Mary's perpetual virginity

  • Thread starter Thread starter Harmony1988
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m just showing how dangerous it is when we use our own interpretation of the Bible.We can not just pick up the bible and interperate on our own,this is why we need the magisterium of Holy Catholic Church,scripture* and* tradition.

2 Thessalonians 2:15
15 So then, brethren, stand firm and hold to the* traditions* which you were taught by us,either by word *of mouth **or ***by letter.

Luke 1:46-49
And Mary said, “My soul magnifies the Lord, and my spirit rejoices in God my Savior,for he has regarded the low estate of his handmaiden. For behold, henceforth *all *generations will call me blessed; for he who is mighty has done great things for me,and holy is his name.
okay, you are are misusing scripture.

The “traditions” you speak of …are actually written scripture now…but we didn’t have our handy dandy OT’s sitting on the living room table. sorry.

…and all generations do call her blessed.

so what?
 
“Therefore we confess that our Lord and God Jesus Christ the only Son of God, who for His own sake was begotten of the Father before all worlds, when in time He was for our sakes: made man of the Holy Ghost and the ever-virgin Mary,” *John Cassian Seven Books on The Incarnation of The Lord against Nestorius, Bk. I Chap. V *

“Who for us men and for our salvation came down, and was incarnate, that is to say was conceived perfectly through the Holy Ghost of the holy ever-virgin Mary, and was made man,” First Council of Constantinople.

“Moreover we confess that one of the same holy consubstantial Trinity, God the Word, who was begotten of the Father before the worlds, in the last days of the world for us and for our salvation came down from heaven, and was incarnate of the Holy Ghost, and of our Lady, the holy, immaculate, ever-virgin and glorious Mary, truly and properly the Mother of God” Second Council of Constantinople.

“Possibly his reason for thinking that our Lord Jesus Christ was not of our nature was this–that the Angel who was sent to the blessed and **ever Virgin Mary **said, "The Holy Ghost shall come upon thee,…” *The Council of *Chalcedon

.
so what.

NONE of this is from scripture. Period.
 
so what.

NONE of this is from scripture. Period.
Non-Catholic Christians have chosen the Bible, since they reject the Church which Jesus Christ founded.
In regards to the Bible itself, just what does it have to say about the Church that Jesus Christ founded?
  1. Did Jesus Christ found the Bible or the Church?
    Does the Bible say it was the Bible? No, it says He founded His Church, Matthew 16:18.
  2. What is the pillar and foundation of the truth?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible? No, it says it is the Church, 1Timothy 3:15.
    This verse also tells us that the Church was already in existence before 1Timothy was written.
  3. Who or what is the final authority?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible? No, it says it is the Church, Matthew 18:15-18.
  4. Who is the teacher of all the wisdom of GOD?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible? No, it says it is the Church, Ephesians 3:10.
  5. Who is to be saved?
    Does the Bible say that all who believe in Sola Scriptura, (the ‘Bible only’), will be saved?
    No, it says those who are attached to His Church will be saved.
    “And the Lord added to the *church *daily such as should be saved”, *Acts *2:47, King James Bible.
    Note the singular, “the church”.
  6. What are we commanded to edify?
    Does the Bible say that we are to edify the Bible?
    No, it says we are to edify the Church, 1Corinthians 14:12.
  7. Who or what rules the Church of GOD?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says it is the Bishops that the Holy Spirit has appointed that rule the Church of GOD, Acts 20:28.
  8. What is it that Jesus purchased with His own blood?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says that Jesus purchased the Church of GOD with His own blood, Acts 20:28, King James Bible.
    cont…
 
  1. For what did Christ give Himself up?
    Does the Bible say it was the Bible?
    No, the Bible says that Christ gave Himself up for the Church, Ephesians 5:25.
  2. What is it that Jesus nourishes and cherishes?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says that Jesus nourishes and cherishes His Church, Ephesians 5:29.
  3. For what is Jesus the savior?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says Jesus is the savior of His Body which is the Church that He founded, Ephesians 1:22-23, and 5:23.
  4. What has neither spot nor wrinkle?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says it is the Church that Jesus Christ founded, Ephesians 5:27.
    The Church is not holy because of us. The Church is holy because of Him.
  5. To whom or to what is the Church subject?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says the Church is subject to Christ, Ephesians 5:24.
  6. What are we commanded not to offend?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says we are to give no offence to the Church of GOD, 1Corinthians 10:32.
    Do you give offence to the Church of GOD that Jesus Christ founded?
  7. What came first, the New Testament part of the Bible or the Church?
    Does the Bible say it was the Bible?
    No, but it tells us that the Church was already in existence for years before any New Testament books were even written.How do we know this?Because it is the Church which is mentioned in these books:
    Matthew 16:18 and 18:17,
    Acts 5:11, for one and many more times in Acts,
    Romans 16:23, and many more verses,
    1Corinthians 1:2, and many more verses,
    2Corinthians 1:1,
    Galatians 1:13,
    Ephesians 1:22, and many more verses,
    Philippians 3:6 and 4:15,
    Colossians 1:18, and many more verses,
    1Thessalonians 1:1. 1Thessalonians is considered to be the first New Testament book written, in about 51 A.D…
    2Thessalonians 1:1,
    1Timothy 3:5, 3:15 and 5:16,
    Titus 3:15, per added note in the King James Version,
    Philemon 1:2,
    Hebrews 2:12 and 12:23,
    James 5:14,
    1Peter 5:13,
    3John 1:6 and 1:9-10,
    Revelation 2:1, plus six more in the same book.
    Since all of these books mention the word Church, the Church had to have been in existence already for years before they were written. If that is true, then how was the teaching accomplished without a New Testament of Jesus Christ? Simply by the same way that Jesus Christ taught, orally. Oral teaching is Tradition. Tradition (capital ‘T’) is Apostolic oral teaching handed down to their successors and to others. The Bible is oral Tradition written down. There was no such thing as Sola Scriptura even then.
    There was not any New Testament scripture for the first twenty years of the existence of the Church.
 
