Is suffering good or bad?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why, even after not losing, but strengthing their faith, keeping their morals intact after many unsavory opportunities to relieve their problems, being mocked and told they are stupid and are they still glad to have their morals- why does it continue? When does God say - you passed? (if only for a brief period of peace)
Suffering ends once you make it to heaven. Realize that even after you die, there may be suffering in purgatory too. Suffering can be a means for purification. When Jesus said we must carry our crosses and follow Him, it means we must be crucified and die on them. This simply means that the crosses in life are means to sanctification. Archbishop Fulton Sheen gives a great short talk about this that will explain the reality of what being a Christian is all about. He speaks about the problem of allowing ourselves to remain merely “good eggs”. A good egg must hatch. No half measures are any good, Christ did not call upon us to carry a cross merely to torment our natural self; the goal is to kill it… Here is a short excerpt from his talk:

"The trouble with most of us is that we are trying to remain what we are, and at the same time to keep a reasonable amount of peace. We want to be “good”. We want our heart and mind to go one way-- maybe it’s after money, maybe it’s after pleasure, maybe it’s after social prestige, and at the same time we do want to remain honestly, and chastely, and keep the commandments. Now that is exactly what our blessed Lord told us we were not to do…"

To listen to the full 20 minute talk CLICK HERE NOW. It’s well worth your time to listen to it–and learn it by heart.

Thus pain and suffering can be a stumbling block for many, but a means to sanctification for the true Christian.

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
If you really think about it, what is suffering? It’s nothing more than not having what our nature craves, wants, needs- Not having comfort, pleasure, not having our desires, wishes, will fulfilled etc. Catholicism teaches that God redeems suffering which is a consequence of sin and makes it a means for salvation. He takes what was meant for evil and draws good out of it, thus showing his greatness even more. He is who is able to fulfil his purposes without thwarting the free will of his creatures and he who is able to bring good, yes, even out of evil.

No contradiction at all- Suffering is not the natural state of mankind per God’s will and we are to attempt to work with God to alleviate it- That’s salvation (saving people from the worst suffering of all- separation from God), but where we cannot alleviate it through work and prayer, we are to accept that God is using it to save us from inordinate attachment (slavery) to ourselves. In this sense we accept both our own suffering and the suffering of others. So suffering in itself is not good, but in God’s hands, it is.
 
If you really think about it, what is suffering? It’s nothing more than not having what our nature craves, wants, needs- Not having comfort, pleasure, not having our desires, wishes, will fulfilled etc. Catholicism teaches that God redeems suffering which is a consequence of sin and makes it a means for salvation. He takes what was meant for evil and draws good out of it, thus showing his greatness even more. He is who is able to fulfil his purposes without thwarting the free will of his creatures and he who is able to bring good, yes, even out of evil.

No contradiction at all- Suffering is not the natural state of mankind per God’s will and we are to attempt to work with God to alleviate it- That’s salvation (saving people from the worst suffering of all- separation from God), but where we cannot alleviate it through work and prayer, we are to accept that God is using it to save us from inordinate attachment (slavery) to ourselves. In this sense we accept both our own suffering and the suffering of others. So suffering in itself is not good, but in God’s hands, it is.
Nicely put, and I agree with your sentiment about suffering. However, I have a question: since G-d uses suffering “to save us from inordinate attachment (slavery) to ourselves,” why should we fight to alleviate it at all, instead of leaving it in G-d’s hands? Just because suffering is not the natural state of mankind? I still see a kind of contradiction there, unless your thesis, based on Catholic teaching, is that earthly suffering is a mystery that is BOTH good and bad.
 
