Is God bound by logic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CeaselessMedik
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Jesus is fully God and Fully Human. You can’t divide the two.

Jesus the Divine, is restricted as Jesus the Human because the Divine nature took on a corporal nature.

So God makes it possible for God not to be able to lift something. God also makes it possible for God to Die.
I’m not really sure how to deal with this part because I’m not solid on the theology of all this, how God’s divine nature is active in the person of Jesus Christ, does Jesus Human nature limit his divine nature, or is Jesus Still Omnicecient (spelling) omnipresent, omnipotent mutable and utterly simple.

but that doesn’t really address the question, lets focus on STA for a second and deal with something he said is contradictory in terms.

Can God create a human that is a donkey?
 
I’m not really sure how to deal with this part because I’m not solid on the theology of all this, how God’s divine nature is active in the person of Jesus Christ, does Jesus Human nature limit his divine nature, or is Jesus Still Omnicecient (spelling) omnipresent, omnipotent mutable and utterly simple.

but that doesn’t really address the question, lets focus on STA for a second and deal with something he said is contradictory in terms.

Can God create a human that is a donkey?
I think you brought up that example. It’s flawed though. You have to define what makes a human, a human first. Is the soul, body, mind ? Something else?

You could have a Donkey Body with a human soul and mind. What is then?

We are God’s creatures, He can created what ever He wishes. :rolleyes:
 
I think you brought up that example. It’s flawed though. You have to define what makes a human, a human first. Is the soul, body, mind ? Something else?

You could have a Donkey Body with a human soul and mind. What is then?

We are God’s creatures, He can created what ever He wishes. :rolleyes:
to be human all you need is simply form and matter. If you have the human form you are human and if you have matter that means you exist. So all existing human beings have human form and matter (not necessarily human matter) But in order to be human you have to have human form. So to say that a human (aka a being that has human form) can be a donkey (aka a being that has donkey form) is contradictory in terms.
 
to be human all you need is simply form and matter. If you have the human form you are human and if you have matter that means you exist. So all existing human beings have human form and matter (not necessarily human matter) But in order to be human you have to have human form. So to say that a human (aka a being that has human form) can be a donkey (aka a being that has donkey form) is contradictory in terms.
David by Michaelangelo has human form and matter is the staute a human?
 
David by Michaelangelo has human form and matter is the staute a human?
I misread this let me try again

the form of the David Statue is David Statue.

The fact that the David Statue doesn’t live means it can’t be human form rather the form statue.
 
I misread this let me try again

the form of the David Statue is David Statue.

The fact that the David Statue doesn’t live means it can’t be human form rather the form statue.
Is English your first language?
 
Yes.

God could not make a triangle that was anything other than 180º and still a triangle. St Thomas treats this at length in his Summa Theologiæ.
Humans can make triangles that have angles whose sum is larger than 180º. If humans can I am sure that God can too. 😉
 
David by Michaelangelo has human form and matter is the staute a human?
I noticed I didn’t respond to this well lets try it again (I think a third time lol)

David by Michaelangelo isn’t human form. Part of Human form is having rational thought, the statue doesn’t have that meaning it isn’t human form. Its form is a human statue.
 
I noticed I didn’t respond to this well lets try it again (I think a third time lol)

David by Michaelangelo isn’t human form. Part of Human form is having rational thought, the statue doesn’t have that meaning it isn’t human form. Its form is a human statue.
That is the problem with your model. You aren’t defining what it means to be human. Form means shape not substance.

You’re talking gobbledegook.
 
Can God do something that is impossible absolutely?
Yes and no. The problem is not with God but with our limitation when we deal with what is possible and impossible. Our limitation is to associate omnipotence with the principle of non contradiction, we are not capable of transcending from that point. We can say that God is omnipotent and that He does not contradict Himself. If we find a conflict with that statement it is because our limitation and how we build our logic, the more we tray to close a logic system the more restrictive we become. The more we keep a logic system open the less it makes sense, the less it is usable.
 
That is the problem with your model. You aren’t defining what it means to be human. Form means shape not substance.

You’re talking gobbledegook.
form does not mean shape in terms of Philosophy form means what it means to be a certain being.*

Humans are made up of this (I’m explain what makes up the soul in terms of aristotle, which all included is the human form)

Sensation (animals have this)
Motion (mostly local motion)
Appetition
Imagination
Thinking (only humans have this)

humans have all 5 of these things, and this is what makes human.
 
Yes and no.
the answer is no, God can’t do things that are not impossibly absolute.

God can’t violate the principle of non contradiction just as much as we can’t violate the principle of non contradiction.
 
form does not mean shape in terms of Philosophy form means what it means to be a certain being.*

Humans are made up of this (I’m explain what makes up the soul in terms of aristotle, which all included is the human form)

Sensation (animals have this)
Motion (mostly local motion)
Appetition
Imagination
Thinking (only humans have this)

humans have all 5 of these things, and this is what makes human.
Thinking isn’t something only humans have. Your model is flawed.
 
Thinking isn’t something only humans have. Your model is flawed.
I would disagree, it may be better to call Thinking rational thought. Only humans have rational thought.

But we are wasting time talking about what makes up human form.

Human form is human form and nothing else.

Human form can’t be donkey form at the same time. That is a contradiction of terms.
 
for the sake of not confusing philosophical form with mathematical form let me explain this in terms of Soul (Soul as seen by aristotle aka the form of living things)

God can’t make the Soul of a Human be the Soul of a Donkey at the same time

The Human soul is the human soul. Nothing else.

If you say that a Human Soul is at the same time a Donkey Soul that would be a contradiction of terms. Meaning it would be absurd meaning it would be impossible absolutely meaning God can’t do it.
 
form does not mean shape in terms of Philosophy form means what it means to be a certain being.*

Humans are made up of this (I’m explain what makes up the soul in terms of aristotle, which all included is the human form)

Sensation (animals have this)
Motion (mostly local motion)
Appetition
Imagination
Thinking (only humans have this)

humans have all 5 of these things, and this is what makes human.
I think that in logic and/or philosophy form is a structure devoid of content. Here you are associating content (being human) to the form. Are you try to express something similar to the concepts of substance and accidents as used in Aristotle’s philosophy?
 
I would disagree, it may be better to call Thinking rational thought. Only humans have rational thought.

But we are wasting time talking about what makes up human form.

Human form is human form and nothing else.

Human form can’t be donkey form at the same time. That is a contradiction of terms.
No we’re not wasting time. You have to define what a human is before you say something doesn’t meet the qualifications to be a human.

You are making empty statements.
 
I think that in logic and/or philosophy form is a structure devoid of content. Here you are associating content (being human) to the form. Are you try to express something similar to the concepts of substance and accidents as used in Aristotle’s philosophy?
I was just trying to explain the characteristics of Souls.

Its what I know best in terms of describing human beings we could use the summa or something else I just choose to use Aristotle, which has a big influence on Thomas

anyway Form is the actuality of existence. It is what organizes material into Human form or tree form, and so on and so forth. Form is like Soul by the fact that it is immortal Form doesn’t pass away, my form always exists but it isn’t active without the matter because I can’t be individuated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top