Non-Catholic Christians have chosen the Bible, since they reject the Church which Jesus Christ founded.

where in scripture did Jesus “found” the "C"atholic Church???

this is a presupposition of yours!

The True Church is ALL believers!! This is the body of Christ…nor simply the Catholic church.

Sorry…
 
  1. Who is the teacher of all the wisdom of GOD?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible? No, it says it is the Church, Ephesians 3:10.
the entire body of believers.

NOT not NOT the "C"atholic chruch.
  1. Who is to be saved
I am sounding like a broken record here…

but your presupposition about the "C"atholic Church is holding you bondage…

There are many people saved that have doings what so ever with the "C"atholic Church…
  1. What are we commanded to edify?
    Does the Bible say that we are to edify the Bible?
    No, it says we are to edify the Church, 1Corinthians 14:12.
who is edifying the bible??

that is just a leather bound book.

I choose to edify the church, …just not the "C"atholic version of it.

I also choose to lift up the WORD OF GOD…which are the scriptures…NOT not NOT the "C"atholic church.
  1. Who or what rules the Church of GOD?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says it is the Bishops that the Holy Spirit has appointed that rule the Church of GOD, Acts 20:28.
well now you are just sounding silly!! Who would let a bound book run the place???

LOL…

No, but I will allow the message via the WORD OF GOD run the place…and the church (NOT not NOT the Catholic church) shall decide…
  1. What is it that Jesus purchased with His own blood?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says that Jesus purchased the Church of GOD with His own blood, Acts 20:28, King James Bible.
cont…

whew…are we done yet?

Have you learned a very good lesson yet???

The Church Christ speaks of…

listen now…

IS…

NOT not NOT solely the "C"atholic Church!!!
 
  1. For what did Christ give Himself up?
    Does the Bible say it was the Bible?
    No, the Bible says that Christ gave Himself up for the Church, Ephesians 5:25.
  2. What is it that Jesus nourishes and cherishes?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says that Jesus nourishes and cherishes His Church, Ephesians 5:29.
  3. For what is Jesus the savior?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says Jesus is the savior of His Body which is the Church that He founded, Ephesians 1:22-23, and 5:23.
  4. What has neither spot nor wrinkle?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says it is the Church that Jesus Christ founded, Ephesians 5:27.
    The Church is not holy because of us. The Church is holy because of Him.
  5. To whom or to what is the Church subject?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says the Church is subject to Christ, Ephesians 5:24.
  6. What are we commanded not to offend?
    Does the Bible say it is the Bible?
    No, the Bible says we are to give no offence to the Church of GOD, 1Corinthians 10:32.
    Do you give offence to the Church of GOD that Jesus Christ founded?
  7. What came first, the New Testament part of the Bible or the Church?
    Does the Bible say it was the Bible?
    No, but it tells us that the Church was already in existence for years before any New Testament books were even written.How do we know this?Because it is the Church which is mentioned in these books:
    Matthew 16:18 and 18:17,
    Acts 5:11, for one and many more times in Acts,
    Romans 16:23, and many more verses,
    1Corinthians 1:2, and many more verses,
    2Corinthians 1:1,
    Galatians 1:13,
    Ephesians 1:22, and many more verses,
    Philippians 3:6 and 4:15,
    Colossians 1:18, and many more verses,
    1Thessalonians 1:1. 1Thessalonians is considered to be the first New Testament book written, in about 51 A.D…
    2Thessalonians 1:1,
    1Timothy 3:5, 3:15 and 5:16,
    Titus 3:15, per added note in the King James Version,
    Philemon 1:2,
    Hebrews 2:12 and 12:23,
    James 5:14,
    1Peter 5:13,
    3John 1:6 and 1:9-10,
    Revelation 2:1, plus six more in the same book.
    Since all of these books mention the word Church, the Church had to have been in existence already for years before they were written. If that is true, then how was the teaching accomplished without a New Testament of Jesus Christ? Simply by the same way that Jesus Christ taught, orally. Oral teaching is Tradition. Tradition (capital ‘T’) is Apostolic oral teaching handed down to their successors and to others. The Bible is oral Tradition written down. There was no such thing as Sola Scriptura even then.
    There was not any New Testament scripture for the first twenty years of the existence of the Church.
to all points.

