Lesbian Parenting Study

  • Thread starter Thread starter GiannaElizabeth
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That poster is right. It doesn’t matter what faith you are - if you *know *that something will gravely offend God, you do it anyway, and it IS grave matter, then yes, you are mortally sinning.

However, that doesn’t mean the lesbian parents are mortally sinning - only God can know that. But it is still truth that the lifestyle they are engaged in is an objective evil.
That’s a fair statement Sancta.
 
You know, I’ve been thinking about the question posed here of letting kids play with the kids of lesbian (or other homosexual) parents, and I’m stumped.

I wouldn’t let my kids play with the kids of drug-dealing parents.
I wouldn’t let my kids play with the kids of polygamist parents.
I wouldn’t let my kids play with the kids of parents who practice Wicca or demon worship.
I wouldn’t let my kids play with the kids of parents who practice an open marriage with multiple sex partners.

I just wouldn’t. Because the kids of those parents would understandably see those things as normal, and their reality could color my own children’s understanding of what is right and what is wrong…potentially leading them into serious sin.

That’s a tough one.

And when I say I wouldn’t let them “play” I mean outside of school or other social events. There would be no spending “alone” time at that child’s house or getting to know the parents through dinners together, etc. I just wouldn’t do it. It would be too much a risk, and I don’t want my children falling into the trap that if it’s okay for that family, then it must be okay, period.

Sure, Christ would sit among them. But my kids are not God. Christ was not tempted to evil like we are… It seems very risky to me - to expose my innocent children’s souls to a kind of evil that.
 
You know, I’ve been thinking about the question posed here of letting kids play with the kids of lesbian (or other homosexual) parents, and I’m stumped.

I wouldn’t let my kids play with the kids of drug-dealing parents.
I wouldn’t let my kids play with the kids of polygamist parents.
I wouldn’t let my kids play with the kids of parents who practice Wicca or demon worship.
I wouldn’t let my kids play with the kids of parents who practice an open marriage with multiple sex partners.

I just wouldn’t. Because the kids of those parents would understandably see those things as normal, and their reality could color my own children’s understanding of what is right and what is wrong…potentially leading them into serious sin.

That’s a tough one.

And when I say I wouldn’t let them “play” I mean outside of school or other social events. There would be no spending “alone” time at that child’s house or getting to know the parents through dinners together, etc. I just wouldn’t do it. It would be too much a risk, and I don’t want my children falling into the trap that if it’s okay for that family, then it must be okay, period.

Sure, Christ would sit among them. But my kids are not God. Christ was not tempted to evil like we are… It seems very risky to me - to expose my innocent children’s souls to a kind of evil that.
you children are sinners, you are a sinner, your children associate only with sinners and with the children of sinners. Those other parents are likely liars, cheats, fornicators, and adulterers. There likely are racists, bigots, alcoholics and abusers. There are Jews, Muslims, atheists and Mormons out there that your children will encounter up against.

Just how much are you afraid of?
 
you children are sinners, you are a sinner, your children associate only with sinners and with the children of sinners. Those other parents are likely liars, cheats, fornicators, and adulterers. There likely are racists, bigots, alcoholics and abusers. There are Jews, Muslims, atheists and Mormons out there that your children will encounter up against.

Just how much are you afraid of?
That is just being silly.

There is a big difference between exposing a child to the general sins of the world and exposing a child - *intentionally *- to the SEXUAL and PERVERSE lives of a few select people.

I would also not let my child stay in the home of my brother in law and his girlfriend, because I don’t want them thinking that unmarried people should be sleeping together.

There is a certain intimacy that comes with friendship. Being around the general public has its sins, yes, but being intimate friends with someone tends to form and mold a person into thinking like them.

I KNOW I’m a sinner. My kids aren’t sinners yet, though. 😛 (At least not in the actively-sinning category!) But there is a HUGE difference to me in my kid seeing gays kissing in a mall and being somewhat immersed in the gay lifestyle of her best friend’s parents. BIG difference.

I am responsible for my kids’ souls, and I choose not to put them in a situation that might cause them scandal or corruption, esp at such an impressionable young age.
 
Also, Larkin, we’re talking about children here. Not adults.

Christ never put Himself in the presence of terrible sinners AND brought along a child with Him.

Christ could certainly handle that temptation.
A mature adult Christian has a good chance of being able to handle that temptation with Christ’s help.
But a child is pretty much just impressionable, until he or she is rooted deeply enough in the Faith to resist such temptation. And to me, this is about respecting and protecting my kids’ SOULS.

