Intelligent Design, most scientific

  • Thread starter Thread starter dcdurel
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
(Reggie tries a bit of quote-mining)

Reggies altered version:
reggieM: “Christ works a miracle every day at Holy Mass”

Barbarian: “Nonsense”

The unedited verision:
Reggie wrote
Christ works a miracle every day, millions of times a day, on every Catholic altar where there is a Holy Mass. To say that God’s miraculous intervention in life is “rare” is to dismiss the Catholic Faith in a serious way.
Barbarian replied:
Nonsense. God does miracles only to teach us something. The mass is precisely that. If God went out and tinkered with nature on a regular basis, we would have a seriously unpredictable universe to live in.

You edited what I wrote to make it appear that “nonsense” applied to the first sentence and not the second. It might have seemed like a clever thing to do, but contrary to Luther’s assertion, a “good strong lie” is never justified.

Shame on you.
 
What else is it, when you make something, and then have to step in from time to time to make it work the way you want?
It’s called freedom on our part and hope on God’s part as far as I can tell.

Just as a parent hoping that their children will make the right choices nonetheless allows their children a certain amount of room to make mistakes and then steps in to correct the mistakes the child makes, so too with God hoping that his creation will make the right choices nonetheless allows his children a certain amount of room to make mistakes and then steps in to correct the mistakes his creation makes.
Romans 8:18-26:
I consider that our present sufferings are not worth comparing with the glory that will be revealed in us.

The creation waits in eager expectation for the sons of God to be revealed. For the creation was subjected to frustration, not by its own choice, but by the will of the one who subjected it, in hope that the creation itself will be liberated from its bondage to decay and brought into the glorious freedom of the children of God.

We know that the whole creation has been groaning as in the pains of childbirth right up to the present time.

Not only so, but we ourselves, who have the firstfruits of the Spirit, groan inwardly as we wait eagerly for our adoption as sons, the redemption of our bodies.

For in this hope we were saved. But hope that is seen is no hope at all.

Who hopes for what he already has?

But if we hope for what we do not yet have, we wait for it patiently.

In the same way, the Spirit helps us in our weakness.

We do not know what we ought to pray for, but the Spirit himself intercedes for us with groans that words cannot express.

And he who searches our hearts knows the mind of the Spirit, because the Spirit intercedes for the saints in accordance with God’s will.
Not the Ionian scientists, who generally acknowledged that there were many things that exist that cannot be discerned. Indeed, democritus demonstrated the existence of atoms by experiments and such reasoning. And any scientist from Bacon on, (or rather from Ibn al-Haitham, whom Bacon emulated) would say that it was possible but untestable at that time.
Ibn al-Haitham was an interesting person.
We used to think lightning was God smiting his enemies. In some ways, progress has been a matter of learning that God didn’t directly intervene in various things, after all. This doesn’t mean that someday we won’t find a case like that, but the evidence certainly suggests that we won’t.
And yet the Scriptures do seem to claim that God really does intervene on a personal level, such as the case of Eliajah calling down fire for example, or Moses and the 10 Plagues for another. Christ our Lord is the most primordial and yet ever present example of God directly intervening in various things.
 
Barbarian asks:
What else is it, when you make something, and then have to step in from time to time to make it work the way you want?
It’s called freedom on our part and hope on God’s part as far as I can tell.
Where I grew up, people called that “tinkering.” If it happened a lot, and the fixes weren’t so good, they called it “cobbling.”
Just as a parent hoping that their children will make the right choices nonetheless allows their children a certain amount of room to make mistakes and then steps in to correct the mistakes the child makes, so too with God hoping that his creation will make the right choices nonetheless allows his children a certain amount of room to make mistakes and then steps in to correct the mistakes his creation makes.
How does an omniscient being “hope?” And why would he grant freedom to a mindless process such as nature?

I think your scriptural reference is appropriate to us, but not to nature, which has no consciousness.

