MARY is She necessary or optional?

  • Thread starter Thread starter De_Montfort
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Semper Zelare,
I apologize for any personal attacks and am glad that you have decided to continue our conversation through PM. I will respond via PM as soon as I have the chance.
 
The only thing that has happened in this thread (besides some minor frustration between users) is facts on Popes who have promoted True devotion and Church history showing promotion and indulgences for doing the Consecration.
Fair enough.
No one has been pushed. Just truth about the Consecration has been given. I will not be made to feel guilty because my approach was foward or I propose the way of St. Louis de Montfort and St. Maximilian Kolbe who are SAINTS and their lives are to be imitated.
Well - feeling pushed can occur even though the other person does not intend it…It’s one of those things that can come up in interactions where the people feel strongly.
My pointing it out was certainly not to make you feel guilty…My hope was that, by making you aware of my feelings, you might be led (by Our Lady) to an even better and more effective approach in future conversations.
I think we differ because you consider devotion to Mary as an option, and I don’t. I know I am not wrong in thinking this, Church teaching and Popes have shown the importance of Marian devotion.
This is where you are wrong. I do not consider devotion to Mary optional. Where we differ is in the form and extent of that devotion.
If I may share…My spirituality is a simple one. I find that it must be that way. The simpler the better. As I have read the various quotes and links etc…I would find myself becoming more confused and troubled and even conflicted. I simply could not digest it all. It is all just too complicated for me.

As an analogy…We often speak of the many teachings and rich traditions of the Church as this huge banquet. And certainly we all know that we must eat to live. But the fact that we must eat does not mean we all have the same appetites, tastes, or even ability to eat certain foods. Some foods taste god, are easily digested and satisfying while others can be difficult - (as I often say about myself, “I like onions but onions don’t like me” :D)
Anyway…I look at all that is displayed on this banquet table, and it is all beautiful and smells wonderful and is enticing. But experience has taught me that I need a simple diet. That I should avoid certain foods, or only take a small amount. That is what works for me.
Someone walking beside me insisting that I need to take more, and different, and how good this or that is, and wanting to “load up my plate” will not have a good outcome…They may think that they are encouraging and being helpful and broadening my horizons…but I would feel pushed…

Sorry - probably over did that analogy a bit…

Anyway - my point is that I need to keep things simple. My heavenly mother understand this - and so does her Son, my Lord and Savior. I do not find these things to be simple…thus they become and interference rather than a help in my spiritual life.
What really gets me is on this website teachings of the Saints are looked down on as if they go against the Catholic Church, when in fact Pope John Paul II was the most to promote True devotion to Mary and St. Maximilian Kolbe. Like I said before I take my advise from the Vicar of Christ. He put it in his teachings!
I do not get that impression at all.

When I see a person who is struggling to learn about the faith and are struggling with Marion devotion, prayer to the saints etc. I will advise them to not get upset or sidetracked…to take it slow…Intercessory prayer is optional. Special devotions such as you promote are optional. What is not optional is Love. Love for God, Love for our Mother and Love for our Brothers and sisters in Christ.
Does that mean I am not devoted to my mother? No it does not. I Love her and know that, since her goal is to bring us to her Son, my advice to others who, like me, need to keep things simple, is the right advice and she would approve.
So even though we differ in opinion I hope we can still be friends In Mary and Christ!
Absolutely you remain my dear friend in Christ and in our Blessed Mother.
One of the beautiful things in this is that, when people DO struggle we can each present an option and the person can read, pray on the matter, and find just the right balance for themselves - or - returning to the banquet table - just the right combination of foods to feed them.

Peace
James
 
I think some or most in the Church think of Our Lady as an option when in fact she is necessary for men to reach the final end Jesus Christ, God Alone.

“Mary IS necessary for salvation because God freely wills it so. She is not optinal. Even more so she is necessary ‘for those who are called to any special perfection.’ ‘It was through Mary that the salvation of the world was begun and it is through her that it must be consummated.’ If Mary is necessary to God in the Incarnation, she is necessary to who share in the Incarnation, since sanctification in nothing more than the extension of ‘the compendium of all mysteries’ the Incarnation of Eternal Wisdom (Jesus Christ).”
Your language is confusing to me. Where do your quotes come from, just so I can better understand - thanks.
 
Your language is confusing to me. Where do your quotes come from, just so I can better understand - thanks.
A book entitled “Jesus Living in Mary”

Bascially it’s saying since we all partake in Christ and since by God’s will Mary was necessary at the Incarnation and since God does not change then since we are the mystical body of Christ, Mary is necessary to us.

