Lesbian Parenting Study

  • Thread starter Thread starter GiannaElizabeth
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We’ve already discussed, ad nauseum, why you believe what you do and why we believe what we do. If you have some further explanation to offer, or a new point to bring up, great. If not, what’s the point in informing us of what we already knew?
What’s the point of having any CA forum when the CCC can suffice? Do you not recognize the prejudicial nature of your questions? Or do you simply not care?

Again, go read the CCC if all you want is the language of dogma. If you would like to speak to other people, even if the position has been stated before (try, “homosexuality is disordered” if you want repetetive statements here).
 
What’s the point of having any CA forum when the CCC can suffice?
Because sometimes discussion can help clarify confusing points of doctrine and aid in understanding.
Do you not recognize the prejudicial nature of your questions? Or do you simply not care?
Prejudicial how? I’m just puzzled as to why you thought it was necessary to state your opinion of homosexual adoption, when it didn’t add anything new to the discussion.
Again, go read the CCC if all you want is the language of dogma.
When did I say all I wanted was dogma?
If you would like to speak to other people, even if the position has been stated before (try, “homosexuality is disordered” if you want repetetive statements here).
I would like discussion and a free exchange of ideas, not “My opinion is X” repeated over and over, as if that will change anyone’s mind. I don’t think anyone here particularly cares what your opinion is; what we would like to know is why you have it and how you justify it to yourself, God, and others. Your comment did not educate anyone on those points.
 
I haven’t read all the posts here but what, indeed, I read was the whole study…not the news. This study was completely BIASED. First, which is acknowledged by the report, the people doing the report sent out questionnaires through 17 years to the mothers and the kids, nevertheless the report was SOLELY based on the mother’s answer. This was my first objection to the report…why? are they hiding the results coming from the kids questionnaires? Is there something the kids are saying that the reporters don’t want to be known?

Just because the information is coming out exclusively from the opinion from the mothers, I don’t think the report is too accurate. This is not based on their academical performance, school reports or nothing, just the mother’s opinion. Do you guys think that the mothers are going to say…yes my kid is having a lot of emotional issues? of course not. This report should be called According to lesbian mothers their kids are coming out better. I bet that had they given the questionnaires to the kids’ friends they would have had a more accurate and non biased result.

On the other hand, the second problem I found while reading the report is that the samples were not properly matched. The group of lesbians that participated in the study were either high middle class/high class educated white women who VOLUNTARILY enrolled in the study. The lesbian women all came out either from Boston, New York or San Francisco. The other group was low class/middle low class heterosexual women from different races (another thing the news got wrong the lesbians weren’t compared to married families, it was simply heterosexual women in all kinds of relationships), who were randomly chosen from anywhere in the country, mostly rural areas, and a big majority had absolutely no education, and many were in unstable relationships. Nobody needs to be a rocket scientist to figure out that between those two groups the economical/educational factor is going to play a major role to determine the outcome and therefore most likely the wealthy kids (which are the lesbian’s kids in this case) are going to do better than the poor kids.

Also, the fact that the lesbian women voluntarily enrolled in the study while the heterosexual women didn’t know about it, that is a major bias because the lesbians do have an interest in the outcome of the study. They know they are being studied, therefore they are not going to behave in the same way as naturally they do and they are going to do everything to get the best outcome. After reading the study, I noticed that the only thing that this study really proves is that children raised by wealthy, educated parents do better that children raised by uneducated parent struggling economically. if they want to do a real study then why don’t they get wealthy, long lasting and loving marriages to compare them to the lesbians? I am sure that results would have been different if that were to be the case.

This study is nothing more but an agenda to convince people that lesbian marriage and lesbian parenting is OK. Just look at the headings of the news, they don’t tell you that the study is based on the mother’s opinion or that is not really married couples…they just say lesbian’s kids fare better…when that not quite exactly what you find in the study, and they are doing a very good job because is amazing how many people are believing that homosexuals can raise children better than married couples.

And to the people in this post saying that lesbians can be great parents I have one question…then WHY THIS STUDY WON’T RELEASE THE RESULTS OBTAINED FROM THE CHILDREN? or is it that the kids are doing not that good after all.
 
No b/c mortal sin requires all 3 criteria to be met. If they don’t KNOW what they are doing is wrong, then they are not in mortal sin.

I don’t agree too much with your reasoning here. I don’t think they “don’t know.” They choose to believe that what they are doing is right which is completely different. When the person doesn’t know means that the person lacks the comprehension and knowledge of the whole situation and acts under lack of knowledge. For example, a three year old kid grabs a toy and walks out of the store with it without paying. The kid doesn’t have the understanding to comprehend the whole situation and doesn’t have the enough information to know that he is stealing, therefore he is not in mortal sin.

