(Post 1 of 2)
since it’s been stated, again and again, that suffering is evil in itself, i would simply like to ask, where does the Church teach this? i have looked through many books, including encyclopedias and dictionaries, and have found no such teaching or definition,
instead i find explanations like this -
“A true good is whatever leads us to the attainment of our last end - everlasting happieness. A real evil is whatever obstructs us in the attainment of our last end”
one of the Catholic definitions of evil
"Evil - The privation of a good that should be present. It is the lack of a good that essentially belongs to a nature; the absence of a good that is natural and due to a being. Evil is therefore the absence of what ought to be there. "
and then from
“The Catechism explained(an exhaustive explanation of the Catholic Religion)” which you can find here -
tanbooks.benedictpress.com/index.php/page/shop:flypage/product_id/409 and you can even read it free here -
archive.org/stream/catechismexplain00spiruoft#page/n5/mode/2up
*"**2. All suffering comes from God, and is a sign of His love and
favor. **
We find in the lives of the saints that the more good works they
undertook for God, the more did suffering assail them, as in the case
of Tobias, and of holy Job. Sufferings seem to be the reward of good
works performed. They are a precious gift, which will avail us to all
eternity. To suffer something for God is in itself a great privilege and
honor. It is a better gift than that of performing miracles and raising
the dead. Parents often punish their children to cure them of
their faults. If they see the same faults in the children of others,
they do not trouble themselves about them, because they do not care
for them. So it is with God; the children whom He loves He often
corrects. Hence Raphael said to Tobias, " Because thou wast pleasing
to God, it was necessary that temptation should prove thee"
(Tob. xii. 13). St. Paul says, " Whom the Lord loveth He chastiseth;
and scourgeth every son whom He receiveth " (Heb. xii. 6). “Gold
and silver are tried in the fire, and acceptable men in the furnace of
tribulation” (Ecclus. ii. 5). The greater a saint, the greater were
in most cases his sufferings. Our Lady was the Queen of martyrs.
The apostles had to suffer much, especially St. Peter and St. Paul
(Of. 2 Cor. xi. 23, seq.}. To be free from suffering is a bad sign.
St. Augustine says : " There is no greater misfortune than the good
fortune of sinners. He who does not suffer now will have to suffer
hereafter."
Yet God never sends us any suffering that is beyond our
powers of endurance.
St. Paul says “God is faithful ; Who will not permit you to suffer
above that which you are able” (1 Cor. x. 13). The peasant knows
how much his beast of burden can carry, and does not load him
beyond his strength. Will God, the all-wise, the all-merciful, lay
more on us than we can bear? The potter does not leave his vessels
too long in the fire lest they should crack. He who plays on an
instrument is careful not to tighten the strings too much, lest they
should break; nor too little, for then they would produce no sound.
The physician apportions his remedies to the power of his patient;
so the heavenly Physician sends us sufferings in proportion to our
power of bearing them. There are some people who make sufferings
for themselves, because they find fault with what gives no cause for
complaint. Even in real sufferings much complaining is a sign of
faint-heartedness and makes us more sensible to suffering.
**3. God sends suffering to the sinner to bring him back into
the right way and to save him from eternal death. **
How many have been converted by means of sufferings, e.g., Man-
asses in the prison at Babylon (2 Paral. xxxiii. 12, 13), Jonas, the
prodigal son, even the wicked Achab (3 Kings xxi. 27). God is like
a surgeon, who cuts away the diseased flesh that it may not cause
death. Sufferings also bring about a disgust for earthly things and
make the sinful pleasures of the world bitter; they destroy our
dependence on earthly things, and take away the desire for the enjoyments
and the pleasures of this valley of tears, and turn our thoughts to
heaven. Sufferings again impress upon us our own helplessness, compel
us to have recourse to God in prayer. They teach us a knowledge of
ourselves and of our own sinfulness. As the trees, after the winter,
flower and bring forth fruit, so does man after suffering bring forth
works pleasing to God. “Sufferings,” says St. Teresa, " though very
hard to bear, are the surest way to God."
God frequently sends bodily sickness to the sinner for the
healing of the sickness of his soul.
How many there are who have been converted to God through the
means of bodily sickness, e.g., St. Francis of Assisi and St. Ignatius
of Loyola. The Wise Man says, “A grievous sickness makes the
soul sober” (Ecclus. xxxi. 2). In sickness God knocks at the door
of the heart and asks for admission. " I am always glad," said St.
Ignatius, " when I see a sinner fall ill, for sickness brings back to
God." How foolish it is then to regard sickness as a mark of God’s
anger, when it is really a mark of His compassion. "*
(continued in next post)