Israel Launches Operation Pillar of Defense against Gaza

  • Thread starter Thread starter pepipop
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
From the live blog on the Al Jazeera English website:

Perhaps hope for a ceasefire?
Let’s hope for the sake of Israel and the Palestinian-Arab people. While I support Israel just going into Gaza, capitulating it and giving moderate Palestinians a pathway to Israeli citizenship. Having a ground-war is just going to give the anti-Semetic crowd more fodder to bash Israel as some “imperialist” and with US being cold to Israel, the UN certainly would make advances to disenfranchise it.

Let’s hope a ceasefire can be arranged.
 
**Nadim Baba: Ask Me Anything on Gaza **
Do you have questions about the assault on Gaza?
Then log onto reddit.com to join the chat with Al Jazeera’s Nadim Baba, who is reporting live from Gaza City.
He will be online today, November 18, starting at 19:00 GMT on Reddit’s “IAmA” page - Ask Me Anything. After the thread goes up, check back here for the link.
aljazeera.com/news/middleeast/2012/11/2012111814125925547.html

I believe that time will be 2 pm, EST or 2 pm in New York City…so coming up soon.
 
Never liked Anonymous, always knew it was a Extreme Left-wing anti-Semetic, Fascist terror-group.

I have no respect for a group that bemoans freedom, all the while restricts it for others whom it disagrees with.
i agree. kind of a stupid name they call themselves. they aren’t very original.
 
The Al Jazeera reporter, Nadim Baba , is finally answering questions

Here is one:

Q: Could you describe the atmosphere in Gaza? What are people’s fears and do they expect to be attacked on ground? How strong is the trust in Hamas and other groups, do people still trust in them?

A: –]NadimBabaAJE 7 points 7 minutes ago

The atmosphere is very tense. The streets are usually busy with traffic pretty much all the time- now they are very very quiet (that goes for the sound of street vendors too). In many parts of Gaza people have found it impossible to sleep because of the huge blasts (airstrikes) and families are sleeping together in one room. Palestinian families in Gaza tend to have many children. The young ones don’t understand the bombardment but some have memories of the 2008-2009 Israeli “Operation Cast Lead” which traumatised many children in Gaza. So, with all the talk of Israel calling up reservists and so on some people are truly worried about what will happen. Not all expect a ground attack, some say it’s too big a gamble for Israel’s army. Anyway, support for Hamas is hard to truly measure but since the assassination of Ahmed Jabari I think Hamas has gained kudos among the armed factions for taking immediate action, launching rockets towards Israel etc. It had been under increasing criticism for its internal performance, and this episode of violence has allowed it to appear strong and take the reigns of the “resistance”.
 
Some additional questions posed to the Al Jazeera reporter in Gaza

Q: How does the Gaza population react to IDF messages and warnings with regards to staying away from Hamas? Is it even possible? We hear reports of Hamas using civilians as “human shields” - are these accurate to any extent?

–]NadimBabaAJE 13 points 8 minutes ago

A: I think the population is sceptical about any such warnings. It is very hard not to be “near Hamas”. Hamas is the government. It runs the social services, the police, the schools, the refuse collection, etc., etc… So staying away from Hamas does not mean much. Having said that, people are wary of being near certain sites such as the Prime Minister’s office, which has now been bombed. But if you happen to live near such sites, your options are not great. If you have relatives elsewhere you could stay with them but once again space is limited as Palestinians typically have large immediate family, lots of children. Remember the Gaza Strip is maybe just 45 kilometres long so very densely populated.

Q: How do the general populace, the average family who are affected and fear to leave their homes, get food and other necessities?

–]NadimBabaAJE 2 points 4 minutes ago

People are going out but generally only in the day. They have also been buying food in larger quantities than usual, like queuing up for bread, to last them for a while. I know many people rely on paying for deliveries of potable water rather than use what comes through the pipes. Today I heard a report of a water tanker (vehicle) being hit in an airstrike. I haven’t had time to follow that up, but if such services were affected, that would be a big problem for ordinary families.
 
Some additional questions posed to the Al Jazeera reporter in Gaza

Q: **Hi Nadim, I have two questions:
Code:
What are some of the things that has gone unreported or underemphasized in mainstream media?

What are some misconceptions you think the public has about the conflict going on there, and what can you share with us to dispel them?
Thank you for doing this and stay safe!**

–]NadimBabaAJE 3 points 6 minutes ago

hi, 1: How politically aware and internationally-minded young Gazans (or Palestinians of Gaza if you prefer) are. It really saddens me to see how hard, if not impossible, it is for most to take advantage of chances to travel abroad to study or just to see the world. There is a high level of education here and given the poor chances of a well-paid job, it must be extremely frustrating to put it mildly. It must be hard to accept or understand. Maybe things will change if Egypt eases travel restrictions through Rafah but I’m not making predictions here.

Q: Do you think there is any bias to Al Jazeera reporting?

–]NadimBabaAJE 6 points 4 minutes ago

I don’t think the right word is bias. I think it’s a style or a tone. All channels have them. I think Al Jazeera (English, since that’s who I’m working for) leans towards stories about people who are struggling, who are at the bottom when it comes to wealth, opportunities or rights. But then I would say that, I’m biased.

