Is suffering good or bad?

Status
Not open for further replies.
that does not say suffering is bad or evil, it says suffering is a consequence of sin, but i never denied that, i said it in my previous posts.
what comes from sin is not only more sin, if God brings good out of evil, and sin is the only true evil, then is not suffering the good brought out of it?
if you hit someone, the hit itself is not the sin, but the hateful intention to hurt is, and if you hit someone by accident, although it still hurts them, there is no sin or evil present.
suffering is a reaction to pain, and a result of sin having entered the world, but it is not in and of itself evil.

but i think the chapters from that book i quoted explain it well enough.
If suffering were in itself good and not bad, or “neither good nor bad”, it would make total rubbish of our entire faith. If it were wonderful, then the most wonderful place/state to be in is Hell! :eek: Then the world that God made before the advent of sin could be said to have been truly deficient and Heaven is the least wonderful place/state to be in ever! Not to mention, the idea that God himself would take on human flesh and human sufferings and humiliate himself to “save” mankind from this suffering, would then become the most absurd, most foolish, most self-contradictory idea of all! :eek:

Obviously, the Christian God HATES suffering- So much so that he would go to unspeakable lengths to save us from it and to give us it’s direct opposite:- Unlimited, eternal bliss and happiness with him.

What Catholicism teaches rather is that God takes what is evil and uses it for good. Remember "evil"is not a subsistent thing in itself but a “lack” where there should be something per the natures that God created. Our suffering is an evil, because it represents the absence of perfect happiness and contentment where these should be. Rather, God takes what was intended for ill, and employs it in the accomplishment of his own purposes- Redemption is what it is. He redeems suffering. What was intended for the ill of man (the suffering that comes from sin) is redeemed by the Almighty, and transformed instead into a means of salvation to save us from that very sin and suffering! Sin is that evil self-love that is in unnatural competition with the love of God in us which itself should be the ultimate love of our whole being.

God is NOT the author of suffering- He made a world without it. What God does is to confound his enemies by taking the harm they’ve caused and using it to bring about the good that the enemy has attempted to thwart. Thus he humiliates the creature of pride even more and shows his unsurpassed greatness, as he is he who is able to bring about the good even from evil and to bring about his purposes without thwarting the free will of his creatures.
 
Basically, suffering is what each person makes of it. Suffering is suffering. It is not a pleasant experience. However, if we try and seek God’s hand while going through it and learn his plan while holding on to the fact he intends something positive to be gained through this - we can somehow muddle through it day by day. .

There are many evil people who simply delight in other’s suffering. Simply because they enjoy it. Thankfully, we have God. I went through a horrible period for two years. Near death and many other horrible things. At the time, I would have laughed at anyone if they told me I would be saying this, but I would go though it all again to ensure I never missed what I gained in the end.
 
There’s nothing pleasant about suffering. But good can come out of suffering. Christ showed us the way.
And he that taketh not up his cross, and followeth me, is not worthy of me. Matthew 10:38. . . Then Jesus said to his disciples: If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me. Matt. 16:24
img812.imageshack.us/img812/3834/picture10xp.png
 
One cannot be a disciple of Christ without suffering.
I would add one cannot be a human being, or any being, without suffering. BTW, does G-d suffer? I know Jesus suffered, but wasn’t that suffering manifested in the human form of Jesus? Still, G-d is described in terms of human emotions in the Scriptures, most probably so we can relate to Him. Is suffering part of our likeness to G-d since we were created in His image? Surely though, it can’t be the same kind of suffering as we experience, or can it?
 
I would add one cannot be a human being, or any being, without suffering. BTW, does G-d suffer? I know Jesus suffered, but wasn’t that suffering manifested in the human form of Jesus? Still, G-d is described in terms of human emotions in the Scriptures, most probably so we can relate to Him. Is suffering part of our likeness to G-d since we were created in His image? Surely though, it can’t be the same kind of suffering as we experience, or can it?
But suffering is lack- God lacks nothing. 🤷
 
But suffering is lack- God lacks nothing. 🤷
Very true. However, there is a (non-doctrinal) view in Judaism that G-d created the universe partially incomplete, so that humanity might complete it by means of its moral behavior. In this sense, G-d depends on mankind’s love transformed into action by improving the lot of others and alleviating their suffering. If we do not fulfill our obligation, G-d grieves.
 
