Are Catholics seriously proposing that we return to the days of book burning?
Das war ein Vorspiel nur, dort wo man Bücher verbrennt, verbrennt man am Ende auch Menschen. (That was only a prelude. Wherever one burns books, one will in the end also burn people.) Heinrich Heine, Almansor (1823), my own translation.
The phenomenon, and the mental picture, of burning books, brings to mind various political movements which the modern mind rightly recoils against. Let’s just say that burning books doesn’t have a good reputation. Burning is just one more means of disposal, morally neutral in itself, but not the most ecologically friendly one — paper that could be recycled is wasted, and the smoke and toxins released are not good for the environment. Ecologically friendly pulping and recycling would be far preferable.