(Assertion that scientists would scoff at invisible things)
Not the Ionian scientists, who generally acknowledged that there were many things that exist that cannot be discerned. Indeed, democritus demonstrated the existence of atoms by experiments and such reasoning. And any scientist from Bacon on, (or rather from Ibn al-Haitham, whom Bacon emulated) would say that it was possible but untestable at that time.
Ibn al-Haitham was an interesting person.
Don’t really know as much about him as I should. I do know he used what we now regard as the scientific method, and that Bacon learned a great deal from him. The point, of course, is that very early on, the notion of the invisible as possible was part of science. Democritus use a clepshydra, for example, to show that air was something, and therefore must be made of atoms (which he demonstrated in a gedankenexperiment on conic sections).

Barbarian observes:
We used to think lightning was God smiting his enemies. In some ways, progress has been a matter of learning that God didn’t directly intervene in various things, after all. This doesn’t mean that someday we won’t find a case like that, but the evidence certainly suggests that we won’t.
And yet the Scriptures do seem to claim that God really does intervene on a personal level, such as the case of Eliajah calling down fire for example, or Moses and the 10 Plagues for another.
To make an obvious point. Not because nature does that. Lightning bolts are just natural phenomena, not the weapons of a vengeful God.

Which is not to say that God can’t use such things to serve His will. Our physical selves, for example are the result of a natural process.
Christ our Lord is the most primordial and yet ever present example of God directly intervening in various things.
Indeed. But not evolution or lightning bolts, which have always been found to be natural phenomena.
 
I will also note that many theistic evolutionists seem extremely reluctant to attempt to draw any kind of “scientific parables” to point people toward God.

In fact, whenever I ask people “What does evolution tell us about God?” I usually hear crickets chirping in background or else the blunt answer “Nothing”.

This is something that I personally find to be a major downfall to the theistic evolutionist position and a boost to the intelligent design movement, even though I myself am subscribing more and more to the theistic evolutionary position.

Instead of looking for ways that one can explain God to people using the “evolutionary parables” like how Jesus used parables of salt, light, coins, etc…, they seem to be content to smugly insist that everyone agree with them without actually offering any explanation as to why we should believe, except – of course – the science says so.

**I am so sorry to hear that. I am constantly, some say too pie in the sky pontificating, babbling about how I find the structure of the universe, the simplicity of the laws of physics, the enormity of what 4 laws can cause in terms of diversity, the unbelieveable diversity of life and habitat and degree of symbiosis. To think that all this can come from simply God’s thought executed into Word, accomplished with such infinite beauty and timelessness. I feel so very sad you’ve never found any theist evolutionist until me to say this. I cannot believe I am odd in this. Rather I have always thought that we who realize that God set all this marvelous thing in motion have been much more pastoral in our explanations than the simplistic and set in stone regurgitation of the Genesis “facts”. **
 
I find the structure of the universe, the simplicity of the laws of physics, the enormity of what 4 laws can cause in terms of diversity, the unbelieveable diversity of life and habitat and degree of symbiosis. To think that all this can come from simply God’s thought executed into Word, accomplished with such infinite beauty and timelessness. I feel so very sad you’ve never found any theist evolutionist until me to say this.
Wow… well when you put it that way… maybe evolution IS compatible with believing in God…
 
Barbarian: “nonsense” applied to the … second sentence.

reggieM’s second sentence: To say that God’s miraculous intervention in life is “rare” is to dismiss the Catholic Faith in a serious way.

God’s miraculous intervention is not rare.

Barbarian stated that this was “nonsense”.
 
To think that all this can come from simply God’s thought executed into Word
Where does evolutionary theory say that all of this came from God’s thought executed into Word?
 
Then again, scientific people tend to not be poetic, so perhaps it’s to be expected. … scientifically hyper-literalists who insist that anything they say be as scientifically accurate as possible-- even to the exclusion of the “creative side” which Jesus himself used all too well. :yup:
Excellent points. Science tends to break things apart. It splits observations into smaller increments to enable study. As a result it cannot see the unifying features of the universe or of nature. This is the poetic aspect which can’t be understood by science. The scientific view of a poem is to break it into syllables or to individual letters.

