Lesbian Parenting Study

  • Thread starter Thread starter GiannaElizabeth
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
No she’s not b/c heteros who resort to IVF are also going against God’s will b/c they are taking God out of the equation.
I mean heteros who want babies for selfish reasons and conceive through intercourse. It is not the “method” that determines the selfishness. It is the motivation.
 
Why is God not also in the petri dish and the science and human wisdom and skill that goes to making this life?

I consider this a stark hypocrisy based on narrow thinking rather than enlightened reason. Should we also let people die whom God, apparently, has “called” to die?

cut me a break
you are coming at this from a purely humanistic/materialistic viewpoint. You are limiting yourself to the values of this world divorced from the timeless, eternal values of the world to come. Whereas Shanny and Serap and other faithful, practicing Catholics participating in this thread are coming at this from a supernatural viewpoint. Thus, as things currently stand, it will be pretty much impossible for you to both see the value of the gift of life, and to appreciate the mystery and even miraculousness of both the origin of life and its earthly end. That is why this discussion with you will end up a brick wall.

😦
 
I mean heteros who want babies for selfish reasons and conceive through intercourse. It is not the “method” that determines the selfishness. It is the motivation.
WHY would we think it a good idea to give method to a motivation that we know to be wrong??! This makes no sense, and THIS is what would be hypocritical.
 
WHY would we think it a good idea to give method to a motivation that we know to be wrong??! This makes no sense, and THIS is what would be hypocritical.
So, you don’t want to discuss selfish heterosexual motivations for having children.

You ARE giving them a pass.

Hypocrisy in faith was reviled by Jesus in the Gospels. He had special criticism for it.
 
So, you don’t want to discuss selfish heterosexual motivations for having children.

You ARE giving them a pass.

Hypocrisy in faith was reviled by Jesus in the Gospels. He had special criticism for it.
Children are a gift, not a right, and should be treated as such.
 
FWIW I would not give heterosexual couples a ‘pass’. It’s heterosexual people who set the precedent for this baby getting phenomenon in the first place. It’s them who availed themselves to IVF, surrogacy, etc. because they wanted a baby SO badly, that they would get one by any means necessary, even ones that are harmful to the child and against human dignity.

The solution is no to just throw up our hands and say, well, since hetero people are acting selfishly and doing the wrong thing, gay people should be able to do the wrong thing too. To wrongs don’t make a right.
What about a gay couple who adopted and lovingly cared for a child with autism or Down’s or a neglected orphan in Russia?
While I would always assume a person embarking on such an adoption would have a big heart and be a very caring person, the fact remains that a child deserves, whenever possible, a married mother and father as parents. I believe this can be where couples who are infertile or childless for whatever reason could be a great blessing to children like this.
 
I mean heteros who want babies for selfish reasons and conceive through intercourse. It is not the “method” that determines the selfishness. It is the motivation.
If a lesbian bears a child, she has decided that her desire to have a child is more important that the child’s desire to live with his or her actual parents. Could a heterosexual woman have the same motivation? Yes, and it would also be wrong.

The Catholic Church doesn’t merely teach that childbearing should be restricted to heterosexuals. The Catholic Church teaches that childbearing should be restricted to what comes from natural sex between married people…and yes, that makes marriage a purely heterosexual arrangement.

If a child is conceived via intercourse between her parents, the parents who will raise her and who have committed to remain with each other for life, you have two people willing to do whatever it takes to live in the same household with the child’s other parent, even until the child has children, and beyond. That is what the Church requires.

That is a sacrifice that a lesbian won’t make, a motivation she does not have. She wants the child, but not the child’s father. Yet there is no selfish motivation that heterosexual couple might have that a lesbian couple could not have just as easily. So who are you calling selfish?

It is better to have a parent than to be an orphan, but kids don’t want “a” parent. A child wants his or her own parents.

I hate to say it, but it is the revolving-door attitude permitting “serial monogamy” that some heterosexuals have taken towards marriage that have even opened this discussion. That is not a door left open by the Catholic Church, though. She has defended the sanctity of marriage from attacks from people of every sexual orientation…so at least you can’t say that the Church is not being consistent.
 
Why is God not also in the petri dish and the science and human wisdom and skill that goes to making this life?

I consider this a stark hypocrisy based on narrow thinking rather than enlightened reason. Should we also let people die whom God, apparently, has “called” to die?

cut me a break
Then go and tell the Pope and the entire Catholic church that they are wrong 🤷

Why are you here? I’m asking you again. Why are you on CAF?
 