The Church…

…does not exclude every other believer on the planet.

Choosing to be Catholic doesn’t make you special…it just means you are following the beat of a different drummer. It just means you are Catholic.

But, the Church that is spoken of within scripture, is not exclusively the "C"atholic church.

Sorry to burst your bubble.
 
So where did your scripture come from to start with?
don’t go there.

ALL scripture is God breathed.

Therefore, if we consider the scripture to be Holy…it is from God, not of a denomination.

Thank you.
 
Not relevant to the question at hand.

How do you know that the Bible is the divinely inspired word of God?
I am getting there…

but you won’t be able to understand it, if you do not believe God…

Do you, or do you NOT believe God?

Scripture tells us something very important…

…but, I am wondering where your heart is…and whether or not you understand it depends on the answer of that question.
 
I am getting there…

but you won’t be able to understand it, if you do not believe God…

Do you, or do you NOT believe God?

Scripture tells us something very important…

…but, I am wondering where your heart is…and whether or not you understand it depends on the answer of that question.
Yes, if I did not believe in God, there are details I probably would not fully understand. However, it still has no bearing on the question I asked.

I want to know your reasoning on why the bible is the inspired Word of God?
 
Yes, if I did not believe in God, there are details I probably would not fully understand. However, it still has no bearing on the question I asked.

I want to know your reasoning on why the bible is the inspired Word of God?
Then you believe 2 Tim 3:16.

I believe God.

He told me scripture is HIS INSPIRED WORD…

…sorry you truly don’t.
 
Then you believe 2 Tim 3:16.
2 Tim 3:16 doesn’t lay out the canon of scripture. Nor does it even say that 2 Tim 3:16 is scripture.
I believe God.
…sorry you truly don’t.
Oh brother, how many times have we seen that reply on these forums. It seems to be a staple of a certain breed of disputatious Protestant (and to be fair, a certain breed of disputatious Catholic too). So spare us, please. Or have you been divinely authorized to judge hearts now?
 
Then you believe 2 Tim 3:16.

I believe God.

He told me scripture is HIS INSPIRED WORD…

…sorry you truly don’t.
So you believe the Bible is His inspired Word 'cause He told you so?

So did you just have a dream one night about and God told you all the books that belong in the bible? What about the Book of Mormon, or the Koran? Those all claim to be divinely inspired.
 
2 Tim 3:16 doesn’t lay out the canon of scripture. Nor does it even say that 2 Tim 3:16 is scripture.

Oh brother, how many times have we seen that reply on these forums. It seems to be a staple of a certain breed of disputatious Protestant (and to be fair, a certain breed of disputatious Catholic too). So spare us, please. Or have you been divinely authorized to judge hearts now?
oh brother…

are you telling me that God’s holy word…bound in the bible…is NOT SCRIPTURE?

okie dokie.
 
So you believe the Bible is His inspired Word 'cause He told you so?
um yes. He has told the entire world so, if you choose to read it.
So did you just have a dream one night about and God told you all the books that belong in the bible? What about the Book of Mormon, or the Koran? Those all claim to be divinely inspired.
nope…just opened up the bible and started reading.

The Holy Spirit reveals the Truth.

Oh yea…

The Catholic Church does not hold the reigns, the monopoly, nor the corner on who the HS speaks to…

The Catholic Church is also not the HS itself.

…just thought I would add that.
 
One historical fact is the fact that the canon of the Bible – the authoritative list of exactly which books are part of inspired Scripture – was not settled and fixed until the end of the 4th century. Until that time, there was much disagreement over which Biblical writings were considered inspired and Apostolic in origin. The Biblical canon varied from place to place: some lists contained books that were later defined as non-canonical, while other lists failed to include books which were later defined as canonical. For example, there were Early Christian writings which were considered by some to be inspired and Apostolic and which were actually read in Christian public worship, but which were later omitted from the New Testament canon. These include The Shepherd of Hermas, The Epistle of Barnabas, and The Didache, among others.
It was not until the Synod of Rome (382) and the Councils of Hippo (393) and Carthage (397) that we find a definitive list of canonical books being drawn up, and each of these Councils acknowledged the very same list of books. From this point on, there is in practice no dispute about the canon of the Bible, the only exception being the so-called Protestant Reformers, who entered upon the scene in 1517, an unbelievable 11 centuries later.
Once again, there are two fundamental questions for which one cannot provide answers that are consonant with Sola Scriptura:
A) Who or what served as the final Christian authority up to the time that the New Testament’s canon was identified?
B) And if there was a final authority that the Protestant recognizes before the establishment of the canon, on what basis did that authority cease being final once the Bible’s canon was established?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top