This is “reductionism”. Where a human being is reduced to being a product merely of material elements. Some will even split a human being into “natural” and “spiritual” aspects – as if they are not bound together.

Jesus’ resurrection was observed and tested. The resurrection on the last day is the unity of soul and body.
 
But what about miracles that aren’t so bold and blatant as to leave undeniable evidence? We know that even many miracles that occur today can’t be proven.
… I’d say that your whole system presumes that lack of miracles unless they are proven, but is incapable of detecting most miracles when they do happen. Where does that leave God?
That’s an excellent point. How is it possible to declare how many miracles God works each day and what they affect without knowing as much as God does about this? There are miracles of healing of the human body that occur without being recorded.
 
Reggi tries it one more time:
(Reggie’s altered version)

God’s miraculous intervention is not rare.

Barbarian stated that this was “nonsense”.

The unaltered version:

Reggie wrote
Christ works a miracle every day, millions of times a day, on every Catholic altar where there is a Holy Mass. To say that God’s miraculous intervention in life is “rare” is to dismiss the Catholic Faith in a serious way.

Barbarian replied:
Nonsense. God does miracles only to teach us something. The mass is precisely that. If God went out and tinkered with nature on a regular basis, we would have a seriously unpredictable universe to live in.

No one wants to hear the excuses. Learn from it, and don’t do it again.
 
Excellent points. Science tends to break things apart. It splits observations into smaller increments to enable study. As a result it cannot see the unifying features of the universe or of nature. This is the poetic aspect which can’t be understood by science. The scientific view of a poem is to break it into syllables or to individual letters.
My son has a degree in English. To my surprise, he showed me that there are ways to analyze poems in a reductionist way that allows one to understand more than the mechanics; one can also look at the effect specific words and phonenemes have within the poem, and thereby the emotional and associative effect they produce.

That being said, when I learned to write sonnets, and did one for my wife, she was charmed largely for my intentions and the rather clumsy expression of love. (like most scientists, I’m usually of the “of course I love you; I told you that when I proposed” temperment) Both are worth understanding. I won’t embarrass all of us by posting the poem here.
This is “reductionism”. Where a human being is reduced to being a product merely of material elements. Some will even split a human being into “natural” and “spiritual” aspects – as if they are not bound together.
The natural and the spiritual are bound together in man, and if we deny the reality of those two parts, we will be often dismayed and misled.

And, BTW, science does not have to be reductionist. Many people, like Konrad Lorenz, were rather thorough holists in their work, but still did useful and interesting science.
 
I find the structure of the universe, the simplicity of the laws of physics, the enormity of what 4 laws can cause in terms of diversity, the unbelieveable diversity of life and habitat and degree of symbiosis. To think that all this can come from simply God’s thought executed into Word, accomplished with such infinite beauty and timelessness. I feel so very sad you’ve never found any theist evolutionist until me to say this.
Wish I had said this. It’s the most precise and elegant expression of the idea I have seen. Do you mind if I quote you elsewhere?
 
You stated that what I said was nonsense and you have not been able to explain why.
You may believe so, but that is not an excuse for what you did. You had no right to change what I said and pretend that is what I meant.

Don’t do it, again, and there won’t be need for excuses.
 
You had no right to change what I said and pretend that is what I meant.
I used your words directly. I offered two statements. You replied “nonsense”. You then claimed that only my second sentence was “nonsense”. I did not change what you said (this is a deceptive response from you, not your first).

You’ve now had four opportunities to explain what you meant when you referred to what I said as “nonsense”.

Normally I would consider a person who responds as you do as a liar. But in your case I really just think that you’re not capable of understanding or of explaining what you mean or what you’re thinking.

You’ve said that you’re a scientist – I would guess that you just lack some verbal and intellectual skills which are necessary for carrying out a conversation like this.

Your recent comment about how the natural and spiritual cannot be separated is a direct contradiction to what you posted to me about how evolution separates man’s nature from his supernature.