He suffered because God allowed him to be tested, knowing Job had the faith to endure what would be brought upon him. Job’s love and faith is what allowed him to survive this horrible period. He knew God had a purpose. However, I don’t believe he was " happy " in these times.
i wasn’t saying it myself first of all, i quoted that from a book, which i pointed out in the beginning of my post,
but regarding the “happiness” they are speaking of, i think they are referring to his contentment “The Lord giveth, and the Lord takest away” contentment is, by definition, happiness, happiness is defined as "good fortune; pleasure; contentment; joy. " and contentment is defined as “assenting to or willing to accept circumstances”
If suffering were in itself good and not bad, or “neither good nor bad”, it would make total rubbish of our entire faith. If it were wonderful, then the most wonderful place/state to be in is Hell! :eek: Then the world that God made before the advent of sin could be said to have been truly deficient and Heaven is the least wonderful place/state to be in ever! Not to mention, the idea that God himself would take on human flesh and human sufferings and humiliate himself to “save” mankind from this suffering, would then become the most absurd, most foolish, most self-contradictory idea of all! :eek:
if what you say is true, can you provide some sources from church teaching to back it up?
suffering in and of itself is not a lack of something, it is a reaction to something, evil on the other hand is a lack of something, a lack of God.
i already quoted church teaching on the matter, from a church approved book that is very well known, you can check it out for yourself, i provided the link where it’s free to read online.
and no where does the church teach that God hates suffering, Jesus suffered greatly for us to redeem us from slavery to sin, not from suffering, instead He commanded us to suffer, to take up our cross daily, deny ourselves, and follow Him, He said if we do not take up our crosses then we are not His disciples.

what makes suffering useful is that it doesn’t feel good, our bodies detest it, and that’s the point! that is how God intended for us to gain control of our bodies, which rebelled against the soul after sin.

and i don’t know where you got the idea that i thought suffering was wonderful, i never said suffering was good because it feels good or is enjoyable, that would be absurd, i only said it was good insomuch as we have very much to benefit from it, it’s good by value, not by feeling, in the same way it’s good to discipline your children, but i already said that about 3 times, if you would like to go back and read what i actually said.

it’s natural to hate suffering, or dislike it, but God does not hate it, God hates sin, and suffering is not sin. i have never read anywhere that God hates suffering, or that suffering is evil.
even the saints sought out suffering, because they knew it’s great value and how much it pleased Jesus for them to suffer for love of Him, it was desirable because it is the most selfless means of proving our love to God…actually, i have a very nice article by Saint Alphonsus on that very subject here - z13.invisionfree.com/DominamStellaMaris/index.php?showtopic=5
that ought to explain alot more on it.

God is not responsible for suffering, we are responsible for it by sinning and meriting the consequences of sin, but suffering is still Gods justice and mercy, it is His justice as a punishment, and His mercy as a means of purifying us and mortifying us.
so as the justice of God, it is something to be feared, but as His mercy, it is a great gift…which is rarely recognized as such.

you say here - "Our suffering is an evil, because it represents the absence of perfect happiness and contentment where these should be. Rather, God takes what was intended for ill, and employs it in the accomplishment of his own purposes- Redemption is what it is. He redeems suffering. What was intended for the ill of man (the suffering that comes from sin) is redeemed by the Almighty, and transformed instead into a means of salvation to save us from that very sin and suffering! "

absolutely not true, i’ve heard such things from protestant teaching, but not from the Catholic church, Jesus did not redeem us from suffering in any way shape or form, quite the contrary, as i already said, He calls us to suffer, sin is the only true evil, and suffering is not a sin, if it were, then it would be a sin to suffer, and Jesus would have had no part of it…our understanding of suffering has become much better since the Passion of Christ, but it’s intended purpose has not changed.
instead the Church teaches this(from the CCC) -
*122. What are the results of the sacrifice of Christ on the cross?

613-617
622-623

Jesus freely offered his life as an expiatory sacrifice, that is, he made reparation for our sins with the full obedience of his love unto death. This love “to the end” (John 13:1) of the Son of God reconciled all of humanity with the Father. The paschal sacrifice of Christ, therefore, redeems humanity in a way that is unique, perfect, and definitive; and it opens up for them communion with God.

