The only thing that has happened in this thread (besides some minor frustration between users) is facts on Popes who have promoted True devotion and Church history showing promotion and indulgences for doing the Consecration.
Fair enough.
No one has been pushed. Just truth about the Consecration has been given. I will not be made to feel guilty because my approach was foward or I propose the way of St. Louis de Montfort and St. Maximilian Kolbe who are SAINTS and their lives are to be imitated.
Well -
feeling pushed can occur even though the other person does not intend it…It’s one of those things that can come up in interactions where the people feel strongly.
My pointing it out was certainly not to make you feel guilty…My hope was that, by making you aware of my feelings, you might be led (by Our Lady) to an even better and more effective approach in future conversations.
I think we differ because you consider devotion to Mary as an option, and I don’t. I know I am not wrong in thinking this, Church teaching and Popes have shown the importance of Marian devotion.
This is where you are wrong. I do not consider devotion to Mary optional. Where we differ is in the form and extent of that devotion.
If I may share…My spirituality is a simple one. I find that it must be that way. The simpler the better. As I have read the various quotes and links etc…I would find myself becoming more confused and troubled and even conflicted. I simply could not digest it all. It is all just too complicated for me.
As an analogy…We often speak of the many teachings and rich traditions of the Church as this huge banquet. And certainly we all know that we must eat to live. But the fact that we must eat does not mean we all have the same appetites, tastes, or even ability to eat certain foods. Some foods taste god, are easily digested and satisfying while others can be difficult - (as I often say about myself, “I like onions but onions don’t like me”

)
Anyway…I look at all that is displayed on this banquet table, and it is all beautiful and smells wonderful and is enticing. But experience has taught me that I need a simple diet. That I should avoid certain foods, or only take a small amount. That is what works for me.
Someone walking beside me insisting that I need to take more, and different, and how good this or that is, and wanting to “load up my plate” will not have a good outcome…They may think that they are encouraging and being helpful and broadening my horizons…but I would feel pushed…
Sorry - probably over did that analogy a bit…
Anyway - my point is that I need to keep things simple. My heavenly mother understand this - and so does her Son, my Lord and Savior. I do not find these things to be simple…thus they become and interference rather than a help in my spiritual life.
What really gets me is on this website teachings of the Saints are looked down on as if they go against the Catholic Church, when in fact Pope John Paul II was the most to promote True devotion to Mary and St. Maximilian Kolbe. Like I said before I take my advise from the Vicar of Christ. He put it in his teachings!
I do not get that impression at all.
When I see a person who is struggling to learn about the faith and are struggling with Marion devotion, prayer to the saints etc. I will advise them to not get upset or sidetracked…to take it slow…Intercessory prayer is optional. Special devotions such as you promote are optional. What is not optional is Love. Love for God, Love for our Mother and Love for our Brothers and sisters in Christ.
Does that mean I am not devoted to my mother? No it does not. I Love her and know that, since her goal is to bring us to her Son, my advice to others who, like me, need to keep things simple, is the right advice and she would approve.
So even though we differ in opinion I hope we can still be friends In Mary and Christ!
Absolutely you remain my dear friend in Christ and in our Blessed Mother.
One of the beautiful things in this is that, when people DO struggle we can each present an option and the person can read, pray on the matter, and find just the right balance for themselves - or - returning to the banquet table - just the right combination of foods to feed them.
Peace
James