ID in public schools

  • Thread starter Thread starter edwest2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hadn’t you heard? It may indeed turn out that Einstein’s cosmological constant may be accurate after all. Einstein himself called it his worst blunder as I recall, but it may in fact have been right. See the new material on dark matter and dark energy. They are seemingly confirming his constant. Now I know very little science but I just saw this on something or other.
What scientists are finding is the rate of expansion of the universe as increasing per time. The cosmological constant they claim might exist would cause the exact opposite to what Dr. Einstein’s constant was supposed to do. Instead of confirming Einstein’s cosmological constant; it actually points to his constant as being a blunder by a greater degree than previously believed.

Andre
 
Few basic sciences have a “founder”; usually, it’s many who were involved, but we can mention a few, among the many:

Chemistry… Democritus of Abdera, Ionian Greek
Infered the existence of atoms from experiments.
I also believe the philosophers have a great part to play within the scientific world. However, most were not scientists. I believe this is an important argument against those who claim that philosophical hypotheses have no place in science.
Democritus’ atomic theory was purely philosophical in essence, not scientific. Therefore, my question is why would one claim a philosopher as being the father of a science, which, by definition, must be a systematically acquired knowledge that is verifiable? Such a definition must automatically exclude Democritus as a scientist even less the father of a science.
However, if we define science as being simply the study of the observable, and the hypothetical laws such observables follow , then Democritus fits perfectly…since we can cut a stone, the two pieces remain an image of each other, we could conclude that either we could go on dividing infinitly, or there would be a basic particle which would be indivisible. Such abstract thought, not unlike the philosophical thought for an infinite or finite universe, are the bases in which scientific hypotheses evolve.However, if we impliment these into science, then, we must, by necessity, also let other philosophical hypotheses as being acceptable as well .

Now we know that Life evolved. Which laws could be implimented that would explain Evolution? Randon mutations along with a non-randon natural selection? True, it is a powerful theory, but such a theory must also mean that, for mutation be totally random, then, we should not **expect **a lifeform to adapt to a harsh environment, although it could,However the chance for survival must be exremely against, and not for the lifeform to adapt.

Why, then, do we observe lifeforms continously adapting to a potential deadly enviroment?Why would one observe, for example, bacteria that are deficient in their ability to utilise the milk sugar lactose, acquire lactose-eating mutations only when lactose is available within a starving environment?

I agree that Darwianian evolution is a good theory. My problem is when other hypotheses are not aloud to be thought in school if such an hypothesis have to do with some intelligent design
of some kind.

livescience.com/strangenews/070816_gm_evolution.html

**“I think one of the greatest mysteries in biology at the moment is whether natural selection is the only process capable of generating organismal complexity,” said Massimo Pigliucci of the Department of Ecology and Evolution at Stony Brook University in New York, “or whether there are other properties of matter that also come into play. I suspect the latter will turn out to be true.” **