“The plan adopted by the three persons of the Blessed Trinity in the incarnation, the first coming of Jesus Christ, is adhered to each day in an invisible manner throught the Church and they will pursue it to the end of time until the last coming of Jesus Christ.”

The quote above is from St. Louis de Montfort in the book entitled “God Alone”

Hope this helps 🙂
 
A book entitled “Jesus Living in Mary”

Bascially it’s saying since we all partake in Christ and since by God’s will Mary was necessary at the Incarnation and since God does not change then since we are the mystical body of Christ, Mary is necessary to us.

“The plan adopted by the three persons of the Blessed Trinity in the incarnation, the first coming of Jesus Christ, is adhered to each day in an invisible manner throught the Church and they will pursue it to the end of time until the last coming of Jesus Christ.”

The quote above is from St. Louis de Montfort in the book entitled “God Alone”

Hope this helps 🙂
I’m working through it, …I’m not clear on exactly how it is that Mary is necessary to us - I can agree - sure she is necessary, but how is it that she must be involved in our lives and why - what leads us to this conclusion… I think part of my problem is that I have learned to read scripture in a certain way. I’m trying to reform how I read it… I’m having a hard time understanding how Mary fits in the puzzle. The answer has not come clear to me yet.
 
I’m working through it, …I’m not clear on exactly how it is that Mary is necessary to us - I can agree - sure she is necessary, but how is it that she must be involved in our lives and why - what leads us to this conclusion… I think part of my problem is that I have learned to read scripture in a certain way. I’m trying to reform how I read it… I’m having a hard time understanding how Mary fits in the puzzle. The answer has not come clear to me yet.
Fulton Sheen wrote in his book “The worlds first love” that if you take away Mary we can never get to Him, because He came to us through Her. We would never understand how the bridge was built between Heaven and earth.

What we do with Mary and how we devote ourselves to Her is imitation of Christ himself. He didn’t come to earth a fully grown man, he came in a frail little child completely dependent on His Mother. When we bring Mary into our lives we are taking the path Christ did.

And lets not forget He said from the Cross that She is our Mother.

If Mary was necesssary in God’s plan for Christ to be born, us being in Christ, what makes some of us think she is not necessary to all who are in Christ Jesus?
 
If Mary was necessary in God’s plan for Christ to be born, us being in Christ, what makes some of us think she is not necessary to all who are in Christ Jesus?
What I have believed is that scripture offers no evidence that Mary even understood Jesus as an adult. She asked him to turn water into wine - he replied to her something like, “woman it is not yet my time.” At one point she tries to stop him from what he is doing thinking he is out of his mind. At the foot of the cross Jesus, in a sense, lets her go - he gives her away to John. He might have put her under John’s care because she needed to be looked after. As Jesus knew he was leaving, he also knew he would be back from the tomb - it could be argued that she wasn’t on his list of people he would see after resurrection; she held little importance to Jesus’ mission. In the rest of the NT Mary is absent. Letters don’t refer to her. Scripture doesn’t seem to point to anything, but that she is just like the rest of us… we have no reason to think, when we read scripture, that she was even part of his life after he entered adulthood except to attempt to shut him down. “…the Son of Man has no place to lay his head.” “…the gospel is like a sword that shall separate father from son and mother from daughter.” Family connections are not emphasized by Jesus. He never mentions his mother. She doesn’t play a part in scripture… Scripture tells us nothing about Mary to cause us to believe that she was anything more than a normal human being who encountered God in a very unique and special way, but beyond that she, just like everyone else in the Bible was a normal human. That is what I have believed.

That doesn’t mean that she was absent - she may have been very influential, especially being entrusted to John. She would likely have been very highly valued by the early church and God may have spoken through her the way he did with the other disciples - all the things that tradition tells us about her may be very true… She may be the key to understanding Jesus… I’m struggling with why this isn’t presented in the Bible. I’m really working on understanding this. Clearly the way I am used to reading scripture leaves out a lot of details. I need to gain clearer understanding and perspective.
Fulton Sheen wrote in his book “The worlds first love” that if you take away Mary we can never get to Him, because He came to us through Her. We would never understand how the bridge was built between Heaven and earth.
Its difficult for me to comprehend why scripture doesn’t directly present this idea
What we do with Mary and how we devote ourselves to Her is imitation of Christ himself. He didn’t come to earth a fully grown man, he came in a frail little child completely dependent on His Mother. When we bring Mary into our lives we are taking the path Christ did.
This is equally hard for me to follow because Jesus didn’t devote himself to Mary in scripture - we only have a record of him submitting to her request to make wine out of water and evidence of his care for her when he offers her to John.
And lets not forget He said from the Cross that She is our Mother.
He didn’t say that. He said it to John.
 
