Is God bound by logic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CeaselessMedik
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
But because it defies human logic, you think it’s impossible for God to make us gods?
 
But because it defies human logic, you think it’s impossible for God to make us gods?
I think the Catholic Faith says yes, But… I don’t understand it for this reason.

Omnipresence.

The Church says that God is omnipresent, yet He is separate from His creation. If He is omnipresent there is nowhere that God isn’t. Any division you make in creation God is present. God is in every atom, proton, neutron, quark, string, membrane, any division of matter you can make or conceptualize. How God isn’t the everything and everything God is beyond my capacity of logic. There is no line you can draw and say God is “here” but not “here”, where with other things we can delineate the separateness of “being”.(until you get to the quantum level, where things get fuzzy)

I know this probably isn’t much help. 😊
 
It seems like many of you are ignoring this question I continue to pose

Can God create something that he can’t life if he is omnipotent?

if you say yes he can what does that say about his omnipotence?

if he can’t what does that say about him being able to do something illogical?

and please don’t try that clever Math stuff you have been pulling the last few slides, simply just answer the question yes or no and then for what ever you say answer the question that goes with your answer.

I would say no God can’t create something he can’t lift because everything he creates he can life.

Meaning that for God to create something that he can’t life would be illogical, meaning my view God can’t do things that are illogical.

No the trinity is not illogical because if the trinity was illogical it couldn’t exist.
 
It seems like many of you are ignoring this question I continue to pose

Can God create something that he can’t life if he is omnipotent?

if you say yes he can what does that say about his omnipotence?

if he can’t what does that say about him being able to do something illogical?

and please don’t try that clever Math stuff you have been pulling the last few slides, simply just answer the question yes or no and then for what ever you say answer the question that goes with your answer.

I would say no God can’t create something he can’t lift because everything he creates he can life.

Meaning that for God to create something that he can’t life would be illogical, meaning my view God can’t do things that are illogical.

No the trinity is not illogical because if the trinity was illogical it couldn’t exist.
I’m going to assume you meant “lift”.

First the Catechism says the Trinity is beyond human understanding -
251 In order to articulate the dogma of the Trinity, the Church had to develop her own terminology with the help of certain notions of philosophical origin: “substance”, “person” or “hypostasis”, “relation” and so on. In doing this, she did not submit the faith to human wisdom, but gave a new and unprecedented meaning to these terms, which from then on would be used to signify an ineffable mystery, “infinitely beyond all that we can humanly understand”.82
The trinity is beyond human logic.

A possible logical solution utilizing the Trinity, (which is beyond logic) might be:

God the incorporeal spirit could make something the Human aspect of God Jesus (both true God and True Man) couldn’t lift. Truly Human means He is subject to the same laws of physics that we are.

But again the Trinity being beyond logic, (infinitely beyond all that we can humanly understand), makes it a fuzzy logic at best.

It does sort of passes the smell test because the only thing that is limiting God is God. So it doesn’t contradict omnipotence.
 
I’m going to assume you meant “lift”.

First the Catechism says the Trinity is beyond human understanding -

The trinity is beyond human logic.

A possible logical solution utilizing the Trinity, (which is beyond logic) might be:

God the incorporeal spirit could make something the Human aspect of God Jesus (both true God and True Man) couldn’t lift. Truly Human means He is subject to the same laws of physics that we are.

But again the Trinity being beyond logic, (infinitely beyond all that we can humanly understand), makes it a fuzzy logic at best.

It does sort of passes the smell test because the only thing that is limiting God is God. So it doesn’t contradict omnipotence.
answer my questions, it will help to show you what I’m trying to get at.

We are simply talking about the omnipotence of God, and please don’t use we can’t understand God as an excuse not to talk about this, because if you use that excuse then all theology on God is pointless because all you have to drop is we can’t understand God so we shouldn’t discuss philosophy and theology about God. If you answer my question I think you will see what I’m getting at.

