Met your spouse online? Advice for those of us searching?

  • Thread starter Thread starter iwillrisenow
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I

iwillrisenow

Guest
This is a message for those of you who have succeeded, so to speak, with online dating. If you met your spouse or serious partner via any online site (Catholic, secular; expressly dating, other activities), what advice would you give to a younger sibling or friend who is just venturing out into that world? Did you go in with very specific parameters (and, if so, what were they) or more of a “let’s see what happens” kind of attitude? Did you have any rules for yourself? And, if your partner has ever shared what caught their eye on your profile, what was it?

As the New Year approaches and many of us are starting to think about making a fresh start with these things, I thought I’d kick off a positive conversation on what can sometimes be a not-so-positive topic 🙂
 
I’ve posted some of this here in the past, so apologies to those who’ve read it before.

I met DH on Ave Maria Singles. We’ve been married for about three years now.

I went into it with the attitude that AMS wasn’t a magic pill that would “fix” my singleness. I had discerned that marriage was my vocation, and while I knew a number of single Catholics IRL, I hadn’t really “clicked” with any of the guys. I saw AMS as a way to expand the number of people I would meet–sort of like attending a party hosted by a friend at which I might expect to meet a lot of new people.

Similarly to the party scenario, I did initiate contact with several guys–DH among them! I figured that if we were at the aforementioned party, there would be nothing wrong with my saying, “Isn’t the wine good? So, how do you know Susan?” and seeing where the conversation went from there. I have to say that I’m glad I did. 😉

I also saw it as a way of honing both my communication/social skills and a way to narrow down what, exactly, I wanted in a spouse. Before I got into online dating, yes, I knew I wanted to find a practicing Catholic husband, one who attended Mass on every Sunday/holy day of obligation, believed as the Church teaches on birth control, NFP, etc. I hadn’t considered that my personality is really not cut out for, for example, the life of a military spouse. I need a certain amount of stability, and I realized after thinking about it for a while and very briefly talking to one or two military guys that I would not make a good military wife, especially if it would involve moving regularly, so it wouldn’t be fair to guys making a career in the military (who, needless to say, I respect and admire enormously!) to lead them on only to have some sort of breakdown around move #5 in 3 years with several small kids.

Don’t take it too seriously. Be kind and considerate of the person you’re dating, but don’t assume that he/she is The One after two dates, or assume that you’ll never find The One because a couple of dates didn’t work out.

Do be safety-conscious, especially if you’re a woman. I always let a friend know where I was going, with whom (including contact info), and when I planned on being home, and checked in with the friend over the course of the evening. Nothing dramatic, just “I’m home safe,” or “we decided to go for coffee after the movie, talk to you later.”

Do stay in separate rooms/buildings. DH and I dated long-distance. We’d stay in hotels when we’d go see each other. Smarter and easier, fewer temptations. By the same token, though, never spending time alone with one another was impractical. We were both grown adults with our own apartments and no family in the area. What was simplest for us was to make a rule about no physical contact in private. Hug/kiss hello/goodbye at the open door, yes. Cuddling on the couch alone in an apartment…nope. We’d hold hands and be physically more affectionate in public, but that way we didn’t have to worry about temptations in private.

Do be honest, but don’t disclose too much information until the relationship is serious. I didn’t know how much DH made per year until we were engaged, and vice versa. I did let him know late in the dating process that my family has alcoholism and general dysfunction in it, as I thought that was important information for him to know when making a decision about who to marry. I didn’t mention it on the first date. 😛

I may think of other things in a bit and post them as they come up.
 
I met my husband on Ave Maria Singles. We met in 2003, dated a year, engaged 8 months, married 10 years. We were both on the site for 2 years before we met each other.

