Interdenominational Relationships

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeBaptsitGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
1ke, what you are saying disagrees with what others have said. Are you saying that if a woman had to choose between having her uterus removed (causing sterility) and dying, she ought to choose death? I actually work for a Catholic hospital, and to its credit, they refuse to perform procedures that the CC is against. A prime example, they closed the OB unit rather than perform abortions. Yet this hospital allows hysterectomys, though I think all due to cancer.
There is a distinction between a legitimate medical intervention due to disease in which sterility is an unintended, secondary consequence and direct sterilization to prevent pregnancy.

I believed you to be talking about the latter, not the former.

Your example above is of a legitimate medical procedure-- removing a cancerous uterus-- that results in unavoidable but unintended sterility. That is not immoral.

Having a hysterectomy or tubal ligation to prevent pregnancy is immoral.
 
There is a distinction between a legitimate medical intervention due to disease in which sterility is an unintended, secondary consequence and direct sterilization to prevent pregnancy.

I believed you to be talking about the latter, not the former.

Your example above is of a legitimate medical procedure-- removing a cancerous uterus-- that results in unavoidable but unintended sterility. That is not immoral.

Having a hysterectomy or tubal ligation to prevent pregnancy is immoral.
In that case everyone is on the same page.

Let me muddy the waters a bit. Would it be immoral for a woman to have them removed for comfort, as in she was having heavy painful periods, endometriosis, or had PCOS? Or if she was beyond normal age, reached menopause and wanted them removed so cancer could not even start?
 
In that case everyone is on the same page.

Let me muddy the waters a bit. Would it be immoral for a woman to have them removed for comfort, as in she was having heavy painful periods, endometriosis, or had PCOS? Or if she was beyond normal age, reached menopause and wanted them removed so cancer could not even start?
That would be a question for the National Catholic Bioethics Center. The Church does have a document clarifying when a hysterectomy may be done, and I do not believe any of your scenarios pose the sort of immediate danger and need for the removal of the uterus, except perhaps endometriosis. I do not think in general your scenarios would rise to the requirements of the principle of double effect.
 
Basicly, the rosary is a prayer aid then?
It is a meditation on the important events in the life of Christ. There are four sets of Mysteries, each with five Mysteries.

The first set is called the Joyful Mysteries, and we meditate on the Annunciation (it begins, “Gabriel announced to Mary …”) the Visitation ("then Mary went up into the hill country to visit her cousin Elizabeth … ") the Nativity ("And the birth of Christ came about in this way … ") the Presentation (“And when the days of her purification according to the law of Moses were accomplished …”) and the Finding in the Temple (“And when they had fulfilled the days, as they returned, the child Jesus tarried behind in Jerusalem; and Joseph and his mother knew not of it …”)

The second set is called the Luminous Mysteries, and we meditate on The baptism of Our Lord in the River Jordan -Luke 3:21-22, Mark 1:6-11, Matthew 3:11-17; The wedding at Cana, when Christ manifested himself - John 2:1-11; The Proclamation of the Kingdom - Mark 1:14-21; The Transfiguration of Our Lord - Matthew 17:1-9; The Last Supper, when Our Lord gave us the Holy Eucharist - Matthew 26:17-30, John 6:53-65;

The third set is the Sorrowful Mysteries: Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane - Matthew 26:36-46; Jesus is Scourged - Matthew 27:25-26; Jesus is Crowned with Thorns - Matthew 27:28-29; Jesus Carries His Cross - John 19:17-18; Jesus is Crucified - Luke 23:45-46

The fourth set is called the Glorious Mysteries: Jesus Rises from the Dead - John 20; Jesus Ascends into Heaven - Acts 1:6-12; The Holy Spirit Descends upon the Church - Acts 2:1-13; Mary ascends into Heaven - Revelation 11:19; Mary is crowned Queen of Heaven -Revelation 12:1
The indulgences are another matter I planned to ask about. My sole understanding comes from a mildly anti-traditional Christian values history professor. As such, my basic understanding was that indulgences are basicly buying forgiveness for sins. (He spent a significant amount of time poking at the Catholic church of the middle ages for selling indulgences and the like). As such, I would be very interesting in hearing about indulgences.
Indulgences are hard for a lot of non-Catholics, who are used to a kind of “magical” idea of God, to wrap their minds around. So, to set the stage, I’m going to start with a bit of history.

