If we are willing to restrict choice for the greater good then that would apply also to guns.
Not so fast! Any physical object, any created matter, from radon to rutabagas, is morally neutral. Indeed, the Church recognizes and teaches that we have a grave duty to protect innocent life.
Abortion kills. Period. It is not choice; it is not freedom; it is not a right. It is license.
Firearms, 99.999% of which are never used in any crime, are frequently used to defend and save lives. Section 2265 and following in the catechism explains this clearly.
Someone or something, wants the public to view inanimate objects as evil in and of themselves. This reasoning is consistent with the argument that every male is a potential rapist. Do we propose castrating all males?
Explain the difference.
What we have is a crisis of suicidal (and thus, homicidal) members of a culture which suffers from blood lust. Where did our Lord teach that evil comes from? Swords? No! He allowed the Apostles to have swords - even at the last supper! Rather, evil comes from the human heart, but our cowardly society is afraid to call things what they are.
Finally, please explain the rationale for penalizing the
innocent due to the actions of the
guilty. Is it that old “all men are rapists” thing again?