Andre
 
I also believe the philosophers have a great part to play within the scientific world. However, most were not scientists.
Democritus, for example, was a philosopher, but also a scientist. His pioneering methodology became the basis for the scientific method. He used careful observation and inferences from evidence to make his conclusions. There is an old tradition that science education should include philosophy. I think it’s a good one.
I believe this is an important argument against those who claim that philosophical hypotheses have no place in science.
Properly speaking, there are no philosophical hypotheses. Science is a methodology which is inductive and procedes from evidence. Can’t be philosophical. But of course, the notion that the universe is knowable and consistent is a philosophical idea on which science rests.
Democritus’ atomic theory was purely philosophical in essence, not scientific.
No. He conducted experiments, and examined the results to make his conclusions. His use of a clepshydra to show that air must be made of something, and his explanation of the nature of conic sections led him to believe that atoms must exist.
Therefore, my question is why would one claim a philosopher as being the father of a science, which, by definition, must be a systematically acquired knowledge that is verifiable?
Because he first used the scientific method and came to scientific conclusions based on them.
Such a definition must automatically exclude Democritus as a scientist even less the father of a science.
I don’t see how. What he did was what scientists still do. He even mocked other philosophers for trying to explain the material world with philosophic speculations. He said that people always want to explain nature by inventing new gods.
However, if we define science as being simply the study of the observable, and the hypothetical laws such observables follow , then Democritus fits perfectly…since we can cut a stone, the two pieces remain an image of each other, we could conclude that either we could go on dividing infinitly, or there would be a basic particle which would be indivisible. Such abstract thought, not unlike the philosophical thought for an infinite or finite universe, are the bases in which scientific hypotheses evolve.However, if we impliment these into science, then, we must, by necessity, also let other philosophical hypotheses as being acceptable as well .
I think the problem is this; philosophy can inform science, but science can’t inform philosophy. Show me where dualism, for example, can be scientifically tested.
Now we know that Life evolved. Which laws could be implimented that would explain Evolution? Randon mutations along with a non-randon natural selection? True, it is a powerful theory, but such a theory must also mean that, for mutation be totally random, then, we should not expect a lifeform to adapt to a harsh environment, although it could,However the chance for survival must be exremely against, and not for the lifeform to adapt.
Which is pretty much what observation shows. This is one of the reasons it’s almost universally accepted among scientists.
Why, then, do we observe lifeforms continously adapting to a potential deadly enviroment?Why would one observe, for example, bacteria that are deficient in their ability to utilise the milk sugar lactose, acquire lactose-eating mutations only when lactose is available within a starving environment?
We don’t. In series of experiments, it was shown that antibiotic resistance (for example) appears even when antibiotics are not present. But such things only come to dominate the population where selection is operating for it.
I agree that Darwianian evolution is a good theory. My problem is when other hypotheses are not aloud to be thought in school if such an hypothesis have to do with some intelligent design of some kind.
Being a religious doctrine, it can’t be taught in public school science classes, but it could be taught in a class on religion.
“I think one of the greatest mysteries in biology at the moment is whether natural selection is the only process capable of generating organismal complexity,”
Genetic drift, for example, can do that. But not to a very high degree. Wherever we find complexity evolving, it generally has a selective cause.
 
I think this is a bit arbitrary then about when science started.

For example, 5,000 years ago someone might carefullly observe that the sun comes up and over and down again quite regularly.
From that observation he might wrongly hypothesise that the sun goes around the earth. However he has made a deduction of the workings of celestial bodies based on careful repeated observations that seems to be then validated by subsequant experimentation or testing - look, it did it again the next day.
Does that make him the founder of astronomy ?

What about 500 years later where they have running messengers from one village to another. A runner might observe that if he starts at dawn each day, and runs his usual pace he inevitably ends up at the same destination village as the sun is setting. He might hypothesise then that not only does the sun regularly travel around the earth but that it takes the same amount of time to do each roatation. He has made an observation about celestial bodies, made a hypothesis and then tested it repeatedly by subsequantly running to the same village from dawn to dusk. He now has a theory. He mentions it to the chief. Its accepted by the chief and he makes the pronouncement that only strong runners should travel to that village otherwise they will have to stop overnight because the sun is only up for so long.
Does that make the runner the founder of astronomy, or perhaps the chief ? Sure they always get the recognition anyway. :rolleyes:

I still think science largely came out of Christian Europe in a form that we can first recognise as science and that’s why the explosion of new scientific fields and scientific laws were born in that period.

If we look not only at the founders (which seem to be contentious here) but actual scientific laws which after all are the fruits of science, they largely first come from Christian Europe. Laws of physics, laws of chemistry, laws of genetics, laws of astronomy etc as opposed to observations that then give rise to hypothesis as mentioned earlier.

I don’t wish to be triumphalist in any way (that would be pointless and childish - i didn’t invent science). I just honestly see the beginnings largely that way.

I respect other people’s different views however to see and define things different to myself.

I agree with both of you that philosophy is important and it is a topic i actually enjoy more than science.

I think the science of quantum mechanics has influenced philosophy tremendously and there is a great cross over now in the area of metaphysics with one influencing the other.

Respect.
 
