Modesty Question

  • Thread starter Thread starter jeanne71350
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I added a last-minute line about nuns standing out.
thanks, I’ll address this
If people in Church started dressing in a manner that significantly makes them different from nuns, you have to face the inevitable: Nuns will stand out.
not all standing out is created equal, and not all standing out is necessarily distracting. I still maintain that a nun’s dress is enormously less likely to tempt others than ways of immodest dress.
Nope. That’s in fact justifying people’s pushy demands to change my “weird” sense of fashion.

If anything should change, it’s how people put excessive focus on physical appearances.
so you maintain a woman showing lots of skin in certain areas, or heck, how about a woman in a super skimpy bikini at mass would be just as likely to lead others to have lustful thoughts as one who was dressed modestly? I find this hard to believe
In other words, if I dressed like a member of the A-crowd and pretended to someone I’m not, just to avoid a “sinful situation” (e.g. getting beat up) then I should.
If this situation were actually avoidable (I’m not saying it is), then sure, why not? Do you value your own selfish individuality more than others becoming holier (i.e. not sinning)?

nb: I’m not saying this would be the best approach.
Just because we shouldn’t tempt others does not mean we justify being labeled as occasions of sin. No good Christian would want to tempt those of weaker self-control. That’s still not an excuse to address the real problem: the weaker self-control.
They are both problems. They might be problems of different degrees, but they are both problems. Saying that something is an occasion if sin is not saying that the person is intending to be an occasion of sin. I’m not saying that at all. You seem very sensitive to others being “judged”, and I don’t think you’re appreciating that people can say that other people are doing something wrong without hating them. Reprimanding and judging unjustly are two different things.
Instead of focusing on people’s clothes like they somehow matter on the same level as their internal character, why can’t we simply man up and say, “Hey Shallow Hal! Get real!”
I didn’t say they matter on the same level. They’re completely different levels. And you can’t treat this like it’s a static situation, where we could just get everyone in the world to “not be shallow” and it would be fine. wrong! New children are constantly being born, so standards of modesty must be constantly in place for the new generations. This is why there won’t be a point when people magically become un-shallow. Individual people might lose their shallowness, but they will die, and a new generation must be taught to value important things.

Furthermore, we haven’t even addressed the attention-seeking and egoism that might be associated with immodest dress. That’s for another thread!

I agree that people care too much about appearance, but in a different direction. When people being too concerned about modesty becomes an issue, I’ll rejoice, because this certainly is not the direction the pendulum is swinging. People are becoming increasingly less concerned with modesty. This may be both a cause and a symptom of things that are gravely wrong with society today.
 
not all standing out is created equal, and not all standing out is necessarily distracting. I still maintain that a nun’s dress is enormously less likely to tempt others than ways of immodest dress.
Tell that to a uniform fetishist.
so you maintain a woman showing lots of skin in certain areas, or heck, how about a woman in a super skimpy bikini at mass would be just as likely to lead others to have lustful thoughts as one who was dressed modestly? I find this hard to believe
You forget that modesty is about not standing out. Obviously a woman in a bikini whilst everyone else in casual attire is going to draw attention. Then again, if people were truly focused, that wouldn’t matter either would it?
If this situation were actually avoidable (I’m not saying it is), then sure, why not? Do you value your own selfish individuality more than others becoming holier (i.e. not sinning)?
Are you actually justifying their shallowness? See, this is exactly the problem I’ve been talking about. You’re response is typical of everybody who tries to justify it. You call me ‘selfish’ when in fact, it’s the bullies’ superficial world views that are selfish in the first place because they want everybody to dress like them or perish. The Modesty Police certainly aren’t any different.
They are both problems. They might be problems of different degrees, but they are both problems. Saying that something is an occasion if sin is not saying that the person is intending to be an occasion of sin. I’m not saying that at all. You seem very sensitive to others being “judged”, and I don’t think you’re appreciating that people can say that other people are doing something wrong without hating them. Reprimanding and judging unjustly are two different things.
If people knew how to control themselves, then there wouldn’t be a need for people to conform to their weaknesses. It’s that simple. If a guy knew that there was more to women than boobs and thighs, then it automatically follows that he has a responsibility to see them that way and not let his hormones get the better of him.