In the Early Church, you may remember that the Apostles and their followers were persecuted by Nero and other really awful people, who were throwing them to the lions, crucifying them, and who knows what else. Many brave Christian souls went to their deaths singing hymns of joy, and looking forward to their immanent reunion with Jesus Christ in Heaven.

But there may have been one or two who did not. They backed out at the last minute, blasphemed against Christ, and saved their physical lives by denying that they had ever been Christians.

Once they got safe, they tried to come back to Church, but the Church had a problem. They wanted to know, “Are you a Christian, or are you not? You told Nero that you are not. Now, you’re telling us that you are. What are we supposed to believe?”

So these people (they even had a special name; they were called “lapsi” meaning “one who has lapsed in his faith”) had to prove themselves by means of Confession and penances.

The Church at that time was not looking for some kind of sissy-pants couple of prayers here and there - no, way. They wanted to see real repentance, so they asked the lapsi to quit their jobs, leave their homes, put on sack-cloth and ashes, beg for alms in the streets, and walk barefoot in the snow. Not just for the weekend, either. For three years. For seven years. Or ten years. Or 25 years. Depending on how bad the situation was.

Over time, the same penances were dealt out for such sins as adultery, theft, murder, gossip, etc.

These penances are called “Temporal punishments.”

Some other definitions you will need, before proceeding:

The Sacrament of Reconciliation is also called “Confession” and takes place when a Catholic goes to his priest and, in a ritual going back to the time of the Apostles, tells his sins to the priest and receives the Absolution. It is how sins committed after the time of Baptism are forgiven.

Baptism takes place when a person who has never before been baptized is placed under water, or has water poured over him, while the words, “I baptize you in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” are spoken by the same person who is doing the baptizing. Baptism washes away all sins, both Original Sin and every personal sin committed up to the time of the Baptism.

The power of the keys is the authority given by Jesus Christ to Peter, and given by Peter to his successors, in Matthew 16:18-19, to bind and to loose on earth, with Heavenly authority.

Now that you know those things:

An Indulgence can be defined as "the remission of the temporal punishments due to sin that has already been forgiven in the Sacrament of Reconciliation or else by means of Baptism which remission is granted by the Church in the exercise of the power of the keys, through the application of the superabundant merits of Christ and of the saints, and for some just and reasonable motive.

More information about Indulgences can be found here:

newadvent.org/cathen/07783a.htm

One thing to realize is that you cannot, and could never, buy an Indulgence. What one used to be able to do (but can no longer do) was that one could receive an Indulgence for giving a sum of money to the poor, or to the Church, or to some other worthy cause. But because of the fact that people were calling this “buying an Indulgence” it is now no longer possible to receive that sort of a Heavenly reward for giving money to good causes. (One should still do so out of love of neighbour, however.) 🙂
 
Piper, that makes sense.

Cast, Easter is pagan. While many Christians have appropriated it, and think it good because it is Christianized, I do not agree. The eggs, rabbits etc are all throwbacks and I personally have no part of it, and in my eyes Easter has no part of Christianity. I personally WILL celebrate what Christ did, that was die on the cross for my sins, and conquer death when he was resurrected.
We celebrate the Resurrection of Christ at Easter time. Catholics have little or nothing to do with eggs or rabbits - at least, I’ve never seen them at Mass during the Easter season.
Why exactly is a Catholic forbidden to commune at a Baptist church?
Because we are only allowed to receive Holy Communion from our own priests, since we are under their authority; not under anyone else’s authority. A Baptist preacher can have all the good intentions in the world, but he does not have sufficient authority over any Catholic to be able to give them Holy Communion. Nor does any Catholic priest have the authority to give Holy Communion to anyone who is not Catholic.

The issue of believing or not believing in Transubstantiation always comes up, but it is a side issue - the real issue is, even if we all believed the same things, we are not under each other’s authority.
Spiritually, what is the purpose of infant baptism to Catholics?
To incorporate the child into Christ, to make him a member of the Church and to wash away Original Sin, without which, he cannot go to Heaven if he dies.
 