I am saying that science was largely founded by the Christians and think this is beyond dispute. That doesn’t mean that the science has since been exclusively developed by Christians. In fact i said it wasn’t in my posts.
I’m afraid that seems completely at odds with the available facts. Just one of Barbarian’s examples, Eratosthenes of Cyrene seems enough to make the point. His work is quite scientific even by modern standards. He most assuredly did not confine himself to philosophy, look at his work on determining the circumference of the earth. He actually endeavored to make precise measurements between locales, perhaps making him the father or modern geography (yes, he devised a method of latitude and longitude centuries before Christ). And his calculations, using trig only, are surprisingly accurate (he was wrong in that the earth is not a perfect sphere). Columbus actually had a copy of his work (Cleomedes’ summary of it at least - most intellectuals in Columbus’ time agreed that the earth was round, Colubus was just convinced that it was much smaller than most agreed - he was wrong).

And, in the spirit of modern science, Eratosthenes tried to apply his theory about the earth’s size and test it through measurement. For example, he attempted to calculate the distance from the earth to the sun and moon, then compare those calculations to other astronomical measurements. His work on proportionals in math seems to suggest that he was even having suspicians about elliptical movements of celestial bodies.
 
Christian Europe, coming out of the dark ages, took science which had been preserved and enlarged by Islam and Indian scholars, and turned it into something wonderous.

We Christians did not establish science, nor did we invent the methodology, or even develop the mathematics needed for it.

Few basic sciences have a “founder”; usually, it’s many who were involved, but we can mention a few, among the many:

Chemistry… Democritus of Abdera, Ionian Greek
Infered the existence of atoms from experiments.

Physics… Archimedes of Syracuse, diaspora Greek
Simple machines, optics, engineering

Hydraulics… Heiro of Alexandria, Hellenistic Greek
First useful hydraulic devices, coin machines, and working steam engine.

Astronomy…Aristarchus of Samos, Greek
Inferred from observation and mathematics that the Moon was much closer than the Sun, and that the Earth revolved around the Sun

Biology… Aristotle Greek

Medicine… Hippocrates Greek

Geography… Eratosthenes of Alexandria
Accurately measured the circumference of the Earth

Aeronautics…Hezarfen Celebi, Turkish
First successful manned heavier than air flight (intercontinental, no less; flew across the Bosphorus, and landed safely)

Modern astronomy…Muhammad al-Battani who revised Ptolemy’s tables, and pointed out the data that later showed the elliptical orbit of the Earth. Copernicus credited al-Battani and his contributions in the book that revolutionized astronomy, De revolutionibus orbium coelestium.

But we did, as abucs asserts, devolop it into something beyond the dreams of the Arabs or Greeks. (modern Greeks and Arabs have certainly contibuted a great deal of fine science, of course)
Yeah I agree. I think Western civilization probably did more on the technology side perhaps. I’m a bit too sensitive I admit on the issue of giving primacy to “Christians” where it doesn’t belong. We are hopefully engaged in a pluralistic world and trying to be better than a Muslim or Jew or whatever is divisiive. I am not in favor of trying to elicit some religious idea that any religion did more than another. It is simply not reflected in the factual history. To put it forth only adds to bad feelings.
 
What scientists are finding is the rate of expansion of the universe as increasing per time. The cosmological constant they claim might exist would cause the exact opposite to what Dr. Einstein’s constant was supposed to do. Instead of confirming Einstein’s cosmological constant; it actually points to his constant as being a blunder by a greater degree than previously believed.

Andre
wow, well I guess those 3 astronomers were just dead wrong in saying that. Thanks for the correction. Do you have a site? The Universe apparently is putting out badly flawed information. Funny that a couple of the scientists are people I’ve seen before on other shows. There is just no excuse for such bad work.
 
Christians need to spend the time in their parishes running workshops and seminars to educate people, rather than arguing with atheists who are never going to be convinced in any case.
I agree with your point that Christians need to be educating their people.

