ID in public schools

  • Thread starter Thread starter edwest2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
SoCalRC,

i guess some theists might feel that way, like some agnostics and some atheists.

I guess i’m stating the obvious in saying though, that many of each of the three categories don’t feel that way.

Respect.
 
Miracles have everything to do with ID and evolution. The only kind of ID I believe in is the one that says God is the Intelligent Designer. The only kind of evolution that works is the God intervened kind. Not the evolutionary theory in textbooks.
Miracles Ed are not the subject of science. If they are, they are not miracles. Science explains nature, the Church explains miracles. There is but one evolutionary theory Ed, why won’t you read? The Church explains the context in which this theory should be viewed period.
And some people seem to think that God does not intervene in His Creation. The Living God does so all the time. He performs miracles, now, today. He operates on “natural” reality in a supernatural way because He is God. No one has unique access to doing science. The 400 year old Pontifical Academy of Sciences does science. I do not separate science from the Church.
That is something I believe as well, but it is not the subject of any science. Its a matter of faith. Glad you mentiioned the PAS. It has nary a creationist on its list of members and apparently the Vatican is okay with that. Why do you think that is Ed?
 
Many scientific hypotheses started with simply a philosophical thought. The universe, for example was thought of as being eternal and static. This was a philosophical opinion having such an influence that even Dr. Einstein “invented” a cosmological constant in order for his model of the universe to remain static.
The atomic theory is another philosophical opinion which was later tested for it’s validity as an hypothesis. Incidently, Dalton’s view of the atom is not what Aristotle had in mind, as the atom is not
the ultimate indivisible particle. Quantum Mechanics would be considered closer to Aristotle’s atomic view, where even spacetime is now believed to be quantized…that is, having indivisible discrete numerical values.

Andre
Hadn’t you heard? It may indeed turn out that Einstein’s cosmological constant may be accurate after all. Einstein himself called it his worst blunder as I recall, but it may in fact have been right. See the new material on dark matter and dark energy. They are seemingly confirming his constant. Now I know very little science but I just saw this on something or other.
 
Innaccurate how? If a ‘theory’ is inherently untestable, it isn’t science.

So it is theology, but is it good theology? God has to leave tracks? Finding those ‘tracks’ is better to appreciate his awe?

It is just another form of constraining God. What happens when and if we better understand dark energy, or dark matter? We know from looking that there is a force at work other than gravity, similiary, we can actually map dark matter’s presence by the way it bends light.

What if the constants then go in flux? Does that ‘disprove’ the existance of God?

How is this any different from literalist interpretations of Genesis. The moon does not glow, it only reflects light from the son - does this contradiction from Genesis ‘disprove’ the existance of God?

What is the point in arbitrarily assigning special significance to one particular aspect of nature, when we know from centuries of experience that our understanding of the natural world continues to expand, shift, and grow?
hopefully the Vatican will proceed carefully and avoid the obvious pitfalls of ID as now projected. Whenever you get specific about what is evidence of “God’s tracks” you run the risk of later and better science explaining it and then you are left with God of the Gaps and another gap is explained. That’s no way to conduct a theology I would assume.
 
SoCalRC,

i guess some theists might feel that way, like some agnostics and some atheists.

I guess i’m stating the obvious in saying though, that many of each of the three categories don’t feel that way.

Respect.
I cannot read the hearts and minds of others. And, as I explained, I don’t share the specific feelings. But it is a very human reaction. And I’ve noticed that anger is often associated with fear.
 
Hi SpiritMeadow,

i prefer to think of it as ‘God on the other side of the gaps’.

Most of our scientific foundations were laid by Christians trying to close those gaps, looking for their God. Of course today there are many others as well.

They all seem to have done a good job. 👍
 
Most of our scientific foundations were laid by Christians trying to close those gaps, looking for their God.
What we call the scientific method was first used by the Ionian Greek philosophers. This was continued first by the Byzantines, and later by the Arabs who developed the empiricism we use today. The Indians (asian ones) developed the place system in mathematics that was modified by the Arabs into algebra (an Arabic word) and this was passed on to Europeans like Bacon, who spread the use of Arabic numerals and the scientific method to others in Europe.

Within Christian Europe, the time was right for a renewal of civilization and science grew and there developed far beyond it’s earlier roots.

