Lesbian Parenting Study

  • Thread starter Thread starter GiannaElizabeth
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Adam 1986,

I left this thread for a while and I totally agree with your perspective.

There is a lesbian couple in my neighbourhood and they are hippie types…strange people. It’s not b/c they are gay…they are just strange. They have two kids. These two kids are loved very much by mom and mom.

Are they better off in their home than having an abusive mother and father? Absolutely!!!
Thats a silly statement.

If kids have a Mom and a Mom they more than likely going to be psychologically abused.

If kids have a Mom and a Dad they are more likely to be well adjusted.

Out of all living beings with a blood pumping heart only some humans want to change what mother nature intended.
 
Thats a silly statement.

If kids have a Mom and a Mom they more than likely going to be psychologically abused.
How so? Why?
If kids have a Mom and a Dad they are more likely to be well adjusted
. All humans have a mother and a father. And most parents are non-abusive. Including most gay parents. What is silly is your prejudice, which is not based on any statistics in contemporary parenting studies. If you have any empirical data to suggest that gay parents do a worse job than straight ones, then I might be persuaded to conclude that there is a difference in parenting according to sexual orientation. Until then, I will not assume that there is any, and I will assume that a loving role model of either gender or either orientation can raise a child as well and between the expected outcomes from good to bad of the history of hetero-parenting performance.
 
Well having been raised in a Catholic family with a Mother and a Father in a stable relationship and now having a daughter with same sex attraction I would say your comments are" warped ".
Huh? How are my comments warped? I was replying to someone else’s faulty logic.
 
JRPO, while you are completely entitled to your opinion, you shouldn’t call other opinions “silly” or “warped”. It’s just not nice.
 
I think for a child, the best parents are his or her parents. That is going to be one man and one woman. If either of those parents, either by death, illness, the choice to sin, or other adverse happenings, cannot carry out their role, then they can’t, but at that point the child is effectively orphaned and the one remaining parent or other adults have to be found to fill that role. People have functioned heroically in that position, but that is not the ideal.

It is another kettle of fish to choose to have a child out of wedlock in order to have a child to enjoy with your lover instead of raising the child with the child’s other true parent. I think that is profoundly self-centered and profoundly wrong. Can a child learn to accept this as a part of life? Certainly. Should a child be put in that position to suit some fantasy scenario of adults? No.
The above post thoroughly sums up my position on this topic

As to the following:
]Well, it’s a good thing that our rights and freedoms are not predicated upon your standards for law, or many of our freedoms would be taken away.
There’s no constitional right to an arbitrary definition of marriage, or a right to exclude one gender. Nor are “our rights and freedoms” contingent upon unique, stylish, faddish, or idiosyncratic re-definitions of social institutions. All rights and freedoms are contextualized within the rights and freedoms of other human beings and within the organizational needs of governing bodies such as states, counties, and cities. Rights and freedoms are defined and limited; they are not boundless, even in the arguably most free country on earth. Governance implies structure, and a wish is not a “right.” No personal freedoms are being denied to gays. They are free to associate with and love whom they will, free to have protections from discrimination and harrassment. That freedom does not, by civil right, extend to the title of marriage, which is not just theirs to seize arbitrarily.

I also think that, again, EasterJoy sums up my position. (The subject of this thread is not gay marriage per say, but parenting; however, in this country, as I have said often, one status assumes another status.) The gays I respect are those that understand from their own experience and from the life experience of others, that a man/woman parenting couple is the best solution when that is possible. In many states, gays have the right to adopt. Responsible gay couples don’t put themselves out there as necessarily the best option for an orphaned child. They understand that a happy heterosexual couple is the best option. (There are gay posters on CAF who have said the same.) To demand equal priority as a straight couple, in the adoption process, is just selfish, as EJ has pointed out. As to reproductive technologies, that crosses even another line i.m.o. That is not an existent child who needs a home; that is a discretionary option that results in a human being without its natural parents. That is an additional level of selfishness.
 
The above post thoroughly sums up my position on this topic

As to the following:

There’s no constitional right to an arbitrary definition of marriage, or a right to exclude one gender. Nor are “our rights and freedoms” contingent upon unique, stylish, faddish, or idiosyncratic re-definitions of social institutions. All rights and freedoms are contextualized within the rights and freedoms of other human beings and within the organizational needs of governing bodies such as states, counties, and cities. Rights and freedoms are defined and limited; they are not boundless, even in the arguably most free country on earth. Governance implies structure, and a wish is not a “right.” No personal freedoms are being denied to gays. They are free to associate with and love whom they will, free to have protections from discrimination and harrassment. That freedom does not, by civil right, extend to the title of marriage, which is not just theirs to seize arbitrarily.
My point is that law, contrary to what you were arguing before you changed direction, is not based on what is “best”. If it were so, there are many privileges and freedoms we would be denied. Marriage law is NOT based on what is “best,” or many forms of marriages would be denied.