BTW just because there are things that God does that we don’t understand doesn’t mean that God can do something illogical. My question deals with something that is illogical. Philosophically speaking which this thread is based around, being on the philosophy board, you can only say one of these two things. Either God is not omnipotent so he can create something that he can’t lift, or God is omnipotent and God can’t create anything he can’t lift. Philosophically speaking God can’t do both, aka be omnipotent and not be able to lift something. Atleast by the Thomistic view of Omnipotance

which is outlined here in the summa

newadvent.org/summa/1025.htm#article3

he never says God Can’t do something but it is implied by the statement when he says that God can do everything that IS POSSIBLE. When I say something is logically impossible, that means it can’t be done not even by God himself.
 
btw I meant to say lift not life in my earlier post. I think you get what I’m getting at anyone.
 
answer my questions, it will help to show you what I’m trying to get at.

We are simply talking about the omnipotence of God, and please don’t use we can’t understand God as an excuse not to talk about this, because if you use that excuse then all theology on God is pointless because all you have to drop is we can’t understand God so we shouldn’t discuss philosophy and theology about God. If you answer my question I think you will see what I’m getting at.

BTW just because there are things that God does that we don’t understand doesn’t mean that God can do something illogical. My question deals with something that is illogical. Philosophically speaking which this thread is based around, being on the philosophy board, you can only say one of these two things. Either God is not omnipotent so he can create something that he can’t lift, or God is omnipotent and God can’t create anything he can’t lift. Philosophically speaking God can’t do both, aka be omnipotent and not be able to lift something. Atleast by the Thomistic view of Omnipotance

which is outlined here in the summa

newadvent.org/summa/1025.htm#article3

he never says God Can’t do something but it is implied by the statement when he says that God can do everything that IS POSSIBLE. When I say something is logically impossible, that means it can’t be done not even by God himself.
If you don’t account for the Triune nature of God, you aren’t attributing to God all his aspects.

So it’s not illogical to say One aspect can restrict another aspect, nor does it contradict omnipotency since They are all God. Self restraint is a strength not a weakness.
 
everyone needs to read what aquainas says on this Subject aka his omnipotence and what exactly it means

newadvent.org/summa/1025.htm#article3

read in article three I answer that.

In this arcile STA says that all confess God is omnipotent (this is made obvious in this thread), but it seems difficult to explain what this means. Aquanias later goes on to say that
If, however, we consider the matter aright, since power is said in reference to possible things, this phrase, “God can do all things,” is rightly understood to mean that God can do all things that are possible; and for this reason He is said to be omnipotent.
So Aquinas before he goes into what does he mean by possible, he already tells us what omnipotence is, and it is that God can do everything that is possible, or God can do everything that isn’t impossible. He will hash this out later

in his next part of this article he will describe two was something can be possible. First in terms of human power, or in relation to some power. For example Man has the power to do things because it is in his nature that he can do that. Another example man has the power to rationally think while a dog doesn’t have that ability (please no debate on animals being able to rationally think, Aquinas would strongly disagree that any animal other then the human animal can rationally think).

Second he talks about possibility in terms of God. He clarifies that he doesn’t mean that God is omnipotent in the fact that he can do everything he can do, which would lead to us having as he says it “a vicious circle in explaining the nature of his power” He next says that God is omnipotent by the fact that he is able to do all things that are possible absolutely. What he means by possibly absolutely is that the terms don’t disagree with the subject. For example this statement would be impossible absolutely, “Man is a donkey” Or as I have tried to explain in this thread, God can’t lift something even though he is omnipotent. So as long as your terms agree with the subject, then God can do it.

By now I really think you get the point, Aquanias goes on to explain this some more but I think it just rehashes the points in greater detail.

but to conclude this I’ll make some statements and I’ll say which ones are impossible and possible

lets start

God can create Man that is a donkey (impossible, if God creates something with the form man it can’t be donkey because in this world we give things their names by their form not by their material)

God can create something he can’t life (impossible, I’ve explained this)

God can be inactive (impossible, God is pure act if God were to be inactive even to himself there would be a contradiction in terms)

God can make the sun disappear tomorrow (possible, even though science would say its impossible, its not impossible because there is no contradiction in terms. There is nothing that says the Sun must always be there.)