Why exactly is a Catholic forbidden to commune at a Baptist church?
This depends on which Baptist church one happens to be attending. Many Baptists consider Catholics cultist or pagan and would not welcome Catholics to Baptist communion.

Why the discrepancy from one Baptist church to the next?
 
Nate, I am not so sure. I have long held the view that when we commune we are doing as Christ said, eating his flesh, and blood. I also do not hold that a mediator is required. I believe we as individuals can hold a relationship with God. Think of all the churches that took place in the past in peoples homes, or hidden churches in oppressive regimes the world over, are they denied communion because some scumbag dictator refuses to let a Catholic preist perform the ceremony? I think not. Such a position flies in the face of Christ’s declaration that all who called upon him would be saved, and Christ says in John 6:53 that you must have his flesh and blood in you to have life. With all that in mind, anyone can call upon Christ and anyone can eat his flesh and blood, without a mediator.
Up until the Protestant Reformation I think you would be hard pressed to find anyone who believed transubstantiation could occur without a priest. The lives of the saints are filled with powerful stories about the events that occurred when the Church was persecuted. The story of Maximilian Kolbe in the Nazi concentration camps is one such powerful story. The Eucharist is a powerful way in which we receive God’s grace but it is not the only method by which this can occur. Christianity was persecuted in the past and is sure to be persecuted in the future. I think your conjecture also would need to be taken further though. What about if the family is not only devoid of a priest, but also of bread and wine to offer? How are they to receive communion without the gifts to offer? Are only bread and wine acceptable offerings? You open up a lot more question when you go down the road you have chosen to go down. You have to look at this teaching in the context of his entire ministry as well as look back into the past and the practice of the Early Church.
 
mark, I think the pre-marriage part requires more explanation for my generation, sadly.

jm, thanks for the rosary explanation. Same for indulgences, I am aware of the early persecution, it always makes me happy that I am an American, and the worst I am likely to ever deal with is someone who laughs at my faith. Still, while indulgences may have been a way to sort those who got scared versus the non-serious believers originally, I cannot help but to question what it became. While selling may not have been direct, I would say indirect selling is still bad. On a different note, I don’t think it is fair to say nonCatholics have a “magical” idea of God. I was raised Baptist, and God was always viewed as involved, and supreme, magic was never thought of.

On Confession, this is something else I don’t quite get. First, let me explain my background. I see our relationship with God as a very personal one. As such, when I screw things up, I can go directly to him and confess my sins. Is the Catholic view not as personal?

This may also tie into authority, I don’t get why it matters so much as long as the Faith is there.

mark, Baptist churches tend to be quite independent. Whereas the Catholic church for example has a visible hierarchy, Baptist churches do not. We may join a larger group, the Southern Baptist Convention for example, but the SBA does NOT have the power to tell individual churches what to do. This has many obvious benefits, but some drawbacks as well. You can get some very shady conmen who call themselves Baptists. I would add, most religious groups, even Catholicism, has this issue, but I would say our individuality makes it worse for us. Your assertion that many Baptists consider Catholics pagan or cultist is something I never have encountered, and I have known quite a few Baptist congregations. We of course disagree on some matters, and there are some who are apprehensive (I would say largely due to misunderstanding) of Catholicism, but I have met very few who would not consider Catholics brothers in Christ.

nate, by the same token, how much splintering to Christianity had occured prior to the Protestant Reformation? Some, but nothing like what occured after.
 
My church takes the view (this is the short version) that all Christians who acknowledge God, and that Jesus died for us, are part of a catholic/universal Church. Regardless of denomination.
This is an enjoyable discussion for me, too (by now I have gotten used to a different tone, especially in “modesty” threads here in CAF Family Life, where I will say that people visiting a Catholic church should cover their shoulders and cleavage, and wear pants or skirts/dresses covering their knees in accord with the dress code imposed by our Pope and Bishops, and someone else will reply, “I doubt any teenage boy would complain about the scenery” *, or, my personal all-time favorite, “it looks as though most men have less self-control than my dogs!” 😃 Meaning, of course, that “To hell with the Pope and Bishops, I’m still going to wear whatever I want to church, and if that bothers you, you must be one of those guys with no self-control!” So, I just wanted to warn you, BG, the tone occasionally gets heated here :D).