Some do believe in the redemptive power of both personal suffering and suffering on behalf of others, although alleviating the suffering of others should not be done explicitly for the purpose of achieving a greater reward in the World to Come, and neither should martyrdom be in order to achieve self-glory. I’m sure Catholicism would agree with this view.
Not exactly. While it is better to do good for love, it is not a sin to do good for glory.
(c) But is not this continual acting “with one eye on heaven”, with which Professor Jodl reproaches Catholic moral teaching, the meanest “mercenary spirit” and greed which necessarily vitiates to the core all moral action? Can there be any question of morality, if it is only the desire for eternal bliss or simply the fear of hell that determines one to do good and avoid evil? Such a disposition is certainly far from being the ideal of Catholic morality. On the Contrary, the Church proclaims to all her children that pure love of God is the first and supreme commandment (cf. Mark 12:30). It is our highest ideal to act out of love. For he who truly loves God would keep His commandments, even though there were no eternal reward in the next life. Nevertheless, the desire for heaven is a necessary and natural consequence of the perfect love of God; for heaven is only the perfect possession of God by love. As a true friend desires to see his friend without thereby sinking into egotism so does the loving soul ardently desire the Beatific Vision, not from a craving for reward, but out of pure love. It is unfortunately too true that only the best type of Christians, and especially the great saints of the Church, reach this high standard of morality in everyday life. The great majority of ordinary Christians must be deterred from sin principally by the fear of hell and spurred on to good works by the thought of an eternal reward, before they attain perfect love. But, even for those souls who love God, there are times of grave temptation when only the thought of heaven and hell keeps them from falling. Such a disposition, be it habitual or only transitory, is morally less perfect, but it is not immoral. As, according to Christ’s doctrine and that of St. Paul (see above), it is legitimate to hope for a heavenly reward, so, according to the same doctrine of Christ (cf. Matthew 10:28), the fear of hell is a motive of moral action, a “grace of God and an impulse of the Holy Ghost” (Council of Trent, Sess. XIV, cap. iv, in Denzinger, n. 898). Only that desire for remuneration (amor mercenarius) is reprehensible which would content itself with an eternal happiness without God, and that “doubly servile fear” (timor serviliter servilis) is alone immoral which proceeds from a mere dread of punishment without at the same time fearing God. But the dogmatic as well as the moral teaching of the Church avoids both of these extremes (see ATTRITION).
newadvent.org/cathen/10202b.htm
 
Again, the purpose of man is to be supremely happy. The only way man can be supremely happy is to be in perfect union with the source of happiness (God). Perfect union with God is enjoyed only by the saints in heaven. The degree of glory in heaven depends upon the degree of love one has lived on earth.
Do you mean the ultimate purpose, or destiny, of Man is to be supremely happy, or the earthly purpose? If the latter, I thought the purpose of Man is to exercise his free will in loving G-d and His creatures, which, I suppose, would bring happiness if carried out to perfection. Still, can and should such love erase all suffering, or is suffering rather a necessary condition of this love?
 
Nicely put, and I agree with your sentiment about suffering. However, I have a question: since G-d uses suffering “to save us from inordinate attachment (slavery) to ourselves,” why should we fight to alleviate it at all, instead of leaving it in G-d’s hands? Just because suffering is not the natural state of mankind? I still see a kind of contradiction there, unless your thesis, based on Catholic teaching, is that earthly suffering is a mystery that is BOTH good and bad.
Certainly, suffering is a mystery- no one can debate that. But my thinking is that whatever suffering there is that can be alleviated by man through work or prayer is intended for alleviation. In that sense, it’s purpose is to “force” us to serve, to deny ourselves and in so doing, it saves us from ourselves. Afterall, you cannot serve where there is no need/lack- and we all lack in one way or another, materially or spiritually.

That which is beyond our efforts to alleviate is what God himself uses (in a sense, without us) to save us, so that our only role is trusting acceptance of the Divine will and wisdom in the circumstances. To borrow from St John of the Cross, I would say it was active vs passive roles in our sanctification (the process by which our wills are conformed to the divine will) as it’s accomplished through the means of suffering of all kinds, material and spiritual. I believe St. John calls it via negativa- privation or darkness.
 
Not exactly. While it is better to do good for love, it is not a sin to do good for glory.

newadvent.org/cathen/10202b.htm
I think this belief is in keeping with Judaism. Maybe Judaism extends even a little further since it believes that while a good deed without any intention of being rewarded, and provoked instead by true compassion, is the best form of charity, that same good deed with the sole intention of being rewarded, in Heaven or on Earth, and performed grudgingly, is still better than no deed at all.
 
