Jindal: End 'dumbed-down conservatism'

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We can’t win the Presidency so we try to change the rules.

Pretty transparent.
Yep, but the backlash has been immediate and severe. Rational GOP members like Haley Barbour and Governor McConnell are trying to keep their party from further damage
 
Yep, but the backlash has been immediate and severe. Rational GOP members like Haley Barbour and Governor McConnell are trying to keep their party from further damage
I hope you are right. The changing demographics in this nation would certainly be concerning to the GOP.

I’m not a rabble rouser but if the GOP ever succeeded in changing the system to cheat I would join in the mass protests and civil unrest that would follow.
 
Huh? I fail to see how choosing our president by popular vote is mob rule. I personally think that the current system has worked just fine for over 170 years, but if people want change…then go to the simplest solution.

John
I bet you also want to change filibuster rules so you only need a bare majority in the senate,right?
 
The latest developments point to your being wrong…the change the electoral clooege system is falling apart at the seams.

Virginia bill on electoral college change appears headed for defeat
washingtonpost.com/local/va-politics/va-house-delays-action-on-redistricting-plan–again/2013/01/25/3b56a4a4-6711-11e2-9e1b-07db1d2ccd5b_story.html

In Pennsylvania, a bill failed in committee that would have split the state’s 20 electoral votes based on the winner of congressional districts. Republican Senate Majority Leader Dominic Pileggi, has said he plans to introduce another in early February that would allocate votes based on the percentage of the popular vote.
In Ohio, a hotly-contested battleground state, Republican Secretary of State Jon Husted has floated the idea of switching the winner-take-all state to allocation by district. But he’s added “it’s not something I am advocating for.”
In Wisconsin, no proposals have yet been introduced but Gov. Scott Walker recently dropped hints that he might consider Electoral College changes, saying it was an “interesting idea” but not one of his top priorities.
And in Florida, some Republicans have expressed interest in making changes. It seems unlikely that any measure would advance as of now, however, since the state’s Republican House Speaker Will Weatherford has come out strongly against the idea.

Read more: businessinsider.com/gop-electoral-college-changes-2013-1#ixzz2J5Wuy0pX

As for your contention that a bipartisan majority favor change my questions are these…what polls are you using? The same ones that said that Romney would win? What change do they support?

I’d be willing to bet hat the majority favor ELIMINATION of the electoral college…not some of the more “creative” plans that some in the GOP have suggested. One man, or woman, one vote.

John
Fact that bills have been proposed is an example of the changing mindsets regarding voting

Gallup, one of the most reputable long standing pollsters in the US

gallup.com/poll/159881/americans-call-term-limits-end-electoral-college.aspx

‘Creative’ plans? Such as? Only systems I have heard be proposed seriously are proportional allocation, congressional district systems or popular vote
 
I hope you are right. The changing demographics in this nation would certainly be concerning to the GOP.

I’m not a rabble rouser but if the GOP ever succeeded in changing the system to cheat I would join in the mass protests and civil unrest that would follow.
Yes,Dems never change the rules. Unless of course you go back to passing Obamacare,where they used reconciliation. Or Reid trying to change the filibuster rules so you only need 51. I could go on.
As for "changing the system"it is on a state by state basis. Probably won’t happen,but states get to decide. Personally,I question the fairness of a guy winning all the electoral votes of a state when they only win a bare majority. Heck,I will be bipartisan. Bush won Florida in 2000 by 500 votes or so. Should have probably had some kind of allocation.
 
We can’t win the Presidency so we try to change the rules.

Pretty transparent.
States have the constitutional right to change the voting system

Is the following organisation, which is devoted to changing the electoral college a republican outfit?

nationalpopularvote.com/pages/about.php

Did you express concern when Rep Steve Israel proposed to change NY’s electoral college to popular vote?

thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/264227-israel-offers-amendment-to-give-popular-vote-winner-29-move-electoral-votes

Why are democrats so concerned about a change in the system? That is the question that needs to be asked. There is outrage from the Left concerning proposed bills to change the system. Electoral college is not fair for a vareity of reasons, so why are you opposed to making it a more fairer system, that doesn’t decrease turn out and increases participation through people understanding that whatever state they live in their vote counts?
 
We can’t win the Presidency so we try to change the rules.

