Melania Trump is the first Catholic first lady since Jackie Kennedy

Status
Not open for further replies.
She’s lived with a twice-divorced adulterer since 2001, spends weekends with him, and travels the world with him, but is living in NYC to avoid giving scandal? That ship sailed a long time ago.
When the story first came out that she wasn’t moving into the White House with President Trump, I thought that was odd. I couldn’t think of a good reason for her not to do so…other than she was still ticked off at him for the whole Billy Bush audio. Maybe the real reason is her son’s education. Maybe it’s nothing more than that. All I know for sure is that at present, Mr. and Mrs. Trump are not living in the same house.
 
Soo…worry about creating a scandal of being in an adulterous relationship will not be a concern once he’s out of (his Episcopal) school?
You keep bringing up the point that their son is attending an Episcopal school. That’s a fair thing to bring up.

Yet if Mrs. Trump came into the Church as recently as this Easter (not sure we can expect her being required to have her son raised Catholic prior to her being Catholic) how do we know their son won’t be enrolling in a Catholic school next year?
 
mary bobo;14677156:
Let’s see: In spite of constant media coverage, she has never been photographed inside a Catholic Church before this last trip, she was married in another church to a man who, in the eyes of the Church, is not free to marry, she baptized her son in another religion and is raising him in that religion.

But questioning a statement for which there is no supporting evidence is an indication that those who do so are “anti-Trump” and wish to denigrate him and his innocent family members.

It couldn’t possibly be that those who defend Trump are people who do not place much emphasis on facts.
Oh, but there are facts – “alternative facts” – namely, that she was baptized in secret, that she goes to church in secret and receives all her sacraments in secret and with the benefit of dispensation, and despite being a major celebrity, has never been photographed inside a Catholic church prior to meeting the pope OR after – and, if that effort weren’t impressive enough, she goes to extra mile to raise her child in a non-Catholic environment because the “liberal media” makes it extra difficult for her. (Is this summation correct?) To say this ‘story’ requires “suspension of disbelief” is an understatement: I’m more inclined to believe that Captain Jack Sparrow is a real person and that “Pirates of the Caribbean” is a documentary. Evidence? Facts? Pfft–! Who needs 'em? :rolleyes:
 
You keep bringing up the point that their son is attending an Episcopal school. That’s a fair thing to bring up.

Yet if Mrs. Trump came into the Church as recently as this Easter (not sure we can expect her being required to have her son raised Catholic prior to her being Catholic) how do we know their son won’t be enrolling in a Catholic school next year?
How many “if’s” are we reasonably expected to concede? We don’t know - period. No amount of conjecture and pretzellian logic will help us to know.
 
Separate bedrooms.

I don’t think anyone needs the Pope’s permission to move in to a house and have separate bedrooms.
You may be right. I have no idea how that process works. I keep hearing about it being scandalous for unmarried persons living in the same house and that could be grounds not to marry a couple in the Catholic Church. I could be wrong about that though. I don’t have any real world examples to go by so I may be way off base.
 
How many “if’s” are we reasonably expected to concede? We don’t know - period. No amount of conjecture and pretzellian logic will help us to know.
All I know is that it has been reported that the First Lady is Catholic. I am happy to hear this news.
 
You keep bringing up the point that their son is attending an Episcopal school. That’s a fair thing to bring up.
Yep. It’s my tongue in cheek counter to “But she carried a rosary when she got married!”

(Also, let it be known that I am also being wry when I say that Ivana should be recognized as the real First Lady).
Yet if Mrs. Trump came into the Church as recently as this Easter (not sure we can expect her being required to have her son raised Catholic prior to her being Catholic) how do we know their son won’t be enrolling in a Catholic school next year?
Let’s have her go to Catholic Mass every Sunday first. That would be a good sign.
 
Why are people so apoplectic about Melania’s claiming to be Catholic, when for years, people have defended gay minister’s like Lizzie Biden and Tim Kaine when they claimed to be Catholic?

This is apparently the liberal version of Obama having to prove his citizenship, except that he obliged, since that was a requirement to be President. There is no such requirement for first lady, and I doubt she feels obliged to answer a bunch of rabid foaming at the month internet warriors.
 
