Lesbian Parenting Study

  • Thread starter Thread starter GiannaElizabeth
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A father who will continually pray for his son. Keeping your children away from such influences while they are being formed is key to keeping such garbage out of their mind. My son is home schooled in a Catholic program so the only religion he knows of is Catholicism. He is being formed for the priesthood. 👍
I just have to say…the bolded part in the quote is kind of icky and weird. It sounds a bit stage-momish and creepy. Men are formed for the priesthood in seminary. Families don’t really form boys for the priesthood, although they can certainly model holiness and devotion, which is appropriate for all children.

What if your son has no call? It is one thing to hope for a call, but this sounds whack. Maybe you should think about your phrasing; it sounds kind of disrespectful of the vocation of priesthood to announce that you are “forming” your 5-year old for it, like you are somehow masterfully guiding him to have a vocation…I am sure you don’t mean that, but this kind of statement creates a creepy, uncomfortable impression.
 
Do you really think Christ would sit down with this couple, break bread and discuss their lesbian marriage? Or do you think he would ask them why they are disobeying Him, how they are misleading their children and setting a bad example for society? Perhaps talk about Gehenna?
Yes, I do. Don’t you remember the story of the prostitute? No one on this forum has any right to judge anyone else.
 
Jesus went among the lepers.
True. But he didn’t pretend that they weren’t sick.

The children are innocent in this. What their mothers have done to them is unconscionable, yet they do not know that. Why? Because no one loves them enough to tell them.
 
Hold on a second. I’m not “letting” my DD play with them. Where did I say that?
My DD bumps into them in the park and we treat them with respect. I’m not going to go out of my way to be friends with them and if my daughter later became friends with a child of a gay couple, I wouldn’t tell her to stop being their friend. I would tell her that a gay couple isn’t healthy for the children and that it’s much better for a child to have a mother and a father who are married.
Reason # 4,986,874,854,876 why my children are educated in the home.
Allowing your children to play with a lesbian couples children could end up pulling your child away from the faith
Do you all realize what you are doing? You are shunning the child. You are making the child an outcast. That is a horrible thing to do. That child is completely innocent. That is a very prejucide attitude. And what a terrible thing to do to a child. I hope you all feel ashamed.
 
Do you all realize what you are doing? You are shunning the child. You are making the child an outcast. That is a horrible thing to do. That child is completely innocent. That is a very prejucide attitude. And what a terrible thing to do to a child. I hope you all feel ashamed.
You’re not Catholic I assume, so you believe something different. No one is spreading hatred here.

Pope JP II said that it’s wrong to have children if you are a homosexual couple. Is he a judgemental man too?
 
You’re not Catholic I assume, so you believe something different. No one is spreading hatred here.

Pope JP II said that it’s wrong to have children if you are a homosexual couple. Is he a judgemental man too?
yes, popes are judgmental
 
If your priest wouldn’t tell them they are in error, perhaps your priest needs to choose a different vocation.
Nobody is trying to punish the children for the sins of their mother(s), but the sad fact is the children will be hurt because their mother(s) are choosing to live a life of sin. Can I say for a fact they are in mortal sin? Absolutely. The Church tells us they are. It isnt a wild guess, it isn’t “what is in their hearts” and yes life is black and white in most instances. Society tells us life is gray, but the Church provides those wonderful colors of black and white. Right is right, wrong is wrong. The truth hurts.
 
I know

I was just answering what I thought was obviously true in response to the question
I meant judgemental in the negative sense and that was also obvious as well 🤷

You called us judgemental and you had a negative spin on it as well. You are not Catholic of course…so what do you believe? Why are you on CAF? Are you here to begin fights with us in our beliefs or are you here to seek answers?

If you ever watched Pope JP II speak, you would have awe for him b/c he did so many wonderful things for our world. He brought peace and justice.

He also believed that homosexuality was wrong, but he was justified in believing that and his judgement came from the Holy Spirit. Did he believe that every homosexual was doomed for Hell; of course not, but he still made the judgement that they were in sin.
 
If your priest wouldn’t tell them they are in error, perhaps your priest needs to choose a different vocation.
Nobody is trying to punish the children for the sins of their mother(s), but the sad fact is the children will be hurt because their mother(s) are choosing to live a life of sin. Can I say for a fact they are in mortal sin? Absolutely. The Church tells us they are. It isnt a wild guess, it isn’t “what is in their hearts” and yes life is black and white in most instances. Society tells us life is gray, but the Church provides those wonderful colors of black and white. Right is right, wrong is wrong. The truth hurts.
No b/c mortal sin requires all 3 criteria to be met. If they don’t KNOW what they are doing is wrong, then they are not in mortal sin.