But if the person as an adult, has heard about all the arguments, pros and cons with regard to homosexuality, has knowledge and full comprehension of the action, has heard about the church teaching regarding homosexuality and heard people explaining why it might be wrong, and that person makes a conscious decision that the wrong teaching is the one that says that homosexuality is a sin and they are right, then that person is in mortal sin.

If we use that standard that the lesbians don’t know because they don’t think they are doing something wrong then we have to say that Son of Sam or Edward Gain weren’t in mortal sin while killing because they in their brain thought that what they were doing was right and they didn’t know they were in mortal sin. That is why the don’t know doesn’t work that way. If you have full knowledge of the circumstances and with that full knowledge you choose to believe that a mortal sin is not a sin, you are in mortal sin whether you like it or not.
 
Prejudicial how? I’m just puzzled as to why you thought it was necessary to state your opinion of homosexual adoption, when it didn’t add anything new to the discussion.

When did I say all I wanted was dogma?

I would like discussion and a free exchange of ideas, not “My opinion is X” repeated over and over, as if that will change anyone’s mind. I don’t think anyone here particularly cares what your opinion is; what we would like to know is why you have it and how you justify it to yourself, God, and others. Your comment did not educate anyone on those points.
Would you please return to the topic? If you have nothing to say on the topic, and continue to comment only in a negative way about the validity of my presence here, I will report you to a moderator. I think that following the rules is important here, as I myself have had moderators remind me.
 
Would you please return to the topic? If you have nothing to say on the topic, and continue to comment only in a negative way about the validity of my presence here, I will report you to a moderator. I think that following the rules is important here, as I myself have had moderators remind me.
I said nothing about the validity of your presence; I merely questioned the function of your comments.

However, back to the topic at hand, then. You said:
I think that gay parents are fine. Period. No caveats.
Do you also believe this in the case of gay parents who are abusive to the child or children in their care? You said “No caveats,” so I am curious if that is truly your stance.
 
I said nothing about the validity of your presence; I merely questioned the function of your comments.

However, back to the topic at hand, then. You said:

Do you also believe this in the case of gay parents who are abusive to the child or children in their care? You said “No caveats,” so I am curious if that is truly your stance.
It’s hard for me to see how this could possibly be a genuine question.

But I will–this time–hazard to answer.

No: I do not support abusive parents of any sexual orientation, or any religious view, or any gender, or any age, or any profession, or any political party, or any race. Etc.

The “caveat” was a reference to the poster THAT I QUOTED who posted some caveats to his/her support of gays as parents. It did not, of course, mean that gay parents could commit crimes against their children and still have my support. Like most humans on the planet, I am opposed to abuse of children.

So, again, back to the lesbian parenting story and the research into the ACTUAL job that gay parents are able to do…
 
I remember a few years back Rosie O’Donnell confessed that her boy said that he wished he had a dad. No foolin’! We can pretend all we wish that love is all that matters, but we can’t flout God’s law without consequence. I can tell you that all boys CRAVE adult male approval. 😦 Rob
I was raised by a single mother. One time when I was a young teen she tried to take me to a boxing match, I guess so that I can experience something that boys who had fathers might do. I appreciated the effort, but I knew it wasn’t the same.
 
It’s hard for me to see how this could possibly be a genuine question.

But I will–this time–hazard to answer.

No: I do not support abusive parents of any sexual orientation, or any religious view, or any gender, or any age, or any profession, or any political party, or any race. Etc.

The “caveat” was a reference to the poster THAT I QUOTED who posted some caveats to his/her support of gays as parents. It did not, of course, mean that gay parents could commit crimes against their children and still have my support. Like most humans on the planet, I am opposed to abuse of children.

So, again, back to the lesbian parenting story and the research into the ACTUAL job that gay parents are able to do…
Research that is shoddy, biased, and altogether unreliable.
 
Exactly. Firstly in that the mother’s opinion alone isn’t really a greatly objective voice of observation. A child’s opinion, and a neighbour’s opinion would be better.
I was raised by a single mother. One time when I was a young teen she tried to take me to a boxing match, I guess so that I can experience something that boys who had fathers might do. I appreciated the effort, but I knew it wasn’t the same.
I agree; it’s not the same when your mother raises you alone compared to when she had a husband (if she had one). I miss my father. He was loving, caring, expressive, and always there for me and my sister. He was also the only sane person in our family, so obviously it’s not the same without him.