123. Why does Jesus call upon his disciples to take up their cross?

618

By calling his disciples to take up their cross and follow him Jesus desires to associate with his redeeming sacrifice those who are to be its first beneficiaries.*

so, if you can, show me where the church teaches that suffering is evil and that Jesus redeemed us from it.
 
i wasn’t saying it myself first of all, i quoted that from a book, which i pointed out in the beginning of my post,
but regarding the “happiness” they are speaking of, i think they are referring to his contentment “The Lord giveth, and the Lord takest away” contentment is, by definition, happiness, happiness is defined as "good fortune; pleasure; contentment; joy. " and contentment is defined as “assenting to or willing to accept circumstances”

if what you say is true, can you provide some sources from church teaching to back it up?
suffering in and of itself is not a lack of something, it is a reaction to something, evil on the other hand is a lack of something, a lack of God.
i already quoted church teaching on the matter, from a church approved book that is very well known, you can check it out for yourself, i provided the link where it’s free to read online.
and no where does the church teach that God hates suffering, Jesus suffered greatly for us to redeem us from slavery to sin, not from suffering, instead He commanded us to suffer, to take up our cross daily, deny ourselves, and follow Him, He said if we do not take up our crosses then we are not His disciples.

what makes suffering useful is that it doesn’t feel good, our bodies detest it, and that’s the point! that is how God intended for us to gain control of our bodies, which rebelled against the soul after sin.

and i don’t know where you got the idea that i thought suffering was wonderful, i never said suffering was good because it feels good or is enjoyable, that would be absurd, i only said it was good insomuch as we have very much to benefit from it, it’s good by value, not by feeling, in the same way it’s good to discipline your children, but i already said that about 3 times, if you would like to go back and read what i actually said.

it’s natural to hate suffering, or dislike it, but God does not hate it, God hates sin, and suffering is not sin. i have never read anywhere that God hates suffering, or that suffering is evil.
even the saints sought out suffering, because they knew it’s great value and how much it pleased Jesus for them to suffer for love of Him, it was desirable because it is the most selfless means of proving our love to God…actually, i have a very nice article by Saint Alphonsus on that very subject here - z13.invisionfree.com/DominamStellaMaris/index.php?showtopic=5
that ought to explain alot more on it.

God is not responsible for suffering, we are responsible for it by sinning and meriting the consequences of sin, but suffering is still Gods justice and mercy, it is His justice as a punishment, and His mercy as a means of purifying us and mortifying us.
so as the justice of God, it is something to be feared, but as His mercy, it is a great gift…which is rarely recognized as such.

you say here - "Our suffering is an evil, because it represents the absence of perfect happiness and contentment where these should be. Rather, God takes what was intended for ill, and employs it in the accomplishment of his own purposes- Redemption is what it is. He redeems suffering. What was intended for the ill of man (the suffering that comes from sin) is redeemed by the Almighty, and transformed instead into a means of salvation to save us from that very sin and suffering! "

absolutely not true, i’ve heard such things from protestant teaching, but not from the Catholic church, Jesus did not redeem us from suffering in any way shape or form, quite the contrary, as i already said, He calls us to suffer, sin is the only true evil, and suffering is not a sin, if it were, then it would be a sin to suffer, and Jesus would have had no part of it…our understanding of suffering has become much better since the Passion of Christ, but it’s intended purpose has not changed.
instead the Church teaches this(from the CCC) -
122. What are the results of the sacrifice of Christ on the cross?

613-617
622-623

Jesus freely offered his life as an expiatory sacrifice, that is, he made reparation for our sins with the full obedience of his love unto death. This love “to the end” (John 13:1) of the Son of God reconciled all of humanity with the Father. The paschal sacrifice of Christ, therefore, redeems humanity in a way that is unique, perfect, and definitive; and it opens up for them communion with God.

123. Why does Jesus call upon his disciples to take up their cross?

618

By calling his disciples to take up their cross and follow him Jesus desires to associate with his redeeming sacrifice those who are to be its first beneficiaries.

so, if you can, show me where the church teaches that suffering is evil and that Jesus redeemed us from it.
Interesting argument. You state suffering represents both G-d’s justice and mercy. The mercy aspect I understand, but the justice part sounds as if G-d doles out suffering as a direct punishment for sin. However, we all know that both morally virtuous and evil people suffer on this Earth, including children. How then is suffering a punishment for sin, unless you are referring to original sin?
 
I would add one cannot be a human being, or any being, without suffering.
Suffering is part of the human condition and is the consequence of Original Sin, and much of the suffering in the world is the direct result of man’s pride, cruelty, injustice, selfishness, greed, indifference, lust, gluttony, avarice, hatred, revenge–a complete misuse of the gifts of Intellect and Will. When we say that God made us in His Image and Likeness, it means that we were given an intellect for Truth, and a will for Goodness and Love. But since Man has made a mess of the world, suffering is the penalty for sin. The good news is that God offers a *salvation *from all this mess. This salvation comes to us through Jesus Christ, but the price is the cross.