God can make something inactive (possible, simply put God can take your life, and when you loose your existence you no longer act)

God can make a human have the material of a donkey (yes but it would be called human not donkey, it would just have donkey material, I actually suspect in the next life we will have new material not human material rather glorified material but we will still be called human)
 
If you don’t account for the Triune nature of God, you aren’t attributing to God all his aspects.

So it’s not illogical to say One aspect can restrict another aspect, nor does it contradict omnipotency since They are all God. Self restraint is a strength not a weakness.
I’m not. Not being able to do something that is illogical doesn’t limit God.

God can’t sin correct?

if God can’t sin does that really limit his nature?

No because sin in itself limits God so for God to sin he would be limiting himself.

By me saying God can’t do something that is impossible doesn’t add a limitation to the unlimited being, all I’m saying is that because this thing is impossible absolutely, meaning give all possible conditions it can never happen, doesn’t limit God in any sort of fashion.

Try this for me, think of a man that is a donkey, can you think of this?

probably not, you will either think of a man donkey mix, which would not be human it would be a human donkey which isn’t the form of human, or you will think of a human, which is the form of human not donkey or you will think of a donkey which is the form of donkey not human.

You cannot think of a created that has the form human but you call it donkey, if you were to call it donkey then you would be naming the form incorrectly. You would as Aquinas said contradicting your terms.
 
Nothing I’ve said contradicts Aquinas 🤷 It is possible for God incarnate to create something impossible for the Human aspect of Jesus to lift. Jesus is fully Human and Fully God. The fully human part is bound by the physical world as all humans are.

Are you saying God diminished Himself by becoming man? :eek:

God cannot be diminished. God made God corporeal. Any limitations that the corporeal body has were placed there and assumed by God when he assumed a corporeal state.

God doesn’t die He is eternal. Jesus died on the Cross, Life and Death are Corporeal restrictions. Restrictions that God assumed for Himself in the person of Jesus.

So just as God assumes the human restrictions of life and death, he can assume the restriction of physics and there would be many rocks that He couldn’t lift. 🤷
 
It seems like many of you are ignoring this question I continue to pose

Can God create something that he can’t life if he is omnipotent?

if you say yes he can what does that say about his omnipotence?

if he can’t what does that say about him being able to do something illogical?

and please don’t try that clever Math stuff you have been pulling the last few slides, simply just answer the question yes or no and then for what ever you say answer the question that goes with your answer.

I would say no God can’t create something he can’t lift because everything he creates he can life.

Meaning that for God to create something that he can’t life would be illogical, meaning my view God can’t do things that are illogical.

No the trinity is not illogical because if the trinity was illogical it couldn’t exist.
God is without limitation, what he wouldn’t be able to lift would be what he immutably chooses shall not be lifted. I hope I have not confused you with my above posts. They are all a roundabout way of saying yes God is bound by logic because he has chosen to be.
 
Once again we come to the question of God’s being limited by the rules he supposedly created.
 
Once again we come to the question of God’s being limited by the rules he supposedly created.
I think you need to have a good long think about the concept of infinity. He is and has all he will ever be. He cannot change, for he has all perfections and so cannot acquire more, and he cannot lose those he has. He chose to make logic as he did because it was in accordance with his immutable will. He is not limited by it, and if he wanted to do something else he would have.
 
Once again we come to the question of God’s being limited by the rules he supposedly created.
It’s self imposed though. Just as you restrict yourself. You don’t act to your full capacity in every situation. You temper your response based on the situation.

So your question is why doesn’t God make us Gods, correct? Why would He? What would be the benefit? What Good would come of it?

In a completely other vein how do you know you’re not God, restricting yourself to preserve the game of pretending not to be God. Essentially hiding from yourself. :eek:
 
It’s self imposed though. Just as you restrict yourself. You don’t act to your full capacity in every situation. You temper your response based on the situation.

So your question is why doesn’t God make us Gods, correct? Why would He? What would be the benefit? What Good would come of it?

In a completely other vein how do you know you’re not God, restricting yourself to preserve the game of pretending not to be God. Essentially hiding from yourself. :eek:
Omniscience would make that impossible.
 