If Mary was necessary in God’s plan for Christ to be born, us being in Christ, what makes some of us think she is not necessary to all who are in Christ Jesus?
What I have believed is that scripture offers no evidence that Mary even understood Jesus as an adult. She asked him to turn water into wine - he replied to her something like, “woman it is not yet my time.” At one point she tries to stop him from what he is doing thinking he is out of his mind. At the foot of the cross Jesus, in a sense, lets her go - he gives her away to John. He might have put her under John’s care because she needed to be looked after. As Jesus knew he was leaving, he also knew he would be back from the tomb - it could be argued that she wasn’t on his list of people he would see after resurrection; she held little importance to Jesus’ mission. In the rest of the NT Mary is absent. Letters don’t refer to her. Scripture doesn’t seem to point to anything, but that she is just like the rest of us… we have no reason to think, when we read scripture, that she was even part of his life after he entered adulthood except to attempt to shut him down. “…the Son of Man has no place to lay his head.” “…the gospel is like a sword that shall separate father from son and mother from daughter.” Family connections are not emphasized by Jesus. He never mentions his mother. She doesn’t play a part in scripture… Scripture tells us nothing about Mary to cause us to believe that she was anything more than a normal human being who encountered God in a very unique and special way, but beyond that she, just like everyone else in the Bible was a normal human. That is what I have believed.

That doesn’t mean that she was absent - she may have been very influential, especially being entrusted to John. She would likely have been very highly valued by the early church and God may have spoken through her the way he did with the other disciples - all the things that tradition tells us about her may be very true… She may be the key to understanding Jesus… I’m struggling with why this isn’t presented in the Bible. I’m really working on understanding this. Clearly the way I am used to reading scripture leaves out a lot of details. I need to gain clearer understanding and perspective.
Fulton Sheen wrote in his book “The worlds first love” that if you take away Mary we can never get to Him, because He came to us through Her. We would never understand how the bridge was built between Heaven and earth.
Its difficult for me to comprehend why scripture doesn’t directly present this idea
What we do with Mary and how we devote ourselves to Her is imitation of Christ himself. He didn’t come to earth a fully grown man, he came in a frail little child completely dependent on His Mother. When we bring Mary into our lives we are taking the path Christ did.
This is equally hard for me to follow because Jesus didn’t devote himself to Mary in scripture - we only have a record of him submitting to her request to make wine out of water and evidence of his care for her when he offers her to John.
And lets not forget He said from the Cross that She is our Mother.
He didn’t say that. He said it to John.

I really am trying to understand - please point me in the right direction. I’m thinking about what you’ve written - Thanks for sharing.
 
I really am trying to understand - please point me in the right direction. I’m thinking about what you’ve written - Thanks for sharing.
Your view seems to be a protestant one. Notice in Scripture it does not say “John” but says the “beloved disciple”. John represents us, we become Christ’s “beloved disciples”

In Scripture after the finding of Jesus in the temple, it says He was subject to them and grew in wisdom. So yes Christ submitted to His Holy Mother.

Nowhere in the bible does it say that we should use Scripture alone. Sacred Tradition goes beside Sacred Scripture.

Paul said to be imitators of Him since he was of Christ. They taught orally in the begininng of the Church, there was no Sacred Scipture written yet

Christ calls His Mother “Woman” at Cana and the Cross because She is the new Eve. All the way back to Genisus, "I will put eminity between Thee and the Woman. God gave the victory to the Woman and Her seed (Mary and Jesus) When Christ answers Her like He did is because He was saying to Her do you understand that doing this miracle starts my mission which will end on the Cross. Notice Chirst does what she asks, and also notice what the command of Mary is… “Do whatever He tells you”…

It seems that once someone accepts the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception, things come together more easily once it’s accepted.

vatican.va/holy_father/pius_x/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-x_enc_02021904_ad-diem-illum-laetissimum_en.html

If Mary is new to you I would start off with the book “The Worlds first love” by Fulton Sheen.

Then I would read St. Louis de Montfort. It may seem scary at first, all he does is give witness to how GOD has exalted Mary. All True devotion to Mary has Jesus Christ for it’s final end. If it doesnt then they do not understand the devotion nor De Montfort.

If you want I can give you links to Church teaching on Mary. Just let me know.
Always remember The Mother of God cannot lead us anywhere except the Lord Jesus.
 