Pretty transparent.
Oldcelt and you are acting as if the proposed bills to change the electoral college are illegal, they are not, states have the constitutional right to change the voting system

Arizona govenor Jan Brewer has said popular vote would be a better system to choose the president

abc15.com/dpp/news/state/electoral-college-popular-vote-gov-jan-brewer-says-popular-vote-is-best-way-to-pick-president

Did you express concern when Rep Steve Israel proposed to change NY’s electoral college to popular vote?

thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/264227-israel-offers-amendment-to-give-popular-vote-winner-29-move-electoral-votes

Why are democrats so concerned about a change in the system? That is the question that needs to be asked. There is outrage from the Left concerning proposed bills to change the system. Electoral college is not fair for a vareity of reasons, so why are you opposed to making it a more fairer system, that doesn’t decrease turn out and increases participation through people understanding that whatever state they live in their vote counts?
 
I hope you are right. The changing demographics in this nation would certainly be concerning to the GOP.

I’m not a rabble rouser but if the GOP ever succeeded in changing the system to cheat I would join in the mass protests and civil unrest that would follow.
Was their civil unrest and mass protest in Nebraska and Maine when their voting systems were changed allocation of votes by congressional district?
 
I hope you are right. The changing demographics in this nation would certainly be concerning to the GOP.

I’m not a rabble rouser but if the GOP ever succeeded in changing the system to cheat I would join in the mass protests and civil unrest that would follow.
Was there civil unrest and mass protest in Maine and Nebraska when their voting system was changed to allocation of votes by congressional district?
 
theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2013/01/the-gop-plan-to-take-the-electoral-vote-rigging-scheme-national/272523
I interviewed Gehrke about the plan and the many objections to it; an edited transcript follows.
Why do this?
What we have currently is a system where there are 10 battleground states and 40 states that don’t matter. So all the federal government has to do [to secure the incumbent party’s reelection] is buy off people in the 10 states and ignore the issues of the people in the 40. You’re asking for a larger, more intrusive federal government – that’s what [the current electoral vote system of] winner-take-all does.
You end up with a situation where on Day 32 of the [2010 Deepwater Horizon] oil spill, Obama has not gone to Louisiana. But on Day 36, when oil starts lapping the shore in Florida, all of a sudden he’s down there walking around with [former Florida governor] Charlie Crist. Or you get, in 2000, Bush supposedly running as a free trader – but he comes out for steel tariffs in Pennsylvania and West Virginia, because he’s trying to win those states. And then in 2008, when West Virginia is no longer in play, Obama feels free to wage a war on coal.
We should have a system where the people running for president have to worry about what’s happening in individual congressional districts. It brings government a lot closer to the people.
If that’s your goal, why not just get rid of the electoral college and elect presidents by pure popular vote?
Abolishing the electoral college is not something I support; it’s what the Founders intended. This is not abolishing or getting around the electoral college at all. Article 2, Section 1 of the Constitution gives exclusive plenary power to state legislatures to award electors in the manner in which they see fit. Massachusetts has changed the way they award their electors multiple times throughout history. There’s a letter from Jefferson to the Virginia delegation asking, after he lost to Adams, to change the way they [awarded electors] before the next election.
Already, Maine and Nebraska award their electors in this way, and nobody seems to be outraged about it. The alternative is something like National Popular Vote [an interstate compact currently in place in eight states and D.C. that would award electors to the winner of the overall vote nationally]. It’s just not practical – folks have been trying to do it for years and they need a lot more states to get it done. It’s not going to happen anytime soon. This [electoral votes by congressional district plan] is a practical solution to a real problem. State legislators anywhere can simply get together and say, hey, how do I get more attention for my state? How do I make sure every vote counts?
I’m not really here to argue for or against this or that electoral system. All I think we have to prove is that this is better than the current system. The current system’s a mess.
 