BUT I also feel that there needs to be an answer to these current best sellers written by atheists. The God Delusion - God Is NOT Great. These books cry out for a Christian response. If we don’t respond it seems as if their arguments are beyond dispute and we are admitting defeat. Atheists needs to see the weakness of their “religion” just as much, perhaps even more, than non-Catholics. They are spiritually MORE needy that Protestants!! I’ve had some conversations with young people who are testing the waters of atheism. Most of them have been disillusioned because of the death of a loved one and cannot reconcile this with a loving God. From everything I see, with materialistic western society going to its logical end, atheism is very much on the ascendancy. Catholic Christians need to be equipped for this apologetic work because these people really are in great spiritual need.

MonFrere
 
wow, well I guess those 3 astronomers were just dead wrong in saying that. Thanks for the correction. Do you have a site? The Universe apparently is putting out badly flawed information. Funny that a couple of the scientists are people I’ve seen before on other shows. There is just no excuse for such bad work.
I think you are referring to the episode on dark matter and dark energy. I think it is a matter of context and presentation. I actually know some of the folks being interviewed and I think that your impression is just a missunderstanding on extent, emphasis, and implication (ex. sometimes the naration is a little over dramatic).

As noted, Einstein did not like that his own theory predicted that the universe would either be expanding or contracting, so he created a force with properties opposite of gravity and used it to predict a static universe. However, then we realized that some celestial bodies were actually other galaxies and, by all apparent measure, are moving away from us.

So, it was filed away as a blunder. However, now it appears that expansion is not slowing, but accelerating. So it appears evident that something other than gravity is involved. If it is a force, it has somewhat opposite properties from gravity. An idea along the same general lines of what Einstein called his greatest blunder. But Einstein’s proposed cosmological constant does not fit the actual data. That is, as a theory, it does not seem match what we know about ‘dark energy’. So, in scientific terms, ‘dark energy’ and ‘cosmological constant’ are two different things.

But it still is an excellent show - and I’m not just saying that because my oldest daughter has had a non speaking cameo appearance!
 
wow, well I guess those 3 astronomers were just dead wrong in saying that. Thanks for the correction. Do you have a site? The Universe apparently is putting out badly flawed information. Funny that a couple of the scientists are people I’ve seen before on other shows. There is just no excuse for such bad work.
So, you’re saying that the universe is static…???

Do you have a site which claims this?

Unfortunately the site you gave me couldn’t upload all the way…I’ll try later, or you could just copy/paste the reference of those three astronomers.

Andre
 
Well i won’t comment again after this one, on this thread anyway. I certainly don’t want to add to any bad feelings but … if people are going to say it certainly is not the case that science largely started in Christian Europe I have no choice but to say it definitely did. I would prefer to use the neutral terms - to me, it seems, from my definitions, from my perspective, but if the gloves are off so be it.

And i do see the start of science as proper science starting in the Christian era. Just one example - I do see Newton (who was in no way friendly to the Catholic Church) as the greatest scientist and founding so many disciplines with his scientific laws. And any reading of his life’s work will see that his science was influenced in PART by his philosophy, and his philosophy was Christian - an ordered and universal intelligent creation, just like the overwhelming founders of the scientific disciplines.

Bacon, Newton, Kepler, Galileo, Pascal, Cuvier, Darwin (when he did his science), Boyle, Dalton, Linnaeus, Mendel, Maxwell, and Kelvin among many, many, many others. Where is the comparable list from India, from China, from Islam, from the ancient Greeks. Please. There isn’t one. Science as we know it today was (with the gloves taken off) largely foundered in Christian Europe.

Just look at where the overwhelming number of first scientific laws in each of the disciplines come from.

Yes, to be sure. People built their knowledge on others just as the runner i mentioned 4,500 years ago had his (name removed by moderator)ut. Those previous civilisations, great civilisations then and now who pioneered philosophy, mathematics, astrology and logic are vitally important and they have eternal credit for those pre scientific disciplines. We are all indebted and science could not have begun without the enlightenment of these verible civilisations. But begin in did, in Christian Europe.

Each are important but when do the scientific laws (as opposed to mathematical) first arise. There are internationally recognised first laws of physics, the second law etc, of genetics, of thermodynamics, biology, etc.

Is Eratosthenes credited with any scientific laws ?