Do you mean the ultimate purpose, or destiny, of Man is to be supremely happy, or the earthly purpose? If the latter, I thought the purpose of Man is to exercise his free will in loving G-d and His creatures, which, I suppose, would bring happiness if carried out to perfection. Still, can and should such love erase all suffering, or is suffering rather a necessary condition of this love?
My, you do have the most difficult questions! Catholicism teaches that man was made for happiness- that happiness is the possession of God in love, aka Heaven or the Beatific Vision. I don’t know if we can say that suffering is necessary for love, because God, the Blessed Trinity is Absolute Love and lacks suffering.
 
Suffering ends once you make it to heaven. Realize that even after you die, there may be suffering in purgatory too. Suffering can be a means for purification. When Jesus said we must carry our crosses and follow Him, it means we must be crucified and die on them. This simply means that the crosses in life are means to sanctification. Archbishop Fulton Sheen gives a great short talk about this that will explain the reality of what being a Christian is all about. He speaks about the problem of allowing ourselves to remain merely “good eggs”. A good egg must hatch. No half measures are any good, Christ did not call upon us to carry a cross merely to torment our natural self; the goal is to kill it… Here is a short excerpt from his talk:

"The trouble with most of us is that we are trying to remain what we are, and at the same time to keep a reasonable amount of peace. We want to be “good”. We want our heart and mind to go one way-- maybe it’s after money, maybe it’s after pleasure, maybe it’s after social prestige, and at the same time we do want to remain honestly, and chastely, and keep the commandments. Now that is exactly what our blessed Lord told us we were not to do…"

To listen to the full 20 minute talk CLICK HERE NOW. It’s well worth your time to listen to it–and learn it by heart.

Thus pain and suffering can be a stumbling block for many, but a means to sanctification for the true Christian.

http://static.artbible.info/large/calvarie.jpg
Indeed, Purgatory puts a different face on suffering, by connecting it to purification, in Catholicism as in Judaism. (Of course, earthly suffering is also associated in a secular sense with the “true artist.”) Does Catholicism also believe that the death penalty–while it should remain rare and used only for the most heinous crimes which were committed beyond any reasonable doubt–serves the function of lessening the intensity and time period of Purgatory suffering?
 
Indeed, Purgatory puts a different face on suffering, by connecting it to purification, in Catholicism as in Judaism. . . . Does Catholicism also believe that the death penalty–while it should remain rare and used only for the most heinous crimes which were committed beyond any reasonable doubt–serves the function of lessening the intensity and time period of Purgatory suffering?
It all depends on the individual being put to death. There’s something about the death penalty that can focus a man’s mind on things eternal, but a man may very well go to his execution and lose his soul, while another, if he’s turned to God and truly repented of his sins, could offer up his predicament in reparation for his sins. You see, we can do our purgatory on earth; those who die in God’s grace but have yet to reach perfection will be cleansed in the purifying fires of purgatory, as mentioned in 1 Corinthians 3:13-15.

You can be sorry for burning down my house, and I may forgive you if you seek my forgiveness; but the house still needs to be repaired…
 
Blessed John Paul II

APOSTOLIC LETTER
SALVIFICI DOLORIS

Assuming then that throughout his earthly life man walks in one manner or another on the long path of suffering, it is precisely on this path that the Church at all times-and perhaps especially during the Holy Year of the Redemption-should meet man. Born of the mystery of Redemption in the Cross of Christ, the Church has to try to meet man in a special way on the path of his suffering. In this meeting man “becomes the way for the Church”, and this way is one of the most important ones.

ewtn.com/library/PAPALDOC/JP2SALVI.HTM

peace
 
(Post 1 of 2)

since it’s been stated, again and again, that suffering is evil in itself, i would simply like to ask, where does the Church teach this? i have looked through many books, including encyclopedias and dictionaries, and have found no such teaching or definition,

instead i find explanations like this - “A true good is whatever leads us to the attainment of our last end - everlasting happieness. A real evil is whatever obstructs us in the attainment of our last end”
one of the Catholic definitions of evil "Evil - The privation of a good that should be present. It is the lack of a good that essentially belongs to a nature; the absence of a good that is natural and due to a being. Evil is therefore the absence of what ought to be there. "

and then from “The Catechism explained(an exhaustive explanation of the Catholic Religion)” which you can find here - tanbooks.benedictpress.com/index.php/page/shop:flypage/product_id/409 and you can even read it free here - archive.org/stream/catechismexplain00spiruoft#page/n5/mode/2up