But we should remember that those roots are not in Christian Europe.
 
I’m reading - What’s So Great About Christianity? The book is an apologetic on the spat of books promoting atheism and denouncing religion, especially Christianity.

Atheistic scientists DO NOT LIKE the Big Bang theory because of its implication of a creator. Atheists have all sorts of NON-scientific theorizing trying to remove the implication that the Big Bang requires a creator. Atheists were far more comfortable with the Steady-State theory of the universe which theorized that the universe is eternal.

However, atheistic evolutionists have a field day beating Christians over the head with evolutionary science – because, as a group, many do not believe in evolution because (not being properly educated on the topic) they feel it undermines the need for God to have created the heavens and the earth. I certainly don’t enjoy the gloating of atheists and (humanly) would LOVE to see them have to swallow their pride.

BUT - science is science AND ONLY SCIENCE. Science, by it self-imposed limitation must confine itself to the physical world. When it begins to reach into the theological/philosophical it quickly gets unfamiliar with the turf and makes mistakes.

So, I think ID is a mistake because IT IS NOT SCIENCE – ID is philosophy. We need to keep science separate from philosophy.

But, I feel the religious community needs educated to the fact that evolution DOES NOT undermine Christianity. Nor does it undermine the Bible. It’s obviously going to take some time because, unfortunately, some theologians/clergy are digging in their heals. My wife’s mother IN THE 50’s!! asked their parish priest about evolution – the parish priest, who was obviously well read and knowledgeable about Church affairs told my mother in law that evolution didn’t pose a problem for the Church or the Bible.

The teaching of ID is well meaning in that it doesn’t want children taught atheism (which they feel evolution would do). But, in time it will be seen that it is the wrong answer to the right question.

What the Christian community needs is books/education that explains how evolution doesn’t contradict the Bible. It needs to be written in the language of religious people demonstrating the power of God. Works that demonstrate the great power of God who creates WITH TIME and not by creating everything by fiat. “Let there be light” really set everything in motion. If people would see this written in language they can understand, in language that doesn’t threaten them - then they would see that THIS isn’t the proper turf to fight atheism.

Christians are to fight the GOOD FIGHT – haggling over evolution vs ID is simply the WRONG FIGHT.

MonFrere
 
Well i wasn’t specifically talking about Europe although that is really where most of the science’s originated from to any great extent - physics, chemistry, genetics, pyschology, geography, paleontolgy, evolution (remember Darwin was a Christian at the time of his scientific investigations with a theology degree), scientific astronomy, biolology, micro biology, etc. I think the explosion of knowledge and process that came out of that period, culture and geography can fairly well claim to be the birthplace of science IMHO. If you look in the encyclopedia’s for the founders of the different science’s you are going to find male Christians.

Modern technology for just about everything all over the world today can trace its history back to the explosion of sciences which came out of that time.

I can see you disagree. 😃

The Arabs of course got their science from the indigenous Christians of the middle east.

And before them the Greeks laid the groundwork in logical thought and philosophy which was largely kept alive by the middle eastern Christians and then shared with the muslims when they arrived on the scene before eventually re-entering Europe to join with the Christian thought there.

Next time.
 
Miracles have everything to do with ID and evolution. The only kind of ID I believe in is the one that says God is the Intelligent Designer. The only kind of evolution that works is the God intervened kind. Not the evolutionary theory in textbooks.
ED, you only have to review my provided resources within the topic National Academies book on evolution(1) starting with my message 79 to know for a fact that ID has been debunked by peer-reviewed scientific articles that have and continue to provide evidence that proponents of the ID movement lack intelligence due to their unscientific claims.The ID movement is defunk. END OF STORY! ABOVE ALL ELSE, NO WHERE IN THE VATICAN: HOLY SEE does it mention as you state ED," God is the Intelligent Designer." I’m absolutely flabbergasted by such a remark nor is it noted that God is omnipresent in the new Catechism of the Catholic Church so Ed that shoots down your remark Ed, " The only kind of evolution that works is the God intervened kind." The Catholic Church does wish for us human beings to be rational which you are negleting to do in my opinion. 😦