Though the world will tell you otherwise, pain and suffering heals the soul, when the soul uses the suffering for sanctification. The world teaches us that we must run from the cross, but Salvation comes through the cross. Suffering and pain repairs the damage caused by sin, when united in spirit to the sufferings of Christ. Then it becomes redemptive for ourselves and for the world. A Christian who understands the mystery of the cross knows that when suffering touches their life it has a value of reparation for the sins of the world when it is carried patiently in union with the sufferings of Christ. The ministry of every follower of Christ very begins within their unique circumstances in life among the circle of people and individuals with whom they happen to interact with.

One must understand that Eternity does not begin at death; our eternal journey began at our conception, and everything we do in our life has eternal ramifications. Those who follow Christ have found the path to Eternal Life. And for a follower of Christ, suffering become redemptive when it is united to Christ’s sacrifice on the cross. Let us be clear. Christianity is not easy. It’s not easy to love enemies and to pray for those who persecute. At the heart of Christianity is a total transformation of the heart, and that is attained through the cross with the help of God’s sanctifying grace.** There is a very narrow gate into heaven, but it is very thorny, bloody and very painful. Christianity is not easy. The only way into heaven is through the cross.**

It is not easy to be a friend of Christ when it’s time to be crucified. There are plenty of people who want Christ, but few who want to be crucified with Him. Bearing the cross and being crucified with Christ means to die to our pride–we must die to our self-love. Most of us will not die perfected on earth, thus if we die in God’s grace will have to go through the painful but purifying fires of Purgatory.
 
Interesting argument. You state suffering represents both G-d’s justice and mercy. The mercy aspect I understand, but the justice part sounds as if G-d doles out suffering as a direct punishment for sin. However, we all know that both morally virtuous and evil people suffer on this Earth, including children. How then is suffering a punishment for sin, unless you are referring to original sin?
it is a punishment for sin both directly and indirectly, we all suffer because of sin, but not always our own, the Blessed Mother, for example, never committed a sin and was conceived without original sin, and yet was also called to suffer, and she suffered very greatly.
sin brought suffering into the world, and still causes suffering every time it is committed,
so even though a child may not have yet sinned, they are still effected by the consequences of sin,
but yes, we are also punished for original sin, insomuch as, by it we are deprived of sanctifying grace, without which we cannot attain heaven,
and then also we can be punished for others sins, but in that case the punishment is medicinal…but to better understand all that, i would recommend reading this - newadvent.org/summa/2087.htm
that explains it all far better than i can.
 
i wasn’t saying it myself first of all, i quoted that from a book, which i pointed out in the beginning of my post,
but regarding the “happiness” they are speaking of, i think they are referring to his contentment “The Lord giveth, and the Lord takest away” contentment is, by definition, happiness, happiness is defined as "good fortune; pleasure; contentment; joy. " and contentment is defined as “assenting to or willing to accept circumstances”

if what you say is true, can you provide some sources from church teaching to back it up?
suffering in and of itself is not a lack of something, it is a reaction to something, evil on the other hand is a lack of something, a lack of God.
i already quoted church teaching on the matter, from a church approved book that is very well known, you can check it out for yourself, i provided the link where it’s free to read online.
and no where does the church teach that God hates suffering, Jesus suffered greatly for us to redeem us from slavery to sin, not from suffering, instead He commanded us to suffer, to take up our cross daily, deny ourselves, and follow Him, He said if we do not take up our crosses then we are not His disciples.

what makes suffering useful is that it doesn’t feel good, our bodies detest it, and that’s the point! that is how God intended for us to gain control of our bodies, which rebelled against the soul after sin.

and i don’t know where you got the idea that i thought suffering was wonderful, i never said suffering was good because it feels good or is enjoyable, that would be absurd, i only said it was good insomuch as we have very much to benefit from it, it’s good by value, not by feeling, in the same way it’s good to discipline your children, but i already said that about 3 times, if you would like to go back and read what i actually said.

it’s natural to hate suffering, or dislike it, but God does not hate it, God hates sin, and suffering is not sin. i have never read anywhere that God hates suffering, or that suffering is evil.
even the saints sought out suffering, because they knew it’s great value and how much it pleased Jesus for them to suffer for love of Him, it was desirable because it is the most selfless means of proving our love to God…actually, i have a very nice article by Saint Alphonsus on that very subject here - z13.invisionfree.com/DominamStellaMaris/index.php?showtopic=5
that ought to explain alot more on it.