Would you let your kids go hang out with the kids of drug dealers? At their home? Develop close friendships with the kids of Witches? What about the kids of a father who you know is openly addicted to porn and whose kids have seen some of it themselves?
 
you children are sinners, you are a sinner, your children associate only with sinners and with the children of sinners. Those other parents are likely liars, cheats, fornicators, and adulterers. There likely are racists, bigots, alcoholics and abusers. There are Jews, Muslims, atheists and Mormons out there that your children will encounter up against.

Just how much are you afraid of?
I think you just enjoy lighting everyone’s skirts on fire 😛
 
Also, Larkin, we’re talking about children here. Not adults.

Christ never put Himself in the presence of terrible sinners AND brought along a child with Him.

Christ could certainly handle that temptation.
A mature adult Christian has a good chance of being able to handle that temptation with Christ’s help.
But a child is pretty much just impressionable, until he or she is rooted deeply enough in the Faith to resist such temptation. And to me, this is about respecting and protecting my kids’ SOULS.

Would you let your kids go hang out with the kids of drug dealers? At their home? Develop close friendships with the kids of Witches? What about the kids of a father who you know is openly addicted to porn and whose kids have seen some of it themselves?
“no” to your examples, but to kids of gay parents?? “Yes, absolutely, and already have.”
 
That is just being silly.

There is a big difference between exposing a child to the general sins of the world and exposing a child - *intentionally *- to the SEXUAL and PERVERSE lives of a few select people.
The kids don’t see the sex, you know. They don’t even know about sex. All they know about is love and comfort: whether these are present or not. And they are no more present in a hetero family than a gay family. It is YOUR issues with homosexuality that is the crux here, not what your kid might think.
 
The kids don’t see the sex, you know.
No, but they see the tender embraces, the kisses, etc…and you see enough of that, it becomes normalized. “It’s just love. Why can they be free to love each other too, Mom?”
It is YOUR issues with homosexuality that is the crux here, not what your kid might think.
Yes, I do have issues with seeing people live out their homosexual lifestyles, since that is contrary to my faith and a perversion of sex. It saddens me.

I have, however, no problem with my children befriending homosexually oriented people who are living chastely as they are called to.

As for my kids, I’m not so much interested in what my kids might think, but how their souls may be affected. Like I said, I would no more let my kids spend the night at an uncle’s house who is living with his girlfriend as though she is his wife.
 
No, but they see the tender embraces, the kisses, etc…and you see enough of that, it becomes normalized. “It’s just love. Why can they be free to love each other too, Mom?”

Yes, I do have issues with seeing people live out their homosexual lifestyles, since that is contrary to my faith and a perversion of sex. It saddens me.

I have, however, no problem with my children befriending homosexually oriented people who are living chastely as they are called to.

As for my kids, I’m not so much interested in what my kids might think, but how their souls may be affected. Like I said, I would no more let my kids spend the night at an uncle’s house who is living with his girlfriend as though she is his wife.
Sancta, don’t take the bait. This guy is just trying to get you all upset and make you feel like you have to justify your religious beliefs.

Just ignore him and he’ll go away 😛
 
Sancta, don’t take the bait. This guy is just trying to get you all upset
That is not true.
and make you feel like you have to justify your religious beliefs.
We were discussing parenting here. No one need participate in the discussion who does not wish to.
 
Of course no woman can be a father. But that is a long way from saying that two parents of the same gender will mess a kid up. Plenty of hetero parents destroy their kids. Gays do not have a lock on screwing up kids. Seems to me, after thousands of years of a so-so job done by heteros, we should at least let them have a try.
No, they should not ‘have a try’. The very way you state that; as if children are a possession a person has a right to have, is very screwed up. It’s not just about the results of the child rearing, because as we all know even children from the very best homes can grow up and ‘turn out’ to be not so great people. The point is, is it a very uncharitable act to purposefully bring a child into an inherently disordered situation (through all kinds of unethical means; IVF, surrogacy, home insemination etc.). It’s all about “I want a kid” not, I graciously accept a gift of a child that God has blessed us with. Big difference.
 
No, but they see the tender embraces, the kisses, etc…and you see enough of that, it becomes normalized. “It’s just love. Why can they be free to love each other too, Mom?”

Yes, I do have issues with seeing people live out their homosexual lifestyles, since that is contrary to my faith and a perversion of sex. It saddens me.

