Is cultural loss a consequence of evangelization?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Curious11
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
What’s wrong with Christianization?

Without the Church, the Pantheon would probably not exist today, or be a shattered ruin.
 
Yeah, but I don’t want to plant a Jesus in a Buddhist temple. Let’s keep it the way it should be
 
Why not?
If it allows for the integration of cultural architecture and the Christian faith, I am all for it.
 
Because Christ doesn’t impose himself on us, he respects us. Buddhist temples should be left the way they are for everyone to see. People should come to Christ of their own free will, not because all trace of Buddhism has disappeared
 
Why? He was a good guy!
Because what he taught included falsehood. Buddhists need Christ, not Buddha.

What was good and true in his teachings can remain preserved in the textbooks. Only one thing matters: the Truth, and the Truth is not a what. The Truth is a Who, and it’s not Buddha.

Don’t care about how “good” or “nice” he was. If the religion surrounding him teaches false things about man’s eternal destiny, it’s something that belongs to history, not in the hearts of men.
 
Yeah we should! As long as human sacrifices and things that contradict Jesus are abolished
 
Yeah we should! As long as human sacrifices and things that contradict Jesus are abolished
And that’s why Buddhism (and the Aztec religion) should be consigned to the dustbin of history.

Things that contradict Jesus. That’s what all non-Christian religions are.

Truth+error = error.
 
Last edited:
You can keep Buddhist festivals and meditation practice and be a christian
 
You can keep Buddhist festivals and meditation practice and be a christian
No, you can’t. You do not mix Christianity and falsehood.

You can celebrate with Buddhists, for example, if they invite you to their homes for a meal; that’s not a problem, for as long as all understand that you’re joining socially, not religiously.

Syncretism is forbidden in Christianity. Christ does not tolerate you worshipping anything or anyone besides himself. You know what he said about those who are neither hot nor cold. He demands that you choose, not waffle.
 
Last edited:
I want the whole world to believe in Jesus, but at the same time i wouldn’t want Buddhists to stop building their temples and learning about Buddha, for Jews to abandon their idiosyncratic religious rites like Torah study/interpretation, for Muslims to stop going to the Kaaba and so on. What do you guys think?
I think this is something we should let these groups of people sort out, because it isn’t about what you want.

I grew up in a protestant family that believed the Earth is ~6-10 thousand years old. There were some very good things I learned growing up, but in other ways I haven’t preserved my old culture and the thought of ever doing so brings a slight shudder down my back.

Although - for good reasons - different cultures are portrayed in a respectful manner, there are many aspects of other lifestyles & belief systems that limit a person’s ability to commune with God. There have been Buddhists converting to the Christian faith in South Korea in mass numbers over recent years, and many of them exceedingly joyful because of it.

A Westerner might look at Buddhism in a certain light that is - more often than not - glaringly incorrect, but an actual person that lives there will look at it differently. A Westerner might think of peaceful people and orange robes and aesthetically attractive temples in the forest. An Asian will not; they will have a picture that more coincides with the reality. This is just one example among many.

Historic buildings, figures, and certain customs, no doubt, will be preserved, as this was the case with Christianity and western paganism. The works of the ancient pagans continue to be preserved & enjoyed in our literature today, as well as various other subtleties. The ancient Romans, Greeks, Egyptians, etc, all built foundations in law, government, language, etc., that continue to echo to the present day. Yet these were also areas that were evangelized and catechized in the ancient world, thereby creating something that merged the old with the new.

So the answer to “is cultural loss a consequence of evangelization?” is yes and no. The culture will indeed change as Christianity asserts itself in a nation.
 
Last edited:
I’m secure enough in my faith I don’t get mad or offended if someone mocks it.
That is immoral. Although a person can and should be mature and disciplined enough to manage themselves in a constructive way and not to lose their inner peace, a Catholic ought to feel a certain indignation if the Eucharist is mocked.
 
I understand where you’re coming from, but since when has getting angry and offended ever changed a persons mind? They won’t feel bad, they’ll feel like they won by bringing me to anger.

Turn the other cheek and all.

I’ll let God handle them when the times right.
 
Last edited:
I understand where you’re coming from, but since when has getting angry and offended ever changed a persons mind? They won’t feel bad, they’ll feel like they won by bringing me to anger.

Turn the other cheek and all.
It could inspire you to say something that makes them think twice about talking about the Eucharist disrespectfully, such as, “We believe this is the body and blood of Our Lord and the Eucharist is very important to us”.

All people have consciences. There is a good chance they will empathize and both you and them will have benefited from the experience.

edit: This is also why a Muslim father, mother, or coworker might respond if you referred to the Kaaba as “just a black box”. You might think twice about how you choose to express yourself around other people, because not just what we say, but how we say things matters.
 
Last edited:
Non-Christian cultures are leading their adherents to hell.

That’s OK?
What is a 'christian culture"? Are you saying that Jewish culture is leading people to hell?

I don’t think human culture necessarily leads a person one way or the other. Culture is a reflection of who human being are, which are made in the image and likeness of God. As we are all fallen creatures, some cultures, like gang cultures, have most aspects that are contrary to the intention of God.
To follow Jesus means that one must give up everything: to include their former beliefs, family, friends, their job, house, and all things of this world.
Certainly we must be willing to give up such things, but He does not necessarily call us to do so. I come from a long line of Italians, and love Italian cooking. Do you think if I give this up, I am more likely to inherit the Kingdom of God?
It’s a nice cultural legacy. Even Christian festivals have pagan origins, like Christmas
you have been misled, Curious11. Christmas is the Mass of Christ. It was created to celebrate His Birthday, of which we do not have an exact date. How could you possibly think that Jesus’ Birthday had Pagan origins? Such nonsense!
If Thailand or Sri Lanka become christian, the last thing I want is the abandonment, christianization or outright destruction of their age-old and beautiful Buddhist temples
No chance of that. The Church just Christianizes the temples.
I wouldn’t want ex Muslim Christian converts to stop making the Hajj, I would just want them to assign to it a cultural meaning, not religious (unless they think it brings them closer to Christ, in which case fine by me)
This seems unlikely, since it is a religious observance required of Muslims.

How do you imagine that a pilgrimage to Mecca would bring one closer to Christ? Would not a pilgrimage to Jerusalem be more relevant?
Because Christ doesn’t impose himself on us, he respects us. Buddhist temples should be left the way they are for everyone to see. People should come to Christ of their own free will, not because all trace of Buddhism has disappeared
I suppose you feel that the building should suffer the same fate as the Hagia Sophia?

Perhaps you feel the cult of Mithra should be continued?
 
Nevertheless, we cannot force them to accept Christ, otherwise, Christ, who is God, would easily make every human a Christian
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top