Stephen168
New member
Do you mean his claim to be Catholic and not Mormon? Or his claim to know something about Catholicism?It’s things like this that make Catholics doubt your claims.
Do you mean his claim to be Catholic and not Mormon? Or his claim to know something about Catholicism?It’s things like this that make Catholics doubt your claims.
Everything you say, that is contained in the bible (with proper interpretation) is true, but such must be a true revelation via the True Church. It must be in scriptural prophecy. Sadly, after Christ, the only prophets mentioned in scripture are 'false prophets". It was into the age of false prophets that Joseph Smith was born. I cannot and will not place my eternity and my relationship with God on the claimed revelation of one man - one self-proclaimed prophet in 1800s America – especially one man whose claimed “revelation” has completely and irrevocably changed the very nature and substance of God. No deal.Indeed, He is on the side of anyone who follows the Savior, and the Savior is a larger Light and a larger Truth than is encompassed in any one religion. “Every knee shall bow and every tongue confess”–that is how large the sweep of the Savior’s saving and redeeming power is. Gospel truths are given as those who desire them, seek them. As in “seek, and ye shall find. Knock, and it shall be opened.” (The reverse is also true.)
(By the way, that “Missionary Commission” may have been singular to your particular mission, since I know many missionaries and was one also and have never heard that used.)
To believe that the Millennium will really happen, is to believe that the Bible is really true, and during the Millennium there will indeed be a time when “the earth shall be full of the knowledge of the Lord, as the waters cover the seas.” There are those of us who look forward to that day, and understand that it is being accomplished in the Lord’s own way and on His own timetable, and it will never be perceived by those who have a “dream of a night vision” and when they awaken, they find that the success they thought they were dreaming about was not the reality. It will come as a surprise, and fulfill the prophecies of Isaiah, of Jeremiah, and of Daniel.
What might that tell you?I have never understood why Mormons have never used the word Christian. Granted they use the name of Jesus in the title of their church, but even from the very beginnings of their church I have never heard that they took the name Christian.
Of course, there is also the part about polygamy, racial discrimination, God being once a man, the Father having a body of flesh and bone, denial of the Trinity, rejection of the creeds, a man sticking his face in a hat and reading crystals, co-eternal “intelligences”, co-eternal matter, heaven cosnisting of ruling over your own planet and creating spirit children for eternity, etc., etc… That might have something to do with it.This criticism of not being Christians seems to have created a true wound for them and one they won’t let go of. I wonder what I would feel if someone said you may believe that Jesus was and is the promised Messiah, is the Son of God, that he died for for all the sins of humanity, was raised from the dead, sits on the right hand of the Father, and will return one day, BUT you are certainly NOT a Christian! I think I would feel wounded too. How do you think you would feel?
Both, though more the first.Do you mean his claim to be Catholic and not Mormon? Or his claim to know something about Catholicism?
Po18guy,Everything you say, that is contained in the Bible (with proper interpretation) is true, but such must be a true revelation via the True Church. It must be in scriptural prophecy. Sadly, after Christ, the only prophets mentioned in scripture are 'false prophets". It was into the age of false prophets that Joseph Smith was born. I cannot and will not place my eternity and my relationship with God on the claimed revelation of one man - one self-proclaimed prophet in 1800s America – especially one man whose claimed “revelation” has completely and irrevocably changed the very nature and substance of God. No deal.
Another thing that bothers me greatly is the constant switching back and forth between the Bible and BoM. One refutes the other. One has mountains of evidence - the other only man’s word. Choose one, but don’t play both sides of the fence. To me, that is being double-tongued.
