Interesting voting guide from the Franciscans

  • Thread starter Thread starter 2cats
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
One of those days here.

Can someone please give me a 1 sentence summary? Is the life issue the primary issue?

Thank you:)
 
The Franciscans don’t seem to me to be differing with what the bishops have said in their guide. They’re just stating what the Franciscan mission priorities are. They are particularly dedicated to poverty, while other religious orders are not necessarily dedicated to it.

Meanwhile I don’t see why this generates criticism of Mr. Romney. He may have not been worried about attempting to gain the VOTE of the famed 47%, but I see no reason to believe he will be indifferent to them as president. Given his penchant for personal charitable giving of money and time, I’m hopeful.
This.

And, as Dale M quoted, the Franciscans share the Bishops’ focus on the life issues. It is a consistent ethic that values the dignity of human beings from “womb to tomb.”
 
I think the objective of this “guide” is laid out in the very first sentence: “…there is often an attempt to link our Catholic faith squarely with one political party.” That assertion is of course incorrect but it is surely true that the teachings of the Church present problems for one party that they don’t present to the other. The Franciscan guide is an attempt to alleviate that problem.

The first part of the guide has a lengthy section on the meaning of “cooperation with evil” and how that can in fact be acceptable. The obvious point here is that this problem is one faced almost entirely by Catholic Democrats so this section provides moral justification for … voting for Democrats despite their positions on abortion, gay marriage etc.

One really ought to question a Catholic voter’s guide whose very first issue, even ahead of the life issues, is global warming, and I think the document’s perspective is made clear when it asks: “How will the candidate’s approach to a number of issues, including the environment, the economy, health care and poverty-related matters, impact life at all stages?” It is specifically on life issues - abortion, euthanasia, ESCR - that Democrats are so at odds with Church teaching. This guide, by broadening “life issues” to include virtually everything that effects humanity, erases the distinction between the right to life and the quality of life. Those are not comparable issues.

That this guide is disappointing does not mean that it should have been unexpected. Regrettably my experience with Franciscans over the last 20 years leaves me unsurprised that they would come out with something like this.

Ender
 
One of those days here.

Can someone please give me a 1 sentence summary? Is the life issue the primary issue?

Thank you:)
Life was mentioned second, after a section on caring for the earth and dealing with climate change.
 
Life was mentioned second, after a section on caring for the earth and dealing with climate change.
Were they listing things in order of importance? Or were they mentioning the fact that there are also other important things, such as XYZ, that should be considered as well as the life issue, which is, of course, very important? Perhaps they assumed that there’s no need to “preach to the choir”, so to speak, about it right-off the bat.

(You also forgot to mention that the guide omitted the fact that transubstantiation is true, etc., etc., etc.) The fallacy of guilt by omission.

My men’s group mentions pornography more than abortion. In fact, it rarely mentions abortion at all, though when it does, it is always noted that it’s a grave evil to kill unborn children. Does this make my men’s group supportive of evil since it doesn’t mention abortion as much as pornography? Or is it merely addressing its target audience with what is relevant?

Go ahead and keep reading what you want into things though, by all means.

Here’s an interesting letter form our Archbishop.

rcav.org/uploadedFiles/gestational%20statement.pdf

It seems to me, according to this letter, one needn’t support a politician who would allow abortion in cases of rape or incest, as Romney does, unless he had a consistent track record of always being against abortion in all cases, which Romney doesn’t, and also made it clear that his current policies were only to try and save some of the unborn, since in the current political climate it would be impossible to pass a complete ban on all abortions for all reasons - also something Romney doesn’t do.

Keep in mind, our Archdiocese was one of the only ones in Canada to defend Humane Vitae and condemn heterodox bishops. The practising Catholics here aren’t your Kennedy-types. Our Archbishop is orthodox and so are most of our priests.
 
Thanks for the link. Couldn’t pass up the dismissive remark …

… these must be the ones they call SAN Franciscans! 😉

When they led off with global warming my quick thought was … " … maybe God knows what he’s doing!"

It’s nice that LIFE came NEXT … and that abortion led the list (alphabetically only … or did they do it by WHAT on the list is weightier)?

THAT it was part of a LIST of four things – well, my moral equivalency radar was bleeping at me.

Abortion - MILLIONS AND MILLIONS KILLED AND BEING PERFORMED AS WE BREATHE.

Torture - not deadly even when (IF?) it is applied. Can be done in such mild degrees as to be 100% recoverable from. Sleep deprivation? A week later, total recovery. Water boarding? Scary, but done right, no lasting harm save fear of the jailer. ALSO justifiable
when more lives are saved by the practice than are lost (0 in some cases … and it has yielded info critical to the capture of bin Laden lest we forget).

Capital Punishment - HARDLY even done, even where it IS still legal. Unless one includes soldiers and police acting in self-defense to boost the numbers. Equivalent? Not hardly. Usually used as an excuse to ignore abortion as the Elephant in the living room still breaking things.

Euthanasia - It is good to warn us about this growing problem. It will be “niced up” like abortion was. It may be going on now. Doctors tell patients’ families to sign off on “Do not resusitate” forms so that they can decide how best to keep the hospital finances healthy.

As much as keeping a “cash cow” patient with lots of money and insurance in the hospital as long as possible … a “negative financial” patient must be gotten rid of as the bed they are taking up might deny room to said “cash cow.”

STILL Euthanasia is dwarfed by the Juggernaut of abortion as a problem. The three latter issues can be put on a scale, and when ABORTION is put on the other side … it smashes the scale flat.