OK, regarding the view of the Church, I used to listen a lot to Evangelical Christian radio, such as the truly excellent Focus on the Family program of Dr. James Dobson. And, indeed, that’s how Evangelical Christians view the Church, too, they view it as the community of all people who acknowledge Jesus Christ as their Savior and call themselves Christians. But this definition exposed a big problem to me, especially in regard to IVF and practicing homosexuals. For example, the Focus on the Family group is staunchly pro-life and rejects IVF as well. However, they are in the minority among Protestants, because most Protestant denominations do not regard IVF as problematic.

So, then, if the Church is the sum of all believers who acknowledge Jesus Christ, how is it that there’s such a huge internal conflict within the Church? Didn’t Jesus tell that no house can stand that is internally divided, and now here we have the “Church” divided on the issue of IVF? And the conflict is just as painful with regard to the Episcopalian Church, and more recently the Presbyterian Church as well, ordaining practicing homosexual Priests and Bishops who live together with their gay partners. Again, if the Church includes all believers who acknowledge Jesus Christ as their savior, then the Church must include both the group of Episcopalians and Presbyterians who enthusiastically embrace homosexuality, and the group of Evangelical Christians who reject it in the strongest terms, as something coming directly from Satan. But, if this is the case, haven’t the gates of hell already prevailed against the Church, in contrast to Christ’s promise that the gates of hell wouldn’t prevail against his Church? Don’t we have a huge internal division in the Church, when some believers embrace homosexuality which is coming directly from Satan?

To top it all off, I remember listening to an Evangelical radio station one day, and the speaker urging the listeners to “find and attend a church that works for them!” And I was like, “a church that works for me?” :confused: 😛 You see, if I suddenly discover that I have homosexual inclinations, all I would have to do is “find a church that works for me”, i.e. a Church that tells me that it’s perfectly OK to have homosexual relationships - and believe it or not, there are Christians, people who believe in Jesus Christ, who would embrace me and support me if I wanted to hear that homosexuality was good and godly. Same thing with IVF. If I’m married and we can’t conceive, my wife and I only need to dump our present church and find another one that “works for us”, i.e. a church made up of Christians who regard IVF as good and acceptable.

In conclusion, I regard the mainline Protestant definition of the Church (i.e. all believers in Jesus Christ) as flawed.

In contrast to the above definition, the Catholic understanding is that the Church established by Christ is the visible organization whose leaders are Peter and the Apostles in communion with him, and all teaching must have the “seal of approval” of Peter and the Apostles. Then, since Peter and the Apostles set up a system of succession (Apostolic Succession), their legitimate successors who oversee all teaching are the Popes and Bishops personally ordained by them through the “laying on of the hands”. That means, according to Catholic understanding, that no one is entitled to decide whether IVF, homosexuality, etc are sinful or not, except for Peter and the Apostles in communion with him, and after the death of the original 12, the legitimate successors of them, i.e. the Popes and Bishops duly ordained and being in the line of Apostolic Succession coming down straight from Peter and the other 11 Apostles. According to Catholic understanding, the “One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church” established by Christ also includes all people in full communion with the Pope and the Bishops around him - and this is the one Church against which the gates of hell will never prevail.

Also, according to Catholic understanding, other Churches and Faith Communities who reject parts of the teaching of the Catholic Church, are in an imperfect communion with the one Church established by Christ, which is the Catholic Church.

The formula contained in the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed, established at the Ecumenical Councils of Nicea (year 321 A.D.) and Constantinople (381 A.D.), which we recite at every Sunday Mass in the CC, is this: “I believe in One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church”. There’s a lot in that short sentence. My above post only expounded on the Catholic understanding that Christ established only one Church, and that Church is built around the system of Apostolic Succession coming down straight from the original 12 Apostles.*
 
jm, thanks for the rosary explanation. Same for indulgences, I am aware of the early persecution, it always makes me happy that I am an American, and the worst I am likely to ever deal with is someone who laughs at my faith. Still, while indulgences may have been a way to sort those who got scared versus the non-serious believers originally, I cannot help but to question what it became. While selling may not have been direct, I would say indirect selling is still bad. On a different note, I don’t think it is fair to say nonCatholics have a “magical” idea of God. I was raised Baptist, and God was always viewed as involved, and supreme, magic was never thought of.
“Magic” in the sense of “I can go directly to God,” without needing a Church, or the Sacraments, etc. Prayer can be very powerful, but it can only get you so far. You also need the Sacraments, and the Church - and indeed, it is the power of the Sacraments, which comes to us through the Church, that enables prayer to work.