Perhaps your scientific skills are very good and I wouldn’t doubt that. But your theology and communication skills are sorely lacking. Personally, I think this is because you’re not self-reflective enough. You fire off responses without thinking about what you just said.

This is a perfect example. You’re acting offended because I simply replayed your comments. No further explaination was offered by you – just the ambiguous and probably incorrect (who knows what you meant) statement is left without comment.

I’m just surprised that anybody can actually carry on a conversation with you. There must be some secret to it that I don’t know at this point.
 
Reggie writes:
I used your words directly.
No, you altered them to make it appear that I said something I did not. Wasn’t as good an idea as you thought, um?
Normally I would consider a person who responds as you do as a liar.
You know what people think of people who do what you did?
You’ve said that you’re a scientist – I would guess that you just lack some verbal and intellectual skills which are necessary for carrying out a conversation like this.
I know better than to try to change a quote when the original is on the board for everyone to see. I may not be the smartest guy in the world, but I’m smarter than that.
Your recent comment about how the natural and spiritual cannot be separated
You got it wrong again. I pointed out that the separation between nature and supernatural things is convoluted but not fuzzy. It’s pretty clear to anyone familiar with both.
Perhaps your scientific skills are very good and I wouldn’t doubt that. But your theology and communication skills are sorely lacking.
Maybe if you would take what I said, instead of trying to change it to suit yourself, you’d have an easier time. You’d get more respect here, I’m sure.
This is a perfect example. You’re acting offended because I simply replayed your comments.
You edited out parts and then pasted it back together to make it look like I said something I didn’t. Big mistake, that.
I’m just surprised that anybody can actually carry on a conversation with you. There must be some secret to it that I don’t know at this point.
Most people call it “integrity.”

Worth learning about.
 
Barbarian asks:
What else is it, when you make something, and then have to step in from time to time to make it work the way you want?

Where I grew up, people called that “tinkering.” If it happened a lot, and the fixes weren’t so good, they called it “cobbling.”
The time frame that we are all growing up in is still not completed yet either-- because on the last day, time itself will apparently come to a screaching halt as the Lord creates the New Heavens and New Earth.

We are already part of that New Creation in Christ too.
How does an omniscient being “hope?”
And why would he grant freedom to a mindless process such as nature?
In answer to your question of how an omniscient being hopes, I would simply ask how does an omniscient being “desire all men to be saved and to come to a knowledge of the truth” as 1 Timothy 2:3-5 states-- even though he knows that there will indeed be some who will “be punished with everlasting destruction and shut out from the presence of the Lord and from the majesty of his power” as Thessalonians 1:9 states?

God’s hope (desire, want, etc.) is not the same thing as God’s will (law, knowledge, etc.)

And in answer to your question of why he would grant freedom to a mindless process such as nature I would simply ask in retort why would he grant freedom to a mindless process such as sin?

This comes right back to the question that you have continually dismissed as me somehow conflating evolution with atheism-- which is not my point as I’ve clearly stated.
I think your scriptural reference is appropriate to us, but not to nature, which has no consciousness.
Then why is the entire order of Creation groaning in the labour pains in eager expectation for the Sons of God to be revealed?
(Assertion that scientists would scoff at invisible things)
Not the Ionian scientists, who generally acknowledged that there were many things that exist that cannot be discerned. Indeed, democritus demonstrated the existence of atoms by experiments and such reasoning. And any scientist from Bacon on, (or rather from Ibn al-Haitham, whom Bacon emulated) would say that it was possible but untestable at that time.
So, if this is true, is it possible for science to reason that God must exist in way similar to how Democritus reasoned that atoms must exist?
 
Don’t really know as much about him as I should. I do know he used what we now regard as the scientific method, and that Bacon learned a great deal from him.
Among the Arab world, he was indeed a powerful thinker who, in my opinion, we here in the West are much indebted to. I think we here in the West would do well to read up on these men before we conclude that the extremist fundamentalists speak for the entire history of Islamic thought.