Q: Hi Nadim, what are the material conditions where you are and how many people are in Aljazeera team? How safe are you at work and during rest periods? Is it difficult to get around, to find something to eat? you are all doing amazing job, stay safe…

–]NadimBabaAJE 4 points 4 minutes ago

Hi, we’re very well off regarding our conditions compared to most people in Gaza. We have a large office full with good internet connection etc. The Al Jazeera English team at the moment is small, maybe ten people including people like myself not normally based in Gaza. I felt fairly safe at work until Sunday morning’s bombing of two media buildings not far away. However, those buildings did house local Palestinian television/radio channels which seem to have be part of the Israeli military’s justification for targetting them. This is from a “summary of events” that we got from the IDF: "the IDF targeted Hamas’ operational communication infrastructures in the northern Gaza Strip, which are used for issuing orders to operatives as well as the spreading of propaganda. Getting food- so far so delicious. Thanks for the encouragement.

Q: Does the aftermath of the “Arab Spring” change the calculus of how countries are responding to the most recent crisis? Especially regarding Egypt’s change of government?

–]NadimBabaAJE 1 point 1 minute ago

Massively. I mean the Egyptian PM driving into Gaza the other day- that’s the last thing Hosni Mubarak’s government would have done. Does it mean a sudden change in dealing with Israel? Not sure. It does mean the new governments are being pushed to act by popular pressure. And starting to react. Personally I think any financial help from these states is what people would welcome here in the first instance, along with diplomatic efforts to lift the embargo on Gaza.
 
This seems to have been the last question answered by the Al Jazeera English reporter in Gaza

Q How do you cope with the threat of death in a war zone?

–]NadimBabaAJE 10 points 30 minutes ago

We listen to our local colleagues, and we also have a security adviser. We avoid risks. We try to spend as little time in potentially dangerous situations as possible. So you know, filming quickly the other day in a bombed out factory then moving on. As for threat of death, I feel very lucky to be staying at a clearly marked hotel and not an anonymous appartment block.
 
I hate to sound pessimistic but I believe that the Israelis and Palestinians will be fighting 50 years from now.

It has become a business for them. I cannot see a solution.
 
I hate to sound pessimistic but I believe that the Israelis and Palestinians will be fighting 50 years from now.

It has become a business for them. I cannot see a solution.
I agree. They’ve been figthing for thousands of years; this is nothing new.
 
I hate to sound pessimistic but I believe that the Israelis and Palestinians will be fighting 50 years from now.

It has become a business for them. I cannot see a solution.
20-25 years ago, I felt the same way. But I also never thought the Berlin Wall would fall in my lifetime. Or that the Soviet Union would simply dissolve into independent countries. Or that China would embrace capitalism (albeit without relinquishing control of the Communist Party)

Unexpected, unpredictable things happen in world affairs.
 
20-25 years ago, I felt the same way. But I also never thought the Berlin Wall would fall in my lifetime. Or that the Soviet Union would simply dissolve into independent countries. Or that China would embrace capitalism (albeit without relinquishing control of the Communist Party)

Unexpected, unpredictable things happen in world affairs.
Don’t forget the Troubles in Northern Ireland.
 
Yes, that also seemed to be an intractable situation. I suppose there are some similarities in the situations of Northern Ireland and of Israel.
I am in no way trying to lessen the pain that plagued Northern Ireland for decades but at most less than 1000 died in the entire affair. Or am I totally wrong here? I’m not that up on the history of the conflicts.
 
I am in no way trying to lessen the pain that plagued Northern Ireland for decades but at most less than 1000 died in the entire affair. Or am I totally wrong here? I’m not that up on the history of the conflicts.
I am not very familiar either. My (admittedly, off the cuff) remark suggesting a similarity between Northern Ireland and Israel had to do with conflicts rooted in religion, ethnicity, and national identity when immigrants laid claim to a land, displacing or dis-empowering, the previous residents. Those religious, ethnic, and national identity issues were never resolved. And the descendants of those immigrants are now natives, feelingl no less right to the territory than their opponents.

But obviously there are big differences between the two countries, so perhaps the comparison doesn’t really stand up.
 
An Outgunned Hamas Tries to Tap Islamists’ Growing Clout
Emboldened by the rising power of Islamists around the region, the Palestinian militant group Hamas demanded new Israeli concessions to its security and autonomy before it halts its rocket attacks on Israel, even as the conflict took an increasing toll on Sunday.
Hamas, badly outgunned on the battlefield, appeared to be trying to exploit its increased political clout with its ideological allies in Egypt’s new Islamist-led government. The group’s leaders, rejecting Israel’s call for an immediate end to the rocket attacks, have instead laid down sweeping demands that would put Hamas in a stronger position than when the conflict began: an end to Israel’s five-year-old embargo of the Gaza Strip, a pledge by Israel not to attack again and multinational guarantees that Israel would abide by its commitments.
Hamas’s aggressive stance in the cease-fire talks is the first test of the group’s belief that the Arab Spring and the rise in Islamist influence around the region have strengthened its political hand, both against Israel and against Hamas’s Palestinian rivals, who now control the West Bank with Western backing.
nytimes.com/2012/11/19/world/middleeast/an-outgunned-hamas-tries-to-leverage-rise-of-islamists-in-region.html?ref=global-home&_r=0

Israel and Hamas both have representatives in Cairo who have been tasked with negotiating a cease-fire. However, those representatives are not directly meeting each other, but relying on Egyptian intermediaries.

