I'm a gay guy. Should I marry a woman?

  • Thread starter Thread starter catholic1seeks
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’ve been at this whole Faith vs Gay thing for about a decade now, and it’s something that haunts me everyday.

So yes, my faith is not always steady, and it’s hard being 24 thinking I have to always now and forever remain celibate, even though I long for a relationship intensely.
 
Last edited:
Why would I marry a woman if I didn’t care for her?

No where did I imply that.
 
What would happen if you acted on your SSA feelings and your wife found out? How would you feel? Hos would she feel? Because she will get tired of it eventually.
 
When I said care for her I meant care for her in the physical attraction sort of way. Meaning if you’re not attracted to women, you shouldn’t marry one. That’s all.
 
See, that statement does really worry me.

I think you need to seek out spiritual direction. Find a kind, experienced spiritual director who can help you with the cross you are carrying. Perhaps reach out to an organization like Courage and see if they can recommend someone in your area.

Acting out of fear isn’t usually a good idea. And it isn’t what God wants of us. Just look at how many times He tells us, “Be not afraid.”

Seek out God’s plan for you. That is the way to peace.
 
I mean, I’ve been at it for a good 10 years without very good answers. I don’t want to be afraid, but I think the fear of loneliness is a quite normal fear. And when you’re gay, I think that adds a certain flavor to it.
 
It is a normal fear. But it doesn’t mean you should act out of fear. And it doesn’t mean you shouldn’t seek out help.

Have you ever reached out to Courage for help or advice?
 
No I haven’t, but I don’t think they’re really prominent where I live.
 

They have an online support function. Maybe you could start there (sometimes that can be less intimidating) and through that make connections with people in your area.

You may still choose to follow this path. But at least you’ll know there are other options and have support.
 
Hey - I’m a lady in a somewhat similar position.

One thing I’ll say is that the time of life you’re in is one of the hardest for what you’re feeling. I’m guessing pretty much everyone around you is pairing off, getting lost in their spouses and tuning out the rest of the world in favor of their partner. People are also moving around the country after college and falling out of contact with old friends. A lot of people who aren’t paired off are starting to seriously look. College tends to provide a ready-made social life that tends to get lost after college; few of these relationships survive after college.

Give it a few years. Get involved in church. You’re a real adult now, you can join normal adult people groups, not special college sort-of-adult groups! I’m sure you’re trying to get a job as well, and you’ll talk to people there too. Say hi to your neighbors, it’s fun, they might say high back. It gets a whole lot less lonely when you have people around who are thinking about things other than dating.
 
But I’m especially appreciative of:

“There are lots of types of marriages. Don’t think you need to fit into other people’s boxes.”
OP, the problem with your first post is that you are thinking of marriage seemingly in terms of its being “the ONLY way of finding lasting, meaningful relationships”. This is the wrong way to think even without the gay/ straight issue.

You get married because you find someone who you absolutely want to have in your life every day on a daily basis. It is possible, though perhaps challenging, for a gay person to find an opposite-sex partner who makes them feel this way and for whom the sexual aspect may not be a big deal. However, you are marrying the specific person, not just getting married for the sake of not being alone or for the sake of fitting into societal expectations.

I was married 23 years (to someone I’d already been with for 10 years when we got married). I had a good marriage, to the point where as a widow it’s hard for me to see myself bothering with any other relationship. However, I did not get married in order to not be alone. And believe me when I say that even in a good marriage, you will have times of feeling very much alone, lonely, etc. I got married because I wanted to be in a marriage with a particular person I met. Not just for the sake of getting married itself.

When you have a particular person who makes you feel like you want to have them around in your life daily, even with all the ups and downs and occasional feelings of loneliness, isolation, anger, frustration, etc., then we can talk about marriage. But kicking the idea around hypothetically when you do not have any actual person in mind is just theoretical chit chat. Feel free to be open to the idea, but your first post pretty much says to me that you have a long way to go before you will be ready to get married, and it’s not because you’re gay or have SSA, it’s a matter of understanding what a day-to-day marital relationship is all about. Which is something you can probably only learn by having a long-term relationship with someone, not by reading posts or talking to priests or reading books on it.
 