God is not responsible for suffering, we are responsible for it by sinning and meriting the consequences of sin, but suffering is still Gods justice and mercy, it is His justice as a punishment, and His mercy as a means of purifying us and mortifying us.
so as the justice of God, it is something to be feared, but as His mercy, it is a great gift…which is rarely recognized as such.

you say here - "Our suffering is an evil, because it represents the absence of perfect happiness and contentment where these should be. Rather, God takes what was intended for ill, and employs it in the accomplishment of his own purposes- Redemption is what it is. He redeems suffering. What was intended for the ill of man (the suffering that comes from sin) is redeemed by the Almighty, and transformed instead into a means of salvation to save us from that very sin and suffering! "

absolutely not true, i’ve heard such things from protestant teaching, but not from the Catholic church, Jesus did not redeem us from suffering in any way shape or form, quite the contrary, as i already said, He calls us to suffer, sin is the only true evil, and suffering is not a sin, if it were, then it would be a sin to suffer, and Jesus would have had no part of it…our understanding of suffering has become much better since the Passion of Christ, but it’s intended purpose has not changed.
instead the Church teaches this(from the CCC) -
122. What are the results of the sacrifice of Christ on the cross?

613-617
622-623

Jesus freely offered his life as an expiatory sacrifice, that is, he made reparation for our sins with the full obedience of his love unto death. This love “to the end” (John 13:1) of the Son of God reconciled all of humanity with the Father. The paschal sacrifice of Christ, therefore, redeems humanity in a way that is unique, perfect, and definitive; and it opens up for them communion with God.

123. Why does Jesus call upon his disciples to take up their cross?

618

By calling his disciples to take up their cross and follow him Jesus desires to associate with his redeeming sacrifice those who are to be its first beneficiaries.

so, if you can, show me where the church teaches that suffering is evil and that Jesus redeemed us from it.
The most suffering is in hell- God died to keep us from it, I don’t see how it’s difficult to see that God must hate the suffering of his creatures, it’s the logical conclusion of his saving actions. Do you think God liked the suffering of Adam and Eve after they went out from the garden? Did he like the suffering of the Israelites when they were in bondage in Egypt and exile? Then why did he save them from it? Of course God hates suffering- That’s the story of your whole Bible- God always comes to the rescue of his creatures from the suffering they’ve caused themselves. Like I said, it’s the logical conclusion that must be drawn from his continuous saving actions.

I also don’t see what the church documents you provided say against what I said at all. I already stated that suffering is an evil that God redeemed and made good/useful for us. Those documents just talk about the goodness and usefulness of the suffering that God is using to save us 🤷 That’s already talk about redeemed suffering, not suffering perse.
 
BTW, does G-d suffer? I know Jesus suffered, but wasn’t that suffering manifested in the human form of Jesus? Still, G-d is described in terms of human emotions in the Scriptures, most probably so we can relate to Him. Is suffering part of our likeness to G-d since we were created in His image? Surely though, it can’t be the same kind of suffering as we experience, or can it?
God does suffer in His People The Church. The People of God make up *the Mystical Body of Christ *. The Church is composed of its members in Heaven, in Purgatory and on Earth. The people in Heaven are known as *The Church Triumphant * which have been perfected; the people being purified in Purgatory are known as The Church Suffering. The people living on earth incorporated into the Body of Christ through baptism are The Church MilitantAnd falling on the ground, he heard a voice saying to him: Saul, Saul, why persecutest thou me? Who said: Who art thou, Lord? And he: I am Jesus whom thou persecutest. Acts 9:4-5

Paul speaks about Christ being the Head of the Church, while The Church are the Members of the Body of Christ.

And he is the head of the body, the church…Col. 1:18 …And if one member suffer any thing, all the members suffer with it; or if one member glory, all the members rejoice with it. [27] Now you are the body of Christ, and members of member. [28] And God indeed hath set some in the church; first apostles, secondly prophets, thirdly…" 1 Cor. 12:24-27
 
The most suffering is in hell- God died to keep us from it, I don’t see how it’s difficult to see that God must hate the suffering of his creatures, it’s the logical conclusion of his saving actions. Do you think God liked the suffering of Adam and Eve after they went out from the garden? Did he like the suffering of the Israelites when they were in bondage in Egypt and exile? Then why did he save them from it? Of course God hates suffering- That’s the story of your whole Bible- God always comes to the rescue of his creatures from the suffering they’ve caused themselves. Like I said, it’s the logical conclusion that must be drawn from his continuous saving actions.