And now I’m alone with my mother and sister… I feel outnumbered. Dear God, please give me the strength to keep me from going mad. :hypno:
 
You’re probably all aware by now that a study was recently published saying, basically, that lesbians make the best parents ever. However, this study, which, of course, the media is shoving down everyone’s throats, was based solely on questions answered by 77 mothers of 78 children – no doctors, teacher, etc. were asked to confirm the answers given by the mothers (who were, don’t you think, maybe a little politically interested?). Anyway, the Ruth Institute, a project of the National Organization for marriage, decided to make its own survey for mothers in heterosexual relationships. Their goal is to get 7,800 reports by Father’s Day – that’s 100 times more than the absurdly small sample size used by the other study. So, moms, please go to the link below and fill out the short survey! 🙂 You can fill it out for each child.

myruth.org/site/c.gpILKXOAJqG/b.6086001/k.8495/Marriage_Quiz_for_June_2010/apps/ka/ct/contactus.asp?c=gpILKXOAJqG&b=6086001&en=7fJLLSMqHfKHLLNvHeIEILMxHiISK0PuFgIQJYOxGgIXIaI

Here are some articles about the Lesbian Parenting Study by Dr. Jennifer Roback Morse, PhD, founder and president of the Ruth Institute.

ruthblog.org/2010/06/11/%25e2%2580%259cchildren-of-lesbians-do-well-8-reasons-why-the-latest-study-doesnt-prove-anything/?tr=y&auid=6486573

ruthblog.org/2010/06/11/3-really-pernicious-messages-behind-the-%25e2%2580%259clesbians-make-better-parents%25e2%2580%259d-story-line/?tr=y&auid=6486574

And here’s the Ruth Institute website:

ruthinstitute.org/?tr=y&auid=6481228

God bless!
I am a gay man and even I will say that I completely disagree that lesbians make the best parents. The best parents are the ones who will care for and love unconditionally their child. I will even go as far as to say in many instances it is better for the child/children to be with a straight couple with the way many LGBT people are persecuted.

However there are many instances in which a homosexual couple would make better parents especially if there is abuse in the home. The situation can of course be reversed as well.

Bottom line there is no best group, just different instances with different outcomes. Also please no one take my comment as pro-homosexual. I’m just stating my opinion only.
 
I am a gay man and even I will say that I completely disagree that lesbians make the best parents. The best parents are the ones who will care for and love unconditionally their child. I will even go as far as to say in many instances it is better for the child/children to be with a straight couple with the way many LGBT people are persecuted.

However there are many instances in which a homosexual couple would make better parents especially if there is abuse in the home. The situation can of course be reversed as well.

Bottom line there is no best group, just different instances with different outcomes. Also please no one take my comment as pro-homosexual. I’m just stating my opinion only.
Adam, I respect your response. However I would like to disagree with this paragraph, and I’ll explain why:
there are many instances in which a homosexual couple would make better parents especially if there is abuse in the home
The response to an unhealthy home environment (if no healthy straight couple is available) is not to replace it with a compromised home environment (which may be healthy in some ways, but equally limiting or unhealthy or artificial in other ways – yielding no real net difference from the child’s previous environment). I.m.o., a better solution would be to replace it with either:

(1) a single, straight parent – male or female – especially if that adopting parent associates often with the opposite gender, has very close friends of that gender, etc.
(2) two straight adults of either gender who relate to each other Platonically – either as friends or as relatives – and who are thus (again) likely to associate with the opposing gender on some regular basis.

Why do I say this? (Other than the reality that children crave parental figures of both genders, and never stop missing that if they never receive it). It’s because one of the critical passages or journeys in becoming fully human is learning how to relate fully to the other gender. One doesn’t have to buy the Catholic view on the importance of biological complementarity in a relationship, in order to appreciate this. Even those who have studied Jung, and those who have studied Eastern religions, see the value in assimilating the male and female principles within our psyches as we develop. That journey cannot be mimicked by adopting superficial gender “roles” in a gay relationship.
 
… It’s because one of the critical passages or journeys in becoming fully human is learning how to relate fully to the other gender. One doesn’t have to buy the Catholic view on the importance of biological complementarity in a relationship, in order to appreciate this. Even those who have studied Jung, and those who have studied Eastern religions, see the value in assimilating the male and female principles within our psyches as we develop. That journey cannot be mimicked by adopting superficial gender “roles” in a gay relationship.
This does not require having two parents of opposite genders, in the same way that understanding this does not require priests to marry (they are prevented, in fact, even from physical relations with women, let alone the learning involved in actual marriage.)

Having loving straight parents is indeed a good thing. Most gays have had this, in fact, as much of the world has. But this, of course, no requirement for anything.
 
