Let's Talk Judaism!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Valke2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s true that most insects are not kosher. But there are kosher locusts mentioned in the Torah (Lev. 11:20). We bascially can’t eat them today because we don’t know which ones the Torah was talking about. But it is possible that during the time of John The Baptist, this wasn’t an issue. That he knew which ones were kosher.
 
What astrological signs are associated with the breastplate stones on the ephod, and the 12 tribes of Israel?
It has nothing to do with astrology, really, since astrology is dealing with divination through the stars. The Torah forbids idolatry and the use of divination to pagan gods, including to the stars. The same goes with the use of spiritism. This interdiction has been confused since the Reformation with praying to saints, which has nothing to do with an act of acquiring knowledge of the future through divination to the idols! If God grants some knowledge of future events somehow, it’s also something else, only you don’t have to have wanted to acquire it.
Better to desire the God of all consolations than just the consolations from God!
 
Jews believe in an afterlife. There’s not a lot of dogma on the subject so opinions on exactly what it is will differ.

There is some jewish teachings on reincarnation, although I wouldn’t say it was part of normative judaism. The Zohar discusses it. Some sources teach that a soul gets 3 chances in this world.
I thought that in Judaism there is no room for reincarnation! That’s something from outside. Unless you would say everything Solomon adopted from his pagan wives is now part of Judaism, maybe?
 
I mean, there might be some Jews who would believe in reincarnation, but I don’t believe that because of that that it’s part of the teachings of Judaism per se. Altered Judaism maybe, but then is it Judaism any more? I don’t believe so!
 
How about reincarnation? I don’t think Jews believe in the afterlife in heaven, purgatory or hell, but how about reincarnation? Or is this life all there is?
Which Jews are you referring to here, Christine77? As you must know, there are Jews and Jews!! Some of them were born Jews but are atheists…
If you are referring to Jews who practice Judaism, it’s different!
 
In Hebrew it is called gilgul. Maimonides discusses Daniel 12:13

“now go your way to the end and rest, and you shall arise to your destiny at the end of days.”

There is also something in Judaism called “yibum”. If a married man dies childless, tradition holds that his spouse should marry the man’s brother and their first-born should receive the dead father’s name.

Rabbi Haim Vital compiled a list of those reincarnated in Jewish history. There is a cycle of reincarnations beginning with Dinah and Shechem. Dina, the daughter of Jacob was raped by Shechem. Shechem did not take responsibility for his actions and blamed them on his upbringing and the fact that Dinah was a noble women. So the role were reversed when Shechem was reincarnated as Zimri, an Israelite general, and Dina as Cuzbi, a Midianite women. Zimri was found consorting with Cuzbi and both were killed by the zealot, Pinhas. Thus when Shechem/Zimri was a noble man and of good birth, he could no longer blame outside sources for his own faults and was punished accordingly. The story continues when Pinhas was reincarnated as Rabbi Akiva and Cuzbi, as the wife of the Roman general Turnus Rufus. She converted to Judaism and helped establish the yeshiva of Rabbi Akiva. By promoting Jewish learning in her next life, she atoned for his sins with Zimri. Thus perhaps ending that cycle of gilgul.

A midrash says that every Jew to ever live, and who ever will live, stood at Mount Sinai when the Jews received the Covenant from God. Reincarnation may help explain how this midrash could be true.

As I said, this is not part of normative judaism and reasonable jews will differ. The Chassidim probably have a stronger belief in reincarnation than other jews. I got the above information from the Jewish Virtual Library.
 
What is kabbalah?
I get the impression it is a grab bag of mysticism, superstition, magic etc. May have some insights, however. What about celebs like madonna following this stuff? Can’t be the best recommendation.

Sounds sort of like Talmud, with good and bad mixed together. I mean, genuine insights, with some odd stuff.
I think there is kabbalah and kabbalah!
The kind of kabbalah which Madonna claims to practice may not have much to do with actual Jewish kabbalah, from what I understand from articles I read once on the topic.
 
In Hebrew it is called gilgul. Maimonides discusses Daniel 12:13

“now go your way to the end and rest, and you shall arise to your destiny at the end of days.”

There is also something in Judaism called “yibum”. If a married man dies childless, tradition holds that his spouse should marry the man’s brother and their first-born should receive the dead father’s name.

Rabbi Haim Vital compiled a list of those reincarnated in Jewish history. There is a cycle of reincarnations beginning with Dinah and Shechem. Dina, the daughter of Jacob was raped by Shechem. Shechem did not take responsibility for his actions and blamed them on his upbringing and the fact that Dinah was a noble women. So the role were reversed when Shechem was reincarnated as Zimri, an Israelite general, and Dina as Cuzbi, a Midianite women. Zimri was found consorting with Cuzbi and both were killed by the zealot, Pinhas. Thus when Shechem/Zimri was a noble man and of good birth, he could no longer blame outside sources for his own faults and was punished accordingly. The story continues when Pinhas was reincarnated as Rabbi Akiva and Cuzbi, as the wife of the Roman general Turnus Rufus. She converted to Judaism and helped establish the yeshiva of Rabbi Akiva. By promoting Jewish learning in her next life, she atoned for his sins with Zimri. Thus perhaps ending that cycle of gilgul.