Respect.
 
Yeah I agree. I think Western civilization probably did more on the technology side perhaps. I’m a bit too sensitive I admit on the issue of giving primacy to “Christians” where it doesn’t belong. We are hopefully engaged in a pluralistic world and trying to be better than a Muslim or Jew or whatever is divisiive. I am not in favor of trying to elicit some religious idea that any religion did more than another. It is simply not reflected in the factual history. To put it forth only adds to bad feelings.
Maybe a more mundane example can be of benefit here. My ancestory is European – italian to be precise. I’m certainly thankful that Marco Polo brought back pasta from China. If you want to give the Chinese credit - that’s no skin off my nose. To give credit to other nationalities, races, etc. for their genuine contributions, be it technology or food, shows our magnimity. Christianity doesn’t need to take credit for every good that has ever been accomplished in our world. The early church fathers were humble enough to use their greek and roman learning to the benefit of the early church. Some of this learning was crucial to the development of some of our doctrines, e.g. the trinity and the hypostatic union.

MonFrere
 
Just one example - I do see Newton (who was in no way friendly to the Catholic Church) as the greatest scientist and founding so many disciplines with his scientific laws.

Is Eratosthenes credited with any scientific laws ?
An interesting example. Newton was brilliant, but he was seemingly not Christian. For example:

isaac-newton.org/heretic.pdf

Put simply, he did not appear to accept the premise that Jesus was God.

Also, Newton proclaimed his scientific laws himself, and believed that he was close to a unified explanation of the universe. He was wrong. When it gets to the very big and the very small, we have to abandon Newtonian physics.

And, Newton was a genius, but he also was widely held to be a somewhat infantile jerk. The whole ‘apple’ story was devised to deny a peer any credit. But even Newton accepted that he relied on the Law of Cosines, sometimes called Al-Kashi’s Law…

Last, yes, actually some of Eratosthenes’ work survives today. Perhaps you recall learning about ‘Prime Numbers’ in school?

I think you are confusing invention with with recollection and name recognition. We don’t know how the Mayan’s came up with some of their amazing mathmatical system, because they vanished. We also know a lot less about the Greek ancients than we should, since much of their collective knowledge was destroyed. You’ve heard of some names, but they have the benefit of not having their books burned and their names forgotten. Even so, few Americans can name the inventor of the laser or the television, but that does not change history.
 
And even Newton (not Christian, but at least believed in the God of the Old Testament) acknowledged (as did Bacon) his great debt to the men who founded science:

"If I have seen further it is by standing on ye shoulders of Giants."
Newton, in a letter to his friend, Robert Hooke

The reason the Mayans beat us to the concept of zero, and developed a more accurate calendar is simple; they cared a lot about it, and their religion depended on projecting dates into the past and the future with great precision.

They excelled in astronomy and mathematics, because it mattered to them.
 
Ricmat wrote:
The D in ID is not talking about design as a verb, a mistake filled process, it’s talking about it as a noun, the final product. There is no constant tinkering implied (although for separate non-ID reasons, I tend to think that God interacts with his creation).
The problem with ID theory is that constant tinkering IS implied, if not outright stated as existing. The fundamental basis of ID “scientific theory” is that certain things that do exist couldn’t exist according to natural law and evolution, and therefore God must have interjected a miracle into the evolutionary process in order for them to exist.

One example that is brought up by ID proponents is the “irreducible complexity” of cell structures which require dozens of simultaneous chemical reactions to occur for them to exist, and these structures are required for the survival of any cell, but the evolutionary process would point to these chemical reactions to have occurred over time, one by one, though that’s plainly impossible given that the structures must exist in order for the cell environment to occur.

So ID, in this case, is postulating that we can “see” where a miracle has taken place in the evolutionary process, and therefore can “scientifically” prove the existence of a Designer. The gross errors with this approach have been demonstrated much more ably by brilliant scientists who DO believe in a Creator and Designer, but who don’t believe that He can be deduced from “gaps” in the evolutionary process. Dr. Francis Collins, head of the Human Genome Project (which should be an indicator of how well he knows his stuff as it regards genes and evolutionary structures!) and devout Christian, is perhaps the best person to read to understand why this kind of ID “theory” is utterly untenable.

