James White Has Completely Lost It [Akin]

  • Thread starter Thread starter Catholic_Opinion
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Because I agree with him; what was posted on White’s blog concerning this issue is not directed at the whole of your particular community; it is directed only at those who are calling for tolerance under the guise of calling for charity.
So it in fact was not meant to be humorous at all, but made to point out the hypocrisy of the position.
 
I am afraid to say, I have frequently confused you two, and in fact, just now realized that there were two:o .

It does explain the seemingly divergent personalities that seemed to be coming from the “same” person.

My apologies, for any past confusion on my part:tiphat:
I’m still betting it’s only one person, “dealing with some issues.” :whistle:
No there’s not. Trust me…I know.
MF 🙂
 
I cant honestly say that I have followed much of James White’s antics. I have heard a debate or two of his and I visited his site and read a few things including the linked post re: Beckwith.
A few things I can say with confidence:
  • However intelligent he may be, if his goal was humor then it was profoundly foolish of him to use anything related to Muslims as a form of humor at this point in history. This is the best possible scenario - all the alternatives put forth by others to explain his motives are much worse. I hope it was a stupid mistake.
  • Whenever you get yourself into situations like this, the most Christian thing to do is to simply apologize to those whom you have offended. It is irrelevent (to a Christian) whether you intended to offend or not; it is also irrelevent if you believe the other person is offending you - we are to “love our enemies”; and we are to “consider how He endured such opposition from sinners in order that you may not grow weary and lose heart” You might, in the process of apologizing, reiterate zealously that you never intended to offend, but you apologize nonetheless. His apparent inability to apologize speaks more loudly than any argument he can muster. Paul told Timothy to beleive the Gospel he had received because he knew from whom he had received it - good men who demonstrated their character to Timothy. All public apologists must carefully consider the image they project and how closely it resembles the image of Christ - James White is no exception.
 
40.png
MariaG:
So it in fact was not meant to be humorous at all, but made to point out the hypocrisy of the position.
As I stated in an earlier post, Maria:
40.png
Sandusky:
You miss the point; White is not joking; he is not retracting his blog post; however, he is using humor **to illustrate the actions of some Catholics. **
 
As I stated in an earlier post, Maria:
So the point of this post?
White is a brilliant theologian, with a superb understanding of the biblical languages, an excellent grasp of church history, and a great sense of humor; one with which he can laugh at himself, and at you—get a grip!

And once you’ve gotten a grip, get a sense of humor! 😃
 
Then the problem of your upset lies completely with you; your expectation of tolerance from White on issues pertaining to what he considers to be errors within your theology are unrealistic, and your attitude in this will always disappoint you—White, as well as others critical of your theology, will persist in their criticisms of that theology, even though that might hurt your feelings. 🙂
Opinions as to Catholic theology are not the issue here. I could care less about White’s, (or your) opinions of Catholic theology. My feelings are not “hurt”, I am objectively protesting, (Since some of you seem to “respectfully protest”. :rolleyes: ) what is nothing more than excess. I will refute anyone around here, but I don’t go out and post mocking doctored photos to infer that other Christians should be seen in the same light as people who make vitriolic calls for the downfall of America and other such.
This certainly is a question of perception; isn’t it?
More like a rational assessment…
And yet so many, many remain unconvinced as to the accuracy of what you believe that you have shown so many, many times concerning White, such that you should wonder what it is that you think you’ve shown them.
The path is wide that leads to destruction…
Because I agree with him; what was posted on White’s blog concerning this issue is not
directed at the whole of your particular community; it is directed only at those who are calling for tolerance under the guise of calling for charity.Yet this is precisely the kind of action that those who called for that charity were speaking.

I fail to understand why so many “Christians” feel that vitriolic arguments, mockery, belittlement, and polemics are appropriate in their efforts to share their faith, particularly with anyone who doesn’t share their specific beliefs. My own conscience won’t allow that and I prefer to deal with the issues and doctrines…facts.

Don’t worry about it though…this is just one more way that some of you choose to insure that Catholics that know their faith will always stand up and refute guys like White.

You don’t win us over…you simply drive us away…
 
Mr. White is in need of a lot of prayers. The attacks he has perpetrated against his own sister attest to that - I know we need to hold ourselves, as members of the Body of Christ, to a very high standard of charity and love. I also know I am incapable of doing so on my own. Thank you, Jesus, for the Sacraments, for our holy priests, for the saints and angels in my life - without them I would be posting similar pictures and thinking, somehow, that I was justified in doing so.
 
…White, as well as others critical of your theology, will persist in their criticisms of that theology, even though that might hurt your feelings. 🙂

This certainly is a question of perception; isn’t it?
Hi Sandusky!

As always, you bring up some good points and a welcomed opposing view. I do find it a little surprising that you don’t seem to recognize a basic element at play here: criticisms of theology are completely separate from hostility directed at a person or group of people. If, for example, I was to ask you which element of Catholic theology was being “criticized” by those photos, would you be able to identify it? Works righteousness, or perhaps Mary Worship? I dont think so; the photos are not addressed at Catholic theology they are addressed to Catholics or, perhaps, Catholic apologists. But even more important is the fact that some people were offended by what he did. And, of course, as you point out, that is a question of perception as to whether it was truly offensive. But where I believe you and Mr White are completely wrong is in the assessment of whose perception is more important: your own or the person you may have offended. You tacitly imply that if White perceives that the photos werent offensive, then he owes no one any sort of apology. I’ve interacted with you many times and know you to be an intelligent, considerate person. You rightly claim that “it is a question of perception”, but apparently wrongly conclude that perception translates into innocence. I disagree: to acknowledge that it is a matter of perception acknowledges that it is possible for another to perceive it as offensive even if you personally do not. I find it difficult to believe that you would not also see that it is irrelevent whether White perceives his actions as offensive. What he should be concerned about - as a Christian - is not his own perceptions and feelings, but those of his neighbor. This is even more critical when you voluntarily enter the public arena as he does. He can profess his intent at humor 'til he breathes his last breath - I have no problem with that - but he should begin by apologizing for having offended another person even if it was not his intent, and even if he believes that person meant to offend him. Dontcha think?
 
