R
ringil
Guest
1 person=1 voteThe popular vote would result in only large urban areas having any sway.
Isn’t that the very definition of fair?
I could get behind a straight popular vote.
1 person=1 voteThe popular vote would result in only large urban areas having any sway.
Agreed, the notion that the popular vote model would somehow favor any area just doesn’t add up. Candidates would have to appeal to every voter individually.1 person=1 vote
Isn’t that the very definition of fair?
I could get behind a straight popular vote.
Michigan state Rep. Pete Lund, a Republican, is considering re-introducing a bill similar to one being advanced in Virginia that would revamp the way Electoral College votes are allocated in the state.
Lund’s explanation for why it failed, via The Detroit Free Press, is rather revealing:
"It got no traction last year. There were people convinced Romney was going to win and this might take (electoral) votes from him."
In other words, as Kevin Drum observes, the interest in this measure is relating to helping Republicans, not actually improving democracy!
Read more: businessinsider.com/republican-electoral-college-plan-michigan-virginia-2013-1#ixzz2J8vvqiCKLater in the story, he attempted to explain why he thinks it would make each vote more important:
“Right now, in most states it’s like the vote doesn’t even matter to presidential candidates,” Lund said. “If we do this, all of Michigan won’t necessarily be in play, but maybe some of it will.”
But The Free Press estimated that under Lund’s proposed plan, Mitt Romney would have won nine of Michigan’s electoral votes, while President Barack Obama would have won seven.
Obama won Michigan by almost 450,000 votes in 2012.
There’s an awkward piece of trivia following Virginia Democrats as they rally to stop a Republican plan to allocate electoral votes by Congressional district: several of them once supported similar bills themselves.
(D), another sitting lawmaker who once backed an electoral vote split in the mold of Maine and Nebraska. Their favored bills — none of which ever came close to passing — were similar to the current proposal by Sen. Charlie Carrico (R), but not identical. Carrico’s would give the state’s two at-large delegates to whichever candidate won the most districts (almost certainly a Republican in the near term), the others would give it to the popular vote winner.Every Democrat contacted by TPM who previously sponsored or voted for such electoral vote changes has since come out against the GOP plan. So has state Sen. John Miller
In Florida, the Republican speaker of the state House of Representatives expressed opposition last week to changing the way the largest swing state allots electoral votes, almost certainly dooming any chance that it will happen there.
Republicans don’t “need to change the rules of the game,” Rep. Will Weatherford told the Miami Herald and Tampa Bay Times. "I think we need to get better."
Ohio Secretary of State Jon Husted, a target of intense criticism from Democrats in 2012 over voting procedures, has backed away from a postelection suggestion that his state move to a system of awarding electoral votes by congressional district. Such a plan would have given Romney 12 of the state’s 18 electoral votes; he lost Ohio by 5 percentage points and wound up with no electoral votes. Husted, a Republican, told the Cincinnati Enquirer that his comments were taken out of context and that he was neither advocating nor promoting the electoral change.
Only Nebraska and Maine allow a divided electoral vote, and it has happened only once: In 2008, Obama won a single electoral vote in Nebraska, while losing statewide, by carrying an Omaha-area district.
“There’s this perception, among the public, that the Republicans were trying to manipulate the presidential election” in 2012, political scientist Michael McDonald of George Mason University said. He warned that if Republicans succeeded in changing the way electoral votes are awarded, it could lead to retaliation against governors and state legislators by “super PACs” and the national Democratic Party.
Just to clarify…walking around money was eliminated in Pennsylvania some time ago…and if you think that such things are peculiar to Democrats, you really need to look a bit deeper.Dems know that they will always win with a popular vote because their base of support are in big metro areas. Lots of chances for vote fraud,whether it be Philly “walking around money”,or the Chicago miracle of people rising from the dead to vote.
Providing links from Heritage foundation regarding the morality of capitalism and the role of government is like going to a PETA site and seeking opinions about the health benefits of eating meat.**Freedom Manifesto: Why Free Markets are Moral and Big Government Isn’t
**
Are we a country founded on the values of freedom and limited government, as envisioned by the founding fathers in the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution? Or, do we want to become a European-style socialist democracy? What best serves the public good – freedom or Big Government?
…
(56 min. Heritage Event w/ Steve Forbes)
heritage.org/events/2013/01/freedom-manifesto
Scholars Agree: High Tax Rates Do Harm Growth
The Congressional Research Service (CRS) stirred controversy last year when it released a study claiming that tax rates do not influence economic growth. Predictably, those who favor higher taxes used the flimsy report to bolster their backward argument that raising tax rates, as Congress and President Obama did with the fiscal cliff deal, would not further slow our economy.
…
In December, in response to the controversy regarding the CRS report, William McBride of the Tax Foundation published a review of the scholarly literature on taxation and economic growth. McBride reported that the empirical work of economists agrees overwhelmingly that higher tax rates slow economic growth and he concludes that “the U.S. tax system is a drag on the economy.”
…
Surveying 26 scholarly studies dating from 1983, McBride finds that 23 of the studies—and every study in the past fifteen years—corroborated the finding that higher taxes negatively affected growth.
