This question is for all Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant Christians on this board. I’d love to have your oppinion on this.
I don’t know if I can be Catholic, because I cannot accept everything that the Church teaches. For one, I can’t accept the teaching that if I commit a grave sin, that Jesus Christ’s forgiveness isn’t enough, and I have to go through a priest, or I’ll go to Hell. I also can’t accept the Catholic teachings about holy days of obligation, because it seems to contradict scripture. I also have great trouble accepting that things like masterbation are sinful, let alone mortal sins.
Now that I’ve said all of this, I’ll say what I do agree with in the Catholic Church. I definitely agree that abortion is murder, because there’s plenty of evidence to support that for me. I sit on the fence when it comes to birth control though. I agree with most of the Catholic teachings about Mary. I believe that she’s the mother of the Church and Mother of God, that there’s nothing wrong with asking her to pray for me, and I believe that the Immaculate Conception and the Assumption are very possibly true, because of Marian apparitions that support them. Whether I’m Catholic or not, I still desire to pray the Rosary, and possibly have other Marian devotions. I don’t have a problem with the sacrament of Confession, because of John 20:21-23, but I also think that Jesus Christ’s forgiveness is just as good or better than absolution from a priest. I also believe in the Real Presence of Jesus Christ in the Eucharist.
So, if I’m not Catholic, then what am I? Should I try an Orthodox church?