Omniscience would make that impossible.
No, it’s self restriction.

[BIBLEDRB]Matthew 26:39[/BIBLEDRB]

Do you think that Jesus didn’t know the outcome?

[BIBLEDRB]Matthew 27:46[/BIBLEDRB]

Do you really think Jesus thought the Father had forsaken Him?
 
Nothing I’ve said contradicts Aquinas 🤷 It is possible for God incarnate to create something impossible for the Human aspect of Jesus to lift. Jesus is fully Human and Fully God. The fully human part is bound by the physical world as all humans are.

Are you saying God diminished Himself by becoming man? :eek:

God cannot be diminished. God made God corporeal. Any limitations that the corporeal body has were placed there and assumed by God when he assumed a corporeal state.

God doesn’t die He is eternal. Jesus died on the Cross, Life and Death are Corporeal restrictions. Restrictions that God assumed for Himself in the person of Jesus.

So just as God assumes the human restrictions of life and death, he can assume the restriction of physics and there would be many rocks that He couldn’t lift. 🤷
Jesus in his human nature can’t life things, Jesus Human nature isn’t omnipotent and so on and so forth but his divine nature is. God didn’t diminish himself but he did empty himself but that actually made God more God, but this isn’t for discussion.

You are not really addressing my contradictions and you didn’t address what STA said.

STA made this point to be omnipotent means that God is able to do all things that are possible. We are talking about the Nature of God, while Jesus is God trying to make a point about the divine nature by saying something about the human nature of Christ. Jesus’ human nature by itself isn’t omnipotent but Jesus’ divine nature by itself is.
 
God is without limitation, what he wouldn’t be able to lift would be what he immutably chooses shall not be lifted. I hope I have not confused you with my above posts. They are all a roundabout way of saying yes God is bound by logic because he has chosen to be.
God isn’t limited by things that are impossible, there are certain things that can never be because they are contradictory in terms. I hope you know what this means. In the nature of being omnipotent there are certain things that can’t be done but those things that can’t be done aren’t possible meaning they don’t limit God. Like STA said God can’t create a man that is a donkey because it contradicts.

I will say this time and time again God is omnipotent in that he is able to do everything that is possible absolutely. That means God is perfect in the ability to do things, because not being able to do something that isn’t possible absolutely doesn’t take away from perfection.
 
Once again we come to the question of God’s being limited by the rules he supposedly created.
But omnipotence doesn’t take into account what rules God created, see God is able to do anything, he may choose to not do something, like have only himself exist, but he has the power to do that. He doesn’t take that power away from himself by creating us, he just chooses not to do that. Again God has the power to do ANYTHING, even things that would go against his own apparent rules, but he CAN’T do anything that are contradictory in terms. Like create something he can’t life (contradictory in terms of omnipotence) can’t create a man that is a donkey (a man can never be the form of a donkey and stay a man).

If you say that God created logic, and because he created logic he can’t act outside of that logic, you have limited God because you imply that God could have created another logic which would allow a man to be a donkey allowing God to do this, meaning that in Omnipotence God would be able to do that. Omnipotence doesn’t mean God is able to do anything just not things he says he can’t do. No God can do anything even things he has decided not to do. Its like God decided not to eat meat on fridays, he has the possibility to do that its in his omnipotence but he chooses not to.
 
Jesus in his human nature can’t life things, Jesus Human nature isn’t omnipotent and so on and so forth but his divine nature is. God didn’t diminish himself but he did empty himself but that actually made God more God, but this isn’t for discussion.

You are not really addressing my contradictions and you didn’t address what STA said.

STA made this point to be omnipotent means that God is able to do all things that are possible. We are talking about the Nature of God, while Jesus is God trying to make a point about the divine nature by saying something about the human nature of Christ. Jesus’ human nature by itself isn’t omnipotent but Jesus’ divine nature by itself is.
Jesus is fully God and Fully Human. You can’t divide the two.

Jesus the Divine, is restricted as Jesus the Human because the Divine nature took on a corporal nature.

So God makes it possible for God not to be able to lift something. God also makes it possible for God to Die.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top