Is this a Sin? Smoking

  • Thread starter Thread starter CHAZER2222
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks for coming on and asking the question.
I find there are a lot of people who come on Catholic Answers with some kind of question that asks how close can I go to the edge without falling off.

As Catholics, we should stand out from the crowd for our purity, our kindness, our love, our self giving. Be the light of Christ in your friends. Be the example of saying No, and offer up any kidding you take to Christ who was reviled and rejected by men. This is what we are called to do. You might say “I’m not addicted, no problem for me” but you don’t know within your circle of friends who will become addicted. Show them how to say No under peer pressure. I can’t do that. You can. This is how an ordinary guy like yourself becomes extraordinary.

God give you wisdom today!
 
im not addicted, more social, i just want to know if what im doing is sinful.
No one plans or expects to get addicted, it happens. It’s the bodies natural response to some drugs, and nicotine is extremely addictive. I am in substance abuse recovery and have friends who tell me stoping smoking was harder than quitting cocain, meth, crack, etc.

Do yourself, your friends (set an example) and your future flock (also set an example) and save yourself tens of thousands of pounds and quit smoking now.
 
We shouldn’t encourage a minor to go against the wishes of his parents.

-Fr ACEGC
 
I’m going to be honest and blunt. I know you said you’re going to be a priest, but as a woman, to me, the top two criteria I have on my list for a potential husband are Catholic, and non-smoker. I frankly despise the habit. I hate the smell, it disgusts me, and I try to avoid hanging around people who do. If I was in line for confession and knew you were in the booth, I’d try to go to another priest if possible, because your smell would be that off-putting. It may be a flaw of mine, but I instantly think less of anyone, man or woman, who smokes. I’m not sure that I would date even a former smoker. It is irrational in the extreme to me, I never knew my grandpa because of that habit, and it’s driving my uncle to an early grave. You’re young and think you’re above it. I would care to say you’re not. It’s designed to get you hooked and you’re in a crowd who will not help you stop. That’s not accidental, it’s easier to get and stay hooked when you’re surrounded by others who do the same thing. On top of that, it’s illegal, and we Catholics are obligated to obey laws that do not conflict with Catholic morality and our parents.

Please, stop now, and save yourself the trouble down the line.
 
Last edited:
Imagine that money for cigarettes can go toward the purchase of a car in a few years. Have a positive goal in mind and if a friend hassles you, let them know they might as well roll up money and smoke it but a car would be way more awesome. Give them a goal too. This is a useful strategy when you are talking to people who are not Catholic or religious at all. Steering them toward a good direction would be pleasing to God. And smart like the dickens.
 
I think it’s because of people like you that I continue to smoke. That and I just enjoy it. I’ll go days without smoking and don’t find it difficult.

For the OP: it’s one thing to enjoy once in a while but when you find you’re getting to 10, 20, or even 40 a day, you’re certainly overdoing it. It’s not hard to do, unfortunately.
 
Last edited:
When your relatives can’t walk for five minutes without needing to catch their breaths due to COPD and you’re raised with multiple stories of people dying agonizing deaths due to lung cancer, you won’t have such a great opinion on it.
 
There are far more factors to take into consideration than they just happened to smoke. Most of my family members who smoked (actually, I think they all did) lived longer than I probably want to.
 
Last edited:
Recall that the heart of the law is found in the two greatest commandments.

Love God with your full heart, mind, soul, and strength
Love your neighbor as yourself.

Notice is AS yourself so that’s a command to love yourself as well.

