Is it unrealistic to be a housewife in 2009?

  • Thread starter Thread starter monphase
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
And so far I have yet to meet a man who lost respect for his wife because she decided to stay home. I think my husband has become more respectful as we’ve grown together and discerned God’s plan for our lives.
I think this might be a cultural difference, but all the guys I meet, they lose respect when the wife decides to stay at home. That’s why if I get married, I’m continuing to work no matter what. I would be a housewife if I knew that I wouldn’t get cheated on, be thought of as stupid/lazy, or being forced to have kids.
 
I think this might be a cultural difference, but all the guys I meet, they lose respect when the wife decides to stay at home. That’s why if I get married, I’m continuing to work no matter what. I would be a housewife if I knew that I wouldn’t get cheated on, be thought of as stupid/lazy, or being forced to have kids.
Children are a gift from God that we should welcome with open arms, not something that we should be “forced” to have.

And I’m not sure what the “cultural difference” is. I’m a convert who lives in Northern California. That’s pretty close, culturally, to Oregon.

The only people that have acted like housewives are stupid/lazy that I have met, are other women. Men are usually much more respectful. But that’s just my personally experience.
 
Children are a gift from God that we should welcome with open arms, not something that we should be “forced” to have.

And I’m not sure what the “cultural difference” is. I’m a convert who lives in Northern California. That’s pretty close, culturally, to Oregon.

The only people that have acted like housewives are stupid/lazy that I have met, are other women. Men are usually much more respectful. But that’s just my personally experience.
In my hometown, your value lies in what you can produce financially. When my best friend gave up working to be a SAHM, people thought she was crazy (even her parents made fun of her).
I should clarify the forced to have children statement. I’m infertile, and I’m good with that. Doctors have said that only way I can have a kid of my own is to do IVF, or use a surrogate, which annoys me. I’d rather be a foster parent or adopt a older child (kids younger than 12 drive me up a wall).
 
I believe being a housewife is the most important, most godly job a woman can have. What could be better than taking care of your husband, family, and home?

In response to those of you who fear your husbands leaving you if you quit your paying job, there is something wrong with him, not you. If your husband actually thinks a paycheck is more important than raising your children, get him into counseling.

I have not been working outside the home, but I’ve been taking classes at the university for the last few years, mostly online, and I can assure you, my husband and family are much happier (and so am I) when I am on a break. Everyone enjoys a clean house and hot meals, and we spend less money when I am less busy because we order less pizza, use fewer disposable diapers, and I can be more creative and take time to plan better. I have been struggling with wanting to quit school, but there is the pressure to finish a degree. But what will I do with it? I still don’t want to leave home.

Please pray for me also, I have a lot of the same issues as you and can relate to how you’re feeling. Your husband would love to have a clean house, unwrinkled clothes, hot healthy meals, and a wife who is not completely exhausted at bedtime. Even before you have children (we have 6) there is an awful lot to do at home, and husbands require a lot of care as well.
 
I teach kids who come from low-income, frequently single-mother households, who are dealing with a lot of issues. Frankly, despite the challenges of that population, I really do like being an influence on their lives,
I hear this sentiment expressed all of the time and I wonder why I am the only person on CAF who is offended by it. You didn’t describe any behaviors your students have that make them difficult for you to teach. You said, “they are poor and come from single family homes”.

If you tell me that half of your children can’t read, ok. Don’t tell me that they all have single mothers and that’s the reason they can’t read, because it is not the reason.

researchnews.osu.edu/archive/singpar.htm

If you tell me that your children will not sit in their seats or respect authority, ok. Don’t tell me they are all poor and that’s why they can’t respect authority, because it is not the reason. If you question that, I would ask you to consider the deference and self-effacement of many impoverished people in the third world.

If your students have problems, do not make assumptions about why, because it is not likely that you will successfully guess. Either decide that you will deal with the problems as they present themselves in your class, or you will leave your profession.