It’s kind of like believing that you can watch TV without the wires that bring you electricity, or wash your dishes without the pipes that bring you your water. Sure, most of the time, these things are invisible, and we don’t give them much thought - but if they were ever to go missing, you would certainly notice the difference. It’s the same with the Church and the Sacraments - they provide us with the connection with God, so that He can be here with us. We don’t notice them acting, and we think we are having a relationship with God entirely under our own power - that we “don’t need” these things. In reality, we are making use of them without acknowledging them.

The Bible you hold in your hand, for example, exists because of 200 years of very hard work done by the Bishops of the Catholic Church in full cooperation with one another, and ratified by the infallible decree made by Pope Innocent I - it didn’t simply fall out of the sky one day, or get found under a rock somewhere. If the Pope were not infallible, and if he had not made the decree that gave us the canon of the Scriptures, you would have nothing to hold in your hand today - nothing to read from at your Baptist Church that tells you the sayings of Jesus, or the doings of David and Moses.
On Confession, this is something else I don’t quite get. First, let me explain my background. I see our relationship with God as a very personal one. As such, when I screw things up, I can go directly to him and confess my sins. Is the Catholic view not as personal?
The Catholic view is more accountable, and more Sacramental. Jesus was both Man and God - physical, and spiritual. We, too, are spiritual beings with physical bodies. So, in order to heal the whole person, we need to physically go to the Mercy Seat - not just in our spirit, or in our imagination, but with actual walking of feet towards the place where Mercy takes place - the Confessional. And we account for ourselves in the presence of a man who can ask us pertinent questions, and probe us to see whether we are sincere, and n the end, give us the absolute assurance of the forgiveness of our sins (called the Absolution).
This may also tie into authority, I don’t get why it matters so much as long as the Faith is there.
How can the Faith be there, if there is no authority to tell us what is Faith - and what is not Faith, but something else (heresy, etc.)? 🤷

How do you know that Jesus died on the Cross for your sins? Is it not because of the Crucifix up on the front wall of your parish church? Is it not because this is what the Church teaches us, day in and day out? If the Church were to cease to exist, who would teach us these things - and more to the point, how would we know they were speaking the truth?
 
OK, regarding the view of the Church, I used to listen a lot to Evangelical Christian radio, such as the truly excellent Focus on the Family program of Dr. James Dobson. And, indeed, that’s how Evangelical Christians view the Church, too, they view it as the community of all people who acknowledge Jesus Christ as their Savior and call themselves Christians.
But even among these Evangelicals, you’ll find many who do not believe Catholics as part of the larger Christian community.

One need only read the comments from other evangelicals’ from ETS leader Francis Beckwith’s blog around the time he left evangelicalism to become Catholic.
 
piper,

The lack of modesty tends to grate on me as well. I have noticed a slight decline in my short life, and I really am not fond of it. People sometimes come to church as though they are going clubbing, and I would really prefer they not treat them as the same. (Texting from the pews is another peeve, am I the only one, aside from the old people, who doesn’t play with a cell during service?)

Regarding a church that works for you, I have always hated that line. I look for a church that teaches the Bible as it is, even if it makes me uncomfortable. I had a distant cousin who used to preach near me, and when he hit some subjects, he once commented he knew he was teaching right when his more liberal congregants left becuase they disliked what he preached from the Bible (abortion tended to really hack the liberals off). As for the One and only Catholic church Christ established, I do not think this is limited to only the RCC. The RCC may be a part of the Catholic Church Christ ordained, but it is not the only part of it. The question of people who call themselves Christians, but ignore the Bible is answered a few ways. (I touched on this earlier in part when I spoke of those who refuse to accept the Bible, and instead follow their desires). Matthew 7:15-29 speaks on knowing them by their works. If you have a church that puts more focus on “environmental justice” homosexual rights, the right to choose, or some other cute little talking point, we know what their works are. We can know what they value, and we can know they are false. I could go on, and will if needed, but I think we can get the idea.

jm,

I must disagree here. Romans 10:9-13 is pretty clear, and there is no mention of sacraments or a requirement to confess to another. While the Catholic way may be more accountable, and accountability matters, I do fully believe it can be used to strengthen individuals and the Church as a whole, but I do not see it as required for salvation.

