Large families

  • Thread starter Thread starter aball1035
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

aball1035

Guest
I have a friend who says that small families are more better to have than large families (more than 4 kids) because not enough time is spent with each kid. For those of you with large families, what do you think of this?
 
I come from a large family and I can safely say I would MUCH rather have all my siblings than have had more time with the parents when I was younger. My family is awesome and I wouldn’t have it any other way. I have eight siblings and each of them feels the same way. I’ve also noticed that those with big families always seem to be the happiest families.

Big families all the way!
 
I grew up in a family w/ 2 kids and my parents rarely spent time with us. I have a large family and we’re almost always together.

I don’t think the # of children determines how close or how much fun a family has… I think it’s totally individual. I do know though that like the previous poster said, my own children totally love each other and even they comment that the house seems too quiet when a couple of their sibs are gone off somewhere.
 
I’d ask a question in return. Better for what?

Yes, it’s true that in a family with fewer children there is the opportunity for parents to spend more time focusing on an individual child. And in the case of children with certain special issues that can be a good thing.

But it’s a good thing for children to have relationships with the parents as a group rather than as individuals. In fact that is very Catholic. We understand that Christ has a relationship with the Church and we relate to Him primarily through our membership in the Church. Protestants often tend to see Christ relating primarily to the individual.

(None of this is to say that parents should not have individual relationships with their children or that Christ does not have a relationship with the individual.)
 
I was one of a two children family and was always a loner, my brother was 7 years my junior. I longed for a sister to share things with, but never had it. My parents were always too busy for children, Dad was a Chemist and Mom was a home maker but the home was all she had time for, every thing had to be spotless.

When I got married my husband and I wanted 13 children, but were only blessed with 7. We were always happy. There were always stories to tell and times to share. My husband and I don’t have a spotless house, but we have beautiful children and lots of memories. They are all grown up now and we have 25 grandchildren and 1 great grandchild.

I thank God every day for our large family.
 
I’ve said this before in ‘small vs large’ family threads, and I’ll say it again: It depends on the parenting. It is entirely possible for kids to be neglected in terms of one-on-one time with their parents in BOTH large and small families. It is also entirely possible for parents to make that sort of thing a priority and make sure they spend some time with each child, whether they have 2 or 12. It always comes back to the parenting.
 
I’ve said this before in ‘small vs large’ family threads, and I’ll say it again: It depends on the parenting. It is entirely possible for kids to be neglected in terms of one-on-one time with their parents in BOTH large and small families. It is also entirely possible for parents to make that sort of thing a priority and make sure they spend some time with each child, whether they have 2 or 12. It always comes back to the parenting.
I definitely agree. It is a matter of the parenting that takes place.
I come from a large family. I was very much a tomboy growing up. It was one day when I was outside playing that I realized an advantage I had over my friends from smaller families. Every Saturday, there were chores to be done. I watched as my brothers worked together to clean the upstairs windows. While my friends may have had more material goods, cooperation is imperative in a large family. I learned many things from my brothers.
My best friend was an only child.
Not knowing how many children I would have, I was careful with my only child to treat her the same as I would if she had siblings. In other words, I did not simply give her everything she wanted. She learned to share at an early age. Instilling values is more important than the material goods that smaller families may have.
 
I say Hogwash!!! I have seen parents with one child neglect that child and spend minimal time with them, and I have seen parents with 6 kids give all their kids the love and attention they need. Also kids from larger families learn that that they can count on their other family member for support, love & attention as much as they can count on their parents. Each family is different and only a husband and wife can discern how big their family should be!
 
I grew up as one of three. My parents tried to spend time with us, but mostly as a group.

I have five children, and I know, because they have told me so, that my children greatly prefer having a large number of siblings. They love always having someone to play with, and the babies are our family treasure. Daughter #3 was trying to convince me the other day that we need three more children. “I want us to have eight children, Mama,” she said. I loved the “us.” 😉 They consider the babies “theirs” as much as “Mama and Daddy’s”. They often spoke pityingly even of their cousins, who had only three kids in each family.

I guess I rubbed off on my Protestant sisters, though. They’re both expecting their fourth. 👍
 
I grew up as one of three. My parents tried to spend time with us, but mostly as a group.

