I'm a Traditionalist but my family isn't: causing hurt

  • Thread starter Thread starter DiscerningCatholic02
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

DiscerningCatholic02

Guest
So I have for the last few months fallen in love with the Traditional Latin Mass and Traditionalist Catholicism in a family that is very suspicious/disliking of Traditionalism. It’s very hard because I can’t drive myself to the TLM and my parents don’t want to drive me to it and they get mad when I want to go to the TLM cause they thinking I’m causing division within my family. I have tried to explain it to them and my mother has been very open (which is weird because she is the most liturgically progressive in the family) but everyone else thinks I’m disillusioned by “stupid YouTube Catholics” which is what turned me on to the trad cats in the first place. I really need help sorry for the long read
 
The best thing you can do right now is get along with your family, quit bugging your parents, and wait until you’re old enough to have your own car and drive yourself.
 
That’s hard to do. Its hard to follow my conscience and my parents at the same time.
 
It’s great that you want to follow your conscience.
But your parents are in charge, and the best way for you to help maintain a harmonious home is to follow their lead.
 
How does conscience enter into it?
You’re allowed to go to Mass in your own language or in Latin.
It’s not a sin to go to non-Latin mass.
As long as you’re getting to any Catholic Mass, you’re okay.
 
Difficult for you,
but please don’t lose sight of the Mass is the Mass is the Mass,
and that the Mass itself is the essential mystery.
If you still live at home with your parents, until you leave home, it might be a little helpful to console yourself with the reality the original language of the Mass is Aramaic, and Hebrew, not Latin.

May God bless you and your family
 
It’s more than language it’s the reverance. Ad Orientam posture, communion rails… The such
 
Be careful, we follow our conscience in matters of faith and morals.

The Ordinary Form of the Mass is perfectly in line with our faith and morals.

You are talking about desiring to follow your personal taste.

Honor your parents. When you are an adult, go to any Mass you want.
 
Consider that you can learn a lot online – and you can also be indoctrinated. There’s nothing wrong with the Latin Mass, liturgical reverence, communion rails, etc. I love them all! But if you prize them above obedience to your parents, you’re in sin territory. Additionally, some of the YouTube videos out there on these topics are extremely problematic. You’re young. When you’re an adult and have complete freedom over your own movements, indulge in whatever Mass you like.
 
I grew up with the Latin Mass, when it was normal.
It was distancing to have everything said in Latin, with altar servers giving the people’s responses speaking as one who spent most of my early life with the ‘traditional’ Latin Mass. If that no longer happens then the current Latin Masses are not really as they were.
It was wonderful to be able to give our responses together as a community in language everyone understood afterVatican 2

I went to the usual “Latin” Mass every day even as a primary schoolgirl, and also continued daily Mass in the vernacular even long after I was married, early weekday Mass before my husband and children woke. The essence of my devotion was Mass itself, not any trappings, not anything rosy surrounding its celebration in either case.

People weren’t so different and suffered distractions, and so on.
The reality is that we cannot really know others spiritual state and should not judge anyone’s inner devotion.
There is always the danger that all the external devotionals can become the focus themselves, and lead some people to feel they are better than others (the attitudes of some people can sometimes seem to indicate that). I’m not claiming that is true of all, and have a dear nephew and niece who are ‘Traditional Catholics’

In either or any form of Eucharist, no human response to God or the Mass is perfect.
It is up to ourselves to be as sincere and devotional in Mass (and generally,) as possible
.
I’m just talking simple realities. I’ve been through times of being frustratingly overzealous and irritating others, but it is my basic nature to go to the heart of things, where truth is clear, honest, and inexpressible.

Try not to cause division in your family when they are already active Catholics. Bide your time in humility and faith, and be truly prayerful and deout at Mass, then make your move according to your desires when you are independent.

God bless you and your family
 
Last edited:
What you could do to get your Family to go to the Latin Mass is go to an Anglican Use Mass (if there is one nearby). The Anglican Use in my opinion is very similar to the Tridentine Mass. So going one can introduce your family to a traditional mass and hopefully get them to be more open to the tridentine mass.
 
@Prodigal1984 I think @on_the_hill is saying that he should just go the a Novus Ordo mass and wait till the OP has a way to go the Latin Mass without upsetting his parents.
 
Of course, as it continued for so long, centuries.
The current form has also and will, bring many to holiness in the years and centuries ahead.
Saint Pio, one of the greatest Saints of the 20th century, was heartbroken when his nun-sister refused to accept Vatican 2
 
Last edited:
Well if you lose your faith because you go to a Novus Ordo, in someways you might have not had much faith.
 
You are right. But it better to go to a Novus Ordo than miss mass all together.
 
Yes, that is the same for me. The Incense, the bells, the latin, and the silence moves me too.
 
I’ve extensively read his books. Naturally he did have concerns. There are pros and cons in practically al human initiatives. But he went so far as refusing to contact her till she obeyed, as obedience was central to his life and spiritualty.
Anyway, I’ve said my piece really, and answered to OP’s question the best I could, so leave the threadt to others.
 
Last edited:
Remember that the hurt can go both ways. Your Mass preferences are a personal thing; family harmony is a group effort and everyone has a part in it. Placing your preferences above the family harmony might be a selfish move. Be careful. Do “you” when you’re out on your own.
 
It is very difficult when something beautiful touches your heart, intellect and spiritual journey but you can’t fulfill your desire to grow in that area by actually participating in it. But thank God you have mass even if it is not the type of mass you prefer. So learn as much as you can about the Latin mass, grow in your love of it and in time you will be able to move in that direction, of course I mean within the Catholic Church with the present Pope. It can also be a cross you are willingly embracing. Just think of all the Catholic in the world who are being persecuted and many can not even get to mass. Offer it up for them. Just think in Sri Lanka–imagine going to mass on Sunday knowing that you could end up killed by a sick, evil minded terrorists. You still have the freedom to go to mass and are blessed you have a family that is Catholic even if they do not understand your love for the Latin Mass. 🙏
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top