To your subsequent point: there are many laws and privileges on the books today that were not in the Constitution. The current case in CA was based on the test of the 14th Amendment. That right IS foundational.
 
My point is that law, contrary to what you were arguing before you changed direction, is not based on what is “best”.
Yes it is! (As to form, not outcome.) That’s where you’re completely wrong. It doesn’t mean that the outcome is guaranteed. Our governing bodies are not in the business of predicting outcomes. They’re in the business of creating structures, and deciding which structures are, by category, best. It’s clear to me that you really don’t understand much about American law. We do not throw out structures haphazardly based on their being flawed structures in particular cases. Otherwise, public education would have been disassembled long ago.
 
Yes it is! (As to form, not outcome.) That’s where you’re completely wrong. It doesn’t mean that the outcome is guaranteed. Our governing bodies are not in the business of predicting outcomes. They’re in the business of creating structures, and deciding which structures are, by category, best.
No. They are in the business of promoting freedom except where the freedom is demonstrably too injurious. But many potentially injurious freedoms are allowed where a greater good (freedom) is evident. America’s rule basically is that you are free until you hurt someone else. We don’t tell you what clothes to wear, what houses to own, what towns to live in, what people to marry, what religions to join, what books to read, what cults to join, what speeches to make, etc. etc. etc. except and until you demonstrably hurt someone else. The GOOD or BEST that is promoted is FREEDOM. All the rest is secondary.
It’s clear to me that you really don’t understand much about American law.
That’s a silly thing to say. I will even claim here that marriage law is NOT the result of any process of deciding what type of pairing is “best.” No other type of pairing has ever been seriously considered. The history of marriage law has nothing to do with this and has to do with religion, biology, child-production, stability, record-keeping, and inheritance.
We do not throw out structures haphazardly based on their being flawed structures in particular cases. Otherwise, public education would have been disassembled long ago.
You’re right. And I am glad that families have fully legal alternatives with equal weight under the law to public education degrees. Now let’s do the same for marriage.
 
Do you guys think being gay is a sin? If so, how do you explain people who feel that they have been gay all their life?
 
Do you guys think being gay is a sin? If so, how do you explain people who feel that they have been gay all their life?
Being gay in itself is not a sin. The Catholic Church states that a homosexual should remain chaste; not engage in marriage or sexual intercourse with the same sex. Further more, the Church states that raising chidren in same-sex households is wrong and sinful.

While I agree that the best outcome is for a child to have a mother and father whom are married, I still tend to agree that a child is better off with same sex parents than an abusive heterosexual household.

If someone said to me: here is Johnnie. He will be sexually abused by his mother if he’s with his birth mother. His father will be an alcoholic who will beat him. He has one other opportunity; to be adopted by a very loving gay couple.

I would say objectively that Johnnie is better off with the gay family.

Having said that, I feel that a child is better off with a loving mother and father than a loving gay couple. I just think that children learn different (important) things from their mother and father while growing up. I see it with my own children already and they are still very young.

However, Larkin is also right to some extent that yes, children can turn out very well adapted having been raised in a same-sex household. Is it sinful? Yes. Is it detrimental to the child’s happiness to be in a heterosexual household? No.
 
Being gay in itself is not a sin. The Catholic Church states that a homosexual should remain chaste; not engage in marriage or sexual intercourse with the same sex. Further more, the Church states that raising chidren in same-sex households is wrong and sinful.

While I agree that the best outcome is for a child to have a mother and father whom are married, I still tend to agree that a child is better off with same sex parents than an abusive heterosexual household.

If someone said to me: here is Johnnie. He will be sexually abused by his mother if he’s with his birth mother. His father will be an alcoholic who will beat him. He has one other opportunity; to be adopted by a very loving gay couple.

I would say objectively that Johnnie is better off with the gay family.

Having said that, I feel that a child is better off with a loving mother and father than a loving gay couple. I just think that children learn different (important) things from their mother and father while growing up. I see it with my own children already and they are still very young.

However, Larkin is also right to some extent that yes, children can turn out very well adapted having been raised in a same-sex household. Is it sinful? Yes. Is it detrimental to the child’s happiness to be in a heterosexual household? No.
If being gay is an abomination, why on earth would god make them be born that way? That is one thing that I really don’t understand. To me, thats like god tricking them and messing with their life.
 
If being gay is an abomination, why on earth would god make them be born that way? That is one thing that I really don’t understand. To me, thats like god tricking them and messing with their life.
The Catholic view is that it’s a cross to bear. In all honesty, I don’t understand it either.

I also don’t understand why beautiful children are born from crack addicts, etc.

Our questions will be answered one day in Heaven.
 
The Catholic view is that it’s a cross to bear. In all honesty, I don’t understand it either.

I also don’t understand why beautiful children are born from crack addicts, etc.