I would also be careful about assuming you are having a positive impact on your children. If you are having a positive impact on them because they are thriving under your discipline, education, and love, then that is one thing. On the other hand, if you believe you are having a positive impact on them simply because they get to see a person from a higher social class everyday and it is your mere prescence alone as an educated, conservative Catholic woman, then I don’t know.
 
I think the argument that “you shouldn’t stay home because your husband could leave you and then where would you be” is odd. Then the statistics are thrown in of how common divorce is in our society.

If you are in a sacramental marriage with a committed Catholic spouse who honors God, is the spiritual head of the home and understands that divorce does not exist, then divorce isn’t really an issue. My husband and I realize that our lives are tied together, no matter what…

Something bad could happen and one of us could be left lone, but something horrible could happen to anyone, preventing them from working or doing the job that they relied upon for years. Living in fear of what could happen doesn’t help anyone. Trust in God, pray and follow where he leads.

This quote popped into my head as I was scrolling through this thread:

And so far I have yet to meet a man who lost respect for his wife because she decided to stay home. I think my husband has become more respectful as we’ve grown together and discerned God’s plan for our lives.
Whether your husband will lose respect for you if you quit working depends on the man. That’s why I think the OP should know how her husband will react before she makes this decision.

Modern society values people in large part based on what they achieve professionally. Just look at how impressed people are with those who attend Ivy League schools, who are doctors and lawyers, who are scientists. And how people who aren’t achievers are looked down on.

She has to know her husband beyond what he will tell her. Of course if she asks him “are you going to stop respecting me if I become a housewife” he’ll say he won’t, but that reaction isn’t really within his control. She has to see how he looks on people who are high achievers vs. those who are not. There could be a subconscious loss of respect that he might never voice, but nonetheless feel if she decides to stay at home for the rest of her life.

As for divorces and accidents (which aren’t as much of an issue because a man can always get a good insurance policy), I think it’s practical to have a plan B. Divorces are common, even if your husband is a faithful Catholic who is to say he will not lose his faith in the future? It is prudent for a woman with children to have a plan for taking care of her children in the case that her husband leaves.
 
I can’t blame you wanting to leave your job and being a stay at home mom. With today’s kids, mostly out of control brats, I don’t know how any teacher makes it past a month. Its not like the old days when discipline was strictly enforced with a paddle.
 
One of the most devastating aspects of the feminist movement was the foolish decision to privilege work over family. It is sadly ironic that the rather positive overall goal of giving women the same opportunities as men has led to the removal of “housewife” from a woman’s list of choices. With women entering the workforce in huge numbers as a result of devaluing the “stay at home” mom, the economy shifted and prices increased. Unfortunately, this means that women like yourself are either economically forced to work or are seized with guilty for staying home.

It’s a sorry state of affairs and the nation’s moral decline is tied into of this devaluation of housewives.

The answer to your conundrum is what others have already suggested. If you and your family want it and can handle it, do it. Any guilt you feel is simply a product of a horrifically twisted modern mentality that began after WWII. This guilt over choosing to stay home will not benefit you or your family.
 
I think it’s practical to have a plan B. Divorces are common, even if your husband is a faithful Catholic who is to say he will not lose his faith in the future?
I can only answer for myself. My husband has seen a statue of the blessed mother shed tears and has touched those tears. I can confidently say I’m not worried about a loss of faith on his part. Things would be tough on our own, if we were forced to survive without him, but they are tough now as it is (we have now been two years without running water, although I am fairly confident that in another two years we will have indoor plumbing). There are quite a few things that are worse than being poor…

I believe it’s best to trust in God and his will for my life.

It is problematic, judging worth by secular standards in such a sick society. I’m not sure I’d hold those standards up as something to live by. It gives the impression that those opinions are valid. Although of course she should take her husbands thoughts into consideration. Ideally they’ll figure it out together.

In response to the original subject I know personally my husband loves that I stay home. We are able to make do with and save a lot this way. I garden, knit, crochet, quilt and stay pretty busy.
 
