C
crazzeto
Guest
Make no mistake, masturbation is most certainly a sin and it most certainly is a grave sin. With regard to pleasuring one another durring the marital embrase, well I might talk to a priest about how they understand this. But I would not take such a possible “gray area” and try extending that out to “well I guess masturbation is no big deal what so ever”. The Churches teaching is clear on the subject clear, and it’s teachings in the area of faith and morals is in fact infallible (though sure, our reading of the Catechism may or may not be…).No, these things are apples and oranges. The Catechism explains the difference between self defense vs murder and sex within marriage vs sex outside of marriage. Masterbation is considered a grave sin per the Catechism…and if I am supposed to take the Catechism literally (and what I hear on here constantly about grave sins), then there should be no exceptions to such a sin. The ends doesn’t justify the means, right?
Now, I am struggling with Church teaching on masterbation/sexual morality within marriage so I’m not necessarily saying that I take issue with what is being said here (re: allowing the woman to finish via masterbation). But to me that sounds like there are certain circumstances when masterbation is okay (granted, within marriage). It truly makes me wonder just how grave this sin is…or if it is a sin at all. It also doesn’t seem right to allow this exception for the woman and not the man. I can understand this thinking when way back semen was considered life itself…and therefore spilling it outside the womb was akin to murder/abortion…but not so much now in this day and age when we know that semen is not life itself.
PS. I have read the book…