All I know is that it has been reported that the First Lady is Catholic. I am happy to hear this news.
And that narrative is being inexplicably pushed despite all indication to the contrary. Are reason and critical thinking skills entirely foreign to the “First Lady is a Catholic Convert” narrative? It’s none of anyone’s business what faith she professes - when Catholics are played for suckers (again), that should be everyone’s concern.
 
Let’s have her go to Catholic Mass every Sunday first. That would be a good sign.
That would be awesome!

Of course, no need for us to be the ones checking in to see if she’s in the pews on a weekly basis.
 
Why are people so apoplectic about Melania’s claiming to be Catholic, when for years, people have defended gay minister’s like Lizzie Biden and Tim Kaine when they claimed to be Catholic?
It’s more about being apoplectic about the double standard. “Melania is Catholic because she carries a rosary! But this person is not a good Catholic because she holds hands during the Our Father!”

That gets us apoplectic.
 
…when Catholics are played for suckers (again), that should be everyone’s concern.
How did we get to the point in society that when it is reported that someone has discovered the beauty of Catholicism that the first reaction is doubt rather than joy?
 
That would be awesome!

Of course, no need for us to be the ones checking in to see if she’s in the pews on a weekly basis.
I have no clue if she’s Catholic or not, baptized or trying to regularize a marriage situation.

However, if you need “pew checkers” to take Mass attendance, or “communion police” to make sure no one is GASP is in mortal sin that is communing, I’ll send over some from my Church.

Mary.
 
All I know is that it has been reported that the First Lady is Catholic. I am happy to hear this news.
Why does this make you happy?

I’m hoping that the report is false. I would hate to think that the world views Melania Trump as an example of Catholicism.
 
To those of you doubting that that Melania Trump is Catholic and pointing out of course she has some issues to resolve regarding marriage etc, which I agree with, I was just wondering…

Would you be disappointed to find out she is Catholic and does regularize her marriage and thus becomes a Catholic First Lady sometime during Trump’s presidency?

Just a wondering for it seems like a witch hunt proving she is not Catholic, has this and that do and I have the impression some here want nothing to do with her as an ‘official’ rule abiding, regularized Catholic First Lady.

Mary.
 
Would you be disappointed to find out she is Catholic and does regularize her marriage and thus becomes a Catholic First Lady sometime during Trump’s presidency?
I would not be disappointed at all.
 
You keep bringing up the point that their son is attending an Episcopal school. That’s a fair thing to bring up.

Yet if Mrs. Trump came into the Church as recently as this Easter (not sure we can expect her being required to have her son raised Catholic prior to her being Catholic) how do we know their son won’t be enrolling in a Catholic school next year?
She attended Easter services at the Episcopal church on Palm Beach. But I don’t know if she took communion there on Easter nor if she also attended a Catholic Mass.

But how do we know her son won’t be enrolling in a Catholic school next school year? Because he is starting in an Episcopal school in MD when the new school yr begins.

Barron Trump, the 11-year-old son of President Trump and first lady Melania Trump, will attend the private St. Andrew’s Episcopal School in Potomac, Md., this fall after he moves from New York to Washington with his mother.

Barron Trump is finishing out the current school year at Columbia Grammar and Preparatory School on the Upper West Side of Manhattan.

First lady Melania Trump said in a statement:

“We are very excited for our son to attend St. Andrew’s Episcopal School. It is known for its diverse community and commitment to academic excellence. The mission of St. Andrew’s is ‘to know and inspire each child in an inclusive community dedicated to exceptional teaching, learning, and service,’ all of which appealed to our family. We look forward to the coming school years at St. Andrew’s.”

The school’s website says it strives to educate students “in an inclusive environment that embodies the faith and perspective of the Episcopal Church.”

washingtonpost.com/news/answer-sheet/wp/2017/05/15/barron-trump-to-attend-private-st-andrews-episcopal-school-in-maryland-this-fall/?utm_term=.4d12545701e7
 
Has Melania Trump been receiving communion in a Catholic Church?
I think you actually have to attend Mass in order for it to be possible to receive communion…

and since she doesn’t go to Mass, I guess the answer to your question is…

Nope.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top