I don’t know your age, but it sounds from your message that you’re young. I know that, especially in my teens, I was what we used to call ‘deep’. I was always more interested in ideas and serious subjects, not silly cr-p like most teenagers dish out. I was quite judgmental about it, feeling that others were the problem. Yes, I had a small circle of friends, and I got along with everyone but I wasn’t really interested in silly sports (still not!) and of course this was the sixties and early seventies on top of it.
It wasn’t until I got into health care work that I came to realize that I lacked the ability to make small talk-at all. I had to learn it, because when you’re taking care of the sick it is important to care, and care well. I spent years doing that. Now, in my fifties, I have learned that I enjoy making conversation with all kinds of people, whether in grocery stores, at Mass, anywhere. I still have the same interests I’ve had all my life, still not what most people would call ‘average’, but I can and do work at making others comfortable in my presence, no matter their background.
I can remember from that classic cult movie, “Harold and Maude” from the early seventies, when Harold, who was extremely uncomfortable with people, marveled at how Maude could make friends with complete strangers. She told him, “Well, they’re my species, aren’t they?” I try to live that day to day now, myself. If you want a Catholic example, read a little on the life of Pope John XXIII (1958-1963). He had that gift!