Bernadettefaith said:
“If he’s not happy then she doesn’t think he has a choice but to leave. She still does not really have many suggestions for us. She even said that maybe we should try someone else to see if they had ideas. I don’t think I want to go back to her if she says she supports marriage but also believes that divorce would make Dh happy.”
That doesn’t sound very promising. It looks like she has gotten to the end of her bag of tricks.
I have no doubt that your husband will experience some momentary relief from separation (no more wiping his feet when he comes in! he can take out the garbage when he feels like it! no more being nice to your mom! no more having to listen to your dad’s stories for the tenth time!), but that’s all a one time effect. He has to go on from there to making himself happy–no one can make him happy if he isn’t capable of happiness. There’s research showing that people tend to revert to their emotional baselines even after major changes. Show your husband this:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hedonic_treadmill
“On the other hand, Dh says that there is progress because he is talking about his anxiety and getting it all out there. It’s really bothering him and I hate seeing him like this. He says that I’m the cause of all of it and I just don’t know how I am - unless it’s just all his built up resentment coming out.”
It seems like the next step would be for your husband to work on his anxiety with a different counselor who actually fixes people, rather than listening to them say the same thing over and over again, blaming other people for making them unhappy. What you’re looking for is a cognitive-behavioral counselor, and you might just want somebody for him, rather than a marriage counselor.
“Most therapists working with patients dealing with anxiety and depression use a blend of cognitive and behavioral therapy. This technique acknowledges that there may be behaviors that cannot be controlled through rational thought. CBT is “problem focused” (undertaken for specific problems) and “action oriented” (therapist tries to assist the client in selecting specific strategies to help address those problems).
CBT is thought to be effective for the treatment of a variety of conditions, including mood, anxiety, personality, eating, substance abuse, tic, and psychotic disorders.”
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_behavioral_therapy
“So yeah, I’m going to be looking for a new counselor most likely. Maybe I’ll try taking to a Christian counselor in town to see how her views on marriage are. There aren’t any Catholic ones locally and I don’t know about another secular one.”
I don’t think you necessarily need a Christian counselor if you can just find the right person.