A midrash says that every Jew to ever live, and who ever will live, stood at Mount Sinai when the Jews received the Covenant from God. Reincarnation may help explain how this midrash could be true.

As I said, this is not part of normative judaism and reasonable jews will differ. The Chassidim probably have a stronger belief in reincarnation than other jews. I got the above information from the Jewish Virtual Library.
Had Sepharad not left the CAF, I wonder what she would have replied to this one…
 
In Hebrew it is called gilgul. Maimonides discusses Daniel 12:13

“now go your way to the end and rest, and you shall arise to your destiny at the end of days.”

There is also something in Judaism called “yibum”. If a married man dies childless, tradition holds that his spouse should marry the man’s brother and their first-born should receive the dead father’s name.

Rabbi Haim Vital compiled a list of those reincarnated in Jewish history. There is a cycle of reincarnations beginning with Dinah and Shechem. Dina, the daughter of Jacob was raped by Shechem. Shechem did not take responsibility for his actions and blamed them on his upbringing and the fact that Dinah was a noble women. So the role were reversed when Shechem was reincarnated as Zimri, an Israelite general, and Dina as Cuzbi, a Midianite women. Zimri was found consorting with Cuzbi and both were killed by the zealot, Pinhas. Thus when Shechem/Zimri was a noble man and of good birth, he could no longer blame outside sources for his own faults and was punished accordingly. The story continues when Pinhas was reincarnated as Rabbi Akiva and Cuzbi, as the wife of the Roman general Turnus Rufus. She converted to Judaism and helped establish the yeshiva of Rabbi Akiva. By promoting Jewish learning in her next life, she atoned for his sins with Zimri. Thus perhaps ending that cycle of gilgul.

A midrash says that every Jew to ever live, and who ever will live, stood at Mount Sinai when the Jews received the Covenant from God. Reincarnation may help explain how this midrash could be true.

As I said, this is not part of normative judaism and reasonable jews will differ. The Chassidim probably have a stronger belief in reincarnation than other jews. I got the above information from the Jewish Virtual Library.
Now, if this was a midrash, it might fall under Fr. Benedict J. Groeschel’s definition of a legend: “Something that never happened but which is true anyway”!!
 
It’s true that most insects are not kosher. But there are kosher locusts mentioned in the Torah (Lev. 11:20). We bascially can’t eat them today because we don’t know which ones the Torah was talking about. But it is possible that during the time of John The Baptist, this wasn’t an issue. That he knew which ones were kosher.
HAH! I’ve been trying to get the answer to the question of “when is it OK to eat locusts?” for MONTHS! I should have known you would be the one to come up with the answer.

Funny. I HAVE read Leviticus. Maybe I wasn’t paying attention in chapter 11. Thanks, Valke2!
 
HAH! I’ve been trying to get the answer to the question of “when is it OK to eat locusts?” for MONTHS! I should have known you would be the one to come up with the answer.

Funny. I HAVE read Leviticus. Maybe I wasn’t paying attention in chapter 11. Thanks, Valke2!
You must really be Jonesing for some grasshopper souffle!

If I were to visit or be part of a jewish community that had a long tradition of eating kosher locusts, then I could eat them. But I can’t just say, at this point in time, that I think this locust is kosher based on the Torah description, and eat it. The tradition of the community establishes the chain to the past, according to the Talmud.
 
You must really be Jonesing for some grasshopper souffle!

If I were to visit or be part of a jewish community that had a long tradition of eating kosher locusts, then I could eat them. But I can’t just say, at this point in time, that I think this locust is kosher based on the Torah description, and eat it. The tradition of the community establishes the chain to the past, according to the Talmud.
You guys are so incredibly “catholic”!
 
Valke2 – how do we count the temples?

Why is Herod’s temple referred to as the “second temple” rather than the third?

Is Zerubbabel’s temple considered a repair job on the Temple of Solomon? Is that why it is not called the second temple?
 
Valke2 – how do we count the temples?

Why is Herod’s temple referred to as the “second temple” rather than the third?

Is Zerubbabel’s temple considered a repair job on the Temple of Solomon? Is that why it is not called the second temple?
We don’t call it the Third Temple because sacrifices continued while Herod was constructing it.
 
It’s true that most insects are not kosher. But there are kosher locusts mentioned in the Torah (Lev. 11:20). We bascially can’t eat them today because we don’t know which ones the Torah was talking about. But it is possible that during the time of John The Baptist, this wasn’t an issue. That he knew which ones were kosher.
Kosher insects are described in Leviticus 11:20

"'All flying insects that walk on all fours are to be detestable to you. 21There are, however, some winged creatures that walk on all fours that you may eat: those that have jointed legs for hopping on the ground. 22Of these you may eat any kind of locust, katydid, cricket or grasshopper. 23But all other winged creatures that have four legs you are to detest.

God was pretty specific about this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top