I see sour grapes on White’s page…
“star convert” (who is actually just a revert).
Is a convert to protestantism somehow less a protestant? 😃
That is terribly funny.

Jokes and debate – why bother?
I mean, a joke is always usable by an opponent against you.
Unless your joke is a reduction of an argument to its absurd conclusion.

What is the difference between a joke and a lie?
(Nothing: It’s always a joke in the end.)
🙂
 
It doesn’t matter; it still remains that it’s inflammatory, and is dismaying to anyone with decency and common sense. So whether the pictures are a response to the accusations, or are the focus of the accusations themselves, the bottomline is that its objective is to disparage and hurt people, and not produce any move towards civil discussion.
And false accusations are hurtful and wrong.

When can JRW expect an apology?
 
Posts that bring up topics other than the issue at hand have been deleted.

The topic of this thread is very clear in the initial post, please discuss that or expect your posts to be deleted and possible moderator action.
MF
Okay, I guess I should be moving on then.

I meant none of you any harm, and I really hope we can work this stuff out better in the future.

May God richly bless you guys and bring you peace.

In Christ,
John
 
We do it all the time and no one here is whining. Just pointing up the fact that White’s sense of humor leaves a lot to be desired.

How would you like it if I photo shopped up those same pictures to apply to you an all your “protestant (reformed)” churches?

Luke 6:31 And as you would that men should do to you, do you also to them in like manner.
You would probably get banned from this board if you did so.

Charity counts around here.

White had better hope it doesn’t count when he meets his Maker.
 
I am still waiting for a reply to my question which was about the photoshopped images being art?

OK, so the White followers did not use the word art – at least not on CAF – one comboxer did however on Akin’s blog. Nevertheless, the excuses defending the photoshopped images have consistently hinged on humour, satire.

These can be features of literary art. But not necessarily.

So: are the photoshopped images art?

btw: prayers are still being said for Dr White on the Prayer forum on a thread reserved for him. Please pray for him. Thank you.
 
let the church leadership he is accountable to handle the situation.
Who is that?
This information can be easily found on his website.

Will it do any good? Your call.
James White’s website reads:
"We believe the Scriptures to be “God-breathed” and therefore fully authoritative in and of themselves"

So we let the Bible handle the situation? Help me out here Truthstalker. Or was there another place on his website with more informtion? Is the answer Pastor Don Fry?
 
40.png
MarcoPolo:
James White’s website reads:
"We believe the Scriptures to be “God-breathed” and therefore fully authoritative in and of themselves"

So we let the Bible handle the situation?
Is the Bible the Church? Hint: No.
40.png
MarcoPolo:
Or was there another place on his website with more informtion? Is the answer Pastor Don Fry?
Has Pastor Don spoken to Dr White? Or is this just a way to link to Pastor Don’s site? If you are sincere, then are you going to ask Pastor Don to speak to Dr White?
 
Church Militant:
Opinions as to Catholic theology are not the issue here. I could care less about White’s, (or your) opinions of Catholic theology. My feelings are not “hurt”, I am objectively protesting, (Since some of you seem to “respectfully protest”. ) what is nothing more than excess. I will refute anyone around here, but I don’t go out and post mocking doctored photos to infer that other Christians should be seen in the same light as people who make vitriolic calls for the downfall of America and other such.
White’s opinions against Catholics, and their theology certainly is at issue here; his opinions, and criticisms are the well from which this has sprung.

It’s not as though White got up on the morning he posted the “offending” blog, and posted it for no reason. It is obvious to me, that by the post in question, White has made his point. The incredulous, and uncharitable responses on this thread, directed at him personally,
evidence that.
Church Militant:
More like a rational assessment…
And I’m certain that in your mind, all of the rationality is from the Catholic side. 🙂
Church Militant:
The path is wide that leads to destruction…
That is biblical teaching, CM; what I was suggesting is that the CA forums attitude toward White has neither changed my mind, or attitude toward White; nor, it would seem, has it affected the attitude of others toward White.
Church Militant:
I fail to understand why so many “Christians” feel that vitriolic arguments, mockery, belittlement, and polemics are appropriate in their efforts to share their faith, particularly with anyone who doesn’t share their specific beliefs. My own conscience won’t allow that and I prefer to deal with the issues and doctrines…facts.
Well, I certainly hope that within “so many Christians” who are vitriolic, mocking, belittling, and polemical, you are including the band of Catholic apologists with which White interacts; this battle, and exchange of words is not a one-way street.
Church Militant:
Don’t worry about it though…this is just one more way that some of you choose to insure that Catholics that know their faith will always stand up and refute guys like White.
Catholics who know their faith will certainly endeavor to defend it against White, but whether or not they successfully refute what he says in his criticisms is another thing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top