Now, as miracles go, I’ve provided in another topic what is the course of action of the CHRUCH. (You and others can scrample through my previous postings in my on-line messages to other topics and find it.) All that I can say is that the Church does have a Medical Commission that reviews the claim along with other commissions of the Church.
The 400 year old Pontifical Academy of Sciences does science. I do not separate science from the Church.
God bless,
Ed
Ed, you should be aware of the fact that Roman Catholics who are in good standing with the Vatican: Holy See and those members of the Pontifical Academy of Sciences(P.A.S.) aren’t creationists. And should know by now that Science and Theology aren’t one and the same though it is important to remind yourself that *Sciences *is listed under the Pontifical Academies which is part of the The Roma Curia Pontifical Commissions. I’ve highlighted in blue the mission of the Pontifical Academy of Sciences below:

*HISTORY OF THE PONTIFICAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES
The Pontifical Academy of Sciences is international in scope, multi-racial in composition, and non-sectarian in its choice of members. The work of the Academy comprises six major areas: Fundamental science; Science and technology of global problems; Science for the problems of the Third World; Scientific policy; Bioethics; Epistemology.

RELATIONSHIP TO THE HOLY SEE
The Pontifical Academy of Sciences is an independent entity within the Holy See. Although its rebirth was the result of papal initiative, and though it is placed under the direct protection of the reigning Supreme Pontiff, the Academy defines its own goals with regard to its statuted aim:
“…to promote the progress of the mathematical, physical and natural sciences and the study of epistemological problems relating thereto” (Statutes 1:2). . . .

Since the deliberations and studies which it undertakes are not influenced by any one national, political or religious point of view, the Academy constitutes an invaluable source of objective information upon which the Holy See and its various bodies can draw. *http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/p...s/rc_pa_acdscien_doc_10121999_history_en.html

The scientists of the Vatican are the creme de la creme! 😃 👍 All of them support evolution.! None of them support the Intelligent Design Movement! NONE! THE END!

1,** National Academies book on evolution **
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=209575&page=6
http://forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=209575&page=6

(p.s. I’m going on vacation so be back later.) 👍
 
I’ve noticed that you and our good friend Spiritmeadow seem to object to “ID” partly based on the thinking that (paraphasing) “God got it right the first time and doesn’t need to tinker with his creation.” I’m not trying to misrepresent your thinking, so either/both of you correct me if I’m wrong. But something struck me about this that I think is important.
In English, DESIGN is both a verb and a noun. As a verb, it implies a process that takes time, and usually some mistakes that need corrected along the way. As a noun, it means “the final product” so to speak. e.g. The architect points at the skyscraper and says “That’s my design.”
The D in ID is not talking about design as a verb, a mistake filled process, it’s talking about it as a noun, the final product. There is no constant tinkering implied (although for separate non-ID reasons, I tend to think that God interacts with his creation).
I think we may be in agreement. What I meant was, I don’t believe that God once, he thought the Universe into existence, in what we refer to as the Big Bang, looked at this or that, and said, oops, I need to tweak this or it won’t turn out as i wanted. I believe completely and totally that God interacts with his creation everywhere and always. He experiences life through us, and acts through us when we grant Him access.That is how I view things. God is as one person said as close as my very breath.
 
No, I resent only the teaching of ID in schools, as science.

However, as far as creationist thinking goes, it is probably important. It is the natural extension of a ‘self importance’ world view.

It falls right in line with arguments on why the earth cannot obrit the sun and why the solar system must be the center of the universe.

If the universe is not static, then change is inevitable. If even our bodies and minds can continue to evolve, then, gasp we may not be the pinacle of creation.

I have no problem with this. The gift of life and thought is already something beyond measure. If it took the wonderous cosmos simply to allow us to exist or rather we are just one voice in a chorus raising our voices to God, I’m happy. I’m here, I can ponder, I can wonder, and I can love.

But other people clearly find this very threatening. A universe with at least 100B galaxys, each with 100B stars makes them feel small, less significant. Seeming uncertainty in the fabric of the universe isn’t seen as a possible source of our own existance or free will, but a sign that they are random, less important, and less safe.

We instinctively don’t like feeling small, alone, afraid, so constraining God and evevating man’s importance in His total creation is probably a normal response. But, since it makes God’s Creation as we can see and measure it, threatening, it probably is counter productive in the long term. God survived a Copernacan solar system and Apolo moon flights just fine…
I hadn’t considered the “self-importance” idea before. I likened most creationists as more fundamentalist in nature. But I actually can see how that really conflates in some ways.