…
blog.heritage.org/2013/01/27/scholars-agree-high-tax-rates-do-harm-growth/
Foreign Aid: There Are Many Ways Conservatives Can—and Should—Help the Poor
Daniel Hannan, a member of the European Parliament and one of Great Britain’s rising conservative political stars, reminds us that the fundamental error of the left is its “elevation of motive over outcome.”
…
blog.heritage.org/2013/01/25/foreign-aid-there-are-many-ways-conservatives-can-and-should-help-the-poor/
I guess to give a more precise comparison, I really should have written that going to the Heritage foundation for an opinion on the ethics of capitalism and role of government would be like going to the American Cattle foundation (is there such thing?) and seeking information on the health benefits of eating meat.Providing links from Heritage foundation regarding the morality of capitalism and the role of government is like going to a PETA site and seeking opinions about the health benefits of eating meat.
I find it rather odd that you would have a problem with links to the conservative Heritage Foundation in a thread that concerns ending dumbed-down conservatism.I guess to give a more precise comparison, I really should have written that going to the Heritage foundation for an opinion on the ethics of capitalism and role of government would be like going to the American Cattle foundation (is there such thing?) and seeking information on the health benefits of eating meat.
Just a question: How does the opinion of one journalist “confirm” anything?Parker: Okay, I’m going to go out on a limb here and predict that nothing much is going to happen with immigration in the next two years because it suits the Democrats to have that out there for the 2014.
Matthews: Are you prodding here or are you planning? Are you prodding them? I think you’re prodding them, but you may be right. I think it is a Democratic issue that helps them, but I think it’s wrong for the country to have that issue unresolved.
newsbusters.org/blogs/noel-sheppard/2013/01/27/kathleen-parker-hillary-wont-run-president-ultimate-revenge-bill
She also says Hillary Clinton will not run
Confirms what republicans have said before. Democrats use immigration as a wedge issue to help them in election, by badgering republicans, and probably explains why when democrats have had the chance to pass immigration reform they have not, like when they controlled congress and the presidency from for the first 2 years of Obama’s 1st term
Typically, economic factors forecast voting patterns; convention suggests that there must be overall improvements in the quality of life for blacks to justify a level of support merely 5 percent lower than the last election. In August of 2012, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported an unemployment rate of 14.1 percent within the black community—less than a percentage point below the 14.9 percent rate at the end of the Great Recession, and well above Bush-era rates, of 9 percent and under.
Furthermore, when looking at household wealth and homeownership, two hallmarks of the American Dream, the Census reports that blacks have fared poorly as well. Between 2005 and 2010, the gap in white and black household wealth widened: whites went from 15 times that of blacks’ to 22 times. CNN Money reports that in 2010, white median household net worth stood at $110,729 versus $4,995 for blacks. This enormous chasm of wealth disparity opened up during the Great Recession and has persisted under the leadership of President Obama. …
The GOP has tried running black candidates on the ticket, and while that’s important, it isn’t the answer. Nor is it enough to feature conservative black pundits on television and radio. Neither of these alone will convert blacks into Republican voters. What will work is illustrating how Republican policies will improve blacks’ lives and economic standing.
History shows that many minority groups, most notably the Irish and Jewish populations, had rough beginnings here in the U.S. but turned them around for the better through hard work and sacrifice.
American Jews weren’t always members of the upper echelons of society. Prosperous Jewish leaders noticed that there were ever-increasing numbers of their people mired in poverty and living in ghettos in New York. As a part of a greater effort to improve the lives of Jewish immigrants, the Federation of Jewish Farmers of America was formed. Historical records from the Jewish Agricultural Society and the Federation of Jewish Farmers show how they set about making a proactive change to better the circumstances of new immigrants through very simple means: teaching them to speak English, and then loaning them funds to buy a farm.
Once the family was set up on their new farm and had paid back the money, that same money was loaned to another family, so they, too, could escape the city. Community leaders stressed that education was of the utmost importance. And through the hard work and determination of the affluent reaching back to help less fortunate, newer American Jews, a tidal wave of success and wealth was unleashed over a few generations.
This plan isn’t limited in its application. It could work for American blacks too. Someone must suggest and implement it; but the Obama administration certainly won’t. The Democrats don’t want more blacks to become successful and free of government handouts. After all, once an individual begins to earn enough money to escape the horrors of inner-city living, he also begins to notice that his tax burden has increased as well. And once a person attends to their tax burden, he usually feels a desire to pay less.
townhall.com/tipsheet/elisabethmeinecke/2013/01/16/the-gop-message-or-minority-probem-n1489116The last election proved that black voters are engaged and willing to go the extra mile for a candidate that connects with them on a personal level. Yet minority outreach in the Republican Party is all but nonexistent. The party must initiate voter contact in the lull between campaigns, when Democrats aren’t working the churches, neighborhoods and shopping centers. Any black person will tell you that the Democrats only show up to seek out votes during election season, and the Republicans make their first attempts just three months before the election. This is abysmal!
LOL that’s about right!!With all due respect, I think Jindal is all wet. He wants to campaign on an intellectual level that cannot compete with the Homer Simpson level of “free beer for everybody”.![]()