Take a quick look at Matthew 5:17 in which Jesus states clearly that He fulfilled not only the law,* but the prophets*. All after Him are, by implication, false. Fulfillment is completion. He speaks of the future false prophets as “leading even the elect astray”. This is why the Catholic Church declares that public revelation closed with the death of the last Apostle. Other faiths continue on, with a succession of disagreeing ‘prophets’. We are clearly in the age of false prophets. I view any religion as false that needs a prophet in addition to Jesus. The Lord promised no prophet after Jesus. Of course, you hold to a different Jesus than Christians do - this much is shown by the drastic difference in very substance of the Mormon “Jesus”. The “hidden in a field” was a parable relating to the finding of a spiritual good. No “golden plates”, no “reformed Egyptian”, no “America”, no “19th century” is ever mentioned. Only false prophets are mentioned.The Bible was given to the world for its betterment, and there are those who are seeking the hidden treasures and hidden wisdom that the Bible repeatedly speaks about, who will find those hidden treasures as well, but only through seeking and not if they seek them in the world’s way. The world’s way “has mountains of evidence”. The Lord’s way “is hidden in a field”. People pass by and notice it not, or turn their backs on it, or scorn and belittle it, because it is not shown to them “in the world’s way” nor will it be found “in the world’s way.” You might want to look up the word “prophet” through any word search tool in an on-line Bible, and if you do you will find that the world “prophet” was not applicable to “only false prophets” after Christ.
Nowhere in the New Testament is anyone encouraged to look forward to any prophet or prophets. Quite the contrary, even Jesus, and especially Jesus, warned to watch for false prophets.Prophets are only helps in following after Him, just as the apostles taught. Christ’s message is that there is indeed a “gospel way” of doing things that is not the way of the world, and that brings inner peace and the knowledge of having found the “pearl of great price” (Matthew 13:46).
The bible is clear that God is One and there is no other beside Him. The bible is clear that Jesus is in God and God is in Jesus; that Jesus always existed as co-eternal. I would expect the LDS to read the bible 180º differently, because of the different nature and substance of the LDS God, ‘Jesus’ and holy spirit.The Bible is clear that it is not the only place in the world where the gospel message was found or will be found. (But it also gives clues that there will be hidden treasures of gospel knowledge for those who seek them with all their hearts, with pure intent.)
Greater than peace is the truth. Peace, while desirable for its own sake, does not set you free. Only the truth does that (John 8:32).A wish of peace to all. The gospel you have is the gospel you desire, and that is as it should be for each of us. What we gain from the gospel is what our free will choice brings us to seek after.
Thank you for your post. The very spirit with which you talk about the Church is the Spirit with which I pray we all can live the teachings of Christ. It is filled with peace and love; completely absent of anger; and allows others to see come of the beauty of the Catholic Church. If we all followed your example the result would be that we would throw wide the doors of the Church and all would flow unto it. Your words teach truth and invite others to find out more.I am committed. I am around many other committed Catholics here in Utah. You are around them right now as well. What astounds me about the Catholics I surround myself with is their spirituality. When I am with them we speak about many things spiritually.
And this is coming from one who once believed Catholics to be cold. You see the first few times I attended Mass they did not all come up to me to welcome me as if I was the most important person in the room. Or a fish to be caught. No I had to get out of myself and turn to them. In this I found the warmest, most loving people I have ever known. My conversion did not come by way of a plan that was going to make my life better, more comfortable, more blessed, rather it came by way of falling in love with Jesus.
No one tells us what we should be doing; we pretty much go with the flow of life. My life consists of before I go to confession, while I am in Confession, then after Confession until I return again. It keeps me close to Jesus so that I can be a better servant for Him as good works is always about Him, never about us. We get to share in His life and this is the best gift we as Christians will ever have been gifted.
Knowing that the Catholic Church is the most charitable organization on earth should tell you something. Not to many Catholics boast on this fact because boasting is a great sin. I bring it because you have brought it. I once asked a Priest for help, he asked what do you need. He gave me what I needed. When I went to embrace him he turned and walked away giving praise to God. I did not recognize this as sin then, giving praise to a man who knew where all praise goes. These are just some of the reasons I love being Catholic. It’s deep in truth, truth about our sin, a great place to take it. The Church gave me a good sense of the Holy Trinity. I know who I am, I know who I am not.
Here is one that I work with as to the RCIA. Take the time to read this. It may open your eyes.
http://utahmission.com/pages/Here_I_am.html
You seem to have a problem?!? You who claim to have read John Paul II’s Encyclical Letter, “Fides et Ratio” and completely missed the entire meaning that when Reason fails Faith must guide us. Then you had the sheer audacity that only ignorance can provide continue to accuse me of distorting John Paul II’s words.Do you mean his claim to be Catholic and not Mormon? Or his claim to know something about Catholicism?
