Interesting voting guide from the Franciscans

  • Thread starter Thread starter 2cats
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The election statement is title Franciscans are not “party animals” and was written by the Franciscan Friars Holy Name Province

The statement has two parts. The second part has already been linked to, so here is a link to the first part.
hnp.org/jpic/pdf/2012%20Elections%20Statement%20Part%201–FINAL%20Approved.pdf

Here is an excerpt from the first part. The second part seems to expand upon those points.
Our Franciscan tradition offers us a framework of five interconnected parameters that can guide our discernment: care for creation, consistent ethic of life, preferential option for the poor, peacemaking and the common good.
Our decision-making starts with the acknowledgement of creation as gift. Through creation God provides all that is needed for life to flourish. To conceive of human life as somehow independent from creation is a grave error. What we do affects creation and creation’s future in determinative ways. The teaching of our faith is clear: God set humanity as creation’s steward, to care for it as God would have us do, according to His love. Therefore, as stewards, not owners, of God’s creation, we have the moral responsibility to examine carefully the impact that our political decisions will have in sustaining and protecting, rather than abusing and destroying, the integrity of creation.
Within the majesty of creation, we recognize the uniquely precious miracle of human life and our responsibility to protect and foster it. Thus, a second parameter for decision-making is the impact of our political decisions on human life. As Franciscans, we are informed by our Catholic-Christian faith that all phases of life, from womb to tomb, are important. Because Jesus identified himself with “the least” brother or sister, we dare not measure the intrinsic dignity and worth of the human person with judgments like innocent or guilty, rich or poor, fetal or senile. We also recognize that in the past few years the Church leadership has enjoined Catholics to pay particular attention to the unborn. The deliberate or direct destruction of innocent human life, at any stage of its existence, is always morally unacceptable. We must approach moral decisions with a consistent ethic that supports all of human life in all its conditions and stages.
Because all human life is sacred, we give special focus to how policy decisions will affect the most easily overlooked. In imitation of Jesus and Francis, we affirm a “preferential option for the poor” as one of our parameters. That is, we are required to pay particular attention to those who are most vulnerable in our society. Economic conditions and economic policies, immigration status and other social factors that affect the poor are significant issues for us in discerning the application of the preferential option.
As Franciscans, we are also known as peacemakers. This peacemaking element is one that impacts not only interpersonal relations but also socio-political affairs. Our commitment to peacemaking includes such issues as civil dialogue in political campaigns, how public resources are used to fund the military, and enhancing diplomatic efforts. The peacemaking tradition in its fullest seeks to support efforts that address the roots of conflict in the world (i.e., poverty, religious intolerance, social marginalization.) Our political decisions ought not lead to, or support, violence.
The final parameter, the common good, is one that holds all of our principles together. It can be described as the circumstances and structures of society that enable people to live their humanity to the fullest within the larger socio-political order and within a flourishing creation. In our Catholic tradition, each of us has the responsibility to foster the common good. But there also is a particular call for government to help in establishing conditions that will enhance the pursuit of the common good. Building the common good does not mean increasing the economic wealth of each person. Its pursuit might require sacrifice, particularly by those who already enjoy greater wealth or power. Such sacrifice makes the world more stable and just by mirroring God’s desire for all to have life and have it abundantly while living harmoniously with the gift of creation.
I think it is a thoughtful and well-explained statement of Franciscan principles and very consistent with Catholic teaching. 🙂
 
The Friars of Holy Name province are great bunch of guys. I spent some time with their formation team when I was in formation with the OFM’s.
 
The U.S. Bishops in Forming Consciences for Faithful Citizenship (2012) state, “A Catholic cannot vote for a candidate who takes a position in favour of an intrinsic evil, such as abortion or racism, if the voter’s intent is to support that position.” [emphasis in original] They further write “a voter should not use a candidate’s opposition to an intrinsic evil to justify indifference or inattentiveness to other important moral issues involving human life and dignity.”
I guess that blows holes right through the arguments of those Americans who claim that their Catholic countrymen *must *vote for Romney.

(Disclaimer: I support neither Romney nor Obama, and wouldn’t vote for either.)
 
Thank you for this posting. Extremely interesting. I’ll be reading it ten times or more. Thanks again.
 
The Franciscans don’t seem to me to be differing with what the bishops have said in their guide. They’re just stating what the Franciscan mission priorities are. They are particularly dedicated to poverty, while other religious orders are not necessarily dedicated to it.

Meanwhile I don’t see why this generates criticism of Mr. Romney. He may have not been worried about attempting to gain the VOTE of the famed 47%, but I see no reason to believe he will be indifferent to them as president. Given his penchant for personal charitable giving of money and time, I’m hopeful.
 
Both parts. Very troubling indeed. Seems very much at odds with the teaching of the U.S. Bishops. For my part I will never vote for a candidate who supports one or all of the of the Five None Negotiables of the Bishops.
I thought the Five Non-Negotiables were designated as such by Catholic Answers. Individual bishops may have hopped on that bandwagon or adopted that language, but I believe it originated with Catholic Answers (which is a different organization from the bishops) circa 2004, reflecting issues that were in the headlines then. For example embryonic stem cells and cloning were all the rage then; now you probably won’t hear candidates even mention that because science has mostly moved on. Catchy as it may be to think in terms of “five non-negotiables”, I think if one were to study the Catechism there are probably a lot more than five non-negotiable issues.
 
👍👍

I was both shocked and over joyed that they actually mentioned the Israelestine issue. Catholic political pamphlets/flyers tend to always omit “Palestine.”
 