*"**2. All suffering comes from God, and is a sign of His love and
favor. **

We find in the lives of the saints that the more good works they
undertook for God, the more did suffering assail them, as in the case
of Tobias, and of holy Job. Sufferings seem to be the reward of good
works performed. They are a precious gift, which will avail us to all
eternity. To suffer something for God is in itself a great privilege and
honor. It is a better gift than that of performing miracles and raising
the dead. Parents often punish their children to cure them of
their faults. If they see the same faults in the children of others,
they do not trouble themselves about them, because they do not care
for them. So it is with God; the children whom He loves He often
corrects. Hence Raphael said to Tobias, " Because thou wast pleasing
to God, it was necessary that temptation should prove thee"
(Tob. xii. 13). St. Paul says, " Whom the Lord loveth He chastiseth;
and scourgeth every son whom He receiveth " (Heb. xii. 6). “Gold
and silver are tried in the fire, and acceptable men in the furnace of
tribulation” (Ecclus. ii. 5). The greater a saint, the greater were
in most cases his sufferings. Our Lady was the Queen of martyrs.
The apostles had to suffer much, especially St. Peter and St. Paul
(Of. 2 Cor. xi. 23, seq.}. To be free from suffering is a bad sign.
St. Augustine says : " There is no greater misfortune than the good
fortune of sinners. He who does not suffer now will have to suffer
hereafter."

Yet God never sends us any suffering that is beyond our
powers of endurance.

St. Paul says “God is faithful ; Who will not permit you to suffer
above that which you are able” (1 Cor. x. 13). The peasant knows
how much his beast of burden can carry, and does not load him
beyond his strength. Will God, the all-wise, the all-merciful, lay
more on us than we can bear? The potter does not leave his vessels
too long in the fire lest they should crack. He who plays on an
instrument is careful not to tighten the strings too much, lest they
should break; nor too little, for then they would produce no sound.
The physician apportions his remedies to the power of his patient;
so the heavenly Physician sends us sufferings in proportion to our
power of bearing them. There are some people who make sufferings
for themselves, because they find fault with what gives no cause for
complaint. Even in real sufferings much complaining is a sign of
faint-heartedness and makes us more sensible to suffering.

**3. God sends suffering to the sinner to bring him back into
the right way and to save him from eternal death. **

How many have been converted by means of sufferings, e.g., Man-
asses in the prison at Babylon (2 Paral. xxxiii. 12, 13), Jonas, the
prodigal son, even the wicked Achab (3 Kings xxi. 27). God is like
a surgeon, who cuts away the diseased flesh that it may not cause
death. Sufferings also bring about a disgust for earthly things and
make the sinful pleasures of the world bitter; they destroy our
dependence on earthly things, and take away the desire for the enjoyments
and the pleasures of this valley of tears, and turn our thoughts to
heaven. Sufferings again impress upon us our own helplessness, compel
us to have recourse to God in prayer. They teach us a knowledge of
ourselves and of our own sinfulness. As the trees, after the winter,
flower and bring forth fruit, so does man after suffering bring forth
works pleasing to God. “Sufferings,” says St. Teresa, " though very
hard to bear, are the surest way to God."

God frequently sends bodily sickness to the sinner for the
healing of the sickness of his soul.

How many there are who have been converted to God through the
means of bodily sickness, e.g., St. Francis of Assisi and St. Ignatius
of Loyola. The Wise Man says, “A grievous sickness makes the
soul sober” (Ecclus. xxxi. 2). In sickness God knocks at the door
of the heart and asks for admission. " I am always glad," said St.
Ignatius, " when I see a sinner fall ill, for sickness brings back to
God." How foolish it is then to regard sickness as a mark of God’s
anger, when it is really a mark of His compassion. "*

(continued in next post)
 
(Post 2 of 2)

and then further on (i’m skipping chapters, but you can read the full section in the link i provided, page 141 )
*
"**5. Sufferings then are no real evil, but are benefits from the
hand of God. **

They are the means of bringing us both to temporal and eternal
happiness.