In my hometown, your value lies in what you can produce financially. When my best friend gave up working to be a SAHM, people thought she was crazy (even her parents made fun of her).
Sounds like it’s time for a new set of friends that share your values.
 
To answer your question, no, it’s not unrealisitc. And I agree that it’s a decision only the two of you can make. Speaking from my personal experience, up until earlier this year I’ve worked full-time since I graduated high school. I’ve never been good at multi-tasking my split responsibilities of work, home and personal lives. Add that to the fact that I was never taught the value of a wife or a well-kept home (let alone how to be/do those things) and you can see how I fell into the feminist trap of having it all. I didn’t know what “all” really was. Now I’ve been home for about 6 months, a little longer maybe, and while I am in college full-time I love my life so much more now. I was never able to really enjoy life before because I was so busy doing something or so stressed out that all I could do was drop down in front of the tv, stuff my face and sleep through my weekends, and that’s not even considering the effects that a 2-income lifestyle had on my marriage. Now it’s so much better than I ever thought it could be, and I won’t sacrifice it for any of those things I thought were necessary, especially not just because others might think ill of me for being home. I know my value and the value of what I do, and so does my husband, and so does my God. That’s all that matters, for me and for you. 😉
I think this might be a cultural difference, but all the guys I meet, they lose respect when the wife decides to stay at home. That’s why if I get married, I’m continuing to work no matter what. I would be a housewife if I knew that I wouldn’t get cheated on, be thought of as stupid/lazy, or being forced to have kids.
Some men do feel that way, but only because our society has taught them that a woman should always do 50% in everything. It is cultural, but since we are Christians, we’re not to conform to it when it opposes our faith. In this instance, I think it absolutely does. We’re to each give 100%, in whatever form that may take, and traditional roles work out best the majority of the time.
I think we would have a stronger, more physically-fit, and civil nation if more women stayed home, kept house, made healthy meals, and raised their own children.
Amen to that! 👍
I think that many young women truly do not know how to do this. Many of their mothers worked, and most of the TV and movie moms work. I know young women at work who, when they have a day off, put their kids in daycare because they literally have no idea “how” to raise children. All the time, women in my workplace tell me that they are bored to death when they stay home with their children. Very sad.
I have also found this to be true. Even with a stay at home mom, I did not learn how to parent, as my mother has some emotional issues and never really saw motherhood as something that she had to work at or pass along to us.
 
the way of life OP describes is a beautiful and valuable one, but I feel compelled to point out that whether or not a woman works outside the home or not she is still a housewife, those duties still need to be done, and it she still has a spirituality of hospitality to guide her in fulfilling those duties. Whether or not it is realistic for you is a question only you and your husband can answer, and your situation may change in the future, but it is a gift to be able to devote yourself single-mindedly to the wifely arts. Some of us have not been so fortunate, so if you are in that position, enjoy it while it lasts. What is not realistic is expecting to live at the same material standard as a couple with two incomes, and allowing oneself to resent material sacrifices you will be called upon to make if you forego the second income.
 
the way of life OP describes is a beautiful and valuable one, but I feel compelled to point out that whether or not a woman works outside the home or not she is still a housewife, those duties still need to be done, and it she still has a spirituality of hospitality to guide her in fulfilling those duties. Whether or not it is realistic for you is a question only you and your husband can answer, and your situation may change in the future, but it is a gift to be able to devote yourself single-mindedly to the wifely arts. Some of us have not been so fortunate, so if you are in that position, enjoy it while it lasts. What is not realistic is expecting to live at the same material standard as a couple with two incomes, and allowing oneself to resent material sacrifices you will be called upon to make if you forego the second income.
Yes, this can be one of the hardest things about not having that second income. In most cases, you may not be living at the same standard as your friends and peers. Even though you make that decision on purpose, it can still get under your skin when you are living in a tiny house and they are living quite differently, or they send their kids to hockey and you cannot. It’s something I find I have to consciously remind myself of, and remind myself specifically that I don’t think things like bouncy-house birthday parties are important when that is the thing everyone is doing.
 