I also don’t see what the church documents you provided say against what I said at all. I already stated that suffering is an evil that God redeemed and made good/useful for us. Those documents just talk about the goodness and usefulness of the suffering that God is using to save us 🤷 That’s already talk about redeemed suffering, not suffering perse.
God hates sin, not suffering, but he doesn’t “like” suffering either, it’s not about hating or liking it, it’s a tool and not evil in and of itself, if you stab someone with a knife, is the knife evil? of course not, the knife is not a sin but the intention to kill is.
no one has been saved from suffering on earth, not even Gods own Son and mother, and He did not come to save us from suffering but from slavery to sin,
the article i posted says that suffering is not evil, that’s the whole point of what i was trying to get across, i will re-quote what i am referring to -
“God, Who loves us tenderly, has no other object in sending us
sufferings but to make us happy. What we count as an evil is the
bitterness of the medicine that is necessary for the health of our
soul. There is really no evil in the world except sin. Sufferings can
never really make us unhappy; men can be happy in spite of all
kinds of sufferings. We see this in Job, in Tobias, in Our Lady.
St. Paul says, " I am filled with comfort ; I exceedingly abound with
joy in all our tribulation” (2 Cor. vii. 4). "

God does inflict sufferings on His creatures, and it is not bad, the punishment is not what’s bad but the actions deserving of punishment are, and hell is bad not because of the sufferings, but because of the separation from God, God hates sin because it separates us from Him, and He uses suffering to draw us closer to Him, it has been that way since suffering began, it’s purpose was always about mercy, though also justice, but both Gods justice and mercy are for our good,
in heaven there will be no need for suffering because man will finally be freed from His rebellious body which “wars against the soul” and at the end of time we will get our bodies back, glorified, and as they were meant to be…so the reason there is suffering on earth, in hell, and in purgatory, is because it has purpose in those places, but it has no purpose in heaven.
so what i’m saying is, suffering is not evil, only sin is evil.

i have never read anywhere that God hates suffering, or that it is evil, and you speak of it as if it is common sense, but then if that is true, there must be teachings on it, can you just show me one church teaching to support your claim? or tell me where you learned it?
 
God hates sin, not suffering, but he doesn’t “like” suffering either, it’s not about hating or liking it, it’s a tool and not evil in and of itself, if you stab someone with a knife, is the knife evil? of course not, the knife is not a sin but the intention to kill is.
no one has been saved from suffering on earth, not even Gods own Son and mother, and He did not come to save us from suffering but from slavery to sin,
Saving us from slavery to sin is also saving us from suffering, since sin is the sole cause of suffering. Any suffering anywhere is evidence of the existence of evil.
the article i posted says that suffering is not evil, that’s the whole point of what i was trying to get across, i will re-quote what i am referring to -
"God, Who loves us tenderly, has no other object in sending us
sufferings but to make us happy. What we count as an evil is the
bitterness of the medicine that is necessary for the health of our
soul. There is really no evil in the world except sin
.
If we look at Job, the Devil petitioned for suffering for Job. So can we truly say that God sent the suffering to make Job happy? Some of the contradiction in why sin is necessary will not be resolved until the end of the world, as God told St. Julian of Norwich.
Sufferings can
never really make us unhappy; men can be happy in spite of all
kinds of sufferings.
See an Interview with an Exorcist by Fr. Amorth (Vatican’s chief exorcist), despair and suicidal ideation = which we would define as unhappiness, are also sometimes out of our control and some of the worst sorts of suffering. St. Faustina also suffered some of these temptations. So sufferings can make us unhappy.
It can be said that man suffers whenever he experiences any kind of evil. In the vocabulary of the Old Testament, suffering and evil are identified with each other. In fact, that vocabulary did not have a specific word to indicate “suffering”. Thus it defined as " evil" everything that was suffering(22). Only the Greek language, and together with it the New Testament (and the Greek translations of the Old Testament), use the verb * = “I am affected by … I experience a feeling, I suffer”; and, thanks to this verb, suffering is no longer directly identifiable with (objective) evil, but expresses a situation in which man experiences evil and in doing so becomes the subject of suffering. Suffering has indeed both a subjective and a passive character (from “patior”). Even when man brings suffering on himself, when he is its cause, this suffering remains something passive in its metaphysical essence.
Thus the reality of suffering prompts the question about the essence of evil: what is evil?
This questions seems, in a certain sense, inseparable from the theme of suffering. The Christian response to it is different, for example, from the one given by certain cultural and religious traditions which hold that existence is an evil from which one needs to be liberated. Christianity proclaims the essential good of existence and the good of that which exists, acknowledges the goodness of the Creator and proclaims the good of creatures. Man suffers on account of evil, which is a certain lack, limitation or distortion of good. We could say that man suffers because of a good in which he does not share, from which in a certain sense he is cut off, or of which he has deprived himself. He particularly suffers when he a ought"—in the normal order of things—to have a share in this good and does not have it. .
The above is from Pope John Paul II, on the Human Meaning of Suffering, vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/apost_letters/documents/hf_jp-ii_apl_11021984_salvifici-doloris_en.html
i have never read anywhere that God hates suffering, or that it is evil, and you speak of it as if it is common sense, but then if that is true, there must be teachings on it, can you just show me one church teaching to support your claim? or tell me where you learned it?
Common sense is also important. Many things that the Church Fathers once taught are no longer believed, i.e. the necessity of slavery. However, none of those things taught that were declared infalliable have changed. Mother Teresa’s order, the Missionaries of Charity was criticized for its perspective on the theology of suffering and its decision to do things such as reuse old needles even though that is medically unsafe. After that criticism, her order stopped that practice. It was a common sense criticism that reached her through the world, not the Catholic Church. But the Catholic Church teaches that natural law is written on the hearts of every single person in this world.
 