Last edited:
I’ve wondered if there were women that would like relationship with a gay man, enjoying the companionship and deep friendship, and forgoing marriage and sex.
Yes. I believe that there are. I think they’re probably in the older crowd (maybe over 40) but I think they certainly exist…as I stated earlier, I could see my self going that route if I weren’t already married (happily I might add lol!).
 
Last edited:
To be fair, marriage offers a special bond to a human being, and I think it’s in a lot of us to crave that connection. To be denied it based on sexual orientation must feel devastating to a gay Catholic.
 
Yes. I believe that there are. I think their probably in the older crowd (maybe over 40) but I think they certainly exist…as I stated earlier, I could see my self going that route if I weren’t already married (happily I might add lol!).
You are right. There are boatloads of these women. Not all of them are older, some of them just really enjoy gay men.
 
To be fair, marriage offers a special bond to a human being, and I think it’s in a lot of us to crave that connection. To be denied it based on sexual orientation must feel devastating to a gay Catholic.
If we accept that marriage is a vocation to which we are called by God, and that God’s plan is perfect (thus He will not ask anything of us of which we are not capable) then we have to consider whether the impulse to get married is actually because that is God’s plan or because of external societal pressures and expectations.
 
Never marry just to marry. I have seen a lot of marriages fail because people married “to avoid loneliness.”
I have never married and have dealt with loneliness much of my life. Yes, it is a Cross but definitely no worse (I’d say a thousand times better) than being in a lousy, lonely marriage or the pain of getting divorced. The older I get, the more I understand that God has actually spared me from much potential grief.
My point is that you should not fear loneliness. We ALL are given a particular Cross–or three–to bear. Loneliness is just one of many, and many are far worse. Whatever you do, don’t try to escape a Cross you haven’t even tasted yet by assuming that’s the one that will be given to you.
 
OP, the problem with your first post is that you are thinking of marriage seemingly in terms of its being “the ONLY way of finding lasting, meaningful relationships”. This is the wrong way to think even without the gay/ straight issue.

You get married because you find someone who you absolutely want to have in your life every day on a daily basis. It is possible, though perhaps challenging, for a gay person to find an opposite-sex partner who makes them feel this way and for whom the sexual aspect may not be a big deal. However, you are marrying the specific person, not just getting married for the sake of not being alone or for the sake of fitting into societal expectations.

I was married 23 years (to someone I’d already been with for 10 years when we got married). I had a good marriage, to the point where as a widow it’s hard for me to see myself bothering with any other relationship. However, I did not get married in order to not be alone. And believe me when I say that even in a good marriage, you will have times of feeling very much alone, lonely, etc. I got married because I wanted to be in a marriage with a particular person I met. Not just for the sake of getting married itself.

When you have a particular person who makes you feel like you want to have them around in your life daily, even with all the ups and downs and occasional feelings of loneliness, isolation, anger, frustration, etc., then we can talk about marriage. But kicking the idea around hypothetically when you do not have any actual person in mind is just theoretical chit chat. Feel free to be open to the idea, but your first post pretty much says to me that you have a long way to go before you will be ready to get married, and it’s not because you’re gay or have SSA, it’s a matter of understanding what a day-to-day marital relationship is all about. Which is something you can probably only learn by having a long-term relationship with someone, not by reading posts or talking to priests or reading books on it.
I think we need to quote this again!!! Excellent post 🙂
 
should I ATTEMPT MARRIAGE WITH A WOMAN??
Are you going to tell her before you propose, that you’re gay and have no physical attraction to women?

Do you think you’ll be capable of having sex with your wife?

Are you willing to have sex with your wife?

Why do you want marriage? Solely for the chance to have sex, or are there other reasons?

What will happen when you feel yourself sexually attracted to some man, and not attracted to your wife, especially since you seem to want marriage mostly to have sex?

What will happen if she stops wanting sex but you still want it, and still are attracted to men and not to her?

These questions just off the top of my head. I’m sure I could think of others if I set my mind to it.
May God bless you and give you comfort, but this is not a good idea.

Also, what Tis Bearself said.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top