Ricmat wrote:
The D in ID is not talking about design as a verb, a mistake filled process, it’s talking about it as a noun, the final product. There is no constant tinkering implied (although for separate non-ID reasons, I tend to think that God interacts with his creation).
The problem with ID theory is that constant tinkering IS implied, if not outright stated as existing. The fundamental basis of ID “scientific theory” is that certain things that do exist couldn’t exist according to natural law and evolution, and therefore God must have interjected a miracle into the evolutionary process in order for them to exist.
One example that is brought up by ID proponents is the “irreducible complexity” of cell structures which require dozens of simultaneous chemical reactions to occur for them to exist, and these structures are required for the survival of any cell, but the evolutionary process would point to these chemical reactions to have occurred over time, one by one, though that’s plainly impossible given that the structures must exist in order for the cell environment to occur.
So ID, in this case, is postulating that we can “see” where a miracle has taken place in the evolutionary process, and therefore can “scientifically” prove the existence of a Designer. The gross errors with this approach have been demonstrated much more ably by brilliant scientists who DO believe in a Creator and Designer, but who don’t believe that He can be deduced from “gaps” in the evolutionary process. Dr. Francis Collins, head of the Human Genome Project (which should be an indicator of how well he knows his stuff as it regards genes and evolutionary structures!) and devout Christian, is perhaps the best person to read to understand why this kind of ID “theory” is utterly untenable.
Now that’s from the scientifically minded Christian side of the equation, but there is a perfectly sound theological argument against ID from the purely theological, and Catholic, perspective.
As St. Thomas Aquinas says in the Summa Theologica:
Some have understood God to work in every agent in such a way that no created power has any effect in things, but that God alone is the ultimate cause of everything wrought; for instance, that it is not fire that gives heat, but God in the fire, and so forth. But this is impossible.
First, because the order of cause and effect would be taken away from created things: and this would imply lack of power in the Creator: for it is due to the power of the cause, that it bestows active power on its effect.
The key point is the second paragraph, and it is that point that causes me to get upset when people argue against the natural efficacy of evolution to produce the biological structures we see around us. In essence they are denying the power of God in order to offer a weak argument in favor of His existence, they are making a small, understandable God out of an infinite and omnipotent one. I believe in the omnipotent power of God, the power to make a natural system that can generate life without the need for miraculous (read: non-natural) intervention.
This doesn’t take away the power of God to cause miracles (He clearly does all the time, in healings and other such things), nor does it mean that God isn’t working at the same time within and with evolution; in a certain sense you could say that God is working AS evolution. The reason for this is that God is constantly supplying the power of existence to everything, and everything is under the design and purview of God. If evolution occurs, it is because God empowers it to occur; this isn’t a miracle because it is not outside the natural operation of things, but rather is the CAUSE of the natural operation of things.
Natures are the effects of God, and anything that exists is a continuing effect of God’s constant activity, not something that stands apart, isolated from the existence of God. This is why we say that God is omnipresent, after all. When a cell gives energy to the body, we can say that the cell is acting 100%, and that God is acting 100%, and that neither is independent of the other, just as when I write with a pen I am writing 100% of the words, and the pen is writing 100% of the words. Science is ONLY disposed to evaluating the natural, or lesser, part of this equation however. Using the example of the writer and pen, science would be the study of how ink binds with the paper; the act of the writer is utterly beyond the consideration of such a study.
continued…