I mean heteros who want babies for selfish reasons and conceive through intercourse. It is not the “method” that determines the selfishness. It is the motivation.
Are you gay? I’m asking you b/c your previous posts would make a lot of sense if you are.
 
Then go and tell the Pope and the entire Catholic church that they are wrong 🤷

Why are you here? I’m asking you again. Why are you on CAF?
I’m a convert to the CC. I hate to say it, but it’s this kind of biting verbage that kept me out of the church for about 15 yrs. I had Catholics “pride themselves” on the church’s teachings, instead of confidently let them speak for themselves…and in love, respectfully voice their viewpoints – the Bible so clearly says that we are to deal with those who oppose the gospel with gentleness and respect (1 Peter, I think)🙂
 
I’m a convert to the CC. I hate to say it, but it’s this kind of biting verbage that kept me out of the church for about 15 yrs. I had Catholics “pride themselves” on the church’s teachings, instead of confidently let them speak for themselves…and in love, respectfully voice their viewpoints – the Bible so clearly says that we are to deal with those who oppose the gospel with gentleness and respect (1 Peter, I think)🙂
Yes, but Larkin was purposely arousing anger in all of us. He was playing a game and it got to me 🙂

He has been suspended anyway. I think CAF moderators also found him to be rude too.
 
Well to me, there’s nothing wrong with two women nor two men raising a child. If you would have been raised by your mother and grandmother, your father and grandfather, multiples nuns or priests in an orphanage, or social workers in a state-run program, no one would raise issue with the question.

The reason Catholics get cautious with homosexual parents is because homosexuals in the situation of raising a child generally feel they have the right to be openly homosexual, and they feel they are right in teaching their children that homosexuality’s OK. After all, look. Your two mommies (or daddies) are raising you, and love you, right, punkin?

This is an obvious conflict of teachings. And while we should still love these people, and especially their children, we must teach our own children both to love sinners (for that is what Jesus did), and that homosexual couples are not doing what God wants. A man and a woman have to come together to make a baby. Women can’t have children without men, men can’t without women. There is something men have and something that women have. When they come together with both of their "something"s, they can make a baby. And for the most part, when they come together because they love each other and they love God, the man and the woman can raise their children to be loving, holy, and Christian children.

And of course, playdates where both sets of parents supervise, social functions, and school are perfectly OK situations for them to meet. It’s not OK for them to meet at their house because you don’t approve of their lifestyle, and I don’t think they would allow their child to be in your house because of fear of what you believe.
 
Well to me, there’s nothing wrong with two women nor two men raising a child. If you would have been raised by your mother and grandmother, your father and grandfather, multiples nuns or priests in an orphanage, or social workers in a state-run program, no one would raise issue with the question.
These guardians which consist of Platonic relationships are qualitatively different, of course, than the intimacy of a genital single-sex relationship.
The reason Catholics get cautious with homosexual parents is because homosexuals in the situation of raising a child generally feel they have the right to be openly homosexual, and they feel they are right in teaching their children that homosexuality’s OK.
That’s part of it, but certainly not all or even most of it. It’s because these relationships are not naturally procreative. The intimacy between the two pseudo-“parents” is not of a nature that, should such parents be fertile, a child could result. There is no even possibility of reproduction that is the product of such intimacy. In addition, such relationships are artificially one-sided, in that they fail to reflect the radical and holistic complementarity which is actualized in a heterosexual relationship – the fusion of which represents the completeness of God himself.

Homosexual relationships are fundamentally incomplete, physically and organically. It doesn’t matter even if one partner is quite “feminine” and the other rather “masculine.” It doesn’t matter how much they “feel” complementary. It doesn’t matter if their temperaments are complementary. They are not complementary in the most essential of ways.

As to the Platonic relationships you referenced, no single-gender dual or group ‘parenting’ should, of course, be specifically sought as a preferred option, if there are more traditional options. The alternatives are always less ideal than a healthy heterosexual relationship. However, a straight mother living with her own mother could potentially intersect with an unattached male who could, depending on the woman’s status, marry her or become a Platonic but consistent companion to her and very regular presence for the child/children. Ditto for similar potential for a Dad living with his Dad. Homosexual couples are by definition less likely to attach *on a regular basis *to an opposite gender role model who would function as the complementary parent figure to any artificially acquired children. The whole situation is just awkward and contrived when it comes to parenting and to the full scope of a child’s needs.
 
Well to me, there’s nothing wrong with two women nor two men raising a child. If you would have been raised by your mother and grandmother, your father and grandfather, multiples nuns or priests in an orphanage, or social workers in a state-run program, no one would raise issue with the question.

