Innaccurate how? If a ‘theory’ is inherently untestable, it isn’t science.
Nowhere did I say that it was testable, or that it was science.
I was responding to your comment (I guess it wasn’t really a definition):But I don’t get how ID fits in. It is the opposite of the Greek definition, instead of wonder, it is the rejection of the observable world.
God has to leave tracks? Finding those ‘tracks’ is better to appreciate his awe?
No God doesn’t have to leave tracks. But what if he did?
I am an engineer and tend to look for “designs” anyway. When I see a good one, I appreciate it. Other people would not respond this way. I’m not saying that finding tracks of design will lead to more awe for everyone, just as finding “beauty” in nature is more likely to inspire awe for “artistic” types.
It is just another form of constraining God. What happens when and if we better understand dark energy, or dark matter? We know from looking that there is a force at work other than gravity, similiary, we can actually map dark matter’s presence by the way it bends light.
Dark Matter / Energy is a whole nother discussion.
Looking for God’s hand in nature is not constraining God. It is using the abilities he gave us to better appreciate his works.
What if the constants then go in flux? Does that ‘disprove’ the existance of God?
Of course not. That’s ludicrous. This is not a situation of “If I find tracks, God exists. If I don’t then God doesn’t exist.” Finding tracks is a bonus, that will help some better appreciate the glory of creation. But it doesn’t work for everybody.
Actually, if the laws go into flux, then that’s more likely to disprove the existence of science [Note: that was a joke].
How is this any different from literalist interpretations of Genesis. The moon does not glow, it only reflects light from the son - does this contradiction from Genesis ‘disprove’ the existance of God?
Literalist interpretations of Genesis say the earth/universe was created in 6 days. I see no connection to looking for design in nature.
What is the point in arbitrarily assigning special significance to one particular aspect of nature, when we know from centuries of experience that our understanding of the natural world continues to expand, shift, and grow?
Science is composed of many things. Many of these things can give the right person (not all) a better appreciation of God’s works, and therefore a better appreciation of God. Looking for elements of design is just one more aspect of this. One more way of expanding, shifting, and growing our understanding of nature.
BTW - a slightly different subject:
I’ve noticed that you and our good friend Spiritmeadow seem to object to “ID” partly based on the thinking that (paraphasing) “God got it right the first time and doesn’t need to tinker with his creation.” I’m not trying to misrepresent your thinking, so either/both of you correct me if I’m wrong. But something struck me about this that I think is important.
In English, DESIGN is both a verb and a noun. As a verb, it implies a process that takes time, and usually some mistakes that need corrected along the way. As a noun, it means “the final product” so to speak. e.g. The architect points at the skyscraper and says “That’s my design.”
The D in ID is not talking about design as a verb, a mistake filled process, it’s talking about it as a noun, the final product. There is no constant tinkering implied (although for separate non-ID reasons, I tend to think that God interacts with his creation).