Isn’t this really a way for Republicans to take advantage of their advantageous 2010 redistricting efforts, which used crazy gerrymandering to give them control of congressional delegations and state legislatures in states where they can’t win a majority of the voters, like Virginia?
The question is fairness. We already have a system where you can win the popular vote and lose the election. I’m not saying this is a perfect system; I’m saying that, given that we have a fundamentally imperfect system, this is an improvement. Ultimately, it’s very hard to argue that it’s better to have a system where presidential candidates can ignore the majority of voters and not address their concerns. I’m not saying our system is perfect, but is this equal or better than what we already have? Do you believe it’s acceptable to have, say, 100 million out of 130 million Americans whose votes effectively dont matter? And this other small group whose votes matter more than anybody else’s, and that distorts policy outcomes with candidates trying to buy them off?
The common thing you’re seeing in those states [where this is being proposed] is that major cities dominate the statewide vote, but meanwhile, people are voting for Republicans in state legislatures, assemblies, and constitutional offices. The divide between rural and urban America has never been bigger in some ways than it is right now. I really think that’s what this is about. You’ve got people in Michigan saying, “Why is it that this is Mitt Romney’s home state, yet he only came here [to campaign] one time?” It’s the winner-take-all system. “Why should Ohio’s votes matter any more than our votes do?” What you’re seeing is that in a lot of these states, these guys want more attention paid to them. If you’re a Democrat and you just won the presidential election but your state got ignored, you’re probably OK with it. If you’re a Republican, you’re probably a little more bothered by it.
But Virginia, the state that’s now looking at passing this, hardly got ignored in the presidential election. It was one of the top swing states.
Well, people in Northern Virginia didn’t have any problem being paid attention to, but people in other parts of Virginia certainly did. I think that’s what you’re seeing [behind this legislation] – legislators who represent individual districts that have gotten ignored. Look at Ohio, the preeminent battleground state in every single cycle. People in Cleveland get plenty of attention paid to them, but meanwhile, Obama’s waging a war on coal in Southeast Ohio. I promise you, there are a lot of guys in Southeast Ohio who wish Obama had to come there and answer their questions and deal with them and ask for their votes. The fact is, he didn’t, and it governed his policy in a way that hurt them.
Isn’t that just because there aren’t as many voters in Southeast Ohio? The reason rural America is losing power just because that’s not where the population is anymore, and politicians are going to go where the votes are – that’s democracy.
The difference, though, is that rural and urban America increasingly have different goals, different aspirations, and different goals they use to evaluate candidates. We’re seeing a situation where people in Michigan say, wait a minute, why should Detroit always get to pick our candidates? I go to Detroit once a year.
Here’s the thing, this is how we already do it [in presidential primaries]. This is not a radical idea. This is why Obama beat Hillary. This is why Santorum was able to stay in [as long as he did against Romney]. He lost Michigan, but he split with Romney in terms of delegates [apportioned by congressional district]. We already do this. We already think this is a perfectly fine way for parties to award their delegates. It’s not some newfangled, crazy idea.
I’ve heard an objection to this idea from some Republicans, who worry that it would have given Obama, for example, an incentive to campaign and turn out voters in their districts, which could hurt reelection chances for Republican members of Congress. Have you heard that objection from your colleagues in the GOP?
The point of this is not to help or hurt Republicans. Competitive elections are a good thing.
I also think this solves the voter-fraud problem. There’s a perception that voter fraud happens on both sides – Democrats believe Republicans do it, Republicans believe Democrats do it, I don’t know who does it more or better. The point is, under this system you don’t have much of an incentive to steal votes.
Why not? Isn’t the incentive to steal votes the same anywhere?
It’s a lot harder to steal votes in Sheridan, Michigan, than Detroit, Michigan. Dead people don’t vote in Sheridan, Michigan. They do in Detroit.
 
A lot of Democrats will hear this as racial code – that you want to disenfranchise urban voters, disproportionately minorities, in the inner cities, while giving more weight to the predominantly white populations of rural areas.
I want to disenfranchise dead people, yes. I believe their franchise ends when they die.
It has nothing to do with race. But I don’t believe anybody in politics would tell you with straight face that there isn’t some sort of problem with the way the Chicago machine works, going back to Dan Rostenkowski – a white guy. It’s not a race issue, it’s about a machine.
**You are a Republican operative, though. And it’s Republican legislators who are pushing this in all the states where it’s come up so far. You can claim this is about policy, but doesn’t it really make it easier for Republicans to win presidential elections?/B]
That could be a byproduct, depending on who drew the lines last and who’s running – a lot of different things. What it’s really about is making sure that more people in more congressional districts get attention.
I think Democrats in Texas should be all over this. Democrats would probably win 15 electoral votes in Texas. I’m not saying this will always be comfortable for Republicans. I’ve had lots of Republicans argue with me about this, too. Why shouldn’t Democrats in Arizona get their voices heard? Why shouldn’t they matter too?**
 
Oldcelt and you are acting as if the proposed bills to change the electoral college are illegal, they are not, states have the constitutional right to change the voting system

Arizona govenor Jan Brewer has said popular vote would be a better system to choose the president

abc15.com/dpp/news/state/electoral-college-popular-vote-gov-jan-brewer-says-popular-vote-is-best-way-to-pick-president

Did you express concern when Rep Steve Israel proposed to change NY’s electoral college to popular vote?

thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/264227-israel-offers-amendment-to-give-popular-vote-winner-29-move-electoral-votes

Why are democrats so concerned about a change in the system? That is the question that needs to be asked. There is outrage from the Left concerning proposed bills to change the system. Electoral college is not fair for a vareity of reasons, so why are you opposed to making it a more fairer system, that doesn’t decrease turn out and increases participation through people understanding that whatever state they live in their vote counts?
Abyssinia,

At no time did I say that these proposals are illegal…and I find myself agreeing with Governor Brewer…a rare occasion indeed.

