Lipinski beats challenger

  • Thread starter Thread starter robertmidwest
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
niceatheist:
When all else fails yell “ABORTION!”
That might mean nothing to you, but it’s a big thing to me and a lot of other Catholics. if you don’t want to hear it, you probably should find a site that isn’t Catholic. You wouldn’t go into the home of a Jew and pull out a bacon sandwich and eat it in front of them. Neither should you deride Catholic belief on this site.
Judging by most of the polls, that suggest most Americans are not opposed to abortion (it’s divided between a minority that won’t no restrictions and those who want some level of restriction), I’d say there are a lot of American Catholics who do not hold your view, so while it might be a rallying cry around here, it’s not of much use in a lot of places in America.

And I’m not deriding Catholic teaching, I’m deriding the notion that just shouting it when you have nothing else to say about Democrats demonstrates the paucity of real subject matter that you can contribute.
 
Nice stereotyping there, RR.

A prolife Democrat won a primary. Why are you all tied up in knots over this?
 
Nice stereotyping there, RR.

A prolife Democrat won a primary. Why are you all tied up in knots over this?
He is probably upset that there exists a democrat that a Catholic could licitly vote for.
 
A prolife Democrat won a primary. Why are you all tied up in knots over this?
He often states that for Democrats, abortion is the only issue. That it is their religion. That they will not support pro-life candidates. Support for Lipinski exposes his position for the falsehood that it is.
 
Last edited:
40.png
ProVobis:
A prolife Democrat won a primary. Why are you all tied up in knots over this?
He often states that for Democrats, abortion is the only issue. That it is their religion. That they will not support pro-life candidates. Support for Lipinski exposes his position for the falsehood that it is.
I guess my point is that it seems probable there are a whole lot of Catholic voters who aren’t going to be swayed by this kind of dog whistle politics. It seems more like the kind of echo chamber rhetoric. And really, Republicans have had no lack of chances over the last 40 years to try to challenge Roe v Wade and it hasn’t happened. It’s clear there’s no real appetite at all in Washington, but it’s a useful way to whip up the hard pro-life conservative voters with a sort of manufactured bit of moral panic. Didn’t help them too much in Alabama, which goes to show you that even the most reliable of dog whistle tricks; abortion, isn’t able to save every ridiculous candidate that gets the Republican seal of approval.
 
Now, just because Donald Trump had unprotected sex with a porn star and committed other behavior that results in abortions doesn’t mean he was complicit in one.
Not that you know anything of the sort.
A complete and total misreading of Catholic teaching. Abortion is a very important issue, but not the only one that Catholics are asked to consider and it’s not surprising that voting was split among Catholics since neither candidate nor party represents Catholic teaching.
Well, the Repubs at least represent Catholic teaching when it comes to killing children legally. They’re against it, and the Dems are for it. That, at least, is plain.

And as the Popes have said, we can’t vote for an abortion-supporting candidate unless there is a "proportionately grave’ reason to do so. What “proportionately grave” Dem issue outweighs killing innocent children?

You just can’t excuse abortion, no matter how hard you try, and you can’t excuse those who promote it.
 
A prolife Democrat won a primary. Why are you all tied up in knots over this?
I’m not. Wish they were all like him. I would probably still be a Democrat if they were, even though I think he and I might differ on guns. Not sure, but I could live with it.
 
He often states that for Democrats, abortion is the only issue. That it is their religion. That they will not support pro-life candidates. Support for Lipinski exposes his position for the falsehood that it is.
Nonsense. I saw a “liger” on tv once; a cross between a tiger and a lion. Exceedingly rare. But its existence doesn’t mean there are no tigers or lions.

You, yourself, attributed his election to local politics but admitted the DNC didn’t support him. You can’t have it both ways just because you think you have a “gotcha” moment when you don’t.
 
Last edited:
I guess my point is that it seems probable there are a whole lot of Catholic voters who aren’t going to be swayed by this kind of dog whistle politics. It seems more like the kind of echo chamber rhetoric. And really, Republicans have had no lack of chances over the last 40 years to try to challenge Roe v Wade and it hasn’t happened. It’s clear there’s no real appetite at all in Washington, but it’s a useful way to whip up the hard pro-life conservative voters with a sort of manufactured bit of moral panic. Didn’t help them too much in Alabama, which goes to show you that even the most reliable of dog whistle tricks; abortion, isn’t able to save every ridiculous candidate that gets the Republican seal of approval.
This is such a tired argument. You know full well that it requires a majority on the Supreme Court to reverse Roe and its progeny, and while the prolife segment of the court is increasing, it’s not a majority yet.

And while it may seem a shock to you, being an atheist and all, there really are people for whom abortion on demand is an abomination, and one that asks for condemnation.
 
You probably know this but anti-abortion is not just a Catholic thing. Abortion was condemned by Cicero and others well before Christ.
 
but admitted the DNC didn’t support him.
  1. I don’t recall that I ever said that the DNC did not support him. I have already corrected you on this.
  2. I did say that the DNCC declined to endorse him. It turned out that that statement was premature. Eventually they did. I have apologized for the error and have invited you to do the same.
The liger story missed the point totally. You tiresome partisan politicking against the Democratic party has been exposed as been based on falsehood.
 
Last edited:
Racism, war, torture. Sorry, but neither party meets the criteria to deserve a Catholic vote, so we can have to choose between two bad choices.
Yes, pro-abortion forces push that narrative.

Well, the Repub party doesn’t stand for any of those things, so you’re still stuck with abortion, which is so important to the Dem party it’s in their platform.
 
I don’t recall that I ever said that the DNC did not support him. I have already corrected you on this.
I did say that the DNCC declined to endorse him. It turned out that that statement was premature. Eventually they did. I have apologized for the error and have invited you to do the same.

The liger story missed the point totally. You tiresome partisan politicking against the Democratic party has been exposed as been based on falsehood.
You corrected me, or yourself? Putting 1 & 2 together, it seems the latter.

Your constant tactic of claiming, e.g. that something “has been debunked” when it hasn’t, or “exposed as based on falsehood” when it hasn’t, is worse than “tiresome”.

The fact is that the Dem party congress people are almost all endorsed by NARAL and virtually none are endorsed by NRL. Both NARAL and National Right to Life list almost no prolife Dems and almost no pro-abortion Repubs.

Abortion is in the Dem platform. The right to life is in the Repub platform.

I don’t need to “politic” against the Dem party. For believing Catholics, it politics against itself. All I do is bring it to light now and then.
 
Actually, it more anti-racism, anti-unjust war, anti-torture forces that push that narrative. And, of course, the Republican party stands for those things, or at least their nominee for President does.
Who started the last war the U.S. was in? Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama, that’s who.
And who keeps the blacks in ghettos under crooked politicians, offering blacks nothing but abortions? Not the Repubs, that’s for sure.
And what is the difference between being waterboarded and living (all three of them) and being burned to death with a hellfire missile like Obama did indiscriminately in Af/Pak? Which of the two is worse?

How many wars has Trump started? None.
How many blacks has he oppressed? None.
How many people has he tortured? None.

I realize Dems cannot be convinced not to hate Trump. He threatens the main Dem value, which is abortion on demand. That, they cannot forgive.
 
There are quite a few anti-Trump Republicans and I’d be surprised if there isn’t a serious primary fight come next election.
 
There are quite a few anti-Trump Republicans and I’d be surprised if there isn’t a serious primary fight come next election.
Pretty doubtful. The anti-Trump Repubs took a serious beating in the last primary, and I really can’t picture them doing it again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top