The article mentions the difficult position Egypt is in. Hamas originated as a radical off-shoot of the Muslim Brotherhood. However, the Muslim Brotherhood is effectively now the ruling party of Egypt and has it has responsibilities it didn’t previously have.
 
This refers to the al-Qassam Brigades, which are the military wing of Hamas

Brigades Firing on Israel Show Deadly New Discipline
Highly organized and increasingly professionalized yet still secretive and cultlike, Qassam is emblematic of Hamas’s struggle to balance its history as a resistance movement and its governing role in Gaza since 2007.
With an expanding arsenal and financing provided by Iran, Syria, Sudan and other foreign sources, Qassam expanded and matured under Mr. Jabari, adopting clear training regimens and chains of command. Last year he even negotiated with Israel to return an Israeli sergeant, Gilad Shalit — whose kidnapping he had engineered five years earlier — in exchange for 1,000 Palestinian prisoners.
Yet Qassam remains a fundamentalist jihadi enterprise whose culture and goals — terrorizing and obliterating Israel — resemble those of ragtag militia cells.
A 2009 paper published by the Washington Institute for Near East Policy contains an organizational chart of the Qassam Brigades showing Gaza divided into six geographic areas, each with its own commander reporting to Mr. Jabari. Each also has separate artillery, antitank and antiaircraft units as well as snipers, engineers and infantry, according to the paper, titled “Hamas in Combat,” with forcewide units handling communications, logistics, smuggling, weapons, intelligence and public affairs.
“Almost by any definition they have become more institutionalized,” said Nathan Thrall, an analyst who covers the Palestinian territories for the International Crisis Group. “They more or less have been keeping a calm in Gaza. A very imperfect calm, and one that has escalations every three or four or five months, but they are the party that Egypt has gone to to ensure that things don’t get out of control.”
nytimes.com/2012/11/19/world/middleeast/brigades-that-fire-on-israel-show-a-deadly-new-discipline.html?pagewanted=2&ref=global-home

The article mentions that the al-Qassam Brigades have a great deal of prestige and influence in Gaza. The members typically have day jobs and live at home, which makes them heroes in the eyes of neighbors.
 
This seems to be getting worse by the day. The IDF just confirmed (haaretz.com/as-idf-strike-kills-entire-family-in-gaza-israel-is-starting-to-get-in-trouble-1.478879) that while targeting Hamas’ rocket chief it mistakenly bombed the home of the Al-Dalou family, killing at least 11 civilians, four of them children and toddlers. The death toll in Gaza is now up to 95 people, 23 of which are children. Reuters is now reporting that Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan is condemning Israel’s military offensive in Gaza as an “act of terrorism.” I don’t think this is going to end well for either side.
 
Another evening is approaching in Israel and Gaza. I worry that Israel may be running out of targets for its air campaign, with no let up from the Hamas missiles and indications from Hamas that it is willing to keep fighting. Israel may feel that it has no option than to use the ground troops which are massed outside of Gaza. If such an invasion does occur, I suspect it will be done under cover of darkness using night vision technology. A sensible time would be in the middle of the night, after people go to bed and before they wake up, perhaps in the 2 AM to 4 AM area. That would be be 7 PM to 9 PM in New York.

But outside efforts to avoid an invasion are being applied.
Hoping to avert an Israeli ground invasion, foreign leaders stepped up efforts to broker a cease-fire. United Nations Secretary General Ban Ki-moon was en route to Cairo, where he intended to “appeal personally for ending the violence,” a statement from his office said.
With little apparent progress in cease-fire negotiations in Cairo, British Foreign Secretary William Hague warned that Israel would lose support from the international community if it followed through on threats to deploy troops in Gaza. President Obama, at the start of a three-day trip to Southeast Asia, reiterated U.S. support for Israel’s right of self-defense but said he was hopeful that the fighting could end through diplomacy.
washingtonpost.com/world/middle_east/israel-strikes-media-buildings-in-gaza-expanding-its-range-of-targets/2012/11/18/938c57ca-3180-11e2-bfd5-e202b6d7b501_story.html
 
I am in no way trying to lessen the pain that plagued Northern Ireland for decades but at most less than 1000 died in the entire affair. Or am I totally wrong here? I’m not that up on the history of the conflicts.
It was around 3,600 including the security forces. I am from there, originally and lived through most of it. The video sent to me, about the Israeli’s pulling down the Palestinian’s homes was entitled - ‘just like Northern Ireland’.

Following the troubles and the peace process, the number of investigative reports of killings/bombings etc, e.g.by Savile and others, were practically reversed - due in part to the strongly biased UK media and the UK government’s reporting of the different occurrences at the time.

Hence, why I am cynical about the MSM in general and look to both reporting sides.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top