My suggestion:
  1. Guard your heart and don’t get sucked in to false intimacy that online dating can engender. Hours of talking, text messages and what-have-you, create a premature sense of intimacy and emotional connection to a person at a pace that you would not have when dating in real life. It leads to unrealistic expectations and to disappointment and disillusionment when it doesn’t work out.
  2. Just because you are on a Catholic dating site doesn’t mean you won’t meet flaky people. You will. You will meet nice people who just don’t work out but you will also meet FLAKES. Also, newbies on the online sites get LOTS of hits. Then, your profile dies down and you start to think “what’s wrong with me”. NOTHING.
  3. Don’t take it personally. People will message you, they will seem nice, sincere, interesting. You will get excited, infatuated, and hopeful. Then they will decide not to communicate any longer. You will be tempted to try to analyze what is wrong with YOU. The answer to that is NOTHING. OR, you will write to someone and they will never even acknowledge or write back. They will have some flaky reason they won’t correspond with you (one guy didn’t want to talk to me because I was a convert and he only wanted a cradle Catholic. another didn’t like that I wore pants to mass). There are millions of people on online sites. You can’t take rejection personally.
4)) Just because you are on a Catholic site, don’t take things at face value. Some people will answer questions dishonestly-- I have no idea why. Also, they may put up pictures that are outdated (i.e. 100 pounds ago, or 10 years ago). Again, I have no idea why.
  1. You will kiss just as many frogs online as IRL.
  2. Don’t expect the magical email that will result in a whirlwind romance and perfect mate. Marriage is hard work, dating is a serious process of discernment and you should keep your skeptic glasses firmly on your face and do your due diligence.
  3. Don’t limit yourself geographically or get too picky on criteria. You never know where the right person will be found.
  4. If, after the above, you still want to do online dating-- go online with your eyes wide open, your heart firmly under guard, and a mature approach to the process and you have good odds of meeting a wonderful Catholic to spend the rest of your life with.
I dated about 7 different men (meaning I at least met them in person once) from Ave before meeting my DH. Two years is a long time online dating, it’s easy to get discouraged. Give the process time to work.
 
don’t assume that he/she is The One after two dates.
Also don’t assume that people are ONLY online. One guy I was talking to on Ave got set up on a date IRL by a friend and he decided to focus on the real, local relationship rather than our online one. So he closed down his profile.

Again, don’t take things personally.
 
I met my husband on Match.com. It is a secular site, but the pool of candidates is large.

I would say: Be explicit about your goals and values; don’t compromise if you see any red flags. Otherwise, be flexible about giving people a chance if you’re at all interested in them.

Move on from the computer stage to phone conversations and actual contact fairly quickly.

Don’t lead on people. If someone seems nice but you don’t feel any attraction whatsoever, best not to continue contact. On the other hand, if you are mildly attracted, give the person a chance and see whether you feel more or less attracted as time goes on.

Don’t be paralyzed by too many choices. When you make a choice (to contact or not), don’t second-guess yourself.

Yes, be safe when meeting people; make sure someone else knows where you are and who you’re with on those early dates.

Don’t take things personally.

Behave in a manner that signals what you want. Your profile picture and profile, your messages, the “pace” with which you proceed should all reflect what you want in terms of a relationship and of a significant other. For me, I purposely did NOT initiate contact with the men on the site. I wanted a guy who was going to take the first step. I tried to present myself as someone who liked things of the mind and the spirit and enjoyed the outdoors, who wasn’t especially interested in pop culture, who wanted a husband and children. I don’t know what exactly made my husband decide to give me a chance, but he did, and I’m quite glad.
 
This is a message for those of you who have succeeded, so to speak, with online dating. If you met your spouse or serious partner via any online site (Catholic, secular; expressly dating, other activities), what advice would you give to a younger sibling or friend who is just venturing out into that world? Did you go in with very specific parameters (and, if so, what were they) or more of a “let’s see what happens” kind of attitude? Did you have any rules for yourself? And, if your partner has ever shared what caught their eye on your profile, what was it?

As the New Year approaches and many of us are starting to think about making a fresh start with these things, I thought I’d kick off a positive conversation on what can sometimes be a not-so-positive topic 🙂
My cousin met his now ex- wife on e-Harmony. Unfortunately, they moved too quickly and ignored some very big red flags.

I think they had a strong physical connection that clouded their judgment.

He now complains she is/was too liberal in her thinking and she now admits he drinks too much. Both of these things were evident during the dating process but they moved in together and got married anyway.

They are not religious people but I thought I would bring up their situation anyway.
 
A friend met her husband on a Christian site. They’ve been married about ten years now. I don’t remember the name of it. I think he was the first and only person she connected with through the site. He was a non-practicing Catholic and she was a Lutheran. Both now attend a Presbyterian church.
 
If you meet someone online and think there’s potential, meet in person sooner rather than later (if they’re local). DH and I met online (though not through online dating), but I doubt much would have come of it if we hadn’t met in person shortly after that.
 
I met my husband on Catholicmatch. I recommend going into it prayerfully and being yourself on your profile. My husband said that he liked my name, my eyes, and the fact that I posted a video of myself singing “Goodnight My Someone.”
 
I met my husband on Catholicmatch. I recommend going into it prayerfully and being yourself on your profile. My husband said that he liked my name, my eyes, and the fact that I posted a video of myself singing “Goodnight My Someone.”
Adorable!
 