Hi, again, Po18guy,Take a quick look at Matthew 5:17 in which Jesus states clearly that He fulfilled not only the law,* but the prophets*. All after Him are, by implication, false. Fulfillment is completion. He speaks of the future false prophets as “leading even the elect astray”. This is why the Catholic Church declares that public revelation closed with the death of the last Apostle. Other faiths continue on, with a succession of disagreeing ‘prophets’. We are clearly in the age of false prophets. I view any religion as false that needs a prophet in addition to Jesus. The Lord promised no prophet after Jesus…
From your own KJV (blue mine): Matthew 11:13-15 “For all the prophets and the law prophesied until John. And if ye will receive it, this is Elias, which was for to come. (Remember that Elias/Elijah was to ‘restore all things’) He that hath ears to hear, let him hear.”
Does the LDS “Jesus” need additional prophets to get his message across? Did he fail in some way? This, I cannot understand.
Nowhere in the New Testament is anyone encouraged to look forward to any prophet or prophets. Quite the contrary, even Jesus, and especially Jesus, warned to watch for false prophets.
Jesus being truly the Only Begotten Son of God does not make Him of a “different substance” than God the Father. It means God the Father was literally His Father, which is why He had the power to resurrect Himself and had the bodily strength to endure the pains of the infinite atonement for all of our sins and all of our pains and afflictions.Of course, you hold to a different Jesus than Christians do - this much is shown by the drastic difference in very substance of the Mormon “Jesus”. The “hidden in a field” was a parable relating to the finding of a spiritual good. No “golden plates”, no “reformed Egyptian”, no “America”, no “19th century” is ever mentioned. Only false prophets are mentioned.
Yes, and in every such case of Biblical teaching, Jehovah (Jesus Christ, the Messiah Himself) is speaking, which is why it speaks of Him being the Savior, and why Jesus said “I Am that I AM.” There is no other Savior beside Him. He is the only Savior.The Bible is clear that God is One and there is no other beside Him.
Yes, and They are one just as Jesus prayed in His intercessory prayer, and we are to be “one” also and be “made perfect in one” and be “one in us”. (John 17:21-23)The Bible is clear that Jesus is in God and God is in Jesus
The Latter-day Saints believe and teach that Jesus always existed and is co-eternal. There is a distinction in that by saying He is the Only Begotten of the Father, Latter-day Saints acknowledge that He did have a Spirit Birth as the First Born Spirit, but that yet He was already in existence before that Spirit Birth, and was “in the bosom of the Father”.that Jesus always existed as co-eternal.
Yes, I love those verses, which is to say “If ye continue in my word, then are ye my disciples indeed; and ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.”Greater than peace is the truth. Peace, while desirable for its own sake, does not set you free. Only the truth does that (John 8:32).
Hi, KathleenGee,Parker,
You did not address the specifics SteveVH addressed to JeanMichael…the difficulties in accepting Mormonism.
Scriptural history reveals God coming to us in various ways…how He came to Abraham, Moses, the prophets…a burning bush, a voice, the Pillar of Fire leading the Jews and the parting of the Red Sea, coming in the gentle breeze…light, fire, water, wind, breeze, His voice, the theophany of God at Christ’s baptism and the appearance of the dove in the Holy Spirit before St. John the Baptist and his followers, up to Christ Himself.
Surely you don’t dispute the possibility of records being kept on a metallic surface with inscribed writings?Smith’s claim of looking into a hat, referring to golden plates and to a some lost tribe in America…these types of medium
Indeed, not using a creed that is neither in the Bible nor is directly Biblical and is thus “another gospel.”, as well as a different creed
Masonry said they got their “rituals” from the builders of Solomon’s temple, so it should really come as no surprise that there might be similarities although not exactly the same or be used in the same way. That is how “apostasy” happens–with small incremental changes from an original source that was pure.and secret rituals reflecting Masonry
The Jews as a people rejected their Messiah, all because their leaders scoffed at Him and rejected His teachings or even the possibility that they could be wrong.and a different practice and exclusiveness other than how God has come to the Jewish people
Which is what I have suggested over and over that people should do, is look at their own heart and seek Him with all their heart and with all their mind and with all their soul.what Christ Himself professed and directed us to look at our own hearts
Which is a different teaching than the apostles taught, in that they taught the Holy Spirit should be with each person on a personal, individual basis.The Holy Spirit continues through the Church.