Modesty Question

  • Thread starter Thread starter jeanne71350
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jeanne71350

Guest
Hi everyone,

First of, I’m not trying to start an argument about what’s appropriate and what’s not. I listen to what the Church says, but I’m asking this question mainly for my own knowledge. Now, I understand why women must cover the chest area, lower back area, and keep skirts and dresses around knee-length, but why is it considered immodest for a women to have bare shoulders?

Any answer is appreciated!

Thanks, God bless, and Happy Easter!

-Jeanne
 
What type of “shoulder-revealing-tops/dresses” would be modest enough to where cleavage or anything isn’t showing? Usually the two go hand in hand…

Also, with some guys, not all, it makes it easier to fantasize about women when something like the shoulders are revealed… I mean, the less cloth, the easier it is for him to imagine removing the clothing… The man’s mind is wired this way. So the more clothing, the easier it is for the man to resist temptation!

Good question and thanks for trying to keep men from having impure thoughts! It really helps to gain respect from the RIGHT guys. Which is really hard in this modern day 'n age where anything goes!

Peace and God bless!
 
Hi everyone,

First of, I’m not trying to start an argument about what’s appropriate and what’s not. I listen to what the Church says, but I’m asking this question mainly for my own knowledge. Now, I understand why women must cover the chest area, lower back area, and keep skirts and dresses around knee-length, but why is it considered immodest for a women to have bare shoulders?

Any answer is appreciated!

Thanks, God bless, and Happy Easter!

-Jeanne
I read a story about a woman who spent many years in purgatory for having bare shoulders. In the story the woman was seen (by a Saint…I forget which one), in purgatory, with snakes crawling all over her. Its immodest. Just thought I’d share.
 
It is not normally immodest to wear sleeveless clothes were your shoulders are practically bear. It is I think immodest to wear them in church though unless you wear something over it. However your breasts do need to be completely covered in in clothing that is not tight.
Mikayla
 
What type of “shoulder-revealing-tops/dresses” would be modest enough to where cleavage or anything isn’t showing? Usually the two go hand in hand…

Also, with some guys, not all, it makes it easier to fantasize about women when something like the shoulders are revealed… I mean, the less cloth, the easier it is for him to imagine removing the clothing… The man’s mind is wired this way. So the more clothing, the easier it is for the man to resist temptation!

Good question and thanks for trying to keep men from having impure thoughts! It really helps to gain respect from the RIGHT guys. Which is really hard in this modern day 'n age where anything goes!

Peace and God bless!
I mean something like this: bragardusa.com/v/hotel_apparel/images/front_desk/wcustom/unitou_sleeveless_dress.jpg

where the neckline and the hem is the right length, it’s just sleeveless.

-Jeanne
 
That would be fine if if it were looser, but it definitly covers enough. Do not worry about wearing sleeveless clothes as long as they are loose enough and cover your breasts and stomach and are long enough. They don’t have to be nee length but almost nee length. Hope this helps!
Mikayla
 
I read a story about a woman who spent many years in purgatory for having bare shoulders. In the story the woman was seen (by a Saint…I forget which one), in purgatory, with snakes crawling all over her. Its immodest. Just thought I’d share.
Could that have been the mysterious Amelia, of Fatima?
 
I’m guessing in the old days with the materials and technology of the times it would have been difficult to have a dress that was of the shoulder that would not reveal the breasts onsome very basic prayerfull positions. :eek:
 
I mean something like this: bragardusa.com/v/hotel_apparel/images/front_desk/wcustom/unitou_sleeveless_dress.jpg

where the neckline and the hem is the right length, it’s just sleeveless.

-Jeanne
If you were that dress into Church, put a light weight shrug with it. Also, make sure any pants you wear are not too tight. Shorts should not be tight and should be more knee-length, too. Of course, this could start another debate on walking shorts in a South Florida parish…but I’m not going to address that one! 😉
 
I read a story about a woman who spent many years in purgatory for having bare shoulders. In the story the woman was seen (by a Saint…I forget which one), in purgatory, with snakes crawling all over her. Its immodest. Just thought I’d share.
Considering we are all born with bare shoulders:🙂 I can’t imagine such fashions being so hideously sinful.

And the presence of snakes, etc, in Purgatory is altogether conjectural.

ICXC NIKA
 
If it is, the story is not from Fatima: I’d never heard such before.
Right - that was just a wild guess on my part. Amelia was real, however. Apparently she was an older girl, a friend of Lucia’s family, who had died recently and was said by Our Lady to be in Purgatory “until the end of time” for unspecified offences, presumably of a modesty-related nature.
And sleeveless garb in Portugal in 1917???
I’m thinking she might have let her boyfriend see a bit of forbidden shoulder-flesh, that brief sensual pleasure assuring her (and him?) a few snake-covered years in Purgatory.
 
Hi everyone,

First of, I’m not trying to start an argument about what’s appropriate and what’s not. I listen to what the Church says, but I’m asking this question mainly for my own knowledge. Now, I understand why women must cover the chest area, lower back area, and keep skirts and dresses around knee-length, but why is it considered immodest for a women to have bare shoulders?

Any answer is appreciated!

Thanks, God bless, and Happy Easter!

-Jeanne
Just a wild guess: It’s not the shoulders per se, it’s the body sides beneath the arms that would likewise be bare and ought not be drawn attention to.

ICXC NIKA
 
Right - that was just a wild guess on my part. Amelia was real, however. Apparently she was an older girl, a friend of Lucia’s family, who had died recently and was said by Our Lady to be in Purgatory “until the end of time” for unspecified offences, presumably of a modesty-related nature.
Yes, I know of her and her association with the Fatima children. This story has left me wondering just what hideous sin could have drawn such a young woman to so much Purgatory!

But no writing about Fatima or publicity at Fatima itself mentions the shoulders or snakes.
I’m thinking she might have let her boyfriend see a bit of forbidden shoulder-flesh, that brief sensual pleasure assuring her (and him?) a few snake-covered years in Purgatory.
Who knows?

ICXC NIKA
 
I mean something like this: bragardusa.com/v/hotel_apparel/images/front_desk/wcustom/unitou_sleeveless_dress.jpg

where the neckline and the hem is the right length, it’s just sleeveless.

-Jeanne
That dress is fine I think. when you said sleeveless, I was thinking like a bandau or haltar type top which I don’t think are at all appropriate for church. Personally, I don’t wear sleeveless dresses/tops very often, because the arm holes are frequently not made well and they gap or are bigger than they should be. But if the dress fits correctly, you should be OK. I would recommend a getting a matching sweater/jacket/shrug.
 
I read a story about a woman who spent many years in purgatory for having bare shoulders. In the story the woman was seen (by a Saint…I forget which one), in purgatory, with snakes crawling all over her. Its immodest. Just thought I’d share.
:eek: Ok… .I have never heard anything like this before… terrifying… I’m becoming a nervous mess. Can someone clarify or defuse this for me!!!

I am already stressed out because I wanted to receive Eucharist tomorrow, but there was no confession because the priest was busy preparing for Easter vigil :😦
 
No offesne guys, but I really did not get an answer to my original question, WHY should shoulders be covered…
 
No offesne guys, but I really did not get an answer to my original question, WHY should shoulders be covered…
Franky, I see nothing wrong with the shoulders… I have no explanation as to why, they are not really a sexualized part of the body.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top