Our questions will be answered one day in Heaven.
What do you mean by a cross to bear?
so the catholics do believe they were born gay? I just don’t understand why god would allow that? that means their whole life on finding love in a gay relationship is pointless. that would be such a hard life to live though, dont ya think? Not being able to fall in love when you want to? A chaste relationship? I don’t think homosexuals in love would remain chaste for very long. They would think ‘this is who i am, god must except me for who i am’.
 
What do you mean by a cross to bear?
so the catholics do believe they were born gay? I just don’t understand why god would allow that? that means their whole life on finding love in a gay relationship is pointless. that would be such a hard life to live though, dont ya think? Not being able to fall in love when you want to? A chaste relationship? I don’t think homosexuals in love would remain chaste for very long. They would think ‘this is who i am, god must except me for who i am’.
Then those people would likely become protestant. Who am I to say what is right. I am just going by Catholic teachings.

Everyone deserves happiness. It’s a very tough cross to bear for sure and they would be rewarded in Heaven.
 
Then those people would likely become protestant. Who am I to say what is right. I am just going by Catholic teachings.

Everyone deserves happiness. It’s a very tough cross to bear for sure and they would be rewarded in Heaven.
That doesn’t answer my question. Are people born gay?
 
That doesn’t answer my question. Are people born gay?
we don’t know. the origins, causation, and development of sexuality and very complex. We don’t know yet exactly why anyone is what they are, gay, straight, or otherwise.
 
If being gay is an abomination, why on earth would god make them be born that way? That is one thing that I really don’t understand. To me, thats like god tricking them and messing with their life.
You can’t say that such and so way of being is intrinsically good because some people are born that way. People are born with all sorts of disorders. Besides, we’re all born in original sin. Rather, any way of being is the stuff on which grace can work. That’s the kind of “messing with” that God does.

I’d put it the other way, actually: It is something for everybody. I expect that the people with the hardest path are judged with the most liberal use of mercy. That would make total sense, even on the elementary level of justice that we can understand. I think you just do your best and do what you can to help as many souls to heaven as you can.
 
You can’t say that such and so way of being is intrinsically good because some people are born that way. People are born with all sorts of disorders. Besides, we’re all born in original sin. Rather, any way of being is the stuff on which grace can work. That’s the kind of “messing with” that God does.

I’d put it the other way, actually: It is something for everybody. I expect that the people with the hardest path are judged with the most liberal use of mercy. That would make total sense, even on the elementary level of justice that we can understand. I think you just do your best and do what you can to help as many souls to heaven as you can.
But it doesn’t make sense! Being colored or disabled or mentally disabled is NOT a sin. So why would god allow people to be born gay when their lifestyle IS a sin. There is no other thing in the bible that says the way somebody is born is a sin, except for being gay. It makes no sense! :confused:
 
But it doesn’t make sense! Being colored or disabled or mentally disabled is NOT a sin. So why would god allow people to be born gay when their lifestyle IS a sin. There is no other thing in the bible that says the way somebody is born is a sin, except for being gay. It makes no sense! :confused:
What about people that are born with the disease of sociopathic disorder. They are capable of being very violent without any remorse. They feel no empathy. It’s the way they are wired. If they kill someone, they are still sinning even though they are wired to behave that way.

Sorry if this is a poor example.
 
What about people that are born with the disease of sociopathic disorder. They are capable of being very violent without any remorse. They feel no empathy. It’s the way they are wired. If they kill someone, they are still sinning even though they are wired to behave that way.

Sorry if this is a poor example.
And are they born sociopathic or become that way due to some trauma, or neglect etc?

We don’t know what causes homosexual desires, or if the cause is uniform for all.
2357 Homosexuality refers to relations between men or between women who experience an exclusive or predominant sexual attraction toward persons of the same sex. It has taken a great variety of forms through the centuries and in different cultures. Its psychological genesis remains largely unexplained. Basing itself on Sacred Scripture, which presents homosexual acts as acts of grave depravity,141 tradition has always declared that "homosexual acts are intrinsically disordered."142 They are contrary to the natural law. They close the sexual act to the gift of life. They do not proceed from a genuine affective and sexual complementarity. Under no circumstances can they be approved.
2358 The number of men and women who have deep-seated homosexual tendencies is not negligible. This inclination, which is objectively disordered, constitutes for most of them a trial. They must be accepted with respect, compassion, and sensitivity. Every sign of unjust discrimination in their regard should be avoided. These persons are called to fulfill God’s will in their lives and, if they are Christians, to unite to the sacrifice of the Lord’s Cross the difficulties they may encounter from their condition.
2359 Homosexual persons are called to chastity. By the virtues of self-mastery that teach them inner freedom, at times by the support of disinterested friendship, by prayer and sacramental grace, they can and should gradually and resolutely approach Christian perfection.
We are all called to chastity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top