As for the work of the early Catholic church to create a Bible for us all, I fully believe this was a great thing, and divinely inspiried, but I don’t really see how that ties into the current topic.

mark,

I think that goes both ways. I am sure there are some who have posted in this thread who do not consider me a Christian because I am not Catholic. I personally attribute it to a poor understanding of the fact that we all worship the same God, and those of us who are faithful are all members of the One Catholic Church ordained by Christ.

I share with you a joke given from the pulpit, by the Baptist minister I grew up listening to:

A tragic bus accident sent a large group of Christians to Heaven at once, where Peter greeted and welcomed them. Because it was such a large group, Peter offered to give them a personal tour. During the tour they came to a doorway, where Peter had them all be quiet until they passed to the other side. Once across, Peter was asked, “So, is God sleeping?” Peter laughed and replied, “No, that is where we keep the Baptists, they think they are the only ones here.”

I share that because I would hope you could see, Evangelicals largely do accept that people outside our specific denomination will make it to Heaven. I doubt God cares more about the name on the side of the building than the Faith in our hearts. I don’t really know many Catholics, but I hope they see it the same, it would, if nothing else, make for a more united Christendom.
 
jm,

I must disagree here. Romans 10:9-13 is pretty clear, and there is no mention of sacraments or a requirement to confess to another.
Romans 10:9-13 is not the whole sum of the Scriptures, nor anywhere close to it. There are more than 40,000 verses of Scripture in total. Some of them do, in fact, speak about the necessity of the Sacraments (“Do this in memory of Me,” - I Corinthians 11:24-25) And I hope that your Bible has not omitted James 5:16, which states plainly, “Confess your faults one to another, and pray one for another, that ye may be healed. The effectual fervent prayer of a righteous man availeth much.”

Furthermore, to “believe” is to act in the way that people act, when they believe a thing. Who believes the tightrope walker when he says he can carry a man in a wheelbarrow across a chasm? The cheering crowd standing safely behind the barrier, or the man who jumps into the wheelbarrow? I’m sure you’ve heard that story before. 😉

But, can men forgive sins? 🤷

Mark 2

1And again he entered into Capernaum after some days; and it was noised that he was in the house.

2And straightway many were gathered together, insomuch that there was no room to receive them, no, not so much as about the door: and he preached the word unto them.

3And they come unto him, bringing one sick of the palsy, which was borne of four.

4And when they could not come nigh unto him for the press, they uncovered the roof where he was: and when they had broken it up, they let down the bed wherein the sick of the palsy lay.

5When Jesus saw their faith, he said unto the sick of the palsy, Son, thy sins be forgiven thee.

6But there was certain of the scribes sitting there, and reasoning in their hearts,

7Why doth this man thus speak blasphemies? who can forgive sins but God only?

8And immediately when Jesus perceived in his spirit that they so reasoned within themselves, he said unto them, Why reason ye these things in your hearts?

9Whether is it easier to say to the sick of the palsy, Thy sins be forgiven thee; or to say, Arise, and take up thy bed, and walk?

10But that ye may know that the Son of man hath power on earth to forgive sins, (he saith to the sick of the palsy,)

11I say unto thee, Arise, and take up thy bed, and go thy way into thine house.

12And immediately he arose, took up the bed, and went forth before them all; insomuch that they were all amazed, and glorified God, saying, We never saw it on this fashion.