God, Who loves us tenderly, has no other object in sending us
sufferings but to make us happy. What we count as an evil is the
bitterness of the medicine that is necessary for the health of our
soul. There is really no evil in the world except sin. Sufferings can
never really make us unhappy; men can be happy in spite of all
kinds of sufferings. We see this in Job, in Tobias, in Our Lady.
St. Paul says, " I am filled with comfort ; I exceedingly abound with
joy in all our tribulation" (2 Cor. vii. 4). "*

so again, suffering is neither evil, nor bad, but only our reception of it may be bad, or the evil intention to inflict it on others is bad, but in and of itself, it is not bad or evil.
 
(Post 2 of 2)
so again, suffering is neither evil, nor bad, but only our reception of it may be bad, or the evil intention to inflict it on others is bad, but in and of itself, it is not bad or evil.
Suffering is a consequence of sin which is by its very nature evil and bad.

ccel.org/ccel/julian/revelations.xiv.i.html
Revelations of Divine Love to St. Julian of Norwich, XXVII
“Often I wondered why by the great foreseeing wisdom of God the beginning of sin was not hindered: for then, methought, all should have been well.” “Sin is behovable—[playeth a needful part]—; but all shall be well”
AFTER this the Lord brought to my mind the longing that I had to Him afore. And I saw that nothing letted me but sin. And so I looked, generally, upon us all, and methought: If sin had not been, we should all have been clean and like to our Lord, as He made us.
And thus, in my folly, afore this time often I wondered why by the great foreseeing wisdom of God the beginning of sin was not letted: for then, methought, all should have been well. This stirring [of mind] was 55 much to be forsaken, but nevertheless mourning and sorrow I made therefor, without reason and discretion.
But Jesus, who in this Vision informed me of all that is needful to me, answered by this word and said: It behoved that there should be sin;92 but all shall be well, and all shall be well, and all manner of thing shall be well.
In this naked word sin, our Lord brought to my mind, generally, all that is not good, and the shameful despite and the utter noughting93 that He bare for us in this life, and His dying; and all the pains and passions of all His creatures, ghostly and bodily; (for we be all partly noughted, and we shall be noughted following our Master, Jesus, till we be full purged, that is to say, till we be fully noughted of our deadly flesh and of all our inward affections which are not very good; ) and the beholding of this, with all pains that ever were or ever shall be,—and with all these I understand the Passion of Christ for most pain, and overpassing. All this was shewed in a touch and quickly passed over into comfort: for our good Lord would not that the soul were affeared of this terrible sight.
But I saw not sin: for I believe it hath no manner of substance nor no part of being, nor could it be known but by the pain it is cause of.
And thus94 pain, it is something, as to my sight, for a time; for it purgeth, and maketh us to know ourselves and to ask mercy. For the Passion of our Lord is comfort to us against all this, and so is His blessed will.
56
And for the tender love that our good Lord hath to all that shall be saved, He comforteth readily and sweetly, signifying thus: It is sooth95 that sin is cause of all this pain; but all shall be well, and all shall be well, and all manner [of] thing shall be well.
These words were said full tenderly, showing no manner of blame to me nor to any that shall be saved. Then were it a great unkindness96 to blame or wonder on God for my sin, since He blameth not me for sin.
And in these words I saw a marvellous high mystery hid in God, which mystery He shall openly make known to us in Heaven: in which knowing we shall verily see the cause why He suffered sin to come. In which sight we shall endlessly joy in our Lord God.97
 
Suffering is a consequence of sin which is by its very nature evil and bad.

ccel.org/ccel/julian/revelations.xiv.i.html
Revelations of Divine Love to St. Julian of Norwich, XXVII
that does not say suffering is bad or evil, it says suffering is a consequence of sin, but i never denied that, i said it in my previous posts.
what comes from sin is not only more sin, if God brings good out of evil, and sin is the only true evil, then is not suffering the good brought out of it?
if you hit someone, the hit itself is not the sin, but the hateful intention to hurt is, and if you hit someone by accident, although it still hurts them, there is no sin or evil present.
suffering is a reaction to pain, and a result of sin having entered the world, but it is not in and of itself evil.

but i think the chapters from that book i quoted explain it well enough.
 
