Keep gutting the UN

  • Thread starter Thread starter Boatswain2PA
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe you should understand the full impact of the “wonderful” UN health proposals such as pro-abortion, euthanasia, population control, vaccines for all nations with some “specific” requirements. Think again. It is not all that wonderful.


http://www.physiciansforlife.org/un...erts-visit-us-denounce-laws-against-abortion/
 
Much of the UN Health and Globalism concepts loosely resemble or maybe even closely resemble the whacked out writings of Alice Bailey in the 20’s and 30’s
 
lazurm:
I can see that in this forum we have many people who don’t understand the full breadth of the U.N. which is involved in health issues and quite successful at it . . . .
(Emphasis mine)

(What do you mean by “sucessful” concerning the UN’s medical involvement? Some of it I might agree with you on, but some of it I may take issue with too.)

First of all lazurm, I think the UN does some excellent things.

Just because I want countries in it to (at least try to) pay their own bill does not equate to wanting the UN abolished (which is what you SEEM to feel that I think here).

Naturally I cringe seeing the US taxpayers forced into financial support of UN killing missions too (regarding abortion).

That being said, the UN has failed miserably in many areas. (I think member states of the UN would all admit that–they would disagree on what those “failures” were though of course).

“Health care” issues have been a mixed bag. But the BIG issue destroying the foundations of at least the outlook of UN health care, has been their evangelization of the religion of secular humanism and the DENIAL of personhood for certain selective politically correct (to discriminate against) human beings. This denial is then used as conscience salve to murder innocent babies via “abortion”.

The problem with your “world wide rational cooperation” (false) pre-supposition is, it can never REALLY be “worldwide” when you re-define “people” as “less than people” so you can rationalize killing those innocent people.

Then the “worldwide” actually morphs into “worldwide minus the humans we elites redefine as LESS THAN full persons”.

That’s what abortion does, and this is part of the “evangelistic” mission of the pro-aborts who have metastasized into the UN apparatus has brought to the world.

And until this disaster is at least put in remission (if not cured), the US needs to re-channel more funds to more “FRUITFUL” avenues.
 
Last edited:
You had some good comments. Unfortunately, the agenda of 2030 proposes medical assistance to needy countries but only if they comply with the rest of the stipulations. These stipulations may include support of abortion, euthanasia, birth control, deferring to the UN basically who lives, who dies. It all boils down to the real goal of controlling populations and their choices.

Many of these “benefits” will be dangled in front of the needy with demands of compliance which will compromise the morals and values of many. They will comply because it may mean saving the life of themselves or a family member. Most people will agree to anything under these circumstances. It is neither a “free choice” nor is “humanitarian” as it seems to be projected, It is a masked attempt at humanism with the idea that -man can save himself. Once again the myth of the international do-gooder riding in to town with their pale blue hats and saving the day, just doesn’t pan out. It is all about control and someone making choices for you.
 
Who funds the UN?


.
.

JW55:
Unfortunately, the agenda of 2030 proposes medical assistance to needy countries but only if they comply with the rest of the stipulations. These stipulations may include support of abortion, euthanasia, birth control, deferring to the UN basically who lives, who dies. It all boils down to the real goal of controlling populations and their choices.

Many of these “benefits” will be dangled in front of the needy with demands of compliance which will compromise the morals and values of many. They will comply because it may mean saving the life of themselves or a family member. Most people will agree to anything under these circumstances. It is neither a “free choice” nor is “humanitarian” . . .
.

Excellent post.

I don’t want to give the impression that I am unaware of these other anti-life and population-control machinations. I am.

In my recent post I just focused on the abortion issue so as not to overwhelm.

But all these other issues are REAL problems too.

.

.

lazurm.

Just MORE for you to address in your paradigm of “success”.
 
Last edited:
It’s so tiresome when one couches their pet issue with words that are as inaccurate as any bias could be. This stated in the context of what is otherwise (in my humble opinion) a fair discussion on your part. “…the religion of secular humanism”, PLEASE. I’ve stated enough on this and, hopefully, it will go away.

I agree, if one is strongly anti-abortion one can correctly wage criticism on the U.N., and many other governing bodies who, today, strongly favor this mode of population control, and some may call it something else, all within the rubric of officially positive purposes. So, for the sake of argument, I will grant you that, that the U.N.'s actions have fostered abortion.

