M
Marybeloved
Guest
If suffering were in itself good and not bad, or “neither good nor bad”, it would make total rubbish of our entire faith. If it were wonderful, then the most wonderful place/state to be in is Hell!that does not say suffering is bad or evil, it says suffering is a consequence of sin, but i never denied that, i said it in my previous posts.
what comes from sin is not only more sin, if God brings good out of evil, and sin is the only true evil, then is not suffering the good brought out of it?
if you hit someone, the hit itself is not the sin, but the hateful intention to hurt is, and if you hit someone by accident, although it still hurts them, there is no sin or evil present.
suffering is a reaction to pain, and a result of sin having entered the world, but it is not in and of itself evil.
but i think the chapters from that book i quoted explain it well enough.
Obviously, the Christian God HATES suffering- So much so that he would go to unspeakable lengths to save us from it and to give us it’s direct opposite:- Unlimited, eternal bliss and happiness with him.
What Catholicism teaches rather is that God takes what is evil and uses it for good. Remember "evil"is not a subsistent thing in itself but a “lack” where there should be something per the natures that God created. Our suffering is an evil, because it represents the absence of perfect happiness and contentment where these should be. Rather, God takes what was intended for ill, and employs it in the accomplishment of his own purposes- Redemption is what it is. He redeems suffering. What was intended for the ill of man (the suffering that comes from sin) is redeemed by the Almighty, and transformed instead into a means of salvation to save us from that very sin and suffering! Sin is that evil self-love that is in unnatural competition with the love of God in us which itself should be the ultimate love of our whole being.
God is NOT the author of suffering- He made a world without it. What God does is to confound his enemies by taking the harm they’ve caused and using it to bring about the good that the enemy has attempted to thwart. Thus he humiliates the creature of pride even more and shows his unsurpassed greatness, as he is he who is able to bring about the good even from evil and to bring about his purposes without thwarting the free will of his creatures.