(Post 2 of 2)
Sufferings can never really make us unhappy; men can be happy in spite of all
kinds of sufferings. We see this in Job, in Tobias, in Our Lady.
St. Paul says, " I am filled with comfort ; I exceedingly abound with
joy in all our tribulation" (2 Cor. vii. 4). "
Where does it speak of Job being happy during his sufferings? I haven’t read it recently, but all I recall is Job being tested, losing more each time and begging to God. I don’t even recall him expressing happiness when he had visitors.

I understand Job never lost faith in God and was finally relieved and blessed, but I don’t recall any happiness before his trials ended.
 
(Post 2 of 2)

and then further on (i’m skipping chapters, but you can read the full section in the link i provided, page 141 )
*
"**5. Sufferings then are no real evil, but are benefits from the
hand of God. ***

They are the means of bringing us both to temporal and eternal
happiness.

God, Who loves us tenderly, has no other object in sending us
sufferings but to make us happy. What we count as an evil is the
bitterness of the medicine that is necessary for the health of our
soul. There is really no evil in the world except sin. Sufferings can
never really make us unhappy; men can be happy in spite of all
kinds of sufferings. We see this in Job, in Tobias, in Our Lady.
St. Paul says, " I am filled with comfort ; I exceedingly abound with
joy in all our tribulation" (2 Cor. vii. 4). "

so again, suffering is neither evil, nor bad, but only our reception of it may be bad, or the evil intention to inflict it on others is bad, but in and of itself, it is not bad or evil.
It seems to me suffering may appear to us as evil because it goes against our human nature to seek pleasure and avoid pain, and against our reason, in particular when we observe the disproportionate suffering of innocent children. However, religion demands that we transcend both our nature and our reason by way of our faith that suffering serves a higher divine function which we cannot fully comprehend.
 
Where does it speak of Job being happy during his sufferings? I haven’t read it recently, but all I recall is Job being tested, losing more each time and begging to God. I don’t even recall him expressing happiness when he had visitors.

I understand Job never lost faith in God and was finally relieved and blessed, but I don’t recall any happiness before his trials ended.
The point is, however, that Job’s faith transcends both his biological and psychological aversion to suffering, both his human nature and human reason. It supersedes his desire and drive toward happiness, comfort, and pleasure. Suffering can redeem us by transforming us from men into angels. It is the surest means of purification and atonement.
 
The point is, however, that Job’s faith transcends both his biological and psychological aversion to suffering, both his human nature and human reason. It supersedes his desire and drive toward happiness, comfort, and pleasure. Suffering can redeem us by transforming us from men into angels. It is the surest means of purification and atonement.
You’re saying Job chose his faith over happiness, comfort, pleasure, and so on. Right?

That’s how I understand it, but I thought the previous poster was referring to something in the Bible regarding Job having found or felt happiness during this trial. I believe he was fairly miserable.

He suffered because God allowed him to be tested, knowing Job had the faith to endure what would be brought upon him. Job’s love and faith is what allowed him to survive this horrible period. He knew God had a purpose. However, I don’t believe he was " happy " in these times.

However, I’m not necessarily the sharpest crayon in the box. 🤷
 
You’re saying Job chose his faith over happiness, comfort, pleasure, and so on. Right?

That’s how I understand it, but I thought the previous poster was referring to something in the Bible regarding Job having found or felt happiness during this trial. I believe he was fairly miserable.

He suffered because God allowed him to be tested, knowing Job had the faith to endure what would be brought upon him. Job’s love and faith is what allowed him to survive this horrible period. He knew God had a purpose. However, I don’t believe he was " happy " in these times.

However, I’m not necessarily the sharpest crayon in the box. 🤷
I agree with you that it is not happiness THROUGH suffering that the Book of Job reveals. On the contrary, it reveals faith and trust in G-d alone DESPITE suffering, rather than faith in nature, the universe, the social order, or anything else. At the same time, however, humanity must not be oblivious to suffering even though the universe itself may be in terms of the rewards and punishments it dispenses. Strangely, I find a kind of Camus-like moral humanism in the Book of Job, except that this is a humanism NOT in a godless, absurd universe but in a universe created by an omnipotent, omniscient, and benevolent G-d whose ways are unfathomable to the human mind. There are numerous Jewish interpretations of the meaning of Job’s suffering and just as many Christian interpretations.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top