That’s just creepy that you think it’s black and white like that. It reminds me of the episode of Little House on the Prairie where that old lady would cry in agony pointing to Heaven while telling people they were doomed for Hell.
 
I meant judgemental in the negative sense and that was also obvious as well 🤷

You called us judgemental and you had a negative spin on it as well. You are not Catholic of course…so what do you believe? Why are you on CAF? Are you here to begin fights with us in our beliefs or are you here to seek answers?

If you ever watched Pope JP II speak, you would have awe for him b/c he did so many wonderful things for our world. He brought peace and justice.

He also believed that homosexuality was wrong, but he was justified in believing that and his judgement came from the Holy Spirit. Did he believe that every homosexual was doomed for Hell; of course not, but he still made the judgement that they were in sin.
my comment had no negative spin

I begin no fights here, and the only thread I have begun is wonderfully free of any dispute whatsoever.

I would work, perhaps, on your own defensiveness.
 
You’re not Catholic I assume, so you believe something different. No one is spreading hatred here.

Pope JP II said that it’s wrong to have children if you are a homosexual couple. Is he a judgemental man too?
Catholic has nothing to do with what I am saying. When you don’t let your kids play with a kid from lesbian parents, you are punishing an innocent CHILD!!! That is a horrible horrible thing to do. That child did not choose those parents and that child has no control over who his/her parents are. Catholics are suppose to be loving. If anytihng you need to befriend that child to teach them the Catholic views. But not allowing children to play with children of lesbian parents is a terrible terrible thing and would make me rething Catholosism if that were really what true Catholics did.
 
If they are not Catholic, they are not in mortal sin. They do not know it’s a grave matter. They are not in mortal sin.
Mortal sin has nothing to do with creed. One does not have to be Catholic to commit a mortal sin. It has to to do with the sin being a grave matter,knowledge of the sin, full consent of the will to commit the sin.
 
Catholic has nothing to do with what I am saying. When you don’t let your kids play with a kid from lesbian parents, you are punishing an innocent CHILD!!! That is a horrible horrible thing to do. That child did not choose those parents and that child has no control over who his/her parents are. Catholics are suppose to be loving. If anytihng you need to befriend that child to teach them the Catholic views. But not allowing children to play with children of lesbian parents is a terrible terrible thing and would make me rething Catholosism if that were really what true Catholics did.
I would NEVER stop my child from playing with anyone as long as they are a good kid. Their parents have nothing to do with the equation. I have kept stating that I wouldn’t stop my child from being friends or playing with them. I would; however, tell her that a child needs a married man and woman and that we shouldn’t judge anyone netatively even if their parents are a gay couple.
 
Catholic has nothing to do with what I am saying. When you don’t let your kids play with a kid from lesbian parents, you are punishing an innocent CHILD!!! That is a horrible horrible thing to do. That child did not choose those parents and that child has no control over who his/her parents are. Catholics are suppose to be loving. If anytihng you need to befriend that child to teach them the Catholic views. But not allowing children to play with children of lesbian parents is a terrible terrible thing and would make me rething Catholosism if that were really what true Catholics did.
I DO AND I WOULD!!! Wow…where did I say EVER otherwise??? Read my other posts 🤷
 
Mortal sin has nothing to do with creed. One does not have to be Catholic to commit a mortal sin. It has to to do with the sin being a grave matter,knowledge of the sin, full consent of the will to commit the sin.
I disagree with these blanket statements and so would many very good priests.
 
I would NEVER stop my child from playing with anyone as long as they are a good kid. Their parents have nothing to do with the equation. I have kept stating that I wouldn’t stop my child from being friends or playing with them. I would; however, tell her that a child needs a married man and woman and that we shouldn’t judge anyone netatively even if their parents are a gay couple.
You suggested otherwise, but this is much clearer now.
 
"Serap:
If they are not Catholic, they are not in mortal sin. They do not know it’s a grave matter. They are not in mortal sin.
mcrane:
Mortal sin has nothing to do with creed. One does not have to be Catholic to commit a mortal sin. It has to to do with the sin being a grave matter,knowledge of the sin, full consent of the will to commit the sin.
I disagree with these blanket statements and so would many very good priests.
That poster is right. It doesn’t matter what faith you are - if you *know *that something will gravely offend God, you do it anyway, and it IS grave matter, then yes, you are mortally sinning.

However, that doesn’t mean the lesbian parents are mortally sinning - only God can know that. But it is still truth that the lifestyle they are engaged in is an objective evil.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top