Rather than feel small, I can only gasp at the possibilities I can hope to encounter some day. I now often seen Jesus as a vagabond hitchhiker traveling the stars, arriving at the next planet that has risen to sentience and is searching for God.
 
The Arabs of course got their science from the indigenous Christians of the middle east.
Hmmm…Democritus, Pythagoras, Aristotle, Eratosthenes, Aristarchus of Samos, Ptolemy of Alexandria…

Which of these were Christians? Can you name one great Christian scientist before the Renaissance?

The science taken by the Arabs was Hellenistic, not Christian.

And modern science, as we think of it was developed in North Africa, by Islamic scholars. Europeans like Roger Bacon were quite outspoken in their regard for Islamic science, and promoted it openly.
 
Hi SpiritMeadow,

i prefer to think of it as ‘God on the other side of the gaps’.

Most of our scientific foundations were laid by Christians trying to close those gaps, looking for their God. Of course today there are many others as well.

They all seem to have done a good job. 👍
I’m not sure i can agree that “most of our scientific foundations were laid by Christians”…I think the basis of our scientific foundations were laid by Greeks mostly, and a whole slue of Arab thinkers during the “dark ages” which apparently weren’t dark for Islamic science.

I agree, science has done a good job and will continue to do so no doubt. We all have very much to thank them for no doubt.
 
I’m reading - What’s So Great About Christianity? The book is an apologetic on the spat of books promoting atheism and denouncing religion, especially Christianity.

Atheistic scientists DO NOT LIKE the Big Bang theory because of its implication of a creator. Atheists have all sorts of NON-scientific theorizing trying to remove the implication that the Big Bang requires a creator. Atheists were far more comfortable with the Steady-State theory of the universe which theorized that the universe is eternal.

However, atheistic evolutionists have a field day beating Christians over the head with evolutionary science – because, as a group, many do not believe in evolution because (not being properly educated on the topic) they feel it undermines the need for God to have created the heavens and the earth. I certainly don’t enjoy the gloating of atheists and (humanly) would LOVE to see them have to swallow their pride.

BUT - science is science AND ONLY SCIENCE. Science, by it self-imposed limitation must confine itself to the physical world. When it begins to reach into the theological/philosophical it quickly gets unfamiliar with the turf and makes mistakes.

So, I think ID is a mistake because IT IS NOT SCIENCE – ID is philosophy. We need to keep science separate from philosophy.

But, I feel the religious community needs educated to the fact that evolution DOES NOT undermine Christianity. Nor does it undermine the Bible. It’s obviously going to take some time because, unfortunately, some theologians/clergy are digging in their heals. My wife’s mother IN THE 50’s!! asked their parish priest about evolution – the parish priest, who was obviously well read and knowledgeable about Church affairs told my mother in law that evolution didn’t pose a problem for the Church or the Bible.

The teaching of ID is well meaning in that it doesn’t want children taught atheism (which they feel evolution would do). But, in time it will be seen that it is the wrong answer to the right question.

What the Christian community needs is books/education that explains how evolution doesn’t contradict the Bible. It needs to be written in the language of religious people demonstrating the power of God. Works that demonstrate the great power of God who creates WITH TIME and not by creating everything by fiat. “Let there be light” really set everything in motion. If people would see this written in language they can understand, in language that doesn’t threaten them - then they would see that THIS isn’t the proper turf to fight atheism.

Christians are to fight the GOOD FIGHT – haggling over evolution vs ID is simply the WRONG FIGHT.

MonFrere
I pretty much agree, but Christians are fighting the wrong battle completely in my opinion. I really don’t care what any atheist thinks about whether anything proves or disproves God. The only fight Christians need make is to make sure other Christians understand what you have elicited, science and religion have no difficulty, they are part of a compatible whole. Christians need to spend the time in their parishes running workshops and seminars to educate people, rather than arguing with atheists who are never going to be convinced in any case.
 
Well i wasn’t specifically talking about Europe although that is really where most of the science’s originated from to any great extent - physics, chemistry, genetics, pyschology, geography, paleontolgy, evolution (remember Darwin was a Christian at the time of his scientific investigations with a theology degree), scientific astronomy, biolology, micro biology, etc. I think the explosion of knowledge and process that came out of that period, culture and geography can fairly well claim to be the birthplace of science IMHO. If you look in the encyclopedia’s for the founders of the different science’s you are going to find male Christians.