I may be a dude (and an imperfect one at that) but I’ve been a victim of such a shallow mentality. Naturally, I have contempt for any judgment on people because of something as superficial as their looks. It’s not a question of separating sin from sinner. It’s a question of how something as temporal as aesthetic appearance can be ascribed with some higher value in the first place.
I didn’t say they matter on the same level. They’re completely different levels. And you can’t treat this like it’s a static situation, where we could just get everyone in the world to “not be shallow” and it would be fine. wrong!
I’m not an idealist. I’m not proposing a solution as much as I’m merely pointing out the true cause for debates like this.

It’s either you think appearances have a higher value or you don’t. If you think that there’s more to everyone than meets the eye, then logically what a person looks like becomes significantly irrelevant.

I don’t expect the whole world to come to this perspective. However, the way the Fashion Police and the Modesty Police overemphasize the same value on looks is glaringly similar.

It’s only right to point that out.
New children are constantly being born, so standards of modesty must be constantly in place for the new generations. This is why there won’t be a point when people magically become un-shallow. Individual people might lose their shallowness, but they will die, and a new generation must be taught to value important things.
You seem to have confused the virtue with the form. Modesty is an internal value (like love, hope, faith etc). The form is an external value in which the idea is expressed. However, unlike internal values that never change, the form does. It’s because physical appearances are ultimately superficial. There is no universal standard for physical beauty or sexiness.

It’s for that reason why the CCC itself does not support you if you think that by standards of modesty, you are referring to form. Forms vary from culture to culture. I’ll go even further and say that cultures vary across the ages. Teaching the value they represent is far different from reinforcing such forms.

I’d rather, instead of being browbeaten into what to wear, a child learn from stories such as Beauty and the Beast, The Frog Prince, and even the Biblical story of David and Goliath because all those stories tell the same message: There’s more than meets the eye.
Furthermore, we haven’t even addressed the attention-seeking and egoism that might be associated with immodest dress. That’s for another thread!
Such associations are never absolute and are ultimately unreliable. See that’s exactly the sort of shallow perspective I’ve been warning against.
I agree that people care too much about appearance, but in a different direction. When people being too concerned about modesty becomes an issue, I’ll rejoice, because this certainly is not the direction the pendulum is swinging. People are becoming increasingly less concerned with modesty. This may be both a cause and a symptom of things that are gravely wrong with society today.
If you think people’s clothes are somehow an indication of a moral climate, then I’m afraid you need to recheck if you’re really not as shallow as you claim.

You might also want to review your history if you think our society is somehow far wors than, for instance, the “modest” age of Queen Victoria.
 
Tell that to a uniform fetishist.
the fact that you bring that up means you’re unable to argue the point. Are you seriously claiming or implying through your offhanded remark that the dress nuns and sisters wear is just as likely to tempt others as immodest dress?
You forget that modesty is about not standing out. Obviously a woman in a bikini whilst everyone else in casual attire is going to draw attention. Then again, if people were truly focused, that wouldn’t matter either would it?
If people were truly focused it wouldn’t matter. But if people were truly sinless, it wouldn’t matter either. But you can’t build an argument around “this is how it should be, so we can act like these problems of focus don’t exist.” They do exist, and saying “but they shouldn’t exist!” doesn’t solve the problem, it restates it. As I have consistently reiterated: the problem is twofold, and should be addressed from both directions, both in the dress one wears and the attitudes of the one who looks upon the person with lust.

If we were to compare this by analogy, it’s like handing 8th grade boys a stack of adult magazines. Now, there is nothing inherently wrong with nudity, you yourself attest to this by saying that a bikini would be acceptable in church if others could focus. So you hand these 8th grade boys this stack of nude magazines, and guess what happens? Their minds run rampant. Now what would be the appropriate response: saying “well the real problem is that they are lusting! they should be able to look upon a woman without lusting!” or realizing that yes, lust is a problem, but that it’s impossible to get under control if the stimulus (the magazines) is not removed?