Pope Paul VI’s Apostolic Exhortation, Marialus cultus, is an important document to read regarding devotion to our Blessed Mother:
This devotion fits-as we have indicated above-into the only worship that is rightly called “Christian,” because it takes its origin and effectiveness from Christ, finds its complete expression in Christ, and leads through Christ in the Spirit to the Father. In the sphere of worship this devotion necessarily reflects God’s redemptive plan, in which a special form of veneration is appropriate to the singular place which Mary occupies in that plan.(4) Indeed every authentic development of Christian worship is necessarily followed by a fitting increase of veneration for the Mother of the Lord.
vatican.va/holy_father/paul_vi/apost_exhortations/documents/hf_p-vi_exh_19740202_marialis-cultus_en.html
 
I never stopped to consider the issue of whether Marian devotion is necessary or optional. I’ve prayed devoutly to our Holy Mother since Catholic grade school. In fact, my devotion to Mary has only increased with the passage of time. I pray the Rosary and Angelus daily and the Memorare remains my favorite prayer of intercession. Christ loved and venerated Mary as His Holy Mother, I can do no less. We contemplate her Assumption and Coronation as Queen of Heaven in the final two decades of the Glorious Mysteries of the Rosary in recognition of her sacred place in the Church and our hearts. Marian devotion is a significant part of my affiliation with Opus Dei and the source of my great respect for the Discalced Carmelites. Salve Regina!
 
Your view seems to be a protestant one. Notice in Scripture it does not say “John” but says the “beloved disciple”. John represents us, we become Christ’s “beloved disciples”
This is one of those things that I definitely need to learn to recognize. I had no idea this was the case and have never heard that before. Would you say ‘John’ is a code word and always represents us, or just in this instance.
Nowhere in the bible does it say that we should use Scripture alone. Sacred Tradition goes beside Sacred Scripture.
This makes sense - a good way to think about it.
Christ calls His Mother “Woman” at Cana and the Cross because She is the new Eve. All the way back to Genisus, "I will put eminity between Thee and the Woman. God gave the victory to the Woman and Her seed (Mary and Jesus) When Christ answers Her like He did is because He was saying to Her do you understand that doing this miracle starts my mission which will end on the Cross. Notice Chirst does what she asks, and also notice what the command of Mary is… “Do whatever He tells you”…
I have for many years have said of the Bible that it is honest. God isn’t playing around and he’s not trying to appeal to only the most intelligent, sensible or devoted people - He’s been trying to reach the lost sheep - those who are poor, lost, sick, suffering - they don’t listen with scholastic ears - they listen, looking for a solution to their problems… So, the Bible is honest with them - it can be read and, very directly, reveals answers to our problems - it lays out its treasure openly. When people argue over the meaning of scripture sometimes its about things that really miss the main message and often the answer is, how important was this to Jesus, what did he say about it, or How important was this to the writers of the letters in the NT? If they don’t mention it, or if they don’t treat it as an important issue, then likely it really isn’t important, or its not an issue. I tend to feel that way about the importance of Mary. I need to hear what sacred tradition says about her.
If you want I can give you links to Church teaching on Mary. Just let me know.
Always remember The Mother of God cannot lead us anywhere except the Lord Jesus.
Thanks for your encouragement - I’m going to look at the site you posted - please feel free to pass on anything that can help me gain clarity!

Merry Christmas
Steve
 
I never stopped to consider the issue of whether Marian devotion is necessary or optional. I’ve prayed devoutly to our Holy Mother since Catholic grade school. In fact, my devotion to Mary has only increased with the passage of time. I pray the Rosary and Angelus daily and the Memorare remains my favorite prayer of intercession. Christ loved and venerated Mary as His Holy Mother, I can do no less. We contemplate her Assumption and Coronation as Queen of Heaven in the final two decades of the Glorious Mysteries of the Rosary in recognition of her sacred place in the Church and our hearts. Marian devotion is a significant part of my affiliation with Opus Dei and the source of my great respect for the Discalced Carmelites. Salve Regina!
Same here, but you know how it is in forums. Everything has to be dissected and ressected ad nauseum. Merry Christmas.🙂
 
Mary, clearly necessary.

Jesus thought it was the most fitting way through which to begin the salvation of the world.

You think we have better ideas than His?

He gave Her to us, too! You want to treat that gift as optional? Oy!
 