I have five children, and I know, because they have told me so, that my children greatly prefer having a large number of siblings. They love always having someone to play with, and the babies are our family treasure. Daughter #3 was trying to convince me the other day that we need three more children. “I want us to have eight children, Mama,” she said. I loved the “us.” 😉 They consider the babies “theirs” as much as “Mama and Daddy’s”. They often spoke pityingly even of their cousins, who had only three kids in each family.

I guess I rubbed off on my Protestant sisters, though. They’re both expecting their fourth. 👍
My youngest brother shared how I was his. It is a common practice to “give” the baby to one of his/her siblings to care for. Obviously this is partly to keep the sibling from feeling left out. The parents still maintain primary responsibility. New babies often get all the attention and it is important to acknowledge the “big brother/sister.”
 
**When I got married my husband and I wanted 13 children, but were only blessed with 7. **
See, this is why I love CAF… 👍

We have eight so far and would love more. As more eloquent people than I have already noted, it’s about parenting and priorities, not the number of children.

My oldest has special needs. While some people would “ideally” have had him raised as an only, or with only one other sibling, I think it’s worked beautifully for him in the long run. He has social difficulties due to Asperger’s Syndrome (along with other issues) and the constant exposure to the range of ages, interests and temperaments amongst his siblings has been enormously beneficial to him. I think he would have far more social difficulties if he’d been raised an only child.

Best,

Margaret

PS It utterly cracks me up that I’ve been relegated back to “Junior Status.” No idea what it would take to “move up” again in the CAF world, and I don’t really care, but perhaps could I get a few years lopped off my age to go with the status demotion??? 😃
 
I only have one sibling (well, three if you count my half-siblings) , an older brother. Honestly the bond I have with my brother is the one I cherish above all other relationships in my family. I agree that neglect can occur just as easily in a small family as a big one, it totally depends on the parents. I’ve heard of kids who felt neglected in big families because they were the oldest or something of that sort, and at the same time I’ve heard of kids with two or three siblings who felt neglected because one of their siblings was “the favorite.” I don’t plan on ever having a family of my own, let alone a big one, but I certainly think it would be wrong to assume many children automatically equals neglect.
 
I grew up in the middle of six brothers. They were and are my best friends. When the sixth child in the family was born we found ourselves in the middle of some serious medical issues and my parents had to balance us with the little fella who lived in the hospital, and the way it turned out we didn’t see them nearly as much as we would have liked for a good period of time. But though they couldn’t often spend real time with us, and certainly not give each one of us individual attention on a regular basis, it had no negative effects on our relationship. We learned to suffer together as a family, and grew astoundingly close… closer, I think, than if we had continued to live the quiet and peaceful life.

So, yup, I’m a gal from a large family. If I get married I hope that God will bless me with many little ones, because through times thick and thin I have never regretted any of my siblings or wished for one less (still wish, in fact, that there could be more). I love 'em, and I thank God for them. 👍
My oldest has special needs. While some people would “ideally” have had him raised as an only, or with only one other sibling, I think it’s worked beautifully for him in the long run. He has social difficulties due to Asperger’s Syndrome (along with other issues) and the constant exposure to the range of ages, interests and temperaments amongst his siblings has been enormously beneficial to him. I think he would have far more social difficulties if he’d been raised an only child.
This is so true. Our little fella who had the medical issues is a special needs kid… he had a stroke when he was a baby, and along with physically handicapping him it set him back mentally. We’ve always been homeschooled, and some of his therapists were concerned that the home education was going to hold him back.

Not with all those older siblings!

Though the therapy was appreciated just because he enjoyed it if for nothing else, it wasn’t what taught him how to talk after all those years. He learned how to talk because he learned how to sing first… he would sit and listen while daddy played the guitar, and his fascination with music made him very, very attentive when his older siblings sang him old folk songs. He learned how to sing Brennan on the Moor and it moved him from baby talk to stringing words together to form genuine sentences. It was awfully cute; I wish I could remember it all better! 😃

He learned to do so much, and he progressed so much physically and mentally, just because he wanted to do the things that his big brothers did. He was in his family, and that meant he was in an environment that was totally accepting of him, without any reserve. I blink a little even now when people make mention of the fact that he’s a special needs boy… I get so used to seeing him simply as a unique individual that it surprises me. Eh? He’s different? Doesn’t every family have an Aidan? 😉

Yes, I’m grateful for my large family not just because of how they formed me, but how they formed him.
 