How is this any different from saying: “yes, there is certainly an issue with people viewing others as objects, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t change the stimulus (what people wear) to make this problem less prevalent”?
Are you actually justifying their shallowness? See, this is exactly the problem I’ve been talking about. You’re response is typical of everybody who tries to justify it. You call me ‘selfish’ when in fact, it’s the bullies’ superficial world views that are selfish in the first place because they want everybody to dress like them or perish. The Modesty Police certainly aren’t any different.
This was a hypothetical situation, which I don’t think would ever occur. But I’m considering it on principle.

If something you did was a non-essential thing, and it would not harm you if you had to give it up, and it was leading someone into sin, would you stop? Would it not be selfish to have the reasonable opportunity to help someone forgo a sin, but not stop because you “shouldn’t have to”?
If people knew how to control themselves, then there wouldn’t be a need for people to conform to their weaknesses. It’s that simple. If a guy knew that there was more to women than boobs and thighs, then it automatically follows that he has a responsibility to see them that way and not let his hormones get the better of him.
I completely agree, but you’re missing the point. I assume you have locks on your house and car doors, and you make sure not to leave out personal belongings in a public place where they could get taken. Now, you shouldn’t HAVE to do this! But you do it anyway. Why? Because you realize the reality of the situation, that open houses, cars and openly displayed belongings are an invitation to steal for people who are unable to control themselves.

So this is completely analogous to the situation with dress tempting others in church. But I would be surprised to hear that you don’t lock your doors because you shouldn’t have to, in fact it would be irrational not to. Guarding against sin is not the same as justifying a sin’s existence. Conforming to others weaknesses in order that they become better is frankly the Christian thing to do, as St. Paul discusses.
It’s a question of how something as temporal as aesthetic appearance can be ascribed with some higher value in the first place.
I’m not assigning it high value per se, I’m saying that it’s relevant because sin has made it relevant. Saying that it shouldn’t be relevant does nothing to fix the problem, as I’ve sufficiently demonstrated with several examples above ^
I’m not an idealist. I’m not proposing a solution as much as I’m merely pointing out the true cause for debates like this.
Worse than not proposing a solution, you’re proposing that one aspect of reality be ignored, and that things be treated as if if something shouldn’t happen, you shouldn’t try and guard against it. I’ve already shown how this viewpoint is inconsistent with reality.
 
ou seem to have confused the virtue with the form. Modesty is an internal value (like love, hope, faith etc). The form is an external value in which the idea is expressed. However, unlike internal values that never change, the form does. It’s because physical appearances are ultimately superficial. There is no universal standard for physical beauty or sexiness.

It’s for that reason why the CCC itself does not support you if you think that by standards of modesty, you are referring to form. Forms vary from culture to culture. I’ll go even further and say that cultures vary across the ages. Teaching the value they represent is far different from reinforcing such forms.
Simply because there is not universal agreed upon standard does not mean there are not generally held beliefs, or Adam and Eve in the garden covering themselves with fig leaves is a culturally relative statement. Furthermore, just because not everyone agrees on something doesn’t mean that something doesn’t exist! I’d cede to the posts of Shin in this thread discussing modesty, as he puts it much better than I can: forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=555751
If you think people’s clothes are somehow an indication of a moral climate, then I’m afraid you need to recheck if you’re really not as shallow as you claim.
are you honestly suggesting that immodest dress is not increasingly a problem, and that those who dress in a more revealing way are more likely to fall prey to the ill-effects of an immodest culture?
 
This bare arms deal is a mystery to me too. I just think it is being extremely scrupulous. No one fell in love or lusted after bare arms.
 
the fact that you bring that up means you’re unable to argue the point. Are you seriously claiming or implying through your offhanded remark that the dress nuns and sisters wear is just as likely to tempt others as immodest dress?
Uh, yes? If that’s so hard to believe for you, then you are very, very naive.
If people were truly focused it wouldn’t matter. But if people were truly sinless, it wouldn’t matter either.
False comparison. A person need not be sinless to focus on something other than something as superfluous as the dress of someone in the pew next to him.