The reason Catholics get cautious with homosexual parents is because homosexuals in the situation of raising a child generally feel they have the right to be openly homosexual, and they feel they are right in teaching their children that homosexuality’s OK. After all, look. Your two mommies (or daddies) are raising you, and love you, right, punkin?

This is an obvious conflict of teachings. And while we should still love these people, and especially their children, we must teach our own children both to love sinners (for that is what Jesus did), and that homosexual couples are not doing what God wants. A man and a woman have to come together to make a baby. Women can’t have children without men, men can’t without women. There is something men have and something that women have. When they come together with both of their "something"s, they can make a baby. And for the most part, when they come together because they love each other and they love God, the man and the woman can raise their children to be loving, holy, and Christian children.

And of course, playdates where both sets of parents supervise, social functions, and school are perfectly OK situations for them to meet. It’s not OK for them to meet at their house because you don’t approve of their lifestyle, and I don’t think they would allow their child to be in your house because of fear of what you believe.
I think that gay parents are fine. Period. No caveats.
 
Yeah, larkin, we’ve read it before. You’ve given us your two cents so often it’s two dollars.
That’s part of it, but certainly not all or even most of it. It’s because these relationships are not naturally procreative. The intimacy between the two pseudo-“parents” is not of a nature that, should such parents be fertile, a child could result. There is no even possibility of reproduction that is the product of such intimacy. In addition, such relationships are artificially one-sided, in that they fail to reflect the radical and holistic complementarity which is actualized in a heterosexual relationship – the fusion of which represents the completeness of God himself.
Homosexual relationships are fundamentally incomplete, physically and organically. It doesn’t matter even if one partner is quite “feminine” and the other rather “masculine.” It doesn’t matter how much they “feel” complementary. It doesn’t matter if their temperaments are complementary. They are not complementary in the most essential of ways.
The part about complementary temperaments I can understand. My mother and father were very much the opposite of the stereotypical parents. My dad was the “mother”, the gentle, kind, and understanding one who loved us and would do anything for us. My mother was kinda loving, but usually she was the one who paid the bills - the breadwinner. She also got cantankerous quite often. But my point is you don’t have to sell me on that.

But you lost me on the pro-creative part. I mean, I know that a couple is supposed to RAISE children, but is having children of your own chromosomes really necessary? Before you say “yes”, may I remind you of the virtue of adopting children? I and my sister were adopted by my parents. They did want their own children, but my mother, being a diabetic, well… So they adopted. Is it un-virtuous of a couple to adopt children - even if they are perfectly sexually healthy?

And even after THAT question, we still have to deal with the stone cold fact that these children have been legally adopted, and their parents are not accusable of child abuse in the eyes of the state. What would we do about it, then? Condemn the mothers; don’t punish the children. Slyly educate the kids if you can. 😉
As to the Platonic relationships you referenced, no single-gender dual or group ‘parenting’ should, of course, be specifically sought as a preferred option, if there are more traditional options. The alternatives are always less ideal than a healthy heterosexual relationship. However, a straight mother living with her own mother could potentially intersect with an unattached male who could, depending on the woman’s status, marry her or become a Platonic but consistent companion to her and very regular presence for the child/children. Ditto for similar potential for a Dad living with his Dad. Homosexual couples are by definition less likely to attach on a regular basis to an opposite gender role model who would function as the complementary parent figure to any artificially acquired children. The whole situation is just awkward and contrived when it comes to parenting and to the full scope of a child’s needs.
It does make me wonder how a child perceives the opposite sex when they don’t have anyone of that sex in their house, nor as an authority figure. Maybe that’s where feminists are born, in the houses of lesbians? shrugs

Homosexual couples are theoretically less efficient than traditional married couples at raising moral and balanced children, agreed, but unfortunately there’s not really much we can do about it, any more than we can do anything about mixed-race marriages or mixed-faith marriages (which can also be less efficient at raising children).
 
How did stating your opinion contribute to the discussion?
Get the bur out of your a**. All of us are just staing our opinions. I quoted the person I was responding to, who partially supported gay parenting. I supported it also, but removed all the caveats.

If you don’t wish to hear contrary opinions on matters, then talk to a mirror rather than post on a discussion forum.
 
Get the bur out of your a**. All of us are just staing our opinions. I quoted the person I was responding to, who partially supported gay parenting. I supported it also, but removed all the caveats.

If you don’t wish to hear contrary opinions on matters, then talk to a mirror rather than post on a discussion forum.
We’ve already discussed, ad nauseum, why you believe what you do and why we believe what we do. If you have some further explanation to offer, or a new point to bring up, great. If not, what’s the point in informing us of what we already knew?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top