You can try to rationalize this any way you want, but the facts are clear. The GOP proposals generally support, or supported, a system that would take maximum advantage of their gerrymandering. Democrats are concerned because the system would have allowed Mitt Romney to win the presidency while getting 5 million fewer votes nationwide.

As I’ve said repeatedly, I have absolutely no problem with going to a straight popular vote, but that is not what some of the GOP wants. They want to cherry-pick the system that will give them victory from defeat.

You say the electoral college is unfair…it was perfectly fair when it gave G.W. Bush the Whitehouse and I don’t recall any Democratic proposals other than going to a straight popular vote.

BTW, as is so often pointed out here…just because something is legal, does not necessarily make it moral.

Anyway, these proposals are dying on the vine as the more reasonable voices in the GOP chime in.

John
 
Abyssinia,

At no time did I say that these proposals are illegal…and I find myself agreeing with Governor Brewer…a rare occasion indeed.

You can try to rationalize this any way you want, but the facts are clear. The GOP proposals generally support, or supported, a system that would take maximum advantage of their gerrymandering. Democrats are concerned because the system would have allowed Mitt Romney to win the presidency while getting 5 million fewer votes nationwide.

As I’ve said repeatedly, I have absolutely no problem with going to a straight popular vote, but that is not what some of the GOP wants. They want to cherry-pick the system that will give them victory from defeat.

You say the electoral college is unfair…it was perfectly fair when it gave G.W. Bush the Whitehouse and I don’t recall any Democratic proposals other than going to a straight popular vote.

BTW, as is so often pointed out here…just because something is legal, does not necessarily make it moral.

Anyway, these proposals are dying on the vine as the more reasonable voices in the GOP chime in.

John
Sandy Adams and Allen West lost their seats. Proof that restricting does not necessarily help the party who has done restricting

Gerrymandering implies that republicans did something untoward in dividing districts, which they did not, what they did was legal and if the democrats were in control you know they would of done the same thing

I do not think the electoral college system, at least in the modern age, has ever been really fair, no matter who the candidate was that won

Popular vote is better than the electoral college, because like the congressional district system it allows everybody has a say in making a difference in the election but the congressional district system is easier to implement than popular vote

You question about Romney winning with the congressional district system with less than 5 million votes; I question is it fair that Obama won the 20 electoral votes in Pennsylvania even though Romney won 55 out of 67 counties but because Obama got more votes in the populous Philadelphia, he won electoral votes

Example of the electoral college favouring populous cities
 
Sandy Adams and Allen West lost their seats. Proof that restricting does not necessarily help the party who has done restricting

I]Gerrymandering implies that republicans did something untoward in dividing districts, which they did not, what they did was legal and if the democrats were in control you know they would of done the same thing
I do not think the electoral college system, at least in the modern age, has ever been really fair, no matter who the candidate was that won

Popular vote is better than the electoral college, because like the congressional district system it allows everybody has a say in making a difference in the election but the congressional district system is easier to implement than popular vote

Didn’t imply it was illegal…just that they want to take full advantage of it in a presidential election. Your second point was made by Haley Barbour as one of his reasons for opposing the Congressional District model.

My prediction…nothing will change.
 
Didn’t imply it was illegal…just that they want to take full advantage of it in a presidential election. Your second point was made by Haley Barbour as one of his reasons for opposing the Congressional District model.

My prediction…nothing will change.
I do not think anything will change en masse, yet, but I saw an article from somebody who is opposed to the proposed bills by republicans but admitted that will probably take hold in a number of battleground states and have an impact on future elections
 
The popular vote would result in only large urban areas having any sway.
 
In large countries of diverse regions like America is, if it comes down to popular vote only, regional interests not having an effective voice will lead to calls for dissolving the country. Red state/Blue state divisions will lead to the formation of different countries.

That is not necessarily a bad thing, but it is the kind of thing that the original constitutional arrangements sought to prevent.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top