I say Hogwash!!! I have seen parents with one child neglect that child and spend minimal time with them, and I have seen parents with 6 kids give all their kids the love and attention they need. Also kids from larger families learn that that they can count on their other family member for support, love & attention as much as they can count on their parents. Each family is different and only a husband and wife can discern how big their family should be!
I know a number of families with 6 or more children. There are a couple of those families that the parents never spend time with the children. They are too busy working, keeping house and the like to really spend time with the children. Then there are a few that seem to truly enjoy spending time with their children. I see the mom out with one or two children shopping or having lunch or going to the movies. Or I will see the dad doing the same thing.

You get the same thing with families that have one or two children.

It really just depends on the parents.
 
See, this is why I love CAF… 👍

We have eight so far and would love more. As more eloquent people than I have already noted, it’s about parenting and priorities, not the number of children.

My oldest has special needs. While some people would “ideally” have had him raised as an only, or with only one other sibling, I think it’s worked beautifully for him in the long run. He has social difficulties due to Asperger’s Syndrome (along with other issues) and the constant exposure to the range of ages, interests and temperaments amongst his siblings has been enormously beneficial to him. I think he would have far more social difficulties if he’d been raised an only child.

Best,

Margaret

PS It utterly cracks me up that I’ve been relegated back to “Junior Status.” No idea what it would take to “move up” again in the CAF world, and I don’t really care, but perhaps could I get a few years lopped off my age to go with the status demotion??? 😃
My older grandson has Asperger’s. His little brother (diagnosed at 99% ADHD) will intentionally egg him on which is not necessarily the safest thing to do. On the other hand sometimes he shows some astute insight. In order to get his little brother to take a bath, he said,“Nobody will play with you if you’re stinky. I might like that but you wouldn’t.” We gave him All Cats Have Asperger’s. As he looked through the book, he kept repeating “Yes, that’s me.” My daughter believes in early intervention.
 
I loved reading the responses so far… definitely agree that it is about parenting and priorities rather than a set “number” of children a family can handle.

It’s good to remember that we don’t measure with the same stick as the “world.” We are called to weigh our decisions about everything (from how we spend money to how we dress to how many children we welcome into our family) by God’s standards. We have such wonderful guidance from our Mother Church and sacred Scripture. We can also spend a lot of time in prayer and discernment for what God wants from us. We should NEVER simply go with “popular opinion” as our moral compass!

My husband and I are expecting our fourth at ages 28 and 29, and we are truly hoping that God has many more children to bless us with in the future. 😃
 
I grew up in a large family, and I loved having siblings to share with 🙂 It was just a two child family, my brother and me, for about 9 years. We were best buddies. And then when I was 10 and he was 9, my mom started having more kids again (weirdo hormones/PCOS) and we got 4 more 🙂 And that was even more fun…to play with all the kids and share toys and have somebody to take care of, more people to share in your joys, more people to beg for your Easter candy that you’re hoarding, more voices when we sing Christmas songs, more jokes, more of everything except money!

But for all that other people say of "spacing to save money’ or “limit # of kids to maintain sanity”…I find that that’s a flawed argument. # of kids does nothing to your sanity, better or worse. God will give you the number of kids you can handle! 😃 And as for money, God will provide. Yes, money is trickier with larger families, but things always work out. Usually it’s a matter of buying store-brand vs name brand, Walmart vs LL Bean, basic cable vs satellite TV, etc…

I definitely want four kids 🙂 More would be nice, but 4 sounds right to me 🙂 It’s a happy medium between my family with 6 kids, and fiance’s family with 2. As my mom would always say about dessert, “one for each paddy”. Kids are sweet, so “one for each paddy” would be great.

(paddy does not equal Irish! 😃 Little baby hands are like little paws, the little pads on the dog paws. And you need a cookie per hand, so a cookie per “paddy” It came from when my sister was little, Mom would give her one cookie, and she would hold it, and look at her other hand, which was empty. She wanted both hands to hold cookies…but then when she got older, she got smart and started holding as many cookies in one hand and wanting the same for the other hand!)
 