And though this issue is “BIG” to you and others of similar persuasion, it’s only a part of the whole medical/health package. The U.N. has also been instrumental in drastically reducing infant and maternal death rates as well as the transmission of STD’s. May I assume that you may be also anti-birth control? If not, then you may applaud its efforts to reduce runaway population growth in nations where that problem leads to starvation and disease in the hundreds of thousands, and not by abortion as much as by simple birth control. If so, then I’ll ditto my above comment on abortion and, for the sake of the argument, let it go as, after all, this is a Catholic forum.

And, with a mention of abortion, I am tempted to add the children issue that U.N. activities has heartily been involved with: UNICEF. This organization protects the rights of children everywhere in the world and works to enhance their living standards. With the significant contribution of UNICEF, the number of deaths for children under the age of 5 has declined from nearly 12 million in 1990 to 6.9 million in 2011 in the parts of the world where this satellite of the U.N. operates.

It really isn’t all about one issue, as you seem to say. Without going into the details let me just list some of the other, important, issues that the U.N. is successfully involved in:

Peacekeeping
Running Elections
War Crimes Prosecution
Fighting AIDS
Land Mine victims
Modern day slavery (and human trafficking)
Food Aid
Aid to Refugees
and a BIG etc.

And THAT is what you want to cut funds to because of one issue that means more to you than any of the above, apparently.

If they need to cut $285 million perhaps a wiser choice would be to cut down the moving castle that is paid for by the U.S. taxpayers every time President Trump moves his people to Mara Lago since we’d be talking about well over 100 million to date, not to mention the real wastes occurring via the efforts of our current administration, the one wanting to cut the U.N. budget. The real reason for that U.N. cut has little to do with abortion and a lot to do with someone high up not always getting his way, the latest vote on Jerusalem being but one example. If it was up to PT, he’d prefer the U.N. to be a complete puppet, yes?
 
Last edited:
[continued from my previous post, bifurcated due to word limitations]
Look, abortion is against Catholic doctrine and for well understood reasons, granted. When this issue becomes more important than anything else the problems arise, and I’m referring to big problems, problems that can evolve into a death and suffering rate far exceeding all the abortions in the last 100 years.

Perspective man…perspective (please), or we shall all perish, and sooner than later.
 
Lazurm:
So, for the sake of argument, I will grant you that, that the U.N.'s actions have fostered abortion. . . . .
No lazurm.

Not “for the sake of the argument”.

Grant it because . . . it’s true.

Then tell me what you think an “abortion” is.

(Then I will go back and show you why your proportionalistic argument is only a partial truth)
 
Last edited:
Peacekeeping
Running Elections
War Crimes Prosecution
Fighting AIDS
Land Mine victims
Modern day slavery (and human trafficking)
Food Aid
Aid to Refugees
and a BIG etc.
Don’t believe the marketing
  • UN Peacekeeping missions are generally a bust
  • Running Elections??? No, the local countries have the elections and outside countries send their own observers. UN Observers are just another pair of eyes.
  • War Crimes are prosecuted by the ICC (think Hague) not the UN
  • Fighting Aids? Yea, everyone is doing that one
  • Land Mine victims? How has the UN made a key difference.
  • Slavery? The UN has failed to stop this one.
  • Food Aid, maybe they help coordinate shipments from donor countries. They often fail in local distribution and people still starve due to the local politics.
  • Aid to refugees. YES, they do manage the refugee camps. This is an important contribution.
Show examples of where the UN makes a difference, not were they are just ‘for something’ that everyone else is working towards. They do make a difference with setting up and managing refugee camps.
 
Last edited:
What I meant by “for the sake of argument” is that I will grant that, if you think abortion is wrong, the U.N. commits a wrong. If it wasn’t for the sake of the argument I may have argued that because abortion is legal mostly everywhere (I think), stating that it’s not wrong would be based on its legality as opposed to its religiously based moral truth. The logic behind the quoted phrase is based on granting its wrongness. Sorry I wasn’t clear on that.
As to its definition, it depends on who you ask but, generally it means ending the life of a fetus, or pre-birth child for a variety of purposes ranging from birth control to health issues.
Please note, this topic isn’t about abortion per se but about the U.N. and its value. As such, I don’t want to continue any more discourse on abortion.
 
