Is HAVING faith enough?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Catholic4aReasn
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
Shibboleth:
Good question,

In terms of Lutheran belief…

The normal avenue that one receives Grace is by way of Baptism by Water in the Name of The Father, Son, and Holy Ghost.

Some might say, well isn’t this a work. Yes and no… It is a work but it is not our work but the work of God and an active and living faith in the Believers involved. The faith does the work we are simply the conduit by which it is done.

Without faith the act of Baptism would have no effect… it would be an empty symbolic gesture.

Once one receives God’s Grace can it be lost and how? Well this really depends on what one means. In a strict Lutheran View – no we cannot loose God’s Grace we can however deny God and thereby cut ourselves off from God’s Grace. God desperately wishes for all of his Children to be saved so he constantly holds his Grace before us and never takes it away do to our sinful acts – he sent his only Son to forgive each and every one of our sins.

How do we come back into salvation?

Well, we cease to reject God and thereby we are no longer cut off from the Grace of God. Once we cease rejecting God the active faith in us will lead us to repent our sins but this is not due to ourselves but the active and living faith within us.
What if a person is menally retarded and can’t understand what faith is can he be baptised. In all respect how can you not be able to lose something and then be able to lose something? And if grace is conferred by water and the spirit, how is faith(knowledgable ascent) necessary? You say we recieve Grace* by* way of… In the Bible whole households were being baptised and as a covenental practice to Jews, the rite of Baptism would eventually (and immediately) replace the holy rite of circumcision. It seems that this would have upset the Jews(converts) to think that
only those who were old enought to have faith(understand) would be baptised, when their faith as parents was sufficient to have younger people circumsized.
Peace and Love
 
40.png
cyprian:
What if a person is menally retarded and can’t understand what faith is can he be baptised. In all respect how can you not be able to lose something and then be able to lose something? And if grace is conferred by water and the spirit, how is faith(knowledgable ascent) necessary? You say we recieve Grace* by* way of… In the Bible whole households were being baptised and as a covenental practice to Jews, the rite of Baptism would eventually (and immediately) replace the holy rite of circumcision. It seems that this would have upset the Jews(converts) to think that
only those who were old enought to have faith(understand) would be baptised, when their faith as parents was sufficient to have younger people circumsized.
Peace and Love
I am not sure who you are confusing me with but I believe in the baptism of infants and so does Lutheranism. We are born spiritually dead as expressed in Eph 2:1. We do not have the ability to spiritually come to God. If one were to claim that they chose to be baptized and become Christian then they, in my humble opinion, are boasting about their works of law.

In 2 Cor 2:14 Paul states "But a natural man does not accept the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him; and he cannot understand them, because they are spiritually appraised.’

Likewise in Romans 8 states: “because the mind set on the flesh is hostile toward God; for it does not subject itself to the law of God, for it is not even able to do so”

2 Cor 3:5 5Not that we are adequate in ourselves to consider anything as coming from ourselves, but our adequacy is from God,

So when it comes to infants and the mentally challenged they need not understand to be received by the holy spirit, because not one of us understands or is capable of coming to God by our own volition.

The baptized infants and mentally challenged do indeed have ‘faith.’

This is why ‘faith’ and ‘works’ are gifts of God’s Grace… outside of God’s Grace they do not exist. Which brings me to a past post of someone… Do daemons believe in God? Sure they do just as I believe in the fact Elton John exists, but Daemons are outside of God’s Grace and therefore do not have ‘faith’ they only have belief.

We do not loose God’s Grace, he constantly holds it before us but we can cut ourselves off from his Grace by rejecting it – God isn’t going to force someone to go to Heaven that does not wish to do so…

I compare it to breathing. We do not consciously choose to participate in our breathing nor is it our choice when we choose to start breathing, but we can reject our ability to breath and hold our breath. However, the minute we cease rejecting our breathing we start inhaling and exhaling without any conscious participation on our part.
 
40.png
Shibboleth:
I am not sure who you are confusing me with but I believe in the baptism of infants and so does Lutheranism. We are born spiritually dead as expressed in Eph 2:1. We do not have the ability to spiritually come to God. If one were to claim that they chose to be baptized and become Christian then they, in my humble opinion, are boasting about their works of law.

In 2 Cor 2:14 Paul states "But a natural man does not accept the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him; and he cannot understand them, because they are spiritually appraised.’

Likewise in Romans 8 states: “because the mind set on the flesh is hostile toward God; for it does not subject itself to the law of God, for it is not even able to do so”

2 Cor 3:5 5Not that we are adequate in ourselves to consider anything as coming from ourselves, but our adequacy is from God,

So when it comes to infants and the mentally challenged they need not understand to be received by the holy spirit, because not one of us understands or is capable of coming to God by our own volition.

The baptized infants and mentally challenged do indeed have ‘faith.’

This is why ‘faith’ and ‘works’ are gifts of God’s Grace… outside of God’s Grace they do not exist. Which brings me to a past post of someone… Do daemons believe in God? Sure they do just as I believe in the fact Elton John exists, but Daemons are outside of God’s Grace and therefore do not have ‘faith’ they only have belief.

We do not loose God’s Grace, he constantly holds it before us but we can cut ourselves off from his Grace by rejecting it – God isn’t going to force someone to go to Heaven that does not wish to do so…

I compare it to breathing. We do not consciously choose to participate in our breathing nor is it our choice when we choose to start breathing, but we can reject our ability to breath and hold our breath. However, the minute we cease rejecting our breathing we start inhaling and exhaling without any conscious participation on our part.
Sorry, didn’t read your profile(re:infant bapt)

But hey , anyway I believe as you do that faith is a gift.

We’ll have to agree to disagree on the specifics re: this. (saved by faith alone-Luther)
Peace and Love
 
40.png
Shibboleth:
Lutherans call it dead faith also… sometimes. After baptism we are given or presented with the gift of Faith – this can never be taken away at this point. Why would God take it away from us? No… we can only reject the faith that he has given us.
God gave us freewill. Free to come and go. Free to believe or not free to start and then stop believing. Satan, fallen angels, Judas, etc. are good examples. Faith is not our greatest gift, Love is. Faith ends, Love is eternal. Satan doesn’t have Faith in God, Satan KNOWS God. Faith is for something you cannot see or touch or feel (A short description here only). When you get to heaven you no longer need Faith for you will know God (i.e. Become God, CCC460).
…The real question that would insight probably some very heated debate is “What is considered Living the Faith.” If a Catholic does not think that Lutherans are living the Faith what does that say about the Lutheran Faith…
You just answered that question in your question.

PS, I attended a Lutheran church for some time and loved it. Thankfully when I starded going to a Baptist church I began to finally ‘see’ the truth. Anyway, except for Luther, whom I never met thank God, all the Lutherans I know are great people and you’ll love the church. Their opinions though we can disscuss elsewhere.
 
ppl…please read matt 24:14 and matt 28:19. its wut we need including faith…follow jesus footsteps. go door to door. sumtimes i wonder “r jw doin the rite thing?” they r doin wut the bible counsels. there r many ppl who may do wrong things, but ppl always look at the wrong things. wut bout catholics? look at wut they do. fricken molest kids like michael jackson. catholics n other religions look at each other n talk bout the bad stuff they do? they say sumting bad about a religion cuz of wun bad person. dammit! ppl these days. ima catholic tho n i do the same. i c all these dam molest cases n im like dam catholics. were bad!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top