By this time the writers of this guide had lost their credibility with me. There might be something valuable in the rest of what they wrote - but if you can’t get the FIRST thing right … you’ve started off on the wrong path. After that virtues like perseverance and speed are corrupted in the vice of leading one further away from the truth found in right priorities.

:curtsey: - this avalanche of verbiage has been brought to you by ME!

:snowing: < YOU! (sorry!) 🙂
 
Vote neither for Obama nor for Romney. Vote for yourself, your Faith and your love for others. Then vote for either Obama or Romney. (And you might actually end up voting for both of them!) 😃
This is what I get for being UP at 3:12 in the morning and making my mind try to work.

I don’t know if you intended it … but this is quite a fine Lewis Carroll imitation. Or if presented in two-person conversational form … Abbott and Costello.

I don’t know what to make of it … but I enjoyed the philosophy of Willy Wonka too.

Willy Wonka: Oh, you should never, never doubt what nobody is sure about.
 
Life was mentioned second, after a section on caring for the earth and dealing with climate change.
Well, there are many ways we kill people. Climate change is one of them. It is a life issue. It is perhaps the mother of all life issues, since some scientists say we could push the climate into runaway conditions as on Venus and end all life on earth (that includes humans too).

This goes way beyond a voting issue – we vote to kill people when we fail to turn off lights not in use or refuse to turn off our engine in drive-thrus. We are caught in a structure of killing people. We are the children of Cain. We can only hope to reduce our killing of people by living prudently, and less profligately.

Unfortunately relecting Obama probably won’t help very much in reducing this life-threatening harm from climate change, just as electing Romney probably won’t reduce abortions – even if he does manage to make them illegal, which probably won’t happen.

The burden really falls back on us. We need to stop killing people – through abortion, environmental harms, etc.

I’ll be glad when this election is over so we can return our focus on that, rather than pinning all our hopes on some political leader to do work that just can’t be done without us doing it.
 
Yes, and after plowing through all those words, no clear guidance remains. One is left with enough verbiage to rationalize voting for the most egregious evil.
My thoughts as I read it also. But those who wish to pretzel themselves into what THEY want rather than what Mother Church teaches will continue to do so.
 
But those who wish to pretzel themselves into what THEY want rather than what Mother Church teaches will continue to do so.
Let’s not ignore the fact that these rationalizations are enabled by those bishops who have failed to present the issues in an unambiguous way. The USCCB document Faithful Citizenship is precisely the type of statement that allows people to pick and choose and that provides not guidance but justification. We deserve better.

Ender
 
Let’s not ignore the fact that these rationalizations are enabled by those bishops who have failed to present the issues in an unambiguous way. The USCCB document Faithful Citizenship is precisely the type of statement that allows people to pick and choose and that provides not guidance but justification. We deserve better.

Ender
I’m with you.
 
Um, isn’t the popular vote just a popularity contest? Doesn’t the electoral vote really count? You can’t choose who becomes president by your votes, as I understand it. :o
 
Just as St. Francis of Assisi encountered Christ and his love in the embrace of
the leper, we as Franciscan-hearted people are invited to embrace the excluded of today and speak for those who are not able to speak for themselves (Proverbs 31:8-9).
Note that the derivation of the word “infant” comes from Latin infans meaning in=not and fans=speak … that is, not speak as in unable to speak.
 
Um, isn’t the popular vote just a popularity contest? Doesn’t the electoral vote really count? You can’t choose who becomes president by your votes, as I understand it.
Not exactly. It is true that the members of the Electoral College actually vote for the president but it is our votes that select who will be sent to the EC. In all but two states, a majority vote for either Obama or Romney will send one of two delegations from that state: the ones committed either to O or R, depending on which receives the most votes. Electors are not chosen at random and while they may actually vote for whomever they choose it is extraordinarily rare for an elector not to vote for the candidate he was sent to represent. Maine and Nebraska (I think) send proportional representation; they are not winner-take-all states.

Ender
 
How did George Bush win? I can’t think of any D voting for an R. Was All Gore that goofy that even his supporters jumped ship?
 
Um, isn’t the popular vote just a popularity contest? Doesn’t the electoral vote really count? You can’t choose who becomes president by your votes, as I understand it. :o
Um…you can’t have an electoral vote without votes from the populace. So, we do choose who becomes president by our votes.
 
How did George Bush win? I can’t think of any D voting for an R. Was All Gore that goofy that even his supporters jumped ship?
Gore won the popular vote. To which I add: I thank God for the Founding Fathers-again.
 
Did I miss it or did they selectively edit out the crucial part from “Faithful Citizenship” in which we are instructed to prioritize problematic candidate stances according to their proportionate impact. When I read this, I see Cardinal Bernadin in my head. Neither anything here, nor in the late Cardinal’s “seamless garment” approach addresses the simple fact that no other issue in play involves 50,000,000 dead human beings. Face it, unjust illegal immigration stances, inadequate social safety nets, poor quality educational systems and even unjust wars in the last 40 years haven’t produced 50,000,000 dead human beings.
Where I get frustrated is that it is difficult to see a connection between what a particular candidate says, or a position statement in a party platform, and that staggering number you mention. Certainly not going to change much via legislation or executive order. The only possible way I see it mattering at a national level is through the Supreme Court. It’s kind of sad that it comes to that - we vote for a president in the hope that, in the following 4 years there will be a chance to replace a pro-abortion justice with a pro-life one. And it’s just that, a hope - there’s no guarantee that the guy we think is pro-life will prioritize that when appointing a justice, vs some other political expediency in getting someone approved. Otherwise I feel like it’s all lip service and “symbolism over substance”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top