Modern technology for just about everything all over the world today can trace its history back to the explosion of sciences which came out of that time.

I can see you disagree. 😃

The Arabs of course got their science from the indigenous Christians of the middle east.

And before them the Greeks laid the groundwork in logical thought and philosophy which was largely kept alive by the middle eastern Christians and then shared with the muslims when they arrived on the scene before eventually re-entering Europe to join with the Christian thought there.

Next time.
I find no reason whatsoever to revise history to support that most everything of importance was started or completed by Christians. Its patently not true. There is simply no need to do this for any argument you are trying to make that I can see. Please fairly state the truth.
 
Spiritmeadow i respectfully disagree.

I am not saying everything of importance was started and ended by Christians and i don’t think you will find that in my posts.

I am saying that science was largely founded by the Christians and think this is beyond dispute. That doesn’t mean that the science has since been exclusively developed by Christians. In fact i said it wasn’t in my posts.

I acknowledged as i do now that logic and philosophy largely came from the Greeks. Mathematics came from many places including the Middle east, China and India.

But neither logic, philosophy nor mathematics are science. They can be tools used in science and need to be a pre requisites to science, but they are not science.

I think i re-iterate the fairly obvious. Science in its multi disciplinary forms quite obviously developed in the Christian cultures.

I cannot see possibly how anyone can come up with any other origin. That would be revision IMHO. I suggest looking at all the early disciplines of science and then seeing who their founder was.

It’s pretty obvious really.

Respect.
 
Christian Europe, coming out of the dark ages, took science which had been preserved and enlarged by Islam and Indian scholars, and turned it into something wonderous.

We Christians did not establish science, nor did we invent the methodology, or even develop the mathematics needed for it.
I suggest looking at all the early disciplines of science and then seeing who their founder was.
Few basic sciences have a “founder”; usually, it’s many who were involved, but we can mention a few, among the many:

Chemistry… Democritus of Abdera, Ionian Greek
Infered the existence of atoms from experiments.

Physics… Archimedes of Syracuse, diaspora Greek
Simple machines, optics, engineering

Hydraulics… Heiro of Alexandria, Hellenistic Greek
First useful hydraulic devices, coin machines, and working steam engine.

Astronomy…Aristarchus of Samos, Greek
Inferred from observation and mathematics that the Moon was much closer than the Sun, and that the Earth revolved around the Sun

Biology… Aristotle Greek

Medicine… Hippocrates Greek

Geography… Eratosthenes of Alexandria
Accurately measured the circumference of the Earth

Aeronautics…Hezarfen Celebi, Turkish
First successful manned heavier than air flight (intercontinental, no less; flew across the Bosphorus, and landed safely)

Modern astronomy…Muhammad al-Battani who revised Ptolemy’s tables, and pointed out the data that later showed the elliptical orbit of the Earth. Copernicus credited al-Battani and his contributions in the book that revolutionized astronomy, De revolutionibus orbium coelestium.

But we did, as abucs asserts, devolop it into something beyond the dreams of the Arabs or Greeks. (modern Greeks and Arabs have certainly contibuted a great deal of fine science, of course)
 
I think i re-iterate the fairly obvious. Science in its multi disciplinary forms quite obviously developed in the Christian cultures.
The modern scintific method and the idea of applied science were invented in the Middle Ages by RCC monks.
And the scholastics idea that humans were made in God’s image and likeness and thus can discover and understand the rules that God used to make the world were a western christian development. That is how empyrical methodological naturalism started.
 
The modern scintific method and the idea of applied science were invented in the Middle Ages by RCC monks.
** Latinized: Alhacen or (deprecated) Alhazen) (965 – 1039), was a Persian[1] Muslim polymath[2][3] who made significant contributions to the principles of optics, as well as to anatomy, astronomy, engineering, mathematics, medicine, ophthalmology, philosophy, physics, psychology, Ash’ari theology, visual perception, and to science in general with his introduction of the scientific method. **

Roger Bacon very plainly credited Islamic scholars with the development of modern scientific method. It’s no secret where he learned of this methodology.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top