Now that’s from the scientifically minded Christian side of the equation, but there is a perfectly sound theological argument against ID from the purely theological, and Catholic, perspective.

As St. Thomas Aquinas says in the Summa Theologica:
Some have understood God to work in every agent in such a way that no created power has any effect in things, but that God alone is the ultimate cause of everything wrought; for instance, that it is not fire that gives heat, but God in the fire, and so forth. But this is impossible.
First, because the order of cause and effect would be taken away from created things: and this would imply lack of power in the Creator: for it is due to the power of the cause, that it bestows active power on its effect.
The key point is the second paragraph, and it is that point that causes me to get upset when people argue against the natural efficacy of evolution to produce the biological structures we see around us. In essence they are denying the power of God in order to offer a weak argument in favor of His existence, they are making a small, understandable God out of an infinite and omnipotent one. I believe in the omnipotent power of God, the power to make a natural system that can generate life without the need for miraculous (read: non-natural) intervention.

This doesn’t take away the power of God to cause miracles (He clearly does all the time, in healings and other such things), nor does it mean that God isn’t working at the same time within and with evolution; in a certain sense you could say that God is working AS evolution. The reason for this is that God is constantly supplying the power of existence to everything, and everything is under the design and purview of God. If evolution occurs, it is because God empowers it to occur; this isn’t a miracle because it is not outside the natural operation of things, but rather is the CAUSE of the natural operation of things.

Natures are the effects of God, and anything that exists is a continuing effect of God’s constant activity, not something that stands apart, isolated from the existence of God. This is why we say that God is omnipresent, after all. When a cell gives energy to the body, we can say that the cell is acting 100%, and that God is acting 100%, and that neither is independent of the other, just as when I write with a pen I am writing 100% of the words, and the pen is writing 100% of the words. Science is ONLY disposed to evaluating the natural, or lesser, part of this equation however. Using the example of the writer and pen, science would be the study of how ink binds with the paper; the act of the writer is utterly beyond the consideration of such a study.

continued…
 
Obviously scientists who say that we can explain natures without God are being foolish, and materialism is actually the least intellectually robust approach to the world (and the least supportable). To me it’s not a question of whether or not materialists are right (they’re obviously not, as any freshman philosophy student should be able to tell you), but whether or not we should be diminishing God in order to fit into their world. The answer to that, I think, should be obvious: it’s utterly blasphemous to propose “scientific ID” as an alternative to pure scientific exploration of evolution. Yes, blasphemous, and that’s why I would personally take my children out of any science classes that proposed ID; it could give them warped and blasphemous understandings of God, IMO.

Peace and God bless!
 
That’s a beautiful picture of St. Theresa, Ghosty:) I love her. She is my favorite saint. I still have in my wallet a picture of her from decades ago when I went to public schools. We didn’t study the bible there but when I got home I did.🙂 “St. Therese of the Child Jesus would have liked to learn the languages of the Bible in order to better understand Sacred Scripture. Following her example and that of St. Jerome, dedicate time to frequent reading of the Bible. By familiarizing yourselves with the Word of God, you will discover Christ and remain in intimate contact with Him.” Benedict XVI (14 nov 2007)
(p.s. This is for my friend Elizabeth too who likes the bible. Be strong Sister! I’m praying for you! Pain is real. I had to take 10 mg of Baclofen to relax the nerve in my back after I . . . . I should have stayed in the ocean. But I’m glad to be here for a brief moment in time.)
 
I also feel that there needs to be an answer to these current best sellers written by atheists. The God Delusion - God Is NOT Great. These books cry out for a Christian response. If we don’t respond it seems as if their arguments are beyond dispute and we are admitting defeat. Atheists needs to see the weakness of their “religion” just as much, perhaps even more, than non-Catholics. They are spiritually MORE needy that Protestants!! I’ve had some conversations with young people who are testing the waters of atheism. Most of them have been disillusioned because of the death of a loved one and cannot reconcile this with a loving God. From everything I see, with materialistic western society going to its logical end, atheism is very much on the ascendancy. Catholic Christians need to be equipped for this apologetic work because these people really are in great spiritual need.
MonFrere
You have a very sympathetic ear with me, MonFrere, although I don’t think most of the Darwinists here really care that much about refuting Dawkins’ work. They don’t seem to care much about the problem of atheism either.