Yes it is very realistic. 😃 I’m the ultimate counter-culture woman. I’m a full time stay at home wife AND I don’t even have children (we can’t due to infertility.) So I stay at home JUST to be a homemaker and my husband’s helpmate. 👍 My husband and I would have it no other way. This truly is the best and most fulfilling option for us both. I tried working at the beginning of our marriage and everything at home fell apart. We even grew emotionally apart at the time and had hardly any time together. 😦

I’m not saying it’s not possible to be a working wife/mother, and there are times when it is absolutely necessary, but so many people don’t realize how very little they can live on and what a great gain the stay at home wife/mother is to her family. (I should know, we live very much day to day, paycheck to paycheck, and often go without many comforts. We go without many so called “needs” of society. We live simply.) It is a far greater gain to her husband and children both than any monetary asset she could give working full time. That is not saying a wife/mother working full time is wrong, it is sometimes absolutely necessary, but I think it should be the exception rather than the norm. 😉
 
I can’t blame you wanting to leave your job and being a stay at home mom. With today’s kids, mostly out of control brats, I don’t know how any teacher makes it past a month. Its not like the old days when discipline was strictly enforced with a paddle.
I truly hope that you have a change of heart about children before you have any of your own! Leaving Mass angry because of a few noisy children? Hoping for a return to corporal punishment in schools? You do not seem to understand that children are a gift from God and made in His image and so worthy of respect and dignity. We don’t become human only when we get to be 18 and/or when we stay out of trouble!
 
I truly hope that you have a change of heart about children before you have any of your own! Leaving Mass angry because of a few noisy children? Hoping for a return to corporal punishment in schools? You do not seem to understand that children are a gift from God and made in His image and so worthy of respect and dignity. We don’t become human only when we get to be 18 and/or when we stay out of trouble!
But children are horrible becasue their parents refuse to raise them correctly. I’ve worked with children for years (before I got burned out from the neglected children). And children are horrible, I had a first grader say the f-word to me, and I wanted to smack him and his mom/dad/whoever. Too many parents don’t care anymore, they are just looking for another trophy to show of (look at me, I had sex, I had a baby!). I’m glad I’m infertile. My friend had a third grader take a gun to school and threatened to shoot the music teacher if she didn’t play music he liked. lost faith all any goodness from children.
 
But children are horrible becasue their parents refuse to raise them correctly. I’ve worked with children for years (before I got burned out from the neglected children). And children are horrible, I had a first grader say the f-word to me, and I wanted to smack him and his mom/dad/whoever. Too many parents don’t care anymore, they are just looking for another trophy to show of (look at me, I had sex, I had a baby!). I’m glad I’m infertile. My friend had a third grader take a gun to school and threatened to shoot the music teacher if she didn’t play music he liked. lost faith all any goodness from children.
Country Singer, considering you don’t have children, and have said before the birth process is “gross”, which is the kind of interpretation I would expect from a 10-year old, I don’t think you are the best authority on children.
 
Country Singer, considering you don’t have children, and have said before the birth process is “gross”, which is the kind of interpretation I would expect from a 10-year old, I don’t think you are the best authority on children.
Actually, I was a school teacher until I got burned out. I worked with children whose parents wouldn’t feed them, so guess who bought food for them? Me. Who made sure they were dressed properly? Not their parents. Who tried to teach them even when parents didn’t care? Me. When there was a person with a gun in the school ,who protected her students? Me. Before that, I worked in day cares, student teaching, etc. I might be heartless, but I wasn’t going to let children suffer. After all those years of working with children, I was done. All I know is that I didn’t want any of my own.

If I hated children, I would have let the gunman have them, let them starve, and not teach them.
 
And this is why we are homeschoolers. I don’t want a teacher that hates children teaching mine. Wow.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top