The only reason it would seem that they make the best parents is because its two women. I’m not saying a man can’t be good at raising the kids, but mostly the mom during the day is best at it. So if you put two of them together, then you got double mom. See what i mean?

Although I don’t know what catholics think about gay marriage, but I personally believe it’s perverted. but thats just my opinion.
 
This does not require having two parents of opposite genders, in the same way that understanding this does not require priests to marry (they are prevented, in fact, even from physical relations with women, let alone the learning involved in actual marriage.)
False analogy. “Understanding” (intellectually) is not the same thing as (a) parenting and (b) the psychological patterning by the child of the male and female archetypes, which cannot be provided by Catholic priests 🤷 or by a same-sex couple playing around with gender-bending, or any such trivial comparison. I understand, appreciate, love, remember, and intuit a lot about men, but that’s because of my experience with my father principally, not because I’ve read about male/female brain differences in books (which I have, and which material merely confirms my life-long personal experience of undeniable differences between genders. Gender matters, deeply and radically. It matters in terms of brain function, in terms of world view, in terms of approaches to life’s daily needs & problems, and much more.
Having loving straight parents is indeed a good thing. Most gays have had this, in fact, as much of the world has. But this, of course, no requirement for anything.
Says you. Deliberately depriving a child of one gender is actually a cruel thing. And that’s what we’re talking about here: not accidents, but choices to exclude. And since
Having loving straight parents is indeed a good thing [and] Most gays have had this
Same-sex parenting is less than what most gays have had. But they’re perfectly willing, despite the privilege, which you acknolwedge, of having parents of 2 genders, to deprive a child or children of the same privilege.

And they call that “love.” Just amazing.
 
Do catholics actually think gay marriage isn’t a sin?
I can reassure you guys that it IS a sin and god calls it an abomination. However I will not chose to control how somebody lives their life and I won’t ever start. But god does say homosexuality is wrong, so you can’t deny it.
 
I am a gay man and even I will say that I completely disagree that lesbians make the best parents. The best parents are the ones who will care for and love unconditionally their child. I will even go as far as to say in many instances it is better for the child/children to be with a straight couple with the way many LGBT people are persecuted.

However there are many instances in which a homosexual couple would make better parents especially if there is abuse in the home. The situation can of course be reversed as well.

Bottom line there is no best group, just different instances with different outcomes. Also please no one take my comment as pro-homosexual. I’m just stating my opinion only.
I think for a child, the best parents are his or her parents. That is going to be one man and one woman. If either of those parents, either by death, illness, the choice to sin, or other adverse happenings, cannot carry out their role, then they can’t, but at that point the child is effectively orphaned and the one remaining parent or other adults have to be found to fill that role. People have functioned heroically in that position, but that is not the ideal.

It is another kettle of fish to choose to have a child out of wedlock in order to have a child to enjoy with your lover instead of raising the child with the child’s other true parent. I think that is profoundly self-centered and profoundly wrong. Can a child learn to accept this as a part of life? Certainly. Should a child be put in that position to suit some fantasy scenario of adults? No.
 
False analogy. “Understanding” (intellectually) is not the same thing as (a) parenting and (b) the psychological patterning by the child of the male and female archetypes, which cannot be provided by Catholic priests 🤷 or by a same-sex couple playing around with gender-bending, or any such trivial comparison. I understand, appreciate, love, remember, and intuit a lot about men, but that’s because of my experience with my father principally, not because I’ve read about male/female brain differences in books (which I have, and which material merely confirms my life-long personal experience of undeniable differences between genders. Gender matters, deeply and radically. It matters in terms of brain function, in terms of world view, in terms of approaches to life’s daily needs & problems, and much more.

Says you. Deliberately depriving a child of one gender is actually a cruel thing. And that’s what we’re talking about here: not accidents, but choices to exclude. And since

Same-sex parenting is less than what most gays have had. But they’re perfectly willing, despite the privilege, which you acknolwedge, of having parents of 2 genders, to deprive a child or children of the same privilege.

And they call that “love.” Just amazing.
Well, it’s a good thing that our rights and freedoms are not predicated upon your standards for law, or many of our freedoms would be taken away.
 
Which “garbage” do you refer to?

Do you think that people become gay by proximity? He will likely meet some gays in seminary as well.
Well having been raised in a Catholic family with a Mother and a Father in a stable relationship and now having a daughter with same sex attraction I would say your comments are" warped ".
 
Adam 1986,

I left this thread for a while and I totally agree with your perspective.

There is a lesbian couple in my neighbourhood and they are hippie types…strange people. It’s not b/c they are gay…they are just strange. They have two kids. These two kids are loved very much by mom and mom.

Are they better off in their home than having an abusive mother and father? Absolutely!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top