Saving us from slavery to sin is also saving us from suffering, since sin is the sole cause of suffering. Any suffering anywhere is evidence of the existence of evil.

If we look at Job, the Devil petitioned for suffering for Job. So can we truly say that God sent the suffering to make Job happy? Some of the contradiction in why sin is necessary will not be resolved until the end of the world, as God told St. Julian of Norwich.

See an Interview with an Exorcist by Fr. Amorth (Vatican’s chief exorcist), despair and suicidal ideation = which we would define as unhappiness, are also sometimes out of our control and some of the worst sorts of suffering. St. Faustina also suffered some of these temptations. So sufferings can make us unhappy.

The above is from Pope John Paul II, on the Human Meaning of Suffering, vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/apost_letters/documents/hf_jp-ii_apl_11021984_salvifici-doloris_en.html

Common sense is also important. Many things that the Church Fathers once taught are no longer believed, i.e. the necessity of slavery. However, none of those things taught that were declared infalliable have changed. Mother Teresa’s order, the Missionaries of Charity was criticized for its perspective on the theology of suffering and its decision to do things such as reuse old needles even though that is medically unsafe. After that criticism, her order stopped that practice. It was a common sense criticism that reached her through the world, not the Catholic Church. But the Catholic Church teaches that natural law is written on the hearts of every single person in this world.
i am not saying that God wants us to suffer, i am aware that God does not like to see us suffer, my only point is that suffering in and of itself is not evil, and we can be happy despite our sufferings, and i am also aware, as i have said, that we also suffer by our own fault or by fault of others which is not from God,
and how suffering can make us happy, which is it’s intended purpose, is not by the suffering itself, but by where the suffering takes us, as i said, suffering draws us closer to God, and with Job, it wasn’t the suffering that made him happy, that part made him miserable, but despite his misery, it drew him closer to God, and he was content, which as i said already, contentment, by definition, is happiness, though you may not feel it as a joy.

but saving us from slavery to sin is not saving us from suffering, as i said, the Blessed Mother was perfectly sinless, and yet suffered, and many saints reached a degree of sinlessness, by the special grace of God, and yet still suffered, no one on earth can escape suffering, it is the consequence of sin, the means of sanctifying ourselves, the means of proving our love to God, the means of doing penance for sin, and of mortifying our senses, it has many purposes, but as i said, it only has purpose on earth, in hell, and in purgatory, but in heaven it has no purpose, because in heaven we will be as we were meant to be.
and i am not speaking of any particular circumstance of suffering, i am merely speaking of suffering in and of itself, there are many different degrees and circumstances and causes of suffering, but that’s entirely besides the point, the only point i’m making is that suffering is not evil, the church teaches that sin alone is evil, which i provided information on already.
 