Later on, Jesus said to His disciples, Verily I say unto you, Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven. (Matthew 18:18) and, Whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whose soever sins ye retain, they are retained. (John 20:23)
 
Good joke, BG. 😃

The CC’s official position is that those Christians who are in an imperfect communion with the CC (and that would include all Christians outside the CC), and non-Christians too, can and will obtain eternal salvation. Being a Catholic is not a guarantee of salvation, either. Dante Alighieri’s Divine Comedy describes Catholic Popes and Bishops in Hell, and although it’s only a fictional poem, I think the CC would have not hesitated to come out and say it’s in conflict with Catholic positions, if it was so. But the CC is apparently OK with the idea that even Catholic Popes and Bishops could be damned to hell.
 
jm,

I am quite aware that what I quoted was far from the sum of scripture, however you cannot just doscount it. I was in fact thinking of the book of James when I mentioned accountability in my previous post. Just as you told me my quotation was not the sum, let me remind you, James 5:16 is not the sum of that passage, you may wish to start at verse 13 and read forward. It starts with individual prayer. Nothing in that entire passage supports a requirement to confess to another man.

Important Note: I am not saying Confession is bad, and to the contrary, I see much good that can come from being accountable to one another, I just do not see any Biblical support to mandate it as a required precursor to salvation.
 
L piperatus:
Good joke, BG. 😃

The CC’s official position is that those Christians who are in an imperfect communion with the CC (and that would include all Christians outside the CC), and non-Christians too, can and will obtain eternal salvation.
Will? So, the position of the CC is that no matter what, you eventually get salvation?
 
Later on, Jesus said to His disciples, Verily I say unto you, Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven. (Matthew 18:18) and, Whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whose soever sins ye retain, they are retained. (John 20:23)
I think, both with the “forgiving of sins”, and with the “do this in memory of me” (that is, consecrating the Eucharist), it’s important to note that Jesus does not talk to the crowds who follow him; he does not talk to the 70; he only talks to the 12 Apostles. That means, only those 12 Apostles received this particular authority from Jesus Christ. Not even Holy Mary, Christ’s immaculate and all-sinless mother received this authority - namely, to forgive sins, and to consecrate the Eucharist.

On a similar note, we always have never-ending disputes with our Eastern Orthodox brethren here at CAF-Non-Catholic Religions subforum, regarding Matthew 16: 18, the Rock, and the Keys. 😃 It always goes like this:

Catholic poster says: Jesus talks only to Simon son of Jonah. Only Simon’s name is changed into Kepha-Peter-Rock (Kepha is Aramaic, Peter is Latin for “Rock”), and only Peter received the Keys to the Kingdom of Heaven.

EO poster responds: No, no. Anyone who confesses Jesus as the Messiah is Rock, and all 12 Apostles received the Keys.

Catholic poster: No, you are wrong. Jesus talks to Simon son of Jonah only, therefore only he is Rock, and only he received the Keys.

…and it goes on like this, page after page, thread after thread. 😛
 
Not even Holy Mary, Christ’s immaculate and all-sinless mother received this authority - namely, to forgive sins, and to consecrate the Eucharist.
This stood out for me. Mary was not sinless, or did I miss the passages in the Bible that acknowledged she was perfect, just like Jesus?
 
Will? So, the position of the CC is that no matter what, you eventually get salvation?
No.

The position of the Catholic Church is (from the Catechism):

“Outside the Church there is no salvation”

846 How are we to understand this affirmation, often repeated by the Church Fathers? Re-formulated positively, it means that all salvation comes from Christ the Head through the Church which is his Body:

Basing itself on Scripture and Tradition, the Council teaches that the Church, a pilgrim now on earth, is necessary for salvation: the one Christ is the mediator and the way of salvation; he is present to us in his body which is the Church. He himself explicitly asserted the necessity of faith and Baptism, and thereby affirmed at the same time the necessity of the Church which men enter through Baptism as through a door. Hence they could not be saved who, knowing that the Catholic Church was founded as necessary by God through Christ, would refuse either to enter it or to remain in it.

This affirmation is not aimed at those who, through no fault of their own, do not know Christ and his Church:

Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, and, moved by grace, try in their actions to do his will as they know it through the dictates of their conscience - those too may achieve eternal salvation.
“Although in ways known to himself God can lead those who, through no fault of their own, are ignorant of the Gospel, to that faith without which it is impossible to please him, the Church still has the obligation and also the sacred right to evangelize all men.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top