurements made within the observable universe; however,apart from basic science, addressing the fundamental questions of existence,Theoretical Physics goes further.
Actually, Democritus cited various kinds of evidence for his theory of atoms. It was, for it’s time, a remarkably good theory, and explained what was then known about matter. Remarkably, he correctly inferred that taste was the result of different shaped atoms on the tongue.
Sorry; my mistake… I meant Democritus.
I certainly agree with you as to the minds of the Greek philosophers being responsible for structuring the way for the scientific disciplines.
My point would be that, within science classes, when taught about the atomic theory, for instance, the theory starts with Democritus, and not Dalton. That is, it begins with a philosophal thought and grows into being a scientific theory.Both are involved; Democritus being as important as Dalton.
Aristotle didn’t like the idea of atoms, and consider matter to be composed of varying parts of four elements; earth, water, air, and fire. And Dalton proposed Democritus’s atoms; indivisible.
Again, sorry; my mistake.
Um, could you expand a bit on that one?
Simply the notion of Democritus being the universe as quantized into what he called atoms. Quantum Mechanics goes further into hypothizing spacetime as being also quantized.
However, my personal view is that maybe, someday, a deeper relationship between massless particles and those that do have mass might be found. In other words; what if the mass particles are actually made of massless particles, such as photon and the still hypothetical gravitron, and the characteristic of mass would come from the forces involved between such particles? Quantum Mechanics, would then be in need of remodification.

Andre
 
Your examples are an explanation of why we have the scientific method and peer review. Einstein developed a theory to explain some anamolous data. He concocted the Cosmological Constant because he didn’t like, emotionally, that it implied that the universe must be either expanding or contracting.
Agreed; my point being simply that his cosmological constant was based on a philosophical concept; not a scientific one.
He later described it as his largest blunder. None of us is perfectly objective, but Einstein is a pretty good poster child. He loathed the implications of quantum mechanics, but still contributed to the development of the theories (it is for that work he was awarded the Nobel Prize).
true.
As for the rest, I’m not sure I follow your point. I suppose one could argue that Aristotle’s views are vaguely like some modern theories. But we could also argue that Genesis is vaguely like big bang and evolution theory - in form one would explain them to a child (or a drunk shriner).
Greek philosophers’ views nevertheless what eventually developped into science theories. Today a scientific theory is explained by starting with such philosophical views. My point being that science cannot exist without philosophy; that’s all.
In hindsight, Einstein might have guessed right, since we are still looking to explain the accellerating nature of the universe’s expansion, but the similiarity between dark energy theory and the cosmological constant do not make Einstein a prophet in the world of science.
I disagree; eventhough a constant might be advanced in order to explain the increase in magnetude in time, recently observed, for the expansion of the universe, it is important to state that the only reason for Einstein to impliment his constant was for the universe to remain static…I would not associate this as being a lucky guess if a cosmological constant indeed exists, since it would be for the opposite reason as to what Einstein was tryin to achieve.

Andre
 
Greek philosophers’ views nevertheless what eventually developped into science theories. Today a scientific theory is explained by starting with such philosophical views. My point being that science cannot exist without philosophy; that’s all.
Actually all of science hangs on one assumption: uniformitarianism. It’s not “everything is gradual”; it means that the rules have always been the same since the beginning.

If that’s philosophical, then it is. But that’s all science needs.
 
Agreed; my point however being that an hypothesis can come from a philosophical thought, being the reason why I believe the two cannot be separated. Certainly, one can specify and speak of science as measurements made within the observable universe; however,apart from basic science, addressing the fundamental questions of existence,Theoretical Physics goes further.
Physics, as the name indicates, can only address the physical universe. It can go that far, and no farther. So it’s unable (as Pope Benedict said) to be a complete theory of everything. Philosophy and theology can go there, but not science.

Barbarian observes:
Actually, Democritus cited various kinds of evidence for his theory of atoms. It was, for it’s time, a remarkably good theory, and explained what was then known about matter. Remarkably, he correctly inferred that taste was the result of different shaped atoms on the tongue.
Sorry; my mistake… I meant Democritus.
I certainly agree with you as to the minds of the Greek philosophers being responsible for structuring the way for the scientific disciplines.
My point would be that, within science classes, when taught about the atomic theory, for instance, the theory starts with Democritus, and not Dalton.
Properly so. And Dalton merely added atomic mass to Democritus’s theories. Both of them were wrong, in the same sense that Newton was wrong; their theory is valid for most things, but neither is complete. Nuclear chemistry and general relativity were extensions to these theories.
That is, it begins with a philosophal thought and grows into being a scientific theory.Both are involved; Democritus being as important as Dalton.
Sagan has a nice little essay in which he contrasts the ideas of Aristotle and the Ionian philosophers. Aristotle and Socrates were inclined to use reason. The Ionians went out and took a look. For a long time, the Aristotlian way ruled, but eventually the Arabs and then the Europeans went back to empiricism. And that marks the rise of science as an effective tool for understanding.

I think you may be right about the future of quantum mechanics, but I don’t have enough understanding of particle physics to say.
 
I’ve noticed that you and our good friend Spiritmeadow seem to object to “ID” partly based on the thinking that (paraphasing) “God got it right the first time and doesn’t need to tinker with his creation.” I’m not trying to misrepresent your thinking, so either/both of you correct me if I’m wrong. But something struck me about this that I think is important.
No, I resent only the teaching of ID in schools, as science.

However, as far as creationist thinking goes, it is probably important. It is the natural extension of a ‘self importance’ world view.

It falls right in line with arguments on why the earth cannot obrit the sun and why the solar system must be the center of the universe.

If the universe is not static, then change is inevitable. If even our bodies and minds can continue to evolve, then, gasp we may not be the pinacle of creation.

I have no problem with this. The gift of life and thought is already something beyond measure. If it took the wonderous cosmos simply to allow us to exist or rather we are just one voice in a chorus raising our voices to God, I’m happy. I’m here, I can ponder, I can wonder, and I can love.

But other people clearly find this very threatening. A universe with at least 100B galaxys, each with 100B stars makes them feel small, less significant. Seeming uncertainty in the fabric of the universe isn’t seen as a possible source of our own existance or free will, but a sign that they are random, less important, and less safe.

We instinctively don’t like feeling small, alone, afraid, so constraining God and evevating man’s importance in His total creation is probably a normal response. But, since it makes God’s Creation as we can see and measure it, threatening, it probably is counter productive in the long term. God survived a Copernacan solar system and Apolo moon flights just fine…
 
I disagree; eventhough a constant might be advanced in order to explain the increase in magnetude in time, recently observed, for the expansion of the universe, it is important to state that the only reason for Einstein to impliment his constant was for the universe to remain static…I would not associate this as being a lucky guess if a cosmological constant indeed exists, since it would be for the opposite reason as to what Einstein was tryin to achieve.
That was my point.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top