The problem isn’t twofold when the real cause is singular.
If we were to compare this by analogy, it’s like handing 8th grade boys a stack of adult magazines. Now, there is nothing inherently wrong with nudity, you yourself attest to this by saying that a bikini would be acceptable in church if others could focus. So you hand these 8th grade boys this stack of nude magazines, and guess what happens? Their minds run rampant. Now what would be the appropriate response: saying “well the real problem is that they are lusting! they should be able to look upon a woman without lusting!” or realizing that yes, lust is a problem, but that it’s impossible to get under control if the stimulus (the magazines) is not removed?
Again, you’re missing the point. Your analogy doesn’t even cut it seeing as how kids can work their way to images worse than that of an adult magazine. However, do we blame the people making the magazine or do we blame the people who have a twisted view on sexuality and corrupted shallow perception of physical appearances as the cause for all the lusting?

Your analogy is also comparing apples to oranges (as with the previous one with the bikini actually). Again, you are forgetting the role cultural contexts play in people’s perception of physical appearances. If a whole crowd of people wearing shorts, sleeveless, mini-skirts attended mass and nobody thought it a big deal, then guess what? It isn’t! You want a similar example? Google for images of Blessed Pope John Paul II during his trip to New Guinea.
How is this any different from saying: “yes, there is certainly an issue with people viewing others as objects, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t change the stimulus (what people wear) to make this problem less prevalent”?
Again, the stimulus is not the problem. It’s the people. Are you aware that the most effective and reasonable argument against pornography is not stating stats that mark it a cause a cause of sexual indency (seriously, just try doing that and you’d have already lost the debate) but the argument of human dignity? It’s the same dignity that transcends shallow physical standards for what is sexy or beautiful.
If something you did was a non-essential thing, and it would not harm you if you had to give it up, and it was leading someone into sin, would you stop? Would it not be selfish to have the reasonable opportunity to help someone forgo a sin, but not stop because you “shouldn’t have to”?
It doesn’t matter if you find it selfish or not. The fact is you have conceded to the true selfish tyrants by making people conform to their weaknesses instead of telling them to man up. Instead of defending people who are being shackled by the lustful or hateful shallowness of such individuals, you choose to make them conform to their weaknesses.

I remember another thread here on Islamic dress and one poster posed a question wondering that if we imposed Islamic dress/modesty on people, would that mean would we be giving to the weaknesses of sexist imams who consider women who don’t veil as “raw meat asking to be eaten”?
 
I completely agree, but you’re missing the point. I assume you have locks on your house and car doors, and you make sure not to leave out personal belongings in a public place where they could get taken. Now, you shouldn’t HAVE to do this! But you do it anyway. Why? Because you realize the reality of the situation, that open houses, cars and openly displayed belongings are an invitation to steal for people who are unable to control themselves.
I’ve heard this analogy before and it still doesn’t justify labeling the source of “stimulus” as the problem.

In the city I live, our mayor boasts it has a drastically low crime rate when compared to the capital. In the capital, you can’t take your cellphone out because a snatcher might just come out and steal it. On the other hand, in my city, I’ve seen at least two-three people texting in every jeepney I commute in. People feel secure and at the same time, these people feel free. Why? It’s not because we lock up our things. Instead, we have harsh policies against snatchers and muggers. If the police don’t get you, the vigilantes will. The issues being addressed are the crimes and the criminals who commit them, not the ones they victimize and deem the source of their temptation.

Even in cities were people are told to do this or that, you think they like it? You think I wouldn’t want to leave my bike without worrying about it being stolen? It only makes them more of a victim.

Here’s another analogy. Suppose you’re the target of an assassination. Because of that, safety measures are required, heavy safety measures. This means you can’t go anywhere with a bodyguard in a suit. You can’t eat anything without it being tested for poison. You can’t even walk on the streets for fear of a sniper. Would you want that? Furthermore, would you like someone blaming you as the source of the problem and not the nutcase trying to kill you?
Worse than not proposing a solution, you’re proposing that one aspect of reality be ignored, and that things be treated as if if something shouldn’t happen, you shouldn’t try and guard against it. I’ve already shown how this viewpoint is inconsistent with reality.
You tell me that I’m ignoring one aspect of reality yet you’re the one who refuses to face the fact that culture plays a significant role in determining forms of modesty.

Look what I’m trying to say is that the Modesty Police is becoming waaaay to clingy to old forms of modesty for comfort. When a culture starts undergoing a fashion change, then expect the form of modesty to change too. In fact, do your clothes really say it more in comparison to your actions or your personality?
Simply because there is not universal agreed upon standard does not mean there are not generally held beliefs, or Adam and Eve in the garden covering themselves with fig leaves is a culturally relative statement. Furthermore, just because not everyone agrees on something doesn’t mean that something doesn’t exist!
First off, God clothed them because He was aware that their view on sexuality has been corrupted by Original Sin. That doesn’t mean those views aren’t going to change over time or that the corruption would take a form that would render certain types of “modest” clothing into “immodest”.

Secondly, just because those standards exist does not mean one shouldn’t brace for change. You can quote Shin all you want but I’ve quoted official church teaching. Official church teaching concedes that forms of modesty vary from culture to culture.

It’s high time the Modesty Police learned to adapt.
are you honestly suggesting that immodest dress is not increasingly a problem, and that those who dress in a more revealing way are more likely to fall prey to the ill-effects of an immodest culture?
More than that. The form of modesty you cling to may not necessarily be the form that general society accepts today.

Furthermore, I don’t see how the fashion sense of blown-up ball gowns and crisp suits prevented the Spaniards from being racist, bigoted dogs during the three centuries they spent controlling my country.
 
I won’t be addressing the rest of your points because I don’t see much use in taking this any further, but thanks for your time and opinions
 
There are people challenging public decency laws on our streets, such as the woman from Portland, OR, who went buck naked on the streets and gave TV interviews telling that nobody should have a right to tell her to dress up. She couldn’t care less about offending other people, including school children, by being totally naked in public.

I guess the debate about why, and what can the majority of population impose on the nudists and public exhibitionists, will rage on.

Thankfully, however, the Church is different - Church property is the private property of the Church, and the Church can impose and enforce whatever dress code it wants to. The Church is not a democratic institution, and its discipline is set by the Pope and the Bishops. Thanks God for that. The naked woman from Portland, OR won’t be able to pretend anytime soon that she has a right to enter a Catholic church in Portland, or visit Vatican City, while wearing nothing but her birthday costume.

Vatican City, and Catholic churches throughout Rome and Italy enforce a dress code according to which shirts and dresses should cover the shoulders, backs, midriffs of people, and cannot be low-cut or expose cleavage. Also, pants, skirts, dresses should be long enough to cover the knees.
 
Burkas should be banned. So should nudity. So should abortion. And so should prostitution and porn… (this includes fining or punishing those who morally or materially cooperate in such acts)
All of this behaviour is showing extreme contempt for the human person’s dignity, sexuality and marriage.
I would never personally change my own behaviour if eg. urged only by men who watched dirty material on the internet. And yes, I have met these kinds of fellers who watch dirty movies on their mobile phones while telling their little sisters to cover up.
Neither should I care for the oppinion of a person who covers totally but out of a fear of own sexuality or internalisation of a demonisaton of especially female sexuality which we also see in the Islamic world.
The more people clean up their own act, the more will other people will follow their example.
I think that in the Western world one of the problems is that men and women don’t respect each other … and they are many times right not to from a purely human point of view. There is much suspicion and understandably so also… I mean, we still see men dominating women through dress, isolation etc. in the whole islamic world and know what the weakness of man will cause in a man if he is given too much power over others. Only a few generations back in Europe many women would have no say over their own body but be asked to obey and have one child after the other in order to alleviate the “tension” of their man…
In the “free world” when you don’t respect someone because he is otherwise indifferent to your needs (like absent fathers), suspect him of impurity, powerstrivings or hypocrisy, you care little about being considerate if it is implied that you ought to be.

It’s that old suspicion from the fall… there is nothing new under the sun in that regard. Only we can hope and believe that Christians do better in all things moral so that neigther judgement, perversion, hypocrisy, lust for power etc. is very much found among us.
 
Only a few generations back in Europe many women would have no say over their own body but be asked to obey and have one child after the other in order to alleviate the “tension” of their man…
I don’t necessarily agree with this statement/conclusion. A couple having relations 1 time a month (without using NFP or otherwise frustrating conception) can easily become pregnant every 18 months or so.

That being said when a couple gets marry the give each other the right to the body. Their bodies are no longer their own. Although this “right” is not a right if abused and not exercised in charity. One should never force their spouse to have relations and one should not refuse relations without good reason and without honest clear and understanding communication. This is something that should be covered in marriage prep but often is not. The ability to have open and non-judgmental communication is really really important for couples considering marriage.
 
IMO, as the rift widens between the Church and the secular world, it will become more important than ever to listen to our Pope and Bishops, and obey the dress code they are imposing on us while visiting Catholic churches, shrines, pilgrimage sites.

As I said before, law enforcement on the beaches of the USA says, “you will be fine as long as your nipples, anus, and vagina (male privates) are covered”. They won’t stop you for wearing an itsy-bitsy thong, and in practice they also allow women to go topless on public beaches in certain areas such as in Miami.

In contrast to the world, stands the Church. I think the best we can do, instead of challenging our teachers the Pope and the Bishops, is to joyfully submit to their measures of Church discipline and dress accordingly.
 
Vatican City, and Catholic churches throughout Rome and Italy enforce a dress code according to which shirts and dresses should cover the shoulders, backs, midriffs of people, and cannot be low-cut or expose cleavage. Also, pants, skirts, dresses should be long enough to cover the knees.
You would find plenty of Traditionalist circles that consider pants to be immodest.
 
I don’t necessarily agree with this statement/conclusion. A couple having relations 1 time a month (without using NFP or otherwise frustrating conception) can easily become pregnant every 18 months or so.

That being said when a couple gets marry the give each other the right to the body. Their bodies are no longer their own. Although this “right” is not a right if abused and not exercised in charity. One should never force their spouse to have relations and one should not refuse relations without good reason and without honest clear and understanding communication. This is something that should be covered in marriage prep but often is not. The ability to have open and non-judgmental communication is really really important for couples considering marriage.
The grandfather of my brother in law told him that the pastor in their church kept an eye on couples. When some women were always pregnant the pastor would take a talk with their husbands.
In the life story of Tolstoy he tells how his wife was exhausted after 5 children in a row and she litterally begged him to stop having relations with her, to which he said he wouldn’t stop.
I myself read another book from a common farmer woman. She had 12 children and nearly died, also because her husband didn’t wish to stop having intercourse.
All that was in a time where
  • many women died during giving birth
  • many children died during or right after birth
  • There was no NFP. You can see how even post modern men and women here, who have a pretty good economy are afraid of getting pregnant. But that time the risks and circumstances were much more extreme than today.
  • many people knew nothing of the sexual rhythms of women, so its safe to bet that many women never were fully satisfied during sex because the knowlege of how to reach a woman’s climax was not very well known earlier.
You might think I generalize too much. I’ll just say that as a woman I am very happy that blessed JP2 existed in my time and wrote stuff like Love and Responsibility (he actually knew alot about female sexuality ) TOB and also for what happend at 2. Vatican Council.

NFP is quite a new thing on the world scene… and the demad for it has come out of historical developments such as equal rights for women, women accepted as sexual beings with desires of their own, respect for protection of women’s wellbeing, her psychological and emotional rights as an equal spouse, who is no longer utterly dependant on a man in order to have roof over her head.

Anyways… this is off topic…
 
You might think I generalize too much.
I think you are taking examples of incidents that were contrary to Church teachings on responsibility and charity and applying them to generations of men who worked hard labor from age 12 to their death 6- 7 days a week, were good fathers and husbands. At least that is how it is coming across to me, that may not have been your intent.
 
I think you are taking examples of incidents that were contrary to Church teachings on responsibility and charity and applying them to generations of men who worked hard labor from age 12 to their death 6- 7 days a week, were good fathers and husbands. At least that is how it is coming across to me, that may not have been your intent.
Whether these men worked hard or their wives cooked well really has no bearing on this question. The point Im trying to make is that some people (maybe incl. you) have an ideal picture of how the earlier generations were just naturally charitable, respectful, and loving in their married life. You think there are only few indicents… I think there were quite a few. We live in a world quite different from that of our grand and geat-grandmothers.
My common sense tells me that priests and pastors have never been too keen on teaching about healthy sexual morality from the pulpit, and even less so before the entrance of the Personalistic Norm of Karol Wojtyla and his contemporaries on the stage of Catholic sexual ethics. Maybe its because even the great doctors in the church rather spoke about rendering the marriage dept and procreation than a true meeting of equal persons in the marital act. Most people didnt read that, but most men will probably have been the providers, heads of their families and been familiar with the “obey your husbands in all things” command for women.
As I said, I am happy to be an educated woman in 2011 with equal rights both in society and in marriage.
 
Grace, please don’t put words in my mouth. Did you even read my original post?
 
You would find plenty of Traditionalist circles that consider pants to be immodest.
Some time ago I did a big internet search to see, what do our Pope, Bishops, and Priests expect from us. I found many articles from Europe (Vatican, Rome, Italy, shrines like Knock, Lourdes, other European countries like Croatia), the USA (several Bishops and Priests), Asia (Philippines, India, Sri Lanka), Australia - I went through at least 25 or 30 articles. I’m emphasizing, these were not the laity’s opinions, they were written by clergy, or else by laity who were speaking for the clergy and not for themselves. The thrust of the articles was that we should cover our bodies (cover the shoulders, back, no cleavage, no midriffs, no shorts or short skirts that expose the knees), and also refrain from using tight or see-through clothing that would expose too much of our bodies. In Sri Lanka, they also made it mandatory for ladies to cover their heads during Holy Communion. But interestingly, none of these articles said that women are forbidden to wear pants. Also, as far as I know, the Vatican, and the churches of Rome do not forbid ladies wearing pants to enter.

There’s another disturbing tendency out there, mainly some women wearing skin-tight pants, yoga pants etc that expose every anatomical detail. The male equivalent would be a man wearing some super-tight cycling pants or triathlon pants, as Nelka joked about, with all the male anatomy bulging out, but I haven’t seen any of that in our churches so far. Aside from the fact that many women do wear these immodest super-tight pants, I just don’t recall seeing any blanket ban on pants per se. I know that Padre Pio forbade women wearing pants to enter his church, but in the contemporary articles I found on the internet, there’s no such ban. At a downtown church I love to attend (because people there dress modestly, almost without exception) I see ladies all the time wearing pants and pant suits, really modest ones that do not fit like second skins, do not accentuate their bodies.

The Russian Eastern Orthodox Church I’m familiar with, to this day forbids women from wearing pants. I have been occasionally to other (Greek, Antiochian) EO churches, but can’t recall whether they also forbid pants for women. In addition, the Russian EOC also makes it compulsory for women to cover their heads, and for men to uncover their heads. I only mention these Orthodox Churches, because their discipline makes me wonder about prescriptions in the Eastern Catholic Churches in Russia, Ukraine, and elsewhere. I wouldn’t be surprised at all if these Eastern Catholic Churches still enforced today their traditions for head covering/uncovering, being this a 2000-year old tradition, directly prescribed by St. Paul in his 1 Corinthians letter. But then, wearing pants in Eastern Catholic Churches - I have no idea. They have their own peculiar discipline in many things like fasting, so maybe they have specific rules about women wearing pants, too, or maybe they don’t. At any rate, it is entirely possible for the Eastern Catholic Churches to have different disciplinary rules from the Roman Catholic.

With the traditionalist circles within the Roman Catholic Church, I would try to concentrate on what those Bishops and Priests tell us who are in full communion and good standing with Rome. But I just don’t know enough about who prescribes what, who is in a good standing with Rome and who’s not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top