As a Catholic there are indeed many things that I disagree with regarding Islam. But there are some shining lights from the Islamic word too, even if the religion of Islam did not produce the original thought.
The point, of course, is that very early on, the notion of the invisible as possible was part of science.
Yes, and many others would not listen to the Ionions precisely because they thought radically different from them. Aristotle probably did more to distract us from the concept of atoms than any other philosopher as far as I can tell.

Speaking of the “invisible”, Romans 1:20 states…
For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that men are without excuse.
Likewise, speaking of that which “was visible”, Hebrews 11:3 states…
By faith we understand that the universe was formed at God’s command, so that what is seen was not made out of what was visible.
What do you think these passages mean?
Democritus use a clepshydra, for example, to show that air was something, and therefore must be made of atoms (which he demonstrated in a gedankenexperiment on conic sections).
What is Spirit made of?

What is the difference between that which has always existed and that which has never existed, since both actually never actually began in the first place?
Barbarian observes:
We used to think lightning was God smiting his enemies.
And, for the record, sometimes I think God has indeed allowed lightning to smite his enemies, such as the case of Elijah “calling down fire” for a potential example.
In some ways, progress has been a matter of learning that God didn’t directly intervene in various things, after all. This doesn’t mean that someday we won’t find a case like that, but the evidence certainly suggests that we won’t.
What about the heptad pattern noted within the chronobiological sciences I noted before?

Would this be a possible case?
To make an obvious point. Not because nature does that. Lightning bolts are just natural phenomena, not the weapons of a vengeful God.
Then what were God’s intentions when bringing on the Great Deludge for example?

Whether of not this was a global event, and regardless of whether this was a supernatural or a natural event, the Scriptures seem to be vlear that this was an intentional act of God’s part. The early fathers seem clear on this poin too.

One could also look to the Sodom and Gamorra events in addition to the 10 plagues of Egupt too (Indeed, the patterns in the 10 plagues of Egypt seem to match in some way some of the plagues mentioned in the Apocalypse too).
Which is not to say that God can’t use such things to serve His will. Our physical selves, for example are the result of a natural process.
So if animals and plants actually have “mortal souls” in contrast to humanity having “immortal souls”, are there any patterns within nature that our immortal souls mirror?

Indeed, is there anything within nature itself which can produce a “mortal soul” which is then completed by God with his breath to make it an “immortal soul”?
Indeed. But not evolution or lightning bolts, which have always been found to be natural phenomena.
Why not?

If this is a subset of God’s “supernature”, then evolution and lightning bolts must in some way mirror the “supernature” so much so that one can draw “scientific parables” from them in the same way that Jesus used salt, oil, light, fire, money, food, wine, and other “mundane things” to present a metaphysical reality overarching the physical.

Indeed, more forcefully speaking, our own practices and methodologies used within our own Seven Sacraments are done specifically with the intention to use “visible elements” to make the invisible visible to humanity. Sacraments are outward signs of inward grace, instituted by Christ for our sanctification. We ourselves are living as a sacrament too-- a visible sign of God’s invisible grace.

If so, then what does evolution make visible concerning God’s will or desire?
 
Excellent points. Science tends to break things apart. It splits observations into smaller increments to enable study. As a result it cannot see the unifying features of the universe or of nature. This is the poetic aspect which can’t be understood by science. The scientific view of a poem is to break it into syllables or to individual letters.

This is “reductionism”. Where a human being is reduced to being a product merely of material elements. Some will even split a human being into “natural” and “spiritual” aspects – as if they are not bound together.

Jesus’ resurrection was observed and tested. The resurrection on the last day is the unity of soul and body.
In some sense I agree with you, but doubt that leads to whatever conclusion about the resurrection you are attempting to make. In other ways I think you are increasingly wrong. One can see a very distinct cross-disciplinary work in a lot of science today. There are today many disciplines brought to bear for instance in anthropology. The wonder is that when each does it small part and all are added together, they present a whole unified coherent complementary statement of the world. That perhaps gives the greatest evidence for evolution to date, though some scientists would argue that the genome project laid to rest any question that evolution was not the correct model. I don’t have to scientific expertise certainly to agree or disagree, but I have no reason to doubt them either.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top