I am new to this thread and it is late so I apologize for not reading the entire thing

Mary is necessary because as I’m sure others have probably mention we would not have the incarnation or salvation without her. Though we are not required to have devotion to her I don’t see why we shouldn’t especially since she has given us Christ. And the church says that devotion to her is an intrinsic part of Christian worship. Not to mention all the sacramentals and promises she has given us. I can honestly say from experience that if it wasn’t for her intercession I’d probably be dead or worse in hell.
 
Mary is necessary because as I’m sure others have probably mention we would not have the incarnation or salvation without her. Though we are not required to have devotion to her I don’t see why we shouldn’t especially since she has given us Christ. And the church says that devotion to her is an intrinsic part of Christian worship. Not to mention all the sacramentals and promises she has given us. I can honestly say from experience that if it wasn’t for her intercession I’d probably be dead or worse in hell.
There’s a careful distinction there, I think. Certainly Mary was integral to the Incarnation, but is she therefore also necessarily part of the personal salvation - the response to Grace in each believer? Certainly some are called to a deeper devotion to her and experience piety because of her, but for those of us who have not experienced her intercession, is that a sign of reprobation (as Louis de Montfort argues in “True Devotion”) or simply that the Lord approaches each person as He wishes?

Also, if Mary had said ‘no’, would God have chosen another woman for the Incarnation?
 
There’s a careful distinction there, I think. Certainly Mary was integral to the Incarnation, but is she therefore also necessarily part of the personal salvation - the response to Grace in each believer? Certainly some are called to a deeper devotion to her and experience piety because of her, but for those of us who have not experienced her intercession, is that a sign of reprobation (as Louis de Montfort argues in “True Devotion”) or simply that the Lord approaches each person as He wishes?

Also, if Mary had said ‘no’, would God have chosen another woman for the Incarnation?
Due to not knowing definite concrete answers I have trouble with some of this, though I will try to respond.

Personally, I am a fan of de Montfort. As for salvation I have heard various apologists say that if Mary had said no God could possibly have found a different way to save humanity or he could have chosen not to save us. We should be grateful that she did say yes and we have salvation history as we know it.

Most forms of protestantism do away with the concept of Marian devotion and the communion of saints and we cannot really say if we know if this effects their potential salvation. Jesus said something like “not everyone that calls on me Lord, Lord shall enter the kingdom of Heaven but he who does the will of my Father.” something like that. However there are parts of the catechism that explain that the law is written on the hearts of all of us regardless of what faith they have, and that following this helps us know what the will of God is. If we do the will of God we will be more likely to enter Heaven. Still no one can earn Salvation as it is still an infinite gift of love from God.

Personally I like Marian devotion because I have had my own private revelation and she is part of how I reverted and came back to the Church and started practicing my faith again. God reached out for me before this but she reminded me that what I experienced was genuine.

I was very scared and she comforted me and led me to her Son once more. And she still does.

May not be the answer you were looking for as I am still learning.
 
Due to not knowing definite concrete answers I have trouble with some of this, though I will try to respond.
I appreciate the acknowledgement.
As for salvation I have heard various apologists say that if Mary had said no God could possibly have found a different way to save humanity or he could have chosen not to save us. We should be grateful that she did say yes and we have salvation history as we know it.
This is something I’d like to ask that theologian. I think it’d be hard to defend that God would essentially condition humanity’s salvation on the yes or no of Mary.
However there are parts of the catechism that explain that the law is written on the hearts of all of us regardless of what faith they have, and that following this helps us know what the will of God is. If we do the will of God we will be more likely to enter Heaven.
This is true, and I appreciate the effort. The thing is, how do we accept, from a theological standpoint, that Montfort’s claim that Mary is necessary for salvation is true? In other words, what’s the mechanism? I’d actually like to know what led him to the conclusion - was it revelation, a careful study of Scripture, systemic theology?

To put it another way, what’s the means by which Jesus saves us? Well there’s multiple levels to that because we have been saved (from certain damnation by the Cross), we are being saved (from falling into Sin by the work of Christ in us), and we will be saved (from condemnation by the perseverence of saints which is a gift of Grace). Let’s take the easiest one to answer, which is why does Christ dying on the Cross mean that we who are condemned from our birth are no longer certain to be condemned? Because the wages of sin are paid by the Blood of Christ, that debt is satisfied and we are redeemed.

So the likewise question to “why is devotion to Mary necessary for salvation” would be “by what mechanism are those who do not have a devotion to Mary necessarily condemned?”
 
I am searching out the truth here. I am not Catholic but want truth so Im asking Caytholics and hoping for honest answers. Is it true that Pope Pius X saod salvation came through Mary? If so does anyone know where I can find this document and where in scripture it is found? 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top