I have, however, no problem with my children befriending homosexually oriented people who are living chastely as they are called to.

As for my kids, I’m not so much interested in what my kids might think, but how their souls may be affected. Like I said, I would no more let my kids spend the night at an uncle’s house who is living with his girlfriend as though she is his wife.
I found this excellent Catholic document on this subject. It explains things fully in the context of our beliefs:

catholic.com/library/Homosexuality.asp

I found St. Paul’s statement interesting:

*Elsewhere Paul again warns that homosexual behavior is one of the sins that will deprive one of heaven: “Do you not know that the wicked will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: Neither the sexually immoral nor idolaters nor adulterers nor male prostitutes nor homosexual offenders nor thieves nor the greedy nor drunkards nor slanderers nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God” (1 Cor. 6:9–10, NIV). *

It’s also interesting that Our Lady of Fatima also said that the biggest reason that many do not go to Heaven because of “sins of the flesh”. I wonder if that is also directed at homosexual couples?

Just a thought…
 
No, they should not ‘have a try’. The very way you state that; as if children are a possession a person has a right to have, is very screwed up. It’s not just about the results of the child rearing, because as we all know even children from the very best homes can grow up and ‘turn out’ to be not so great people. The point is, is it a very uncharitable act to purposefully bring a child into an inherently disordered situation (through all kinds of unethical means; IVF, surrogacy, home insemination etc.). It’s all about “I want a kid” not, I graciously accept a gift of a child that God has blessed us with. Big difference.
Wanting a child is wrong? Where do you get this from?
 
No, they should not ‘have a try’. The very way you state that; as if children are a possession a person has a right to have, is very screwed up. It’s not just about the results of the child rearing, because as we all know even children from the very best homes can grow up and ‘turn out’ to be not so great people. The point is, is it a very uncharitable act to purposefully bring a child into an inherently disordered situation (through all kinds of unethical means; IVF, surrogacy, home insemination etc.). It’s all about “I want a kid” not, I graciously accept a gift of a child that God has blessed us with. Big difference.
You made a great point that children are a gift from God given to one man and one woman.

I have a question though and I am honestly just seeking an answer for this thought.

What about a gay couple who adopted and lovingly cared for a child with autism or Down’s or a neglected orphin in Russia?

This is my personal conflict and I know it does not coincide with the Church’s beliefs.
 
Wanting a child is wrong? Where do you get this from?
Wanting a child isn’t bad. Wanting a child so badly that you intentionally bring him into a disordered situation by unethical means that do not respect the dignity of the human person, is. It’s very selfish.
 
Wanting a child is wrong? Where do you get this from?
A married couple ‘wants’ a child and then they use NFP to conceive one. If it doesn’t happen, it’s not God’s will and they are called to be a childless couple.

Giving in to IVF because they ‘want’ a child even though they are unable to have one, is considered a sin b/c it goes against God’s will. The love between a married couple is resorted to an IVF dish instead of the loving act of making a baby. God is purposely left out of the equation.

Given this, a gay couple is physically unable to conceive a baby together, so they can either adopt or go the IVF route with a donor sperm. Either way, it is not God’s will for a same sex couple to assume the role of marriage between one man and one woman.

Hmmm…I think I just answered my own question 😛
 
Wanting a child isn’t bad. Wanting a child so badly that you intentionally bring him into a disordered situation by unethical means that do not respect the dignity of the human person, is. It’s very selfish.
Do we screen heteros for selfish reasons for wanting children? Are you including heteros in the “selfish” category here, or are you giving them a pass?
 
Do we screen heteros for selfish reasons for wanting children? Are you including heteros in the “selfish” category here, or are you giving them a pass?
No she’s not b/c heteros who resort to IVF are also going against God’s will b/c they are taking God out of the equation.
 
A married couple ‘wants’ a child and then they use NFP to conceive one. If it doesn’t happen, it’s not God’s will and they are called to be a childless couple.

Giving in to IVF because they ‘want’ a child even though they are unable to have one, is considered a sin b/c it goes against God’s will. The love between a married couple is resorted to an IVF dish instead of the loving act of making a baby. God is purposely left out of the equation…
Why is God not also in the petri dish and the science and human wisdom and skill that goes to making this life?

I consider this a stark hypocrisy based on narrow thinking rather than enlightened reason. Should we also let people die whom God, apparently, has “called” to die?

cut me a break
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top