I did not meet my husband on line. (We have been married for 50 years)

But, I know several couples who have:
My daughter
My Son
My Husband’s two nephews.

All four have been good matches.

They have many of the same experiences.

Take your time. My son said that after a while you get a real sense of when a person is lying or just playing games.

Be honest!!

Important but often over looked:

Do you both like animals? A dog or cat lover is not a good match for someone who can’t put up with dog or cat hair.
Are you both active and enjoy hiking etc.? Or do you both enjoy a much more sedentary life?
Do you share the same religion with same intensity?
Do you both want to live in the country or in the city?
Do you both enjoy eating out?
Do you laugh at the same things?
How clean and organized do you want your home to be?
Do you both want children?

My son and his wife are “on fire” for Christ - together
My daughter and her husband enjoy going to fancy restaurants and traveling. They approve of how each other relates to their children.
One nephew and his wife love history and run a ranch.
The other nephew and his wife are involved in computers and education.

Great matches. God speed.
 
I have only been doing online dating for about a year and I have not found the person I want to be with yet. However, my main piece of advice would be to stay away from okcupid (and any other free site that may spring up). Yes, that is a truly free online dating site with a lot of members, but the people on there are just looking around and not actively looking for dates/relationships. Most of the Catholics on okcupid are in name only and it’s really just a waste of time.

I went into online dating with the goal of finding a lifelong partner. A religious vocation is not my calling in life. The criteria I used to look for people goes as follows:

-Catholic (obviously)
-Prolife all the way
-No hardcore body-modders
-Must be a virgin
-Must be loyal
-Same race as me
-Similar recreational interests

Your best bet is to go on a dating website exclusively for Catholics. That’s what I will be doing next. Whatever you do, don’t let anyone pick your spouse for you and don’t let anyone mock your relationship goals. I’m head-strong about marrying someone who is completely prolife and a virgin. I’ve endured quite a bit from people over those requirements, but I’m not backing down. Listen to your gut and never be afraid to show your true colors.
 
I went into online dating with the goal of finding a lifelong partner. A religious vocation is not my calling in life. The criteria I used to look for people goes as follows:

-Catholic (obviously)
-Prolife all the way
-No hardcore body-modders
-Must be a virgin
-Must be loyal
-Same race as me
-Similar recreational interests

Your best bet is to go on a dating website exclusively for Catholics. That’s what I will be doing next. Whatever you do, don’t let anyone pick your spouse for you and don’t let anyone mock your relationship goals. I’m head-strong about marrying someone who is completely prolife and a virgin. I’ve endured quite a bit from people over those requirements, but I’m not backing down. Listen to your gut and never be afraid to show your true colors.
While I admire people who keep their standards high, I think it’s very possible that you’re shooting yourself in the foot with the 2 requirements that I made red. The church is UNIVERSAL. You’re more likely to meet a compatible spouse if you widen your search to someone beyond your own race. And please don’t tell me that the only attractive women you have ever seen are of your own race. There are faithful and beautiful Asian, Black, Indian, Latina, and White women in the church (listed alphabetically, and not to be taken as any sort of ranking). You may be overlooking a gem because she doesn’t share your skin color. That seems a little shallow. . .

As far as virginity, I think that’s a great aspiration but would you really disqualify a girl who had everything else but that??? And I say that as someone who has waited. While I am hoping for a guy who also has, I’m more interested in his current situation, not his past.

God doesn’t really work with rigid requirements. Focus on the qualities that you require in a match rather than things like race. Instead of saying “she must be X race” say “I must be physically attracted to her.” That opens the possibility that it might be an attractive girl of another race. Instead of saying “she must be a virgin” say “she must be chaste.” Again, opens up the possibilities. Be open to God’s will, whoever the girl might be.
 
My number one piece of advice is: be patient. It took me seven years of online dating. (Yes…seven!) I wasn’t always subscribing and took some breaks, but in that time period, I met several nice Catholic men after doing messaging and phone conversations. Yet nothing worked out. Often it was me doing the rejecting. I just knew it wasn’t right and wasn’t going to settle. My favorite site was CatholicMatch and that is where I met my fiance last year. When I met him, I knew. He was the one for me, and is everything I hoped to find in a spouse. We are getting married in the summer.

All those online…don’t give up! I went through a LOT of doubts and wanting to quit, but I am so glad I didn’t!
 