+JMJ+
i am not saying that God wants us to suffer, i am aware that God does not like to see us suffer, my only point is that suffering in and of itself is not evil, and we can be happy despite our sufferings, and i am also aware, as i have said, that we also suffer by our own fault or by fault of others which is not from God,
and how suffering can make us happy, which is it’s intended purpose, is not by the suffering itself, but by where the suffering takes us, as i said, suffering draws us closer to God, and with Job, it wasn’t the suffering that made him happy, that part made him miserable, but despite his misery, it drew him closer to God, and he was content, which as i said already, contentment, by definition, is happiness, though you may not feel it as a joy.

but saving us from slavery to sin is not saving us from suffering, as i said, the Blessed Mother was perfectly sinless, and yet suffered, and many saints reached a degree of sinlessness, by the special grace of God, and yet still suffered, no one on earth can escape suffering, it is the consequence of sin, the means of sanctifying ourselves, the means of proving our love to God, the means of doing penance for sin, and of mortifying our senses, it has many purposes, but as i said, it only has purpose on earth, in hell, and in purgatory, but in heaven it has no purpose, because in heaven we will be as we were meant to be.
and i am not speaking of any particular circumstance of suffering, i am merely speaking of suffering in and of itself, there are many different degrees and circumstances and causes of suffering, but that’s entirely besides the point, the only point i’m making is that suffering is not evil, the church teaches that sin alone is evil, which i provided information on already.
I just have one thing to point out: If, as you say, “God does not like to see us suffer”, and we are called to relieve the suffering of others, then how can suffering not be evil in itself?

And I think you should read this: , Pope tells hospital patientsevil of suffering
 
+JMJ+

I just have one thing to point out: If, as you say, “God does not like to see us suffer”, and we are called to relieve the suffering of others, then how can suffering not be evil in itself?

And I think you should read this: Only Christ can transform evil of suffering, Pope tells hospital patients
i read the article, and i agree with it, but it says nothing about suffering being evil, the title does, but who wrote the title? the article does not say suffering is evil, but only "because none of us is capable of eliminating the power of evil, which … is a constant source of suffering.”

God doesn’t like to see us suffer, that doesn’t mean he hates suffering itself, that is, suffering for what it is in itself, a tool used for our good,
it is the same way, as i’ve said, a parent does not like to discipline their child, but they don’t hate discipline itself.
suffering is a reaction to pain, and that reaction itself is not evil, we are told sin alone is evil, but who could say suffering is a sin? and God cannot cooperate with what is evil, but He does inflict sufferings on us, for example, those who suffered the stigmata, that was not something merely “aloud”, since it is purely supernatural, it is something given by God as a great gift.

but why we are called to relieve the sufferings of others i already explained in my first post, i will quote -
“it is good to suffer, but that is personal, we should not cause suffering to others, unless it is someone under us, such as children who must be disciplined, and we should alleviate the sufferings of others because often times, while God allows suffering for our benefit, He also allows it in others as a chance for us to show charity to others, and be an example to them of followers of Christ, and also as a chance to do good to Jesus, who tells us that what we do to others, good or bad, by action or neglect, we also do to Him,”
while God does not like to see us suffer, He does allow and inflict it for our good, since true love does what is best for the one loved, and not merely what is desired,
God is our Father, and has the right to discipline more than anyone else, but as any parent knows, you can only hope that your child learns from the discipline you give, you can’t force them to be good by it.

it is good to relieve the sick and suffering because, all the same, God wants us to have relief and comfort, He doesn’t want us to suffer for sufferings sake(He doesn’t *want *us to suffer at all), but He desires our good and so allows it, and then as we know “Whatsoever you do to the least of these my brethren, you do to me.”
 
God doesn’t like to see us suffer, that doesn’t mean he hates suffering itself
But why would he dislike what is not bad? The disliking by God itself says that what is disliked must be a bad thing, because God knows all things and his disliking something must mean that thing is a bad thing.

Also, sin is not the only “evil”- it’s moral evil, but all types of disorder in God’s creation represents an evil as it deviates from God’s plan- wherever there is lack where something was meant to be per God’s plan- that is an evil…
 
We feed infants pablem.
We feed children good food.
We feed adults about anything.

We learn basic math first.
We learn algebra and geometry next.
We learn trig last.

We learn to love and know God as children.
We learn to love and Know God as minor adults.
We learn to love and know God as adults.
We learn to love and know God as seniors, which includes suffering.

One exception, the mystics learned about suffering as a jewel early.
For the real understanding of suffering, we must turn to them.
And even then the repulsiveness of this is too much for some to understand.

Just an unprofound thought.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top