I grew up in the middle of six brothers. They were and are my best friends. When the sixth child in the family was born we found ourselves in the middle of some serious medical issues and my parents had to balance us with the little fella who lived in the hospital, and the way it turned out we didn’t see them nearly as much as we would have liked for a good period of time. But though they couldn’t often spend real time with us, and certainly not give each one of us individual attention on a regular basis, it had no negative effects on our relationship. We learned to suffer together as a family, and grew astoundingly close… closer, I think, than if we had continued to live the quiet and peaceful life.

So, yup, I’m a gal from a large family. If I get married I hope that God will bless me with many little ones, because through times thick and thin I have never regretted any of my siblings or wished for one less (still wish, in fact, that there could be more). I love 'em, and I thank God for them. 👍

This is so true. Our little fella who had the medical issues is a special needs kid… he had a stroke when he was a baby, and along with physically handicapping him it set him back mentally. We’ve always been homeschooled, and some of his therapists were concerned that the home education was going to hold him back.

Not with all those older siblings!

Though the therapy was appreciated just because he enjoyed it if for nothing else, it wasn’t what taught him how to talk after all those years. He learned how to talk because he learned how to sing first… he would sit and listen while daddy played the guitar, and his fascination with music made him very, very attentive when his older siblings sang him old folk songs. He learned how to sing Brennan on the Moor and it moved him from baby talk to stringing words together to form genuine sentences. It was awfully cute; I wish I could remember it all better! 😃

He learned to do so much, and he progressed so much physically and mentally, just because he wanted to do the things that his big brothers did. He was in his family, and that meant he was in an environment that was totally accepting of him, without any reserve. I blink a little even now when people make mention of the fact that he’s a special needs boy… I get so used to seeing him simply as a unique individual that it surprises me. Eh? He’s different? Doesn’t every family have an Aidan? 😉

Yes, I’m grateful for my large family not just because of how they formed me, but how they formed him.
What a wonderful story! Every family should be so lucky to have an Aidan. And to think that many adults would not only want “so many kids”, many would not want one with special needs, when time after time, I read and hear stories like yours about how much that special child taught their families and how they wouldn’t trade him for the world.

Why don’t people get it? If there’s “not enough love and time to go around”, then why would anyone have more than one baby? The second one would be taking time away from the first. What is the magic number, in people’s minds, that amounts to too many kids? If four is okay, then why not five? Is it that big of a difference?

We have 7. If we had 2, or 4, I might have a full time job now. How does that amount to more time with my kids? People fill their lives until they’re full. Maybe it would be travel, education, or jobs, but they don’t necessarily spend the extra time with their kids.
 
My daughter asked me over the weekend, why we didn’t have more children. I told her that had God chosen to bless me with more children, I would have been thrilled. I feel for her as she is an only child. It can be lonely and as an adult she will not have siblings helping her through the adult trials she will face (dying parents, etc.). I have a brother and a sister and they are my best friends. They’ve been with me through thick and thin and will stand by me no matter what and vice versa.

I agree that it’s the parenting that matters. It seems to be the case with all the “parenting” issues actually, whether to have a 2 working parent household, whether to breastfeed/use formula, whether to home school or send kids to school, public v. catholic school,…it all comes down to the parenting skills that the parents have. We do the very best we can for our own families. That may not be the same things that another set of parents would do, but that doesn’t make it wrong. The goal is to raise children to be young adults who can contribute to society in a positive way in whatever way they are capable of contributing all with the ultimate goal of glorifying God.
 
I have a friend who says that small families are more better to have than large families (more than 4 kids) because not enough time is spent with each kid. For those of you with large families, what do you think of this?
My thoughts: Your friend is entitled to his/her opinion, but I question how your friend arrived at this opinion. On what basis does your friend conclude that parents with an arbitrary number of children don’t spend “enough time” with their children, while parents with fewer do? How does your friend define “enough time”?

The idea of limiting children for the sake providing more parental attention seems based in sibling rivalry along with a limited ability to think much into the future. Large families usually don’t have their children all at once. The oldest children are born into smaller families. As the older children grow up and move out, the number of children living at home “shrinks”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top