Last edited:
I can sit here and research each issue, point by point, and recite the history recounting numerous success stories (and failures also, yes) and, if you wanted to, so can you (at least research them). And then we can argue each tiresome issue, point by point, ad infinitum but it seems to me that the main drift of your argument is that, yes, the U.N. is just another body doing the same things some nations are doing so therefore it isn’t valuable or in some instances the U.N. may have had good intentions but failed nonetheless. (As for war crimes, the U.N. has investigators and its members voted for the Geneva Convention, plus more things to say but, heck, look it up if you care to). That’s like saying that Christians haven’t been able to prevent or reduce sin (or abortion if that’s your preference) so therefore their organizations shouldn’t be funded by those that do the funding.
It’s the idea behind the U.N. that is its foundation. Its successes are great; it’s failures something that needs to improve if we can ever legitimately hope for international law to become the standard by which nations exist together in our world. If the U.N. fails, if the concept of international law fails in this day of a shrinking world and a vast increase in the power of weapons then, simply put, we are doomed as a technological civilization, perhaps another failure in a large gamut of failures of technological civilizations in our universe.
Like I stated previously, if we don’t learn to live together (“world wide rational cooperation”) we will kill ourselves off together and sooner than later. The U.N. is, currently, mankind’s only viable attempt at international cooperation by the standards of law (as opposed to geopolitical power) and, so, shouldn’t be defunded but, rather, the support increased in any way possible and by any and all entities. There really isn’t anything like it on our planet so what it stands for should be nurtured and valued and improved.
 
Last edited:
You seem to want to trade tit for tat, that because they are giving medicines to needy kids they are somehow concerned about children, so I guess abortion is ok, it offsets a wrong by doing a right,and we just have to lower the population anyway. Well isn’t that wonderful that the UN gets to decide to abort babies that will never have a chance to live as long as they give vaccinations with a price tag of conformity with their other vices attached. How incredibly humanistic of them. In your analysis it almost seems like a cold clinical or laboratory analysis of well abortion is commonplace around the world so it is just accepted, so it is ok. If we negate abortion as just a side issue, then euthanasia is one too. If we don’t deal with life from the beginning then none of the rest of it matter either, because we just pick and choose cost effectiveness or convenience. No different than moves on a chess board. When we abandon our God-given moral guidelines we just make ourselves God. We, nor no agency should have the right to brush aside abortion as just another minor issue

Are you at all familiar with the writings of Alice Bailey? Most of Agenda 2030 is just a rewrite of her views. Bailey was an occultist. She didn’t believe in family. What she taught and the UN advocates is education of children apart from the parents, where their value system is instilled in them apart for God and the beliefs of the parents. That man is the answer to his problems, not God.

Regarding war, 150+ countries getting along is not going to be decided by a group of indifferent representatives sitting in a room in New York, Brussels or anywhere else. They are not resolving the issue of war. We have more wars and conflicts now probably than we ever did They are only adding another element to it. We have wars around the world continuously. Has the UN really averted wars? How long has conflict been raging in the Middle East, various conflicts in Africa? What has the UN really changed in these regards. We can also say that all the nations of the world are represented. They may be there, but basically everything runs through the members of the Security Council.
 
lazurm:
As to (abortion) its definition, it depends on who you ask but, generally it means ending the life of a fetus, or pre-birth child . . .
So you and I would agree, this abortion that the UN promotes, or at least an overwhelming majority within the UN, is the purposeful murdering of an innocent human being.

You also said. . . .
Please note, this topic isn’t about abortion per se but about the U.N. and its value. As such, I don’t want to continue any more discourse on abortion.
The problem is, the UN itself keeps bringing the killing of innocent human beings back into the picture.

“Abortion” is known by a lot of euphemisms because when you are promoting child sacrifice, euphemisms become quite necessary for conscience salve because everybody knows (irrespective of if they admit it or not), that murdering innocent baby humans is self-destructive of a healthy society.

You don’t murder innocent people and turn a blind eye to it (much less channel US taxpayer dollars to it).