Both parts. Very troubling indeed. Seems very much at odds with the teaching of the U.S. Bishops. For my part I will never vote for a candidate who supports one or all of the of the Five None Negotiables of the Bishops.

I also see the Franciscans have been drinking the cool aid on " global warming. " :eek:
Where does it say in the catechism or the bible that we shouldn’t take care of the earth. 🤷
\
 
Both parts. Very troubling indeed. Seems very much at odds with the teaching of the U.S. Bishops. For my part I will never vote for a candidate who supports one or all of the of the Five None Negotiables of the Bishops.

I also see the Franciscans have been drinking the cool aid on " global warming. " :eek:
Franciscans are one of the last group of people I would view as having “drank the kool aid” on anything, especially a trendy political view point.
 
I loved this guide (part 1 & 2).

I’ve been very troubled that Catholics have been putting elective abortions ahead of everything, even all of life on planet earth (including miscarriages thru environmental harms). I’ve been thinking it was because the thinking that even saving the life of one baby from elective abortion is worth all of life on earth, which could be totally sacrificed for the one baby, esp since it would be a terribly heinous sin of the part of the woman to have an abortion, whereas our individual small parts in destroying all of life on earth would not even come close to being as evil as a woman having an elective abortion.

I like that they included our duty to be good stewards of creation, and they did mention how all their principles are interdependent - “Because these parameters are interdependent, there is no easy checklist.”

However, I really think it needs to be made clearer that the environment, God’s creation, is fundamental and foundational for life, including human life. If we destroy our subsistence base and cause life to end, it’s just another way of killing people (as well as others of God’s creation) – and there are so many ways in which we kill people. The environmental is fundamental; the economy contingent and instrumental.

And now we are faced with 9 or more very serious human-caused environmental issues and problems that threaten life on earth, including (but not limited to) global warming.

Anyone who is truly pro-life would not only be against abortion and do all they can to stop it, but would also be in favor of mitigating global warming and these other environmental problems. I can imagine a person for selfish reasons who would want others to have abortions so his/her children could stand a better chance, but I cannot imagine a person who is against others having abortion who would be in favor of destroying our subsistence based causing most or all people to die. That really doesn’t make sense to me, and I question the true motives of such people.
 
I liked the Franciscans’ voters guide, and I thought it was very refreshing and easier to understand than the one put out by the USCCB.

The one put out by the USCCB reminds me of some of the gibberish written by the IRS when they’re trying to explain when you can and can’t deduct something.

I am totally sick of hearing about the “five non-negotiables.” The word “non-negotiable” does not even appear in the Catholic Cathecism.
 
Vote neither for Obama nor for Romney. Vote for yourself, your Faith and your love for others. Then vote for either Obama or Romney. (And you might actually end up voting for both of them!) 😃
 
Vote neither for Obama nor for Romney. Vote for yourself, your Faith and your love for others. Then vote for either Obama or Romney. (And you might actually end up voting for both of them!) 😃
Or you could vote for one of the other people who are standing for election. Or you could refrain from voting in that race.

What is it with Americans and this perverse, pervasive belief and insistence that there are only two choices for anything and everything when it comes to political decisions? Change takes time and sacrifice. While I don’t support them, I can’t help but notice that our own NDP has existed, in various forms, for well over 50 years as a federal party, and it has only now made it to the level of Her Majesty’s Loyal Opposition. They didn’t get to be there by everyone always voting either Tory or Liberal.
 
Sometimes we would learn a great deal from what is not stated.

What was not stated?

Does it say anything about inheriting the Kingdom by love? Luke 10: 25-28)

Does it say anything about the Good News?

Does it say anything about the commandment of eternal life? (John 12: 50 And I know His commandment is eternal life.

I did not read it. Thus I am really asking, does it address Love?

This is America and I am free to discuss my faith in the political realm.

Blessings!!!
 
Did I miss it or did they selectively edit out the crucial part from “Faithful Citizenship” in which we are instructed to prioritize problematic candidate stances according to their proportionate impact. When I read this, I see Cardinal Bernadin in my head. Neither anything here, nor in the late Cardinal’s “seamless garment” approach addresses the simple fact that no other issue in play involves 50,000,000 dead human beings. Face it, unjust illegal immigration stances, inadequate social safety nets, poor quality educational systems and even unjust wars in the last 40 years haven’t produced 50,000,000 dead human beings.

Call me cynical, but rationalizing always takes a lot more words than simply following moral principles. Sometimes things really are simpler than they seem. Basic triage applies: stop the worst bleeding first.

And btw, that does NOT limit you to any one particular candidate. It just rules at least one candidate out…
 
Did I miss it or did they selectively edit out the crucial part from “Faithful Citizenship” in which we are instructed to prioritize problematic candidate stances according to their proportionate impact. When I read this, I see Cardinal Bernadin in my head. Neither anything here, nor in the late Cardinal’s “seamless garment” approach addresses the simple fact that no other issue in play involves 50,000,000 dead human beings. Face it, unjust illegal immigration stances, inadequate social safety nets, poor quality educational systems and even unjust wars in the last 40 years haven’t produced 50,000,000 dead human beings.

Call me cynical, but rationalizing always takes a lot more words than simply following moral principles. Sometimes things really are simpler than they seem. Basic triage applies: stop the worst bleeding first.

And btw, that does NOT limit you to any one particular candidate. It just rules at least one candidate out…
Yes, and after plowing through all those words, no clear guidance remains. One is left with enough verbiage to rationalize voting for the most egregious evil.
 
@manualman: the “proportionate reason” anaylysis is referenced in Part 1 linked by Dale M above.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top