But if you would like to give it a try I would enjoy hearing what you have to say.

Dawkins’ view is that natural laws working on matter of the universe are responsible for the formation of the earth and life on earth and of human life and all there is to it.

As he sees it, there is no need for God to exist since everything that exists came about through accidental, blind processes.

How do you refute that?
 
Democritus, for example, was a philosopher, but also a scientist. His pioneering methodology became the basis for the scientific method. He used careful observation and inferences from evidence to make his conclusions.
However, his inference were philosophical, not scientific, for there was no way he could experiment on them. I agree that he was a giant in the method of reasoning.For example
He believed that all matter is made up of various imperishable, indivisible elements which he called atoms.He also theorized that the universe contained many other worlds, some of them inhabited:

"In some worlds there is no Sun and Moon while in others they are larger than in our world and in others more numerous. In some parts there are more worlds, in others fewer (…); in some parts they are arising, in others failing. There are some worlds devoid of living creatures or plants or any moisture."

My point is not in trying to say whether he is right or wrong but simply to point out his method of reasoning, however powerful it might have been, was not truly scientific in essence.
There is an old tradition that science education should include philosophy. I think it’s a good one.
I fully agree.
Properly speaking, there are no philosophical hypotheses. Science is a methodology which is inductive and procedes from evidence. Can’t be philosophical. But of course, the notion that the universe is knowable and consistent is a philosophical idea on which science rests.
However, some scientific inductions are, in my opinion, philosophical in essence since they are not directly verifyable, such as the quantum multiple space dimentions, the Point of singularity, and Democritus’ atom.
No. He conducted experiments, and examined the results to make his conclusions. His use of a clepshydra to show that air must be made of something, and his explanation of the nature of conic sections led him to believe that atoms must exist.
Would you have a link which I could maybe read up on this?
I don’t see how. What he did was what scientists still do. He even mocked other philosophers for trying to explain the material world with philosophic speculations. He said that people always want to explain nature by inventing new gods.
Well, he actually proposed the soul to be made up of a specific form of atoms. Again, my point is mearly to show his method as philosophical in nature, instead of scientific.
I think the problem is this; philosophy can inform science, but science can’t inform philosophy. Show me where dualism, for example, can be scientifically tested.
What I mean by philosophical is more directed towards the metaphysical, not necessarily the religious. Again, the point of singularity and quantum worlds are examples.
.
We don’t. In series of experiments, it was shown that antibiotic resistance (for example) appears even when antibiotics are not present. But such things only come to dominate the population where selection is operating for it.
But would’nt this be an example of genetic drift? If so, random mutation is not the explanation as I understand it.
Also, would you have a site where observations
were made where bacteria deficient in their ability to utilise the milk sugar lactose, acquired lactose-eating mutations when lactose was **not **available within their environment?
Being a religious doctrine, it can’t be taught in public school science classes, but it could be taught in a class on religion.
Here we seem to have some misunderstandings as to how we define intelligent desing. I don’t refer to id (as opposed to ID) as a form of intelligent design in terms of a god of the gap theory, but a process which exists having a purpose and direction. Now, in Darwin’s theory of evolution, while, natural selection is said to be the “directional element” (something I’m having problems with), it certainly cannot be said to be purposeful in nature.
Tell you what… let’s leave the term intelligent design aside. Would you be in agreement to simply let schools teach Darwin’s theory of evolution as such with the inclusion of having **some **hypotheses arising identifying the nature of mutations as being non-random in essence, and let the implication as to what this means, left to the
students?

Andre
 
What would be the consequences of teaching ID in public school science classes?
You mean BESIDES the promotion of a pseudoscience with no serious empirical or theoretical credibility? 🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top