“Women’s health”, “girls rights”, “choice”, “empowerment”, and other phony names and phrases meant to at least partially cover up the heinous nature of these outrages.

So YOU get THE UN to quit talking about abortion (and quit supporting it).

In the meantime, they have joined themselves to this monstrosity, so no I won’t ignore that issue.

If the UN is to be discussed, what the UN does and PROMOTES MUST be part of the discussion.

YOU were the one that brought up other functional areas of the UN such as peacekeeping.

Would it be appropriate for ME to say, "Look. I don’t want to discuss “UN peacekeeping missions"or “UN food distribution” programs?” (Just like YOU are attempting to do with ME concerning the UN sponsorship of killing innocent humans)

No!

And what good is “peacekeeping” to the girl that’s dead because your organization helped bring about her murder?

What good is a food distribution program if you are dead due to abortion? How’s that food program going to help this kid who was murdered in the name of “empowering girls?”

Running elections? What kind of vote can you cast if you are killed?

War crimes? WHY ignore the war on pre-born humans? Because many would be forced to convict themselves that’s why.

Refugee camps? Camps where often Christians must keep their Christianity a secret or be persecuted or killed by other “campers”?

And I am supposed to throw MORE money at this shenanigans?

And about “the good”?

Are we to ignore the atrocities supported because of some “goods”?

That seems more like enabling to me.

Should Hitler be extolled because he and his National Socialists gave Germany the autobahn?

My German grandmother who fled (her family fled) such a toxic environment would be horrified at such lack of principles.

Yet YOU want ME to FUND such shenanigans because of other “goods”?

Is that what you think?
 
Last edited:
Again, I’m all for having the round table meeting room where the countries get together and work through issues.

I’m against the false presentation that the UN is an effective entity as an entity. The sheer amount of politics is what causes them to fail in achieving mission objectives.

Here is a good article on their peace keeping. They’ve had some success but far too often have only served witness to atrocities. This is probably due to their command structure, rules of engagement, and that their troops are often hired from the least capable countries. The troops are as likely to participate in sexual abuse and exploitation as prevent it.

 
Last edited:
The problem with a singular focus is that, even if the issue focused on can be linked in some manner to other issues, it fails to see the whole picture and what it sees is skewed too much in one direction. At this point we can only agree to disagree. In your best case scenario, assuming the majority opinions on abortion doesn’t change nor does the U.N. policy in this regard, we’ll have a less effective U.N. since it’ll be funded by less monies. In the worst case we’ll have no U.N. In either case abortion isn’t really addressed, nor will important issues, as listed by me, be. How is that making a better world?
I simply suggest making the U.N. a better body by suggesting improvements, regardless of cost (as long as the costs aren’t due to inefficiencies and/or corruption).
 
There really isn’t anything like it on our planet so what it stands for should be nurtured and valued and improved.
We should be preparing for a post-American future where the US is just one of the crowd.
 
40.png
lazurm:
There really isn’t anything like it on our planet so what it stands for should be nurtured and valued and improved.
We should be preparing for a post-American future where the US is just one of the crowd.
Perhaps. But I think that’s a long ways down the road. Russia really is more of a regional than global threat these days. China is rising, but it has a considerable number of endemic problems and is incredibly reliant on the West to keep its economic engine going. It also isn’t without competitors in Asia, and certainly India is hot on its tail.

And really, for all of Donald Trump’s isolationist talk during the election, I’m seeing precious little of it in practice. The last time the US went towards isolationism, at the end of WWI, it did so in a serious way, letting the armed forces wither to some extent. I don’t see much evidence of that now, and even if Trump wanted to, Congress is still dominated by those who have no desire to see the US simply fade away.
 
The idea that the US should determine the future of the rest of the planet is looking rather tawdry, Trump or not.
 
Kaninchen wrote:
We should be preparing for a post-American future where the US is just one of the crowd.

This is outside the U.N. subject but how does one prepare for this as, typically, it comes slowly unless after a major war? I think a “post American future” is too nebulous and, at this point, somewhat meaningless. What is true is that other countries have significantly increased their materials production ability and can find markets that compete well with U.S. goods (clothing and Solar Power are examples). I don’t think this is necessarily negative. Mutual economic inter-dependency promotes peace, historically. Fact is, everyone is connected, whether they know it or not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top