C
ChiRho
Guest
thanks, I’ll address thisI added a last-minute line about nuns standing out.
not all standing out is created equal, and not all standing out is necessarily distracting. I still maintain that a nun’s dress is enormously less likely to tempt others than ways of immodest dress.If people in Church started dressing in a manner that significantly makes them different from nuns, you have to face the inevitable: Nuns will stand out.
so you maintain a woman showing lots of skin in certain areas, or heck, how about a woman in a super skimpy bikini at mass would be just as likely to lead others to have lustful thoughts as one who was dressed modestly? I find this hard to believeNope. That’s in fact justifying people’s pushy demands to change my “weird” sense of fashion.
If anything should change, it’s how people put excessive focus on physical appearances.
If this situation were actually avoidable (I’m not saying it is), then sure, why not? Do you value your own selfish individuality more than others becoming holier (i.e. not sinning)?In other words, if I dressed like a member of the A-crowd and pretended to someone I’m not, just to avoid a “sinful situation” (e.g. getting beat up) then I should.
nb: I’m not saying this would be the best approach.
They are both problems. They might be problems of different degrees, but they are both problems. Saying that something is an occasion if sin is not saying that the person is intending to be an occasion of sin. I’m not saying that at all. You seem very sensitive to others being “judged”, and I don’t think you’re appreciating that people can say that other people are doing something wrong without hating them. Reprimanding and judging unjustly are two different things.Just because we shouldn’t tempt others does not mean we justify being labeled as occasions of sin. No good Christian would want to tempt those of weaker self-control. That’s still not an excuse to address the real problem: the weaker self-control.
I didn’t say they matter on the same level. They’re completely different levels. And you can’t treat this like it’s a static situation, where we could just get everyone in the world to “not be shallow” and it would be fine. wrong! New children are constantly being born, so standards of modesty must be constantly in place for the new generations. This is why there won’t be a point when people magically become un-shallow. Individual people might lose their shallowness, but they will die, and a new generation must be taught to value important things.Instead of focusing on people’s clothes like they somehow matter on the same level as their internal character, why can’t we simply man up and say, “Hey Shallow Hal! Get real!”
Furthermore, we haven’t even addressed the attention-seeking and egoism that might be associated with immodest dress. That’s for another thread!
I agree that people care too much about appearance, but in a different direction. When people being too concerned about modesty becomes an issue, I’ll rejoice, because this certainly is not the direction the pendulum is swinging. People are becoming increasingly less concerned with modesty. This may be both a cause and a symptom of things that are gravely wrong with society today.