Let’s say Yoga was very possibly adapted for military “needs”.
New idea for Yoga:
Patient complains. Sees military psychologist. Then goes to Yoga practioner. Soldier goes back to troops feeling a bit better. Soldier revisits medic, who says: “
Socks up soldier, how you doin’?” And there we have the beginnings of said-fad.
- Assessed outcomes during Yoga.
- Success or failure in reaching target objective.
- Fine for illnesses. Soldiers apparently believed they were improving.
Okay, this all seems reasonably logical.
Yoga being used for medicinal purposes proves that Yoga in the military was and possibly still is encompassing the ‘spiritual’ aspects; hence, why the military have been using Sikhs to train them - quite long distances to go for just exercise!
To reiterate: the military have sikhs training their soldiers - unnecessary, if training is only simple exercise.
Research points to the fact that
Yoga is a sum of its parts. There is no easy separation for Yoga from its philosophical and ‘spiritual’ origins.
From data provided by a poster who was in the military -
new ideas have a regimented shelf-life based on performance targets.
So, soldiers feel a bit better from having done Yoga, and Yoga is kept as medicinal therapy in the U.S army…
Absolutely begging the question:
when, how and why soldiers who were not ill, began training with the use of Yoga…?
What caused the army - what success in what practices - to deem it okay in reports for the use of Yoga to continue for routine army training for those who are not ill?
Was the practice / practices of Yoga challenged, and if so,
what were the performance targets that allowed Yoga, despite being questioned, to carry over into routine army training for those whe are not ill?
What ‘strain’ of Yoga was kept and what strains were left to be used in the training of fit soldiers?
Who decided it was possible to split Yoga into strands?
When did the military bring in Sikhs, and why? Was this before or after performance targets were drawn up for the use of Yoga in the military?
**None of this can point to effective use of Yoga in military ops. **
Especially if there is no action to be assessed.
Let me repeat this:
**None of this can point to effective use of Yoga in military ops. **
Especially if there is no action to be assessed.
Only proof is in effective enhancment (or not) of troop’s performance in training.