So Honor your Father and Mother. How? By loving them? Is love mere servile obedience? No, that would make us willing to obey to an unreasonable degree. Rather properly discerning this means looking at what fosters a healthy loving and respectful relationship with your parents. How does your disobedience effect them? Does it needlessly make them worry? Does it foster an attitude in you that makes you more prone to disrespect on larger issues? And then loving yourself? Is it taking care of the body God has given you to smoke? In that regard, it’s similar to gluttony. We have a duty to try to eat healthy and exercise. We do fail at this a lot. Then there is the question of whether this particular sin is the sin you should be focusing on today? You do have to prioritize your vices as you grow in holiness. The alternative is to be a prideful fool who takes too much fault in some cases, and not enough in others. This leads others to say “You’re too hard on yourself” AND “You really need to eat your pride and apoligise some.” When the sins he is blind to are pointed out, he becomes defensive, thinking of the times he was overly hard on himself as evidence of his great humility.
 
Regardless of the law in your country, you’re disobeying your mother who doesn’t want you to smoke.

Smoking is addictive and can lead to diseases like cancer. Cancer leads to death. Do you really want your mother to have to bury you because you couldn’t man up and tell your mates no to the ciggies?
 
1 Cor:6 19
Doesn’t anybody here know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit…if you want to defile it then go ahead and smoke
 
Re your saying that the smell is disgusting to you… about a year after I quit smoking, I sat down next to a smoker in the church and immediately thought to myself, “Oh my Lord, did I smell like that?” What an embarrassing realization. Smokers really don’t know how bad they smell because they’re so used to it. It is disgusting.
 
Last edited:
Blessings
Your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit. We are to take care of it and keep it pure. Smoking slowly kills you. My husband is on oxygen and can’t get off it. He gasps for breath and turns blue. Not good! I’m overweight! Not good! Believe me, not good. That’s a sin!
Being immodest and not protecting certain parts of our bodies is a sin. Alcohol & illegal drugs is a sin. Disobeying parents is a sin. And sex outside of marriage is a sin.
Friends, what to do w aimless lingering around w friends=DONT AIMLESSLY HANG AROUND! Live and have fun. Go to your houses & watch Tv. Make a picnic in back yard. Watch good movies in a DVR. Don’t watch sexual movies. Action movies. Christian movies.
You know, this is a weird idea but could be fun. Talk to Mom, etc. Get a watch old movie group going. Take turns in each houses. Black & white horror movies! Bella Lagosi, DRACULA. Lon Chaney =WEREWOLVES. Vincent Price did colored movies of Edgar Allen Poe! Old Christian movies. THE TEN COMMANDMENTS, BEN HUR, the Cross (B&W) Claudette Colbert. THE FREATEST STORY EVER TOLD. JESUS OF NAZARETH w Robert Patterson playing Jesus. Great movie. I kid you not you’ll love them. Like a book reading club. Movies on Amazon. I don’t know prices in UK.
It’s better than lingering. Help each other clean houses to help our parents. Violunteer w RED CROSS. I can’t recall what that is in UK.
I know you started out w smoking but you are at that age where trouble finds you. Keep your school grades up.
JEREMIAH 29/11. I have a plan for you! It is a good plan w/o Evil. It has a future & a purpose…
Why were you born? What is your job in this life?
In Christ’s love
Tweedlealice
 
Don’t smoke, it ain’t good for ya. That being said it is not sinful, since nothing made by God is in and of itself immoral to consume, (1 Corinthians 10:25-26)
 
Last edited:
Don’t do it. You are harming yourself. Doing what your friends do is not a good reason to do it, copying other people is pretty boring, be your own person, smoking smells and is disgusting even vaping. You should honour your parents (that is a commandment which you are breaking if you know they would not want you to do it and you are anyway). The law of the country makes no difference, God’s law is above that. That guilt you feel, that is God in your heart telling you not to do it. Listen to him (commandment no 1). Sorry to sound so harsh, but rather give it up now than when you can’t. Also as I said you are harming yourself, a temple of the Holy Spirit and a tabernacle of Jesus. You should really try to keep yourself free from harm and sin for the reason of the fact that the Holy Spirit dwells in you and that Jesus lives in you too assuming you receive the body of Jesus. God bless you.
 
What about weed?, EDIT: Ah yeah for medical.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top