While I admire people who keep their standards high, I think it’s very possible that you’re shooting yourself in the foot with the 2 requirements that I made red. The church is UNIVERSAL. You’re more likely to meet a compatible spouse if you widen your search to someone beyond your own race. And please don’t tell me that the only attractive women you have ever seen are of your own race. There are faithful and beautiful Asian, Black, Indian, Latina, and White women in the church (listed alphabetically, and not to be taken as any sort of ranking). You may be overlooking a gem because she doesn’t share your skin color. That seems a little shallow. . .

As far as virginity, I think that’s a great aspiration but would you really disqualify a girl who had everything else but that??? And I say that as someone who has waited. While I am hoping for a guy who also has, I’m more interested in his current situation, not his past.

God doesn’t really work with rigid requirements. Focus on the qualities that you require in a match rather than things like race. Instead of saying “she must be X race” say “I must be physically attracted to her.” That opens the possibility that it might be an attractive girl of another race. Instead of saying “she must be a virgin” say “she must be chaste.” Again, opens up the possibilities. Be open to God’s will, whoever the girl might be.
Right.

Also, with virginity, how are you planning on checking? :eek:

Insisting on a virgin may expose you to the risk of turning away chaste, honest non-virginal women while selecting a dishonest non-virginal woman.
 
I met my husband on Match.com.

I was a non-practicing Catholic and he was a Christian. We converted, together, later on.

I think my husband and I are one of those rare cases where we met each other fairly quickly through online dating.

I was on Match for about 3-4 months max. I met and went on a couple of dates with one guy before I met my husband.

My husband wasn’t even on Match for a whole month and I was the second or third girl he messaged but the first to reply.

I had fairly loose criteria when I went on and started looking.
My qualifications for men were:
  1. Located within 30-45 mins driving distance from my house.
  2. Employment
  3. Fairly good looking by my standards
  4. No smokers, no drug use, no excessive alcohol use.
  5. Willing to meet ASAP
  6. Dating prospects only.
We exchanged a handful of e-mails and then made plans to meet and go on a date.

8 years, a marriage, 3 kids, a house and a plethora of other things in the mix later and here we are. The rest is history.

My two biggest pieces of advice is to meet as soon as you can…don’t carry on a relationship until you go on a physical date.
Skype/texting/online anything doesn’t count as dating.

Also, the longer you are online and looking means you need to loosen your standards a little bit more if you want it to work.
 
While I admire people who keep their standards high, I think it’s very possible that you’re shooting yourself in the foot with the 2 requirements that I made red.
I’m fully aware that my requirements will be difficult to satisfy. But I would rather not get married at all than to marry someone I’m not interested in. I’ve never been attracted to other races romantically. They are still God’s creation and God loves them just as much. But the attraction just isn’t there for me. In regards to virginity, I don’t want a chaste non-virgin. I’ve already turned down a few of them and never once have I had any regrets.
Right.

Also, with virginity, how are you planning on checking? :eek:

Insisting on a virgin may expose you to the risk of turning away chaste, honest non-virginal women while selecting a dishonest non-virginal woman.
Such a marriage would be illegitimate and it could be annulled. I’m not terribly worried about a girl lying. There are plenty of non-virgins who don’t care about sexual history. I don’t come from money.

This is all I’m willing to say about my own requirements in this thread. If anyone still has questions they are itching to ask, then shoot me a PM. It would be unfair to OP to have the thread hijacked.
 
Such a marriage would be illegitimate and it could be annulled.
Your opinions are your opinions in terms of wanting a chaste-virgin…but this is not a fact.

So…if they confess and are absolved it doesn’t matter?

Hubby and I weren’t virgins when we met. We were both with other people.

We also converted and confessed our sins.

Actually my husband was actually baptized a Catholic only 2 weeks before we got married.

Is our Marriage illegitimate?

None of the priests or the deacon we spoke with thought so.
 
I’m fully aware that my requirements will be difficult to satisfy. But I would rather not get married at all than to marry someone I’m not interested in. I’ve never been attracted to other races romantically. They are still God’s creation and God loves them just as much. But the attraction just isn’t there for me. In regards to virginity, I don’t want a chaste non-virgin. I’ve already turned down a few of them and never once have I had any regrets.

Such a marriage would be illegitimate and it could be annulled. I’m not terribly worried about a girl lying. There are plenty of non-virgins who don’t care about sexual history. I don’t come from money.

This is all I’m willing to say about my own requirements in this thread. If anyone still has questions they are itching to ask